Times the writers took a character too far

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
The question I asked regarding his integrity - that his words (spoken at Jock's trial) and his actions (over the following two weeks contradicted each other - is related to something you had mentioned previously:



This situation, which began with Cliff instigating Jock's trial, depicts an absence of conflict between Bobby's loyalty to his family and his morality. Cliff did something so inexcusable that JR vowed to run him out of the state if Texas, and Bobby replied that JR would have to get in line behind him, it's one of those rare situations where JR and Bobby both agreed that the same thing had to be done and the only question was which one of them would have the honor of doing it.

JR seemed to be fine with letting Bobby be the one to get to do the job. There again, there is no conflict. Bobby wants to get to do it and JR is alright with that. Over the next two weeks Bobby does nothing to run Cliff out of Texas. Maybe you'd think if Bobby lacked the integrity to do what he said he'd do then JR would do what he originally wanted to do himself anyway, except there was one big problem with that. Two weeks later JR was in the hospital because someone had shot him. That looks like valid excuse to me as to why JR didn't pick up the slack when Bobby wouldn't or couldn't make good on his word.

There is conflict here but it isn't between Bobby and his family. The conflict is between what Bobby says he will do and what he actually does. Bobby says a lot but does nothing. Bobby didn't even try to make good on his word. Bobby has both morality problem and an integrity problem. Bobby's words and his actions blatantly contradicted each other! Bobby proves to be a hypocrite - one who claims to have moral standards or beliefs to which his own behavior doesn't conform.

That by itself would have been disappointing, that Bobby either wouldn't or couldn't do what he said he wanted to do, but then Bobby makes things worse. Bobby makes it clear that he didn't just fail to do, or forget to do what he said he would do to Cliff for trying to send his Jock to prison for a crime he didn't commit. Now Bobby decides that instead of running Cliff out of Texas, he's come up with something even more appropriate: Bobby wants to reward Cliff by making him a partner in the Ewing 23 oil field!

Jock says there is no way he could ever be partners with the man who almost sent him to prison for a murder that he had nothing to do with. Bobby reacts as if he's been mortally wounded. Except JR is the one who gets shot. Bobby just can't understand why cutting Cliff in on the profits of Ewing 23 isn't even a better way to handle the situation than his original plan of running Cliff out of the state. Bobby isn't mortally wounded but he may be morally wounded, or more to the point, he doesn't have any clue as to what he stands for. First he wants to punish Cliff and then he wants to reward Cliff. Only a man bereft of morals wouldn't be able to decide whether he should punish or reward someone for instigating a trial that almost sent his father to a prison for a crime he didn't commit.


Yes that annoyed me as well how Bobby seemed no to remember what Cliff had put the Ewings through. This and the family voting JR out as President of Ewing Oil in that ridiculous voting shares storyline I wanted JR to remind them all the things that Cliff put them through including trying to send Jock to prison.
s
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Yes that annoyed me as well how Bobby seemed no to remember what Cliff had put the Ewings through. This and the family voting JR out as President of Ewing Oil in that ridiculous voting shares storyline I wanted JR to remind them all the things that Cliff put them through including trying to send Jock to prison.
s

That voting share storyline, while entertaining, was not too intelligent. Even if Jock had decided to allocate voting shares, does anyone really think he'd have given Gary 10%? Gary wasn't even there to vote! Then he gave Miss Ellie a huge 30%, which is way too much for a woman who had never worked in the oil industry.

Realistically I don't think he'd have wanted any of the family to vote on who should run Ewing Oil since Bobby was the only one besides JR who could do it anyway. Nobody but JR and Bobby were qualified to be be able to vote on who should run the company. I think all he'd have done is write something saying that he'd appreciate it if both JR and Bobby would work together running Ewing Oil in his absence, and if one couldn't or wouldn't do it, the other would run it by himself.

I'd have enjoyed a scene where when Miss Ellie announces that she thinks JR should be voted out for setting a trap for Cliff, JR had replied: "Before you judge me on how I've treated Cliff, let me remind you on how he has treated not just me, but our whole family." Then he could go on to list things such as Cliff abusing his power in the OLM to shut down every single Ewing Oil well in the entire state. Mention how he treated their whole family, when Cliff claimed that he was the father of John Ross. Talk about how Cliff instigated the trial that almost sent Jock to prison and then ask Miss Ellie "What is it that you find sympathetic about him?

Cliff had tried so hard to seriously hurt their family that when I think of Bobby demanding that Jock make Cliff his business partner, I consider what Bobby did to be a betrayal of his family. I considerate it treason against his own family.
 
Last edited:

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
That voting share storyline, while entertaining, was not too intelligent. Even if Jock had decided to allocate voting shares, does anyone really think he'd have given Gary 10%? Gary wasn't even there to vote! Then he gave Miss Ellie a huge 30%, which is way too much for a woman who had never worked in the oil industry.

Realistically I don't think he'd have wanted any of the family to vote on who should run Ewing Oil since Bobby was th only one besides JR who could it anyway. Nobody but JR and Bobby were qualified to be be able to vote on who should run the company. I think all he'd have done is write something saying that he'd appreciate it both JR and Bobby would work together running Ewing Oil in his absence, and if one couldn't or wouldn't do it, the other would run it by himself.

I'd have enjoyed a scene where when Miss Ellie announces that she thinks JR should be voted out for setting a trap for Cliff, JR had replied: "Before you judge me on how I've treated Cliff, let me remind you on how he has treated not just me, but our whole family." Then he could go on to list things such as Cliff abusing his power in the OLM to shut down every single Ewing Oil well in the entire state. Mention how he treated their whole family, when Cliff claimed that he was the father of John Ross. Talk about how Cliff instigated the trial that almost sent Jock to prison and then ask Miss Ellie "What is it that you find sympathetic about him?

Cliff had tried so hard to seriously hurt their family that when I think of Bobby demanding that Jock make Cliff his business partner, I consider what Bobby did to be a betrayal of his family. I considerate it treason against his own family.


Thank you. I have always said the same thing. List the things that Cliff had done to the Ewings including trying to send Jock to prison. Not only that, I would have had something like this, "Do you guys know what you were doing when you were 15? Bobby was bedding every cheerleader at college, Lucy was cutting classes, and Ray was doing nothing of consequence. Well when I turned 15, I began my internship at Ewing Oil. Daddy had me visit every oil field, worked at every position in the company so that I could understand the workings of Ewing. Not only that Lucy you don't have a real job and do you know why? Because Daddy and I have made it so you would not have to work." So if you want to vote OK vote and understand I refuse to let my future in Ewing Oil be decided by Lucy, Ray or Gary none of whom know anything of Ewing Oil.

As for Bobby, his reason for leaving Southfork was dumb and disloyal. The Ewings owed Cliff nothing.
 
Top