Billy Wall
Telly Talk Dream Maker
This is the Merriam Webster definition of an antihero:
Definition of antihero
: a protagonist or notable figure who is conspicuously lacking in heroic qualities
JR was an antagonist, not a protagonist.
This is the Merriam Webster definition of an antihero:
Definition of antihero
: a protagonist or notable figure who is conspicuously lacking in heroic qualities
R was an antagonist, not a protagonist.
Read more closely. It says "a protagonist or notable figure...'
Here's another:
Oxford defines antihero as: A central character in a story, film, or drama who lacks conventional heroic attributes.
Please stop embarrassing yourself.
It’s not that important. You win.
The times JR crossed the line for me was when he stole Lucy from Valene and when he raped Holly and Laurel. He could justify these actions in his mind, of course, but they're when he was firmly under the heading of villian.
Morality and values always lead to shades of grey. It's the human condition, and it's what makes characters such as JR, Sue Ellen, Jock et.al, so interesting.
The times JR crossed the line for me was when he stole Lucy from Valene and when he raped Holly and Laurel. He could justify these actions in his mind, of course, but they're when he was firmly under the heading of villian.
In these prime time soaps there's usually a distinction between villainous and dangerous characters.Kenny, you made a good point about JR drawing the line at murder
What gives you the idea that viewers don't like and enjoy the villains?If you didn't like JR Ewing, you weren't watching every Dallas every Friday night
What gives you the idea that viewers don't like and enjoy the villains?
The times JR crossed the line for me was when he stole Lucy from Valene.
You're missing the point: viewers enjoyed hating him.If a villain isn't getting the audience to hate him, the actor playing him isn't doing his job
They definitely were. Valene had every right to hate both of them.
Miss Ellie did try and make up for it by buying Val and Gary a house, though.
You're missing the point: viewers enjoyed hating him.
What gives you the idea that viewers don't like and enjoy the villains?
There's a difference between liking a character for what he does (being deliciously and shockingly nasty) and liking a character for what he is.They may very well have enjoyed hating some characters and they probably loved it when something bad happened to one of those characters, but you asked this
Just because JR has an enemy doesn't automatically make him a protagonist. It was a feud, but not based on good vs evil.They gave us protagonist (antihero) JR and antagonist Cliff.
There's a difference between liking a character for what he does (being deliciously and shockingly nasty) and liking a character for what he is.
That happened before the series began so I can only speculate in what was going on, but knowing that Gary was an alcoholic and a compulsive gambler who got a 15 year old Valene pregnant, isn't it possible that Jock and Ellie both agreed that Valene and Gary weren't capable at that time, of taking good care of their daughter, that it was unsafe to leave Lucy in their care? From the way they made it look, they were both welcome by Ellie and Jock to move into Southfork to be with their daughter but they declined that opportunity. I remember Lucy remarking how little her parents even bothered to visit her.