He wouldn’t be Gary. We are at our very foundation the person our parents created.
I think Jock was an impossible father - a man no one could please. Poverty does that to a man, something in his soul he never sheds even when he’s rich. He wanted his sons to be perfect in a way he never could be and with all there advantages (money), why couldn’t they be, or so he figured. They needed to be ruthless and well liked, honorable and never caught at taking what they wanted. Women should want them yet they had to be faithful to their wives. Good to their wives but keep them in their place. A man of the earth but drill for oil. Loved but not need anyone. Keep the family together but fight even your brother. Be your own man but be Jock’s definition of a man. If that had not been Jock, JR and Gary would have both been different and maybe both got along and while JR would have been inclined to build the business, he’d have been happy to see his brother with the ranch.
Miss Ellie I think wanted to baby all 3 of them. Maybe thats natural for a mother. Jock just took over with JR and he didn’t really get in her way with Gary. If they had partnered on raising children, respected each other, each would have been a better parent. But as was Gary was weakened by his mother, let people get to him too easily, turned to drink to cope, turned to women to fill the slightest void, manipulated and confused. That’s something JR had no problem with. Jock taught him to be strong, no one gets at him, he needs nothing (drink) and no one (a woman), fill the void with power and manipulate before you’re manipulated and most of all never be confused, it’s not if your right or wrong, it’s you’re always right even if you’re wrong or have no idea what your talking about.