I´d say that Gary was the one who seemed to have no Ewing DNA in his blood and might have been the son of Digger and Miss Ellie, from an affair they had when Jock was in service. That would have been hugely ironic since Jock himself was impregnating his sweet nurse from the baby who´d become the foreman of his ranch...
(Both): "He´s a bastard..."
About Gary being weak, that depends on who you ask, I guess. And probably anybody who saw him on "Knots" is aware that he only proved he was weak in the first three seasons. He became to rebel even against Abby at the end of Season 4, and he got stronger and stronger (or more and more stubborn) right after he inherited Jock´s money.
Re Gary and Val, he wasn´t being weak while he was married to her (aside from when he cheated on her, of course). She never manipulated him, only wanted the best for him and probably treated him like a "porcelain doll" for awhile. That affected his ego and, since he seemed to have his alcoholism controlled, the only way to prove himself he was a "true man" (Texas-Style) was sleeping with next door´s slut (who turned out to be the Abster, as we all know.
"Isn´t this fun? Everybody sleeping with everybody?
Like in that TV show, "Melrose" something?"
Weak? I think each and every Ewing and Barnes was weak in their own way because that was ideal to create conflict and drama. Even Miss Ellie was really weak before Jock died. Sometimes understandably (her reaction to her mastectomy), others not so much (her over-reaction to Julie´s return, the Takapa affaire, even her denial to Jock´s death). But it was strength what defined her, unlike what defined Gary (his mistakes).
I´ve always thought that, in real life, I´d be like Gary if I had had a family like the Ewings. I also have two brothers, by the way, though none of us is as well-defined as these soap characters we love. I think that leaving home (as I also did), was a way to prove everybody he wasn´t the weakest in the family. We (or the writers) have hardly discussed the fact that Gary might have been somewhat traumatized by the fact that J.R. and Jock had Lucy kidnapped from Val.
"When I´m all grown-up, I want a blond child who looks like this one...
but not from you, mister, and take your hands off me!"
Gary did love Val then and he might have known how deeply that event might have hurt her (and it did: "The 3 Sisters" and the Shulah incident were proof of that). In that aspect, I do think that Gary was terribly weak for not going after Val to take care of her, and also leaving Southfork and Lucy behind. He didn´t do what his folks wanted him to do, but he didn´t do the right thing either. He just started wandering around and drinking himself to oblivion (as Sue Ellen would say).
"What about spinning me off to your show, Daddy?"
"Try telling that to Jacobs & Filerman, sweetheart"
Therefore his biggest weakness was that, and not what we saw him do on "Knots", which might have been, at best, morally debatable. So in hindsight, it was the lack of concern about Val what eventually became his most cruel fault. But who´s going to blame a hopeless drunk for things he might not even remember had happened during his "lost weekends"? That was the mother of all Gary-related conflicts, IMHO.