Dallas Character Was JR afraid of anyone?

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
Do you think there was anyone who truly intimidated JR or who he was even frightened of?

JR is the epitome of manliness - strong, sexual, powerful, charming and - dangerous. He is a hugely intimidating figure when he wants to be and it’s hard to believe he would be actually afraid of another person.

But, he does have feelings. There are certainly situations he would fear. Threat to family members such as Sue Ellen, John Ross, Miss Ellie or Bobby.

He has some fierce adversaries in Wendell, Carter McKay and the gentler of the two, Cliff Barnes.

I wonder if JR fears situations rather than the people themselves. Some people fear others and the consequences those people bring.

Apart from Jock, I struggle to find a person that JR would be afraid of. A good example may be BD Calhoun, he did seem to show fear around the time Calhoun was in action against him.

Clayton could be intimidating to JR but I wouldn’t say he feared him.

He wasn’t afraid of Sue Ellen but was afraid of some of her actions - for example taking John Ross or making the movie. He did look afraid when he mistakenly believed her to be the shooter instead of Kristin, on the day Kristin came to Southfork.

He certainly wasn’t afraid of Pam or Cliff. Or even his Mama.

So what do you think? Did JR really fear anyone?
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
He seemed riddled with fear to me.
JR is the epitome of manliness - strong, sexual, powerful, charming and - dangerous.
Oh, boy.
 
Like a lot of people, JR's fears were irrational and quite basic. It's strongly implied that he's afraid of things he needn't be. Most of all others' potential.

JR was strong in business but closer to home I don't think he outgrew childhood fears that his status at home would be usurped by a sibling. Perhaps that's most evident in his relationship with Gary. Gary has no interest on being on Southfork or being a player in the oil business, but JR is still afraid of his potential and feels the need to keep him in his "place", just as he did Ray and - to a degree - Bobby.

Gary said:
He's incredible, isn't he? All that money; all that power - he just inherited half of Ewing Oil; an' he's still afraid I'm gonna get in his way. How? I mean, even if I wanted to, how would I go about it, JR?


His most telling statement on it comes around the one minute mark here:
Abby said:
You're always so contemptuous of Gary. If he's so inept, why is he dangerous to you?
JR said:
That man is real anger. Frustration. Maybe even hatred, I don't know. If he ever channelled all that energy... well, it could make my life miserable.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
During the show's peak years, as long as he had the back-up of Harry McSween for certain situations, he didn't really fear much, except failure. Perhaps the fear of failure drove him on.

The later seasons, for example seeing him go to a kangaroo court in Haleyville - in the show's peak that simply wouldn't have happened. Cally's brothers would have exited very swiftly.

Swami
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Maybe Jock and that’s it. But even that’s debatable considering some of the things he did right under Jock’s nose.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
We saw JR show fear quite a few times in the show. Several of them have already been listed. Off the top of my head I can think of a lot of examples (Sue Ellen at the pool when he thought she had shot him, Bobby's temper and brute force on several occasions, On the phone with Sue Ellen when she told him Calhoun had John Ross, During the fire at Southfork, anytime Jock was ticked off at him).

I'm not sure JR was scared of any PERSON. Maybe Jock, but on the other hand, he schemed and lied to Jock as much as he did anyone else, so he couldn't have been TOO afraid of him.

Seems to me like JR had only one real fear - the fear of failure.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
During the show's peak years, as long as he had the back-up of Harry McSween for certain situations, he didn't really fear much, except failure. Perhaps the fear of failure drove him on.

The later seasons, for example seeing him go to a kangaroo court in Haleyville - in the show's peak that simply wouldn't have happened. Cally's brothers would have exited very swiftly.

Swami

Or would have tried to shoot them to death (think of the Owens bunch...).
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Excellent idea for a thread, Sarah!

Do you think there was anyone who truly intimidated JR or who he was even frightened of?

JR is the epitome of manliness - strong, sexual, powerful, charming and - dangerous. He is a hugely intimidating figure when he wants to be and it’s hard to believe he would be actually afraid of another person.

Why do you think he became the icon he did? Those are universally admired qualities in a man. JR had those qualities in spades. Another quality JR had was that he remained surprisingly calm, almost cavalier in a crisis. He kept his composure in the most stressful situations, like when he had mortgaged Southofrk and then a typhoon hit his offshore oil operation. He was pretty damn close to losing everything including Southfork and throughout it all remained relatively calm.

The character never would have had anywhere the success it had if JR hadn't been as fearless as he was. Larry Hagman brought to that character exactly what it needed and the proof is in the success that character brought to the whole show. Larry Hagman knew what the character needed to be and portrayed him as having those qualities you mentioned. The scripts helped too!

No, I didn't see anything that indicated he was ever afraid of anyone. Interestingly, Wendell said JR was the only man who he possibly considered a threat. That's high praise from a man like Wendell. JR didn't fear people; people feared JR!

JR loved Bobby and that allowed Bobby to get away with a lot of crap that nobody else would have dared to pull. I remember a scene where JR says: "Stay out of my marriage, Bobby"! Bobby replied: "How do you plan to stop me"? Obviously JR isn't gonna do anything to Bobby because he's his brother and he loves him, and Bobby would exploit that from time to time. Notice that when JR criticizes something in Bobby's marriage, Bobby replies the same way JR does - tells him to stay out of his marriage. Bobby would get so touchy if anyone would say something about how he's running his life, yet somehow always felt entitled to tell other people how to live theirs. You see that sense of entitlement in people who were spoiled as kids and Jock claimed he spoiled Bobby, so it adds up.



But, he does have feelings. There are certainly situations he would fear. Threat to family members such as Sue Ellen, John Ross, Miss Ellie or Bobby.

He has some fierce adversaries in Wendell, Carter McKay and the gentler of the two, Cliff Barnes.

I wonder if JR fears situations rather than the people themselves. Some people fear others and the consequences those people bring.

The situations JR feared regarding his family are what anyone who loves his family would fear. If his family was in danger then he was afraid for them - but not for himself. JR looked right up at the gun BD Calhoun was pointing at him and said to go ahead and shoot him if he wanted, but to just not let his son see his daddy be killed. JR wasn't afraid for himself, but for what it would d to his son if he saw his father get killed. What a father! That's the kind of thing you've gotta admire. To be able to look down the barrel of a gun and say go ahead if that's what you're gonna do - that takes guts! Jock had done the same thing when Tom Owens was about to shoot him. He told him if you're gonna shoot me, then shoot me. JR got that toughness from his dad.
 
Last edited:

James from London

International Treasure
"JR was so quiet, so shy. When I took him shopping, he held onto my skirts so tight. I think Jock scared him at first, and then when Gary came along, Jock just took over raising JR. 'Make him a man’s man,' he said."

"I loved my daddy and I respected my daddy, but most importantly, I feared my daddy."


I think that fear was at the root of most of what JR did. If he hadn't had any fear, he'd have been quite a boring character.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
I don't think JR feared Pam, Donna or Valene, but I always felt what got under his skin about them was that he couldn't corrupt them. Especially since they were women and he had certain, uh, dismissive attitude toward women in general. They were beyond his reach in that they had an inner strength he just couldn't understand. People usually have at least a little fear if what they don't understand.
 
"JR was so quiet, so shy. When I took him shopping, he held onto my skirts so tight. I think Jock scared him at first, and then when Gary came along, Jock just took over raising JR. 'Make him a man’s man,' he said."

"I loved my daddy and I respected my daddy, but most importantly, I feared my daddy."


I think that fear was at the root of most of what JR did. If he hadn't had any fear, he'd have been quite a boring character.

Says it all, Jock was the only man he both loved and feared, everything he did - good or bad was to please his daddy and he was a chip of the old block,
he learned at the feet of the master for all the dirty deals and double crossing and the use of the 3Bs and how to be a business man
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
We saw JR show fear quite a few times in the show. Several of them have already been listed. Off the top of my head I can think of a lot of examples (Sue Ellen at the pool when he thought she had shot him, Bobby's temper and brute force on several occasions, On the phone with Sue Ellen when she told him Calhoun had John Ross, During the fire at Southfork, anytime Jock was ticked off at him).

I'm not sure JR was scared of any PERSON. Maybe Jock, but on the other hand, he schemed and lied to Jock as much as he did anyone else, so he couldn't have been TOO afraid of him.

Seems to me like JR had only one real fear - the fear of failure.

Also when Edgar Randolph fired a shot at him, and seeing Katherine trying to stick a needle in Bobby at the hospital.

Swami
 

Herofan

Telly Talk Active Member
JR had money and power. As long as he had that, I don’t think he feared anyone that would go up against him in that manner. I do think JR was often squeamish when it came to a one on one that might end in physical confrontation. I recall when Mandy spotted the fellow that was following her. JR marched over there like he was going to put him in his place. JR talked tough for a second, but when the guy got firm, JR didn’t seem interested in pushing anything at that moment. He got McSween to handle it for him later.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
I think what JR feared the most wasn't people, it was not being in control.

He was happiest when he was manipulating people, even his family to get what he wanted.

That's why he had no qualms about re-mortgaging Southfork for instance.

He did what he had to do for the good of Ewing Oil as that was the one true love in his life.

Ewing Oil always came first. :)
 
Last edited:

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
So what do you think? Did JR really fear anyone?

The answer depends on by what context you're using the word "fear". Of course he was a human being so there were times and situations where he'd be afraid, either for himself or someone he cared about, such as in the Calhoun/John Ross situation. In general J.R. was not a physical man, his toughness came from his money and power. Bobby was the one who would beat you up if you crossed him, J.R. would be more likely to pay some "good ol' boys" to beat you up for him if you crossed him. Remember in the hunting trip with Jock, Bobby, and Ray, those were the ones ready and eager to get into a bar fight, J.R.'s first reaction was to hide his gold watch, and he just sat there. And of course he was terrified of Nicholas Pierce's father when he showed up with his armed goons to kidnap to get revenge for Nicholas' death. But who wouldn't be in that situation?

He definitely had what I'd call a respectful level of fear for Jock. Sure, he occasionally lied to and tried to sneak things past him, but that's because J.R. believed in the philosophy of the ends justify the means. Something he learned from Jock, who taught him plenty of his own dirty tricks (Jock tended to be lionized after Jim Davis' death, but I think it was always meant to be implied that Jock was also a ruthless businessman in his day), but as Jock once lamented the problem was he never taught J.R. went to, y'know, stop. So for example when J.R. went behind his parents backs to mortgage Southfork to buy those Asian oil field and at the last minute the deal worked and made the family richer than ever, in J.R.'s mind that justified what he did and he expected to be praised, but Jock was still mad because they almost lost Southfork and that's a line that even Jock would have never crossed.

I think Jeremy Wendell is the only business adversary that J.R. ever feared. But it was fear strictly in a business-sense. This was the one adversary that had even more money and power than J.R. and was even more single-minded, so J.R. knew he could cause him a lot of trouble (but this fear didn't extend to either Wilson Crider or Carter McKay when they ran WestStar, as they didn't share the same ruthlessness as Wendell). But he certainly wasn't scared of him in the traditional sense, as evidenced by his threat when Wendell took over Ewing Oil and was about to touch Jock's portrait. J.R. would have definitely beaten the old man to death.
​
The later seasons, for example seeing him go to a kangaroo court in Haleyville - in the show's peak that simply wouldn't have happened. Cally's brothers would have exited very swiftly.

Oh it still would have happened, it's just the aftermath would have been very different. Once he escaped jail and made it back to Dallas, the old J.R. would have immediately set out plotting his revenge. Cally's brother's, the Haleyville Sherriff who arrested him, the Justice of the Peace who sentenced him to jail, and the guard who brutalized him while he was in jail, would have all been specifically targeted for some vicious payback. And for good measure he would have likely destroyed the whole town of Haleyville too, like buy up all the land and kick everyone out and have it all paved over for a large shopping center or something.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
He definitely had what I'd call a respectful level of fear for Jock. Sure, he occasionally lied to and tried to sneak things past him, but that's because J.R. believed in the philosophy of the ends justify the means. Something he learned from Jock, who taught him plenty of his own dirty tricks (Jock tended to be lionized after Jim Davis' death, but I think it was always meant to be implied that Jock was also a ruthless businessman in his day), but as Jock once lamented the problem was he never taught J.R. went to, y'know, stop.

Which part of Dallas makes you think that "the ends justify the means" is something JR learned from Jock? I don't recall Jock teaching anything like that. He did tell JR that he had to "learn the art of subtlety" and to "leave a man some dignity." Those are very different lessons though, almost opposite from "the ends justify the means.

Had Jock believed the ends justify the means was the way to go, he'd have taught it to Bobby. He was Jock's favorite, after all. Matter of fact, when Bobby ended his run at Ewing Oil in season four and JR said to Jock that Bobby had lost them millions of dollars, Jock's response was not the anger JR hoped for but: "He showed people Ewing Oil stands for something. He's a hell of a son, a hell of a man."
 
Top