An honest opinion and I agree with you. Far too many TV Series today have sanitized male characters. Why is it the writers/producers are afraid to portray men as strong leaders? Jock was tough but when it came to his family, Miss Ellie in particular, he was a softy. I'd also want someone of Jock's stature in my corner at pub fight...and Donna!
You're right about a bunch of things here. Jock was sensitive towards Miss Ellie, especially when she was in trouble. When she had breast cancer he was visiting her so much at the hospital that Bobby and JR were afraid he wasn't sleeping at all! Miss Ellie was a very tough woman so it's only natural she married a tough man. The fact that their marriage was such a happy and successful marriage ad it lasted 40 years, until Jock died, is a testament that they were good to each other.
Regarding the main subject at hand, are you sure that what's causing this problem is writers and producers are afraid to portray men as strong, as tough, as rugged, and as leaders? What about that is scary? Hell, it's not scary, it's inspiring!
When it comes to that rugged, independent, highly driven man with lots of ambition, courage and toughness, I think of the roles that men like Clint Eastwood and John Wayne usually played. They were very believable in those types of roles and they were massive box office attractions as a result. Are writers/producers afraid of hiring an actor who could turn out to be another huge box office attraction and become not just a star but an icon? I would hope they're not afraid of that; I think they'd be ecstatic over such a find.
Maybe "find" is the key word. Maybe casting agents can't find an actor who has a rugged masculine image and therefore would be believable in a Jock Ewing type role. I asked why don't they just hire some young actors who are cut from the same cloth as men like Jim Davis or Clint Eastwood or John Wayne? I can't imagine they're afraid to since the result for those men was the companies those actors worked for made a ton of money off them - particularly Eastwood and John Wayne. So since the desire to find the next Eastwood or John Wayne ought to be there, and finding the next Jim Davis could mean that he'd play the next Jock Ewing which means there'd be "a next Dallas" which in itself would be awesome, why aren't they hiring those types of men?
There's only one answer I can think of right now that's somewhat believable (since being afraid of discovering the next American icon is irrational to say the least). I'm wondering if they just can't find any young actors who are cut from the same cloth as a man like Jim Davis. As I stated before, the men I've seen on modern TV shows tend to somehow be feminized! When I say that, I mean they're not rugged, they're not tough and they're not someone who you'd want in your corner in a bar fight. They're overly emotional, they're insecure and they're afraid of almost everything. They look like they've never bee in a fight in their lives.
If it's true that casting agents can't find any young actors who are cut from the same cloth as the actors I named, what is the cause for that? Is it that men who fit that description just aren't gravitated towards the acting business in this era? Possibly, but I doubt it. Why wouldn't they be gravitated towards an industry where you can become famous do something fun for money, and make a ton of money doing it?
Usually the expression "They don't make 'em like that anymore" is more figurative than literal. I suppose it would be in this case too After all, evolution doesn't occur fast enough for them to "not make men like that anymore." So it's not genetic. If not, then it's environmentally caused. Is it that we live in a sick society that is failing to produce tough, confident, ambitious, wise and rugged men? I don't know the answer to that. After all, they say art imitates life.
So if you and I agree that we don't see characters like Jock Ewing on TV anymore and that whole type of rugged, independent, inspiring man is gone from our TV screens is it because art is imitating life once again? That's a scary thought. Still, if that's true, and I stress "if" because I'm just supposing this may be the case, but if it's true, what exactly is the sickness in our society that's causing men to be feminized and what can be done to correct the problem so that we once again have a healthy society?