Was There Ever A Time When You Were Glad One Of The Original Ensemble Left Dallas?

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Dallas had a tremendous original cast. It was an ensemble filled with great talent. It was sad that Jim Davis passed away at a relatively young age because he was such an integral part of the show as well as for humanitarian reasons of course.

There was one actress that I believe was allowed to overstay her welcome, not for a lack of talent, but because they had done everything they could think of to do with her character so what they ended up doing is being extremely repetitive and ultimately destructive, having her appear in quite a number of extremely similar storylines.

The character I'm writing about is Sue Ellen. By season 8, DVD count, they had had Sue Ellen break up with JR and then get back together with him so many times that the sheer repetition had reached the point where I just din't find to interesting or fun to watch their relationship anymore. By around the middle of season 10, I not only didn't enjoy the constant cycle of break-up and make-up between Sue Ellen and JR but it was becoming really annoying. And by season 11 when she started having an affair with Nicholas Pearce while JR was having an affair with Kimberly Cryder, I found it nearly intolerable to watch Sue Ellen and JR continue to argue with each other and to hear from Sue Ellen that despite how bad of a husband JR was, she had no intention of leaving him. My reaction to that was: She's going to stay?!?! How bad would she have to be treated to leave? Wouldn't it be a lot smarter and more mature on her part to leave so that she'd be free to date and marry someone with whom she could actually enjoy her life?

A lot was made of her supposed growth in emotional strength and maturity and as far as her quitting drinking goes, that was a valid point. However, I believe it would have been much more satisfying to Linda Gray and the Dallas audience to show her mature to the point where she realized that the best revenge is living well. Instead of staying with JR just to try to make him miserable and forfeiting her ability to remarry to someone with whom she would have a chance to love and be loved in the process was damaging to her and immature but sadly there was another very negative aspect to it that doesn't seem to get addressed very often if at all.

That sad, even tragic element that arose in season eleven was demonstrated very well when she started having an affair with Nicholas Pearce. For years she had been wanting to leave JR because of his cheating on her with other women and the more chances she gave him to only end up being cheated on again taught her, or should have taught her that he was never going to change. They wasted a perfect opportunity to show true growth in Sue Ellen's character, an admirable change for the better, when instead of having her leave JR in season 8 or 10, displaying newfound maturity, emotional growth and having improved herself overall as a person, they instead hd her take the opposite path. Instead of having her refuse to sink to JR's level and opt for the high road, instead she chose to lower herself to JR's type of behavior by starting an affair with Nicholas Pearce who still married to JR, and affair she didn't even try to manage discreetly (the way both she and JR agreed to be discreet about their affairs when she moved back into Southfork in season 9 for the purpose of giving John Ross the opportunity olive with both of his parents).

Divorcing JR instead would have given Sue Ellen the opportunity to fully pursue a relationship with Nicholas Pearce to the utmost and would have made it possible for him to propose to her and for her to accept. It would have set a much better example for John Ross as well. He wouldn't have grown up thinking that a husband and wife in a constant state of animosity and turmoil was normal or the way things are supposed to be between a man and a woman who are married.

I believe that The Dallas series would have been better if they had avoided the mistakes I've described above and have had Sue Ellen choose more mature, healthier priorities for herself. It would have been admirable and satisfying to see her personal growth reach a level where she decided that living well is the best revenge, that nothing justifies staying in a loveless and painful marriage, and instead of having an affair with Nicholas Pearce since JR was having an affair with Kimberly, have her take the high road and say to herself, "I'm not going to become like JR for revenge or any other reason. I'm better than that and my life is too valuable to spend any more of it in a loveless, painful marriage. Giving myself the opportunity to be single so I can get married again to someone who is capable of making me happy, of loving and being loved, is infinitely more rewarding than staying with JR so I can try to make him miserable!"
 

Alexia

Telly Talk Fan
Dallas had a tremendous original cast. It was an ensemble filled with great talent. It was sad that Jim Davis passed away at a relatively young age because he was such an integral part of the show as well as for humanitarian reasons of course.

There was one actress that I believe was allowed to overstay her welcome, not for a lack of talent, but because they had done everything they could think of to do with her character so what they ended up doing is being extremely repetitive and ultimately destructive, having her appear in quite a number of extremely similar storylines.

The character I'm writing about is Sue Ellen. By season 8, DVD count, they had had Sue Ellen break up with JR and then get back together with him so many times that the sheer repetition had reached the point where I just din't find to interesting or fun to watch their relationship anymore. By around the middle of season 10, I not only didn't enjoy the constant cycle of break-up and make-up between Sue Ellen and JR but it was becoming really annoying. And by season 11 when she started having an affair with Nicholas Pearce while JR was having an affair with Kimberly Cryder, I found it nearly intolerable to watch Sue Ellen and JR continue to argue with each other and to hear from Sue Ellen that despite how bad of a husband JR was, she had no intention of leaving him. My reaction to that was: She's going to stay?!?! How bad would she have to be treated to leave? Wouldn't it be a lot smarter and more mature on her part to leave so that she'd be free to date and marry someone with whom she could actually enjoy her life?

A lot was made of her supposed growth in emotional strength and maturity and as far as her quitting drinking goes, that was a valid point. However, I believe it would have been much more satisfying to Linda Gray and the Dallas audience to show her mature to the point where she realized that the best revenge is living well. Instead of staying with JR just to try to make him miserable and forfeiting her ability to remarry to someone with whom she would have a chance to love and be loved in the process was damaging to her and immature but sadly there was another very negative aspect to it that doesn't seem to get addressed very often if at all.

That sad, even tragic element that arose in season eleven was demonstrated very well when she started having an affair with Nicholas Pearce. For years she had been wanting to leave JR because of his cheating on her with other women and the more chances she gave him to only end up being cheated on again taught her, or should have taught her that he was never going to change. They wasted a perfect opportunity to show true growth in Sue Ellen's character, an admirable change for the better, when instead of having her leave JR in season 8 or 10, displaying newfound maturity, emotional growth and having improved herself overall as a person, they instead hd her take the opposite path. Instead of having her refuse to sink to JR's level and opt for the high road, instead she chose to lower herself to JR's type of behavior by starting an affair with Nicholas Pearce who still married to JR, and affair she didn't even try to manage discreetly (the way both she and JR agreed to be discreet about their affairs when she moved back into Southfork in season 9 for the purpose of giving John Ross the opportunity olive with both of his parents).

Divorcing JR instead would have given Sue Ellen the opportunity to fully pursue a relationship with Nicholas Pearce to the utmost and would have made it possible for him to propose to her and for her to accept. It would have set a much better example for John Ross as well. He wouldn't have grown up thinking that a husband and wife in a constant state of animosity and turmoil was normal or the way things are supposed to be between a man and a woman who are married.

I believe that The Dallas series would have been better if they had avoided the mistakes I've described above and have had Sue Ellen choose more mature, healthier priorities for herself. It would have been admirable and satisfying to see her personal growth reach a level where she decided that living well is the best revenge, that nothing justifies staying in a loveless and painful marriage, and instead of having an affair with Nicholas Pearce since JR was having an affair with Kimberly, have her take the high road and say to herself, "I'm not going to become like JR for revenge or any other reason. I'm better than that and my life is too valuable to spend any more of it in a loveless, painful marriage. Giving myself the opportunity to be single so I can get married again to someone who is capable of making me happy, of loving and being loved, is infinitely more rewarding than staying with JR so I can try to make him miserable!"

Great post!! I agree with most of what you wrote!!:clap:
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Kenny Coyote said:
I believe that The Dallas series would have been better if they had avoided the mistakes I've described above and have had Sue Ellen choose more mature, healthier priorities for herself. It would have been admirable and satisfying to see her personal growth reach a level where she decided that living well is the best revenge.
And she eventually did just that. But Sue Ellen was never just going to wake up and say, "My God, I'm healthy!" and really mean it overnight. If she did, she would have left Southfork and Dallas immediately.

It was more in character for Sue Ellen to "flip" the sadomasochistic dynamic once she was in a position of relative power for the first time, and not abandon the sick situation in Texas until she got bored with it and then decide there was something more out there for her. Which is what she did.

JR can't be the only character who acts like a jerk, after all.

jr-and-sue-ellen.jpg
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Great post!! I agree with most of what you wrote!!:clap:

Thank you, Alexia! They talk about how the best dramas , even if some call them nighttime soap operas" have characters that are realistic. Well, the inspiration for one of the points I made came from a dear friend of mine, a lady I've known for quite some time, and whom I really respect a lot of her life decisions. The following is all based directly on my friend, so it's as realistic as it gets since this actually happened and worked out for the best in my opinion and hers as well. To make a long story short:

She got pregnant from a boyfriend with whom she had been living with for about two years. She had the baby but didn't marry him. They did continue to live together of course and he helped her take care of the baby if I remember correctly. But after a while her boyfriend began to change. He began to get jealous of the time she spent wither newborn son. Talk about insecure!

He was especially jealous of the time she spent breastfeeding their son and told her: "If you don;t stop spending so damn much time with him, I'm gonna leave you"! My friend simply replied by pointing and saying "There's the door. Bye"!

He didn't leave her but from then on they started fighting over everything imaginable.Most of their fights were over very petty things - not major incidents at all. One night he was really laying into her with the criticism and he snapped. She jumped om his back from behind and started punching his head and face repeatedly. Fortunately he didn't fight back; he just got her off of him and left their home for a few hours.

It was just a short time after that, a fw weeks or at most, 2 or 3 months when she took her baby boy and left her boyfriend. Here's where the story gets deep as far as I'm concerned:

I asked her if she left him because of his jealousy of the time she spent with the baby and she said no,not exactly. I asked her if she left him because of him physically attacking her and she said, "No, he's never hit me." So I asked her: "What was the main reason you left the guy you'd been living with for about 4 years and is the father of your son"? My friend replied very eloquently. She said: I'm a very nonviolent person. I decided anybody who could make me so mad that I'd jump up on his back and start punch and clawing at his face is somebody it isn't healthy for me to be around. But there was na even bigger reason and it's that I didn't want my son to grow up thinking that the way my relationship was with my ex-boyfriend, always fighting all the time, was the way that a loving relationship between a man and a woman is supposed to be." Wow! What a mature and beautiful reason!
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
And she eventually did just that. But Sue Ellen was never just going to wake up and say, "My God, I'm healthy!" and really mean it overnight. If she did, she would have left Southfork and Dallas immediately.

It was more in character for Sue Ellen to "flip" the sadomasochistic dynamic once she was in a position of relative power for the first time, and not abandon the sick situation in Texas until she got bored with it and then decide there was something more out there for her. Which is what she did.

JR can't be the only character who acts like a jerk, after all.

jr-and-sue-ellen.jpg

I agree that "JR can't be the only character who acts like a jerk, after all." There needs to be at last one more jerk. I thought that's what Cliff Barnes was for! ;o)
 

TJames03

Banned
Lucy, for me! Nothing against CT (and the writers really did seem as though they tried to find story lines for her), but the "Hot Biscuit" sh=t was inane.

Regarding Sue Ellen, she was one of the most useless and pathetic characters ever to be on a serial. By '84, she and JR were beyond rote and it was painful (once again, nothing against the actress).
 

Presea

Telly Talk Addict
Lucy, for me! Nothing against CT (and the writers really did seem as though they tried to find story lines for her), but the "Hot Biscuit" sh=t was inane.

Regarding Sue Ellen, she was one of the most useless and pathetic characters ever to be on a serial. By '84, she and JR were beyond rote and it was painful (once again, nothing against the actress).
And the worst part was when they just started randomly throwing Lucy into a couple of scenes for about two minutes in the later seasons. She had no storylines, period. I heard that Charlene Tilton didn't want to leave after season 8 (dvd), so when they let her come back, it was almost like the people in charge were saying "Hey, you're the one who wanted to come back, so don't complain about your lack of airtime and s*** storylines!" It was truly sad.

Overall, I didn't mind Sue Ellen, but her repetitive break-up storylines with JR got boring for me. It was like this: JR cheats, Sue Ellen gets mad and refuses to sleep with him and they have several little bitchy bedroom quarrels that stop being funny after a point, JR and Sue Ellen make up and have a ton of make-up sex with no real communication and Sue Ellen's screen time even gets reduced sometimes, JR cheats again, and then the whole process repeats all over again! It got old fast, and it reminded me horribly of a co-dependent relationship that a friend of mine had.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Bobby.

I believe his departure in "Swan Song" was just the shot in the arm Dallas needed. By this point the repetition in Bobby and JR fighting for Ewing Oil was beginning to wane. His death was just what I was hoping for to propel the story further, only because so many scenarios involving our beloved characters would have intensified. I was really looking forward to the following season and see what the writers had installed for Miss Ellie, Clayton, JR, Sue Ellen, Pam, Jenna, Ray, Donna and Lucy. The story could have went in any direction. Most importantly I desperately held hope the writers would take JR to a very dark place. A man full of hate and revenge. By the time of Bobby's death I was getting a little tired of JR's winning smile freeze framing the end of an episode. The "love to hate" relationship the audience had with JR was beginning to tip over to the comic side that crept into Dallas, which I didn't appreciate.

After a recent viewing of Lorimar Dallas I realized the producers were careful when filming on location to avoid any weather events, though it was fun on occasion hearing rolling thunder in the distance. When Dallas returns the following season after Bobby's death I would have like to see a storm or heavy rain event over Southfork to inform the audience we're in for a rocky time.
 

Presea

Telly Talk Addict
Bobby.

I believe his departure in "Swan Song" was just the shot in the arm Dallas needed. By this point the repetition in Bobby and JR fighting for Ewing Oil was beginning to wane. His death was just what I was hoping for to propel the story further, only because so many scenarios involving our beloved characters would have intensified. I was really looking forward to the following season and see what the writers had installed for Miss Ellie, Clayton, JR, Sue Ellen, Pam, Jenna, Ray, Donna and Lucy. The story could have went in any direction. Most importantly I desperately held hope the writers would take JR to a very dark place. A man full of hate and revenge. By the time of Bobby's death I was getting a little tired of JR's winning smile freeze framing the end of an episode. The "love to hate" relationship the audience had with JR was beginning to tip over to the comic side that crept into Dallas, which I didn't appreciate.

After a recent viewing of Lorimar Dallas I realized the producers were careful when filming on location to avoid any weather events, though it was fun on occasion hearing rolling thunder in the distance. When Dallas returns the following season after Bobby's death I would have like to see a storm or heavy rain event over Southfork to inform the audience we're in for a rocky time.
And the worst part was that it eventually turned into this: JR and Bobby: Welcome to the JR and Bobby Show!! JR: Where I, will lose a large portion of my IQ and eventually turn into a complete and utter failure who loses to just about everybody, and marry a girl who is less than half my age so we can have a parody of a marriage! Bobby: And I, will continue to bed hop around Dallas as I pursue my ultimately meaningless love life! JR: This is gonna be great, Bob! Bobby: Of course, JR! As long as it's us, all of the fans will absolutely love it!
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
There wasn't an original core cast member that I didn't miss when they were gone.

But the way the show survives such absences is by making that character's exit and absence into a character in itself -- so the audience can adjust while watching the remaining family members adjust.

DALLAS did a decent job of that when Jock and Bobby were gone. Not so much with Pam. And Sue Ellen's exit was less jarring because the show was in its final chapters anyway.


Regarding Sue Ellen, she was one of the most useless and pathetic characters ever to be on a serial. By '84, she and JR were beyond rote and it was painful (once again, nothing against the actress).
But her uselessness was what made her useful. You weren't necessarily suppose to like Sue Ellen or even be sympathetic to her narcissistic suffering, but her hang-ups and lust sick relationship with JR told the viewer a lot about JR's issues and what life at Southfork was about.

And let's face it: you can never have too much of this:

Starta-dagen-med-en-shot.jpg
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
"...and I'm gonna throw you out!"
Man, Sue Ellen was unlikable back then however that is exactly what I loved about her. Raised to marry wealth she had it in the form of the Ewing family. She was well respected in Dallas society with her charity involvements. But behind the scenes she was a drunk. It was obvious she loved JR but knew of his mistresses. Sue Ellen's womb was aching to incubate a Ewing heir, if only she could bed JR long enough to secure his swimmers.
 

Presea

Telly Talk Addict
Man, Sue Ellen was unlikable back then however that is exactly what I loved about her. Raised to marry wealth she had it in the form of the Ewing family. She was well respected in Dallas society with her charity involvements. But behind the scenes she was a drunk. It was obvious she loved JR but knew of his mistresses. Sue Ellen's womb was aching to incubate a Ewing heir, if only she could bed JR long enough to secure his swimmers.
The puzzling part was how Sue Ellen suddenly turned into a completely different character in season 5 (dvd). All of the sudden, the delightfully bitchy lady of the manor turns into someone who is overly needy, clingy, all of the sudden good pals with Pam and Miss Ellie, makes facial twitches and stutters almost every two seconds, and struggles with living alone and managing her own finances. Were they afraid that we thought Sue Ellen seemed too mean or something when they made her like that?
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Bobby.

I believe his departure in "Swan Song" was just the shot in the arm Dallas needed. By this point the repetition in Bobby and JR fighting for Ewing Oil was beginning to wane. His death was just what I was hoping for to propel the story further, only because so many scenarios involving our beloved characters would have intensified. I was really looking forward to the following season and see what the writers had installed for Miss Ellie, Clayton, JR, Sue Ellen, Pam, Jenna, Ray, Donna and Lucy. The story could have went in any direction. Most importantly I desperately held hope the writers would take JR to a very dark place. A man full of hate and revenge. By the time of Bobby's death I was getting a little tired of JR's winning smile freeze framing the end of an episode. The "love to hate" relationship the audience had with JR was beginning to tip over to the comic side that crept into Dallas, which I didn't appreciate.

After a recent viewing of Lorimar Dallas I realized the producers were careful when filming on location to avoid any weather events, though it was fun on occasion hearing rolling thunder in the distance. When Dallas returns the following season after Bobby's death I would have like to see a storm or heavy rain event over Southfork to inform the audience we're in for a rocky time.

Taking JR "to a very dark place" and turning him into a man full of hate and revenge" would have been a big mistake in my opinion. I think the popularity of The JR Ewing character was that even though he was capable of doing some very underhanded deeds, he still always had enough redeeming qualities and in general a likability which made him unique from typical TV "bad guys." People loved the freeze frames of JR's smile at the end of episodes. They liked and respected JR for being such a good father. They liked and respected him because he loved his parents, John Ross, Bobby and was an extremely competent businessman. Speaking of Bobby, he physically threatened JR more times than I can remember. JR never physically threatened Bobby. He loved Bobby too much to even consider trying to physically injure him.

JR had a lot of understated, positive qualities. A great example of one happened during a conversation JR and Bobby had in the exercise room, if I remember correctly. It was a conversation where JR was telling Bobby that Bobby, Pam and Christopher would be better off if Bobby didn't go after custody of Jenna's baby. JR pointed out that certainly Pam and Christopher would be happier without Jenna's baby in their lives. Bobby replied, "Maybe you're just worried that that baby adds up to one more Ewing heir." The scene ended with JR saying to Bobby: "Bobby this may come as a surprise to you but not all of my motives are selfish. Maybe sometimes yours are." Powerful!
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Taking JR "to a very dark place" and turning him into a man full of hate and revenge" would have been a big mistake in my opinion. I think the popularity of The JR Ewing character was that even though he was capable of doing some very underhanded deeds, he still always had enough redeeming qualities and in general a likability which made him unique from typical TV "bad guys." People loved the freeze frames of JR's smile at the end of episodes. They liked and respected JR for being such a good father. They liked and respected him because he loved his parents, John Ross, Bobby and was an extremely competent businessman. Speaking of Bobby, he physically threatened JR more times than I can remember. JR never physically threatened Bobby. He loved Bobby too much to even consider trying to physically injure him.

JR had a lot of understated, positive qualities. A great example of one happened during a conversation JR and Bobby had in the exercise room, if I remember correctly. It was a conversation where JR was telling Bobby that Bobby, Pam and Christopher would be better off if Bobby didn't go after custody of Jenna's baby. JR pointed out that certainly Pam and Christopher would be happier without Jenna's baby in their lives. Bobby replied, "Maybe you're just worried that that baby adds up to one more Ewing heir." The scene ended with JR saying to Bobby: "Bobby this may come as a surprise to you but not all of my motives are selfish. Maybe sometimes yours are." Powerful!
But you have to realize that not everybody sees JR in the inflated, glorified way that you do.
 

KayLloyd

Telly Talk Addict
Taking JR "to a very dark place" and turning him into a man full of hate and revenge" would have been a big mistake in my opinion. I think the popularity of The JR Ewing character was that even though he was capable of doing some very underhanded deeds, he still always had enough redeeming qualities and in general a likability which made him unique from typical TV "bad guys." People loved the freeze frames of JR's smile at the end of episodes. They liked and respected JR for being such a good father. They liked and respected him because he loved his parents, John Ross, Bobby and was an extremely competent businessman. Speaking of Bobby, he physically threatened JR more times than I can remember. JR never physically threatened Bobby. He loved Bobby too much to even consider trying to physically injure him.

JR had a lot of understated, positive qualities. A great example of one happened during a conversation JR and Bobby had in the exercise room, if I remember correctly. It was a conversation where JR was telling Bobby that Bobby, Pam and Christopher would be better off if Bobby didn't go after custody of Jenna's baby. JR pointed out that certainly Pam and Christopher would be happier without Jenna's baby in their lives. Bobby replied, "Maybe you're just worried that that baby adds up to one more Ewing heir." The scene ended with JR saying to Bobby: "Bobby this may come as a surprise to you but not all of my motives are selfish. Maybe sometimes yours are." Powerful!


J.R. was certainly unique. I tend to agree with Rove. J.R. was much more interesting when we saw flashes of his vulnerability. A storyline of him moving heaven and earth to track down and prosecute Katherine for killing Bobby, and Pam having to process the emotional roller coaster of Katherine's trial with Cliff's help, would have been quite compelling. It was the logical path for the writers to go down and it never made sense to me that they didn't pursue it.

J.R. didn't physically threaten Bobby because he was bright enough to know that Bobby could kick his ass any day of the week, so blackmail was the safer way to go .

I'd say that J.R's bad qualities far outweighed his decent ones, but he did have his moments every now and then.
.
 
Last edited:

KayLloyd

Telly Talk Addict
The puzzling part was how Sue Ellen suddenly turned into a completely different character in season 5 (dvd). All of the sudden, the delightfully bitchy lady of the manor turns into someone who is overly needy, clingy, all of the sudden good pals with Pam and Miss Ellie, makes facial twitches and stutters almost every two seconds, and struggles with living alone and managing her own finances. Were they afraid that we thought Sue Ellen seemed too mean or something when they made her like that?

I agree, SE was at her best when she was making snide comments about people that she felt superior to. Her line at the breakfast table about how that Jenna Wade is truly amazing the way she goes from man to man and the look that Bobby gives her is priceless.
 
Top