What if Deborah Shelton and Jennilee Harrison would have refused to come back

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
Yes, I think the dream solution still would’ve been used if Deborah or Jennilee (or both) did not return. I don’t think either character was major enough for them to not go in the direction they did. They probably just would’ve written them out by other means. J.R. goes to Mandys condo to find out she skipped town and he finds a note, Jamie decides to move back to Alaska, etc. If they had to be abruptly written out it would’ve been something like that imo and the dream resolution would’ve continued without them.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
It seems like there was another thread a while back where we talked about this.

Honestly, fans had already made peace with the exit of those characters, so as @DallasFanForever said, they could have been written out and it wouldn't have been too jarring for viewers. Neither character was crucial to the plot. Mandy could have been replaced with any other actress as JR's mistress and Jamie was a "wanderer" anyway so it would have made sense that she just picked up and left town.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
I think they would have killed Jamie off screen because they wanted to continue the storyline of Cliff inheriting her share of wing Oil. Writing Mandy out would have required a bit more creativity but the old soap opera classic of a hitherto unmentioned mother become sick and Mandy tells JR in a phone conservation (that we only see his half of) that she has to go away suddenly to look after her would have worked.
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
It might have been better if they had used one of those solutions anyway. Bringing Jamie back and killing her again was just one more jarring slap at the viewers.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
Jamie dying twice did kind of stretch the imagination a little for me but I’m guessing they felt that was the way to go so Cliff could legally get his hands on her share of Ewing Oil. It makes sense in that respect but yes it was overkill (no pun intended)
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I have a TV Guide article lying somewhere around, from the summer of 1986. Deborah is quoted as saying how Bobby coming back to the show “saved” her. She basically gave away the resolution to Bobby in the shower.
 
Last edited:

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
Jamie dying twice did kind of stretch the imagination a little for me but I’m guessing they felt that was the way to go so Cliff could legally get his hands on her share of Ewing Oil. It makes sense in that respect but yes it was overkill (no pun intended)
In a lot of ways they just did the plots they wanted to do, dream or not; Sue Ellen still getting revenge on JR even if they changed her motivation, Cliff getting his hands on Jamie's shares and of course they just changed Ben to Wes but kept the Jock plot.
 
Considering Dallas was a number 1 rated show around the world - I wouldnt want to leave and Id be rather keen to return If i were them to a top rated show, getting a good pay cheque and getting my face on TV around the world and raising my profile.

I think Mr Katzman and Hagman were always keen for Mandy/Deborah to be on the show ;) Wonder why? :)

I always felt they werent in the same league/boat as Kristin, Katherine, Afton
 
Top