What if John Ross had been Cliff’s child?

Ukdallasfan

Telly Talk Fan
I’m new to this site but loving it already, so please forgive me if this has been posted already. I remember watching the big reveal episode and thinking there’s no way that the baby could be JR’s. The story had been written, convincingly, that JR barely touched Sue Ellen but then Cliff came along and six weeks later- boom!
If the blood test had gone the other way (thank goodness for the subsequent discovery of DNA) there would have been total disaster. Cliff didn’t want Sue Ellen, in my opinion, and it was debatable how committed he would be to his child. In fairness to JR he had a real wish for a son and Sue Ellen meant enough to him that he was never willing to let her go. The reveal episode was, for me, one of the strongest. Humour with the knowing lawyer, Harve, and then Sue Ellen quashing Cliff’s downfall on the ground that it was only what a true lady would do. Absolute classic. Interested to know what you super fans think :)
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
It would have changed a lot. There's no way a man like JR Ewing would raise his most hated rival's son or stay married to the woman who had given birth to him. JR said if the baby was Cliff's then he was going to let Sue Ellen walk the streets without a dime and I believe he would have. Maybe then Cliff marries Sue Ellen. I think at some point JR would have married someone else. JR seemed to like the idea of marriage even though he wasn't cut out to be married.

Would the show have worked out as well as it did? I'll let other people speculate on that. I'm sure it would have been a problem for the people who liked the idea of seeing JR and Sue Ellen together. That was never a make or break factor for me; JR could have had any wife and I would have watched it anyway. I was drawn to the show for other reasons - the family aspect of it, JR, the Barnes-Ewing feud, and of course the poolside scenes with Victoria Principal.
 
Last edited:

Ukdallasfan

Telly Talk Fan
I agree that the writers had to make the baby JR’s. The dysfunctional relationship between him and Sue Ellen was too good in terms of drama to throw away. I loved the big pause from Harve before he announced the outcome of the first blood test and the way that Sue Ellen and Bobby looked at each other. Then the relief for JR was funny. I think, had it gone the other way, that JR would have bounced Sue Ellen and the baby out of Southfork and let them take their chances with Cliff, which would have been interesting, although I sense disastrous in the end. Cliff was way too cheap for her and she would have become tired of his little condo and take out food. Whether JR would truly have been able to let her go completely is another matter. He always told her that she belonged to him :)
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I agree that the writers had to make the baby JR’s. The dysfunctional relationship between him and Sue Ellen was too good in terms of drama to throw away. I loved the big pause from Harve before he announced the outcome of the first blood test and the way that Sue Ellen and Bobby looked at each other. Then the relief for JR was funny. I think, had it gone the other way, that JR would have bounced Sue Ellen and the baby out of Southfork and let them take their chances with Cliff, which would have been interesting, although I sense disastrous in the end. Cliff was way too cheap for her and she would have become tired of his little condo and take out food. Whether JR would truly have been able to let her go completely is another matter. He always told her that she belonged to him :)

I specifically remember JR telling her that if the baby was Cliff's, he'd get the quickest divorce in Texas history and let her walk the streets without a dime. Granted, it's fiction, and at the push of a pen, they could have anything happen, but I'm going to go with what I observed. I agree that Cliff was not going to be willing to give Sue Ellen the nice lifestyle she had become used to, but if she valued that lifestyle, she should have taken to steps to ensure she wouldn't lose it, such as not seeing Clif personally at all. My suggestion to her would be to run from that marriage and never look back! Their marriage looked like an absolute nightmare to me! Fun for people to watch of they enjoy that, but not fun for someone in a marriage resembling it.

I also have another reason why I believe JR would have immediately divorced Sue Ellen. It goes back to that policy Bobby had of never wanting to sleep with any woman who ever slept with a man JR slept with. Bobby said "any woman JR touches, he fouls." I've gotta think that JR would have had a similar attitude in the sense of, if Cliff had impregnated his wife, then Sue Ellen would be permanently fouled in JR's eyes. I just don't see a man like JR willing to put up with being married to a woman who let his hated rival get her pregnant. It goes against what I know of the character. Again, it's fiction, so they could have had whatever they wanted happen. Those are just my guesses based on what I saw of the character of JR.

That's all I can base it on: what I saw of the show. I could say what I'd do, but it would have nothing to do with the show, and who here cares what I would do? Ha ha!

Oh, by the way, I see you're fairly new here, so welcome to the forum! I'm Kenny Coyote and watched Dallas from 1980 until it ended and then later saw the first three seasons. I started watching just before we found out Kristin shot JR. When did you start watching? My favorite characters are Jock, JR, Pam and April.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
JR would have destroyed Cliff totally, thereby reducing the possibilities for Cliff bouncing back, as he tended to do after every defeat at JR's hands. Plus Sue Ellen had already seen that Cliff had used her, so I'm not sure she would have paired up with him long-term.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
JR would have destroyed Cliff totally, thereby reducing the possibilities for Cliff bouncing back, as he tended to do after every defeat at JR's hands. Plus Sue Ellen had already seen that Cliff had used her, so I'm not sure she would have paired up with him long-term.

Swami

What? Sue Ellen turn down an opportunity to be abused? I guess anything's possible.
 

Ukdallasfan

Telly Talk Fan
Thanks for the insightful responses. Yes, I’m new to this. Found it by accident but enjoying the debates and the information. I didn’t watch the mini series when it first aired but I remember my mum telling me that there was this really good show on BBC1. I think the first episode I watched properly involved Lucy going missing. Can’t tell you what season that was now- getting old.
Later, I went back to the parts I’d missed. It was a massive part of my teenage years. All my friends watched it even though the content wasn’t always appropriate for younger teens as we were when we first began watching it. But, it was on at 8pm. My favourite characters were always JR and Sue Ellen. Maybe I have always rooted for them to be happy together although I did enjoy the barbed and horrid remarks they made to each other. I also liked Bobby and Pam, especially when Pam did something that really annoyed JR, like smuggling John Ross out to Sue Ellen. To be honest, I loved all the original cast, together with Donna and Clayton who came in later. What’s show! There’s never been another like it, at least not for me. I never became invested in Knots Landing but I did enjoy Falcon Crest. Thanks for the welcome to the forum. I’m going to plough through some of the stories too, when I have time. Stay safe and healthy all :)
 

Michelle Stevens

'The Lovely Michelle'
Welcome @Ukdallasfan. :welcome:

I do think it would have been an error to have John Ross as Cliff's child. It would have ruined Sue Ellen's role in the Ewing family and I can't imagine what would have happened to her as the years passed. JR would likely have to find a new wife to have his heir and their (JR/Sue Ellen) special dynamic would have been lost.

What if John Ross had been Ray’s child?

What if John Ross III was Digger's child!!! :jk: Think about that one for a second. :eek:
 

southfork88

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
In hindsight, it's surprising that wasn't flagged up as a possibility, after all Sue Ellen and Ray did have that one-night stand.

Swami

At that time genetic testing was not so precise. And, after all, Ray was J.R.'s half-brother, although this detail was not known to anyone. So more statistical probabilities Ray and J.R. were genetically more similar than Cliff Barnes.
 
Top