The above lines and Amazon's generic image of a figure in a dark hoody (with a backdrop of Helen Hunt and her family looking concerned) were all I had to go on.
This has been in my watchlist for a long time, but somehow there was always another film that was preferable. I was expecting some kind of procedural with a bit of community drama... slow paced with with strong performances. And that is, indeed, what was delivered... but it came with a whole lot more, and was all the better for it.
Because of the non-linear way in which the story unfolded, the film's genre was very difficult to pinpoint. Is it a ghost story, a mystery, a home invasion film a story of losing the plot or a film about The Enemy Within? The short answer is "Yes". It's kind of everything, except when it's not.
I'd describe this as a skein. It started off slow and ambiguous, but dragged me in and fascinated me with each shift. At some point in the final act, I reflected that it was so twisty it had felt rather like watching an entire season of a drama series in the space of ninety minutes . And not only did it deliver in its "season finale", it also never felt rushed at any point, which is remarkable.
Helen Hunt was my main reason for watching. My only reason, really. I'm sure I'd have skipped it if she weren't present, but she's such a fine actress I could watch her in a bad film and still find something to enjoy (has she made any bad films? Perhaps I'm only familiar with the hits). She is terrific here, but I found her performance surprisingly passive, which I'm sure is deliberate given what's going on here. I liked the subtlety of her character's sedative dependency. We only really see her taking a couple of pills in one sequence - and even there it's not given voice - but much of her dialogue is delivered with borderline slurring. It never becomes a thing or escalates to a denouement. It's simply who this character is. At one point I forgot about it and thought Helen Hunt herself was having a bad day. It's typical of how she embodies a character.
All the other actors were unfamiliar to me, and I loved how the film subverted my expectations based on first impressions with almost all of them. At a very specific point, it stops and goes back to fill in some gaps, showing scenes from a different perspective. This is achieved by introducing what feels like the two most annoying characters on the planet, and I wrote them off almost immediately... until I spent some time with them. This is a film where nothing is quite what it seems, and I didn't have the luxury of becoming attached to ideas about particular characters. The shifts made the investment worthwhile.
I feel it may be inevitable to predict some of the turns, so I won't give the film a hard time over those theories I held that turned out to be correct. What mattered was at what point I guessed. My partner had spotted a significant clue I'd missed in an early scene which didn't mean anything to him until the scene was reframed much later. And from this, I feel it's a film where one could rewatch once the full context is known and spot hundreds of details that were missed the first time round.
Also, I'd never heard of phrogging, and you can be sure steps will be taken to ensure it doesn't take place in my house.
When I said about watching certain scenes in isolation, I was thinking of the scene in the cabin with the axe. It was so histrionic and almost overwrought, if watched without context it would read as B-movie camp.
I'm actually glad. I tried to be relatively non-specific in a lot of my comments so as not to spoil it should... someone.... wish to watch it.
While I've never seen Inside No. 9, I am familiar with The League Of Gentlemen from the same team, and I can see that kind of tone here. I definitely get the Killer Bob vibes (but that hadn't clicked until you said).
The launch of home VCRs made for interesting times. Up to that point, audiences could be managed by The Powers That Be, through age restrictions at the cinema (albeit they were reliant on the vigilance of the ticket sellers and whether or not someone could "pass" for a certain age) or by scheduling on TV, where horror would be restricted to generally after 9 or 10pm, when the vast majority of children would be in bed.
But suddenly any adult could rent a film and show it to an audience of any age at any time, so I can understand some of the concern.
There's been a similar conversation with the internet more recently (although, surprisingly, it's taken a lot longer to address than video nasties). And even our pleasant little corner of the interglobe has been affected by some of those changes.
So glad you enjoyed it, Willie.