What went wrong -- and right -- with DALLAS?

Jock Ewing Fan

Telly Talk Star
If I had been in charge, I would have made Sue Ellen marry Clayton. He dies of heart attack and she inherits all his money. Her drinking and catting around, she marries a gold digger who swindles it all- JR to the rescue!

In those early years, I'd have introduced Granny Ewing, estranged mother of Jock who constantly undermines Miss Ellie. SHe moves in for a few years after Jock dies. She treated JR like a king, her favorite.

Lucy and Mitch marry, but Mitch has a gambling addiction. Lucy dumps him after some high trouble and becomes a lawyer.

The introduction of the Ewing cousins was great, but they needed to blend in more. Jamie Ewing should have been a tad closer to JR's age- she comes to town and worships the ground he walks on- JR has a new protege. Jack is a gambler/drunk, fills the void left by Gary's old ways. AND JASON is alive. Just like old times, they talk of the reunion he and Jock had, the argument was seen in The Early Years, before their years of separation.

Getting rid of Jena sooner.
Not killing off Bobby in a permanent way.
I would have introduced a Ewing from Jock/Amanda. Could have led to some interesting family dynamics with JR, Bobby, Ray and Cliff could have formed an alliance with him/her. I guess Cliff/Jamie was a version of that
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I haven't read this thread in several years -- will I still like and agree with it?

aaewingssouthfork.jpg
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I often return to older threads and ask myself, " Did I write that? " It's why I wish Warner Bros would make an official announcement if they will release Dallas on Blu-Ray or not as I think my outlook criticisms on those later seasons of Dallas will change with enhanced quality.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I wondered if your views had changed at all, if you still liked this thread and agreed with it as you hadn't read it for some time.

Probably. Let me go re-read it.

I often return to older threads and ask myself, " Did I write that? " It's why I wish Warner Bros would make an official announcement if they will release Dallas on Blu-Ray or not as I think my outlook criticisms on those later seasons of Dallas will change with enhanced quality.

I'm desperate to see Season 10 (per DVD count blahblahblah) in the new HD version -- despite the controversial scene which opens the year, it's one of the most re-watchable seasons. Yes, it gets a little self-parodic, but it gets the balance right and doesn't go too far with it.

It's like DALLAS' ghostly farewell ... post-Mis-Ellie, post-dream... Only now, it will be a little less ghostly without that 1986 Telepictures video blur.

1986barbecue-jpg.42865
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I wondered if your views had changed at all, if you still liked this thread and agreed with it as you hadn't read it for some time.

Probably. Let me go re-read it.

It's hard for me to re-read because some of my apostrophes were deleted in the transition. So I might have to just listen to it via my "read allowed" feature.

At first glance, I appear a little over-harsh on Victoria's acting (because she just improved so much after her first four years!). But, yes, from most of what I see I still seem to agree with myself.

06698f20aceade4c03666d3736ef65c2--dallas.jpg
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
The loss of Bobby (for me anyway) wasn't as jarring as when the series lost Pam just two years later, that was a big big loss in a long line of losses (Donna, Ray, Jenna, Miss Ellie and Clayton) but while JR was the pulse of Dallas Pam was the spirit of the show, who kept going strength to strength season after season until season 10 when she's forced to take a backseat role for Bobby, even in the early seasons Pam never took a backseat role, this was such a massive retrograde for the character it was no wonder VP left in the end, I think had PD not returned I think VP would've stayed on for one more season at least

Bobby's departure was perfect timing, his character had reached a natural end in 1985, everyone around him was moving on and he seemed to be in some sort of existential crisis all season.

There was one mistake early Dallas made, wasting Lucy's potential, Lucy should've been motivated by a desire to do what her father couldn't do: beat JR, and had they introduced James Beaumont circa 1981/82 there could've been fireworks and a rivalry between the two cousins, but instead they had her sitting by the pool marry some jerk, divorce the jerk only to remarry the same jerk two years later then divorce the jerk again three years later, have her dabble in art (something which she never showed any interest in during her first go round on the show) then leave again, after wasting her potential for the second time! and they let her replacement Jamie Ewing take the storylines Lucy should've had.
Lucy should have been a carbon copy of JR. He had the most influence on her, the mere mention of her drunk daddy would send her into a rage. I would have went that route, she adores JR and helps him in his schemes.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
Lucy should have been a carbon copy of JR. He had the most influence on her, the mere mention of her drunk daddy would send her into a rage. I would have went that route, she adores JR and helps him in his schemes.
It’s better than the same storylines that were constantly recycled for her over and over. Lucy acting more like the Lucy from the miniseries and aligning with J.R. in his schemes would’ve given her much more to do at the very least.
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
It’s better than the same storylines that were constantly recycled for her over and over. Lucy acting more like the Lucy from the miniseries and aligning with J.R. in his schemes would’ve given her much more to do at the very least.
Yes, she is his defacto daughter. He raises, and influences her out of spite of Gary. Too bad we didn't get a second prequel film- one that covered the middle years- the JR Gary conflict, Gary's teen bride and the birth of Lucy.
 

Jock Ewing Fan

Telly Talk Star
So much can be explored

Pam's departure weakened the central theme of the Barnes-Ewing feud,
and Cliff seemed without direction afterward.

Cliff's (temporary?) realization that Jock didn't cheat Digger - A mistake, IMHO
Dallas had a good dynamic when there was at least some question about it to explore.
This was part of a rewrite that made Jock above reproach, a big mistake.
Jock was a tough man in a tough business.
He wasn't necessarily good or bad, he would have done whatever he needed to do to
keep Ewing Oil profitable.
He probably saw Bobby as the representation of his better nature, and
Bobby had the luxury of being more ethical, since
Jock and JR handled the heavy lifting before he was running/co-running Ewing Oil.
Of course, Bobby was not above playing hardball when it suited him,
but not to the same extent, in general.
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Excellent article! I can't disagree with anything.
The first 8 seasons are it's most entertaining and aside from Jamie miscast, things were good. An interesting point about Donna Reed coming in as another character. Certainly they could have found a Southworth cousin to fill the void while Ellie was away, but they likely felt BBG was not interested in returning.
I can enjoy the show all they up through Pam's exit. I'm struggling to watch 11. I won't likely won't bother with the rest.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
I can enjoy the show all they up through Pam's exit. I'm struggling to watch 11. I won't likely won't bother with the rest.
11 isn’t bad. It has its strong points but there are also a lot of moments where you start to realize the glory days are over. The mummy debacle, Katherine returning and then gone just as quickly, it’s all very frustrating. I actually enjoy Nicholas’s story this season but ultimately to a lot of people I know it feels like a storyline that isn’t quite Dallas.
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
11 isn’t bad. It has its strong points but there are also a lot of moments where you start to realize the glory days are over. The mummy debacle, Katherine returning and then gone just as quickly, it’s all very frustrating. I actually enjoy Nicholas’s story this season but ultimately to a lot of people I know it feels like a storyline that isn’t quite Dallas.
True! Why didn't they have Katherine kidnap her, then she's returned and it's Margret Michaels? Bobby is reluctant to search for her, at first thinking she left on her own, but the story doesn't add up, realizing Katherine likes to write phony notes! Anything would have worked better.
 
Last edited:

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Let's see me write a better storyline than Leonard HACK Katzman.

In an alternative storyline to Bobby Ewing's exit from Season 8 of the TV show "Dallas," Bobby is involved in a hit-and-run accident and is left in a coma due to severe injuries. The identity of the driver responsible for the accident remains unknown, leading to a mystery that unfolds throughout the season.

As Bobby lies unconscious in the hospital, his family and friends are determined to uncover the truth behind the hit-and-run and bring justice for him. The investigation becomes a central plotline, with various suspects and potential motives emerging as they search for answers. It's later revealed to be a hit of sorts from Jeremy Wendell.

Meanwhile, while in his coma, Bobby experiences vivid dreams and flashbacks that allow viewers to revisit key moments from his past. These dream sequences provide a great way to keep Bobby "alive" without Patrick on the show.

As the season progresses, tensions rise within Ewing family as they struggle with their emotions over Bobby’s condition while also dealing with their own personal dramas. The search for the hit-and-run driver leads unexpected twists and turns that keep viewers guessing until culminating in a dramatic reveal. JR, Miss Ellie, and Pam would occasionally visit "Bobby," (a lookalike of course) talking about the episode's plots and their thoughts on this whole mess- much like how JR would talk to Jock's portrait.

Jenna would have a life-threatening miscarriage.

Ultimately, when Bobby finally emerges from his coma- instead of the insipid Shower scene- he is determined to find closure and move forward with his life despite lingering physical challenges. His recovery becomes an inspirational journey that brings renewed hope and strength to those around him. I would have given him a cane to walk with for a few seasons. The best part would be to weave in the Ben Stivers storyline..... as he tells Ellie, "I heard our boy was nearly killed. I had to come to see him." Ellie- "OUR Boy?"
 
Top