Dallas Character What's the best scene with JR and Miss Ellie?

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
It was always a little fuzzy how famous the Ewings were supposed to be. It fluctuated depending on the storyline at the time and for the most part I think that was fine. That said, by the time Mandy comes into the picture, JR and Sue Ellen have already been at the public centre of a paternity suit, a custody fight, a bitter divorce and remarriage, plus she'd been arrested for his shooting (and never proved innocent; rather, charges were dropped due to lack of evidence) and her sister had died in bizarre circumstances while he was present. So within that context, Mandy's line makes sense. But I'm so glad the Ewings weren't regarded as wacky celebs the way the Carringtons are in New DYNASTY, for instance.
Pointing all of that backstory, you're right. The noteriety of Soap characters such as the Ewings would reach levels of absurdity given all the trials, shootings and remarriage if they didn't let it ebb and flow as the script called for it. How could John Ross show his face at school?
The lines, however, imho seem very later Dallas. They seem to dilute the urgency of the situations.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
Yes, this has got to be it --- and a scene which, in retrospect, signaled that DALLAS' identity had now gelled and had entered its most important era which would last another 6 years or so until Bobby ostensibly died --- plaintive, haunting, and sprinkled with elegiacal scores by Bruce Broughton (and others).

I never thought of this, but the final lines of the scene - “I gave you up too soon. I should have held on to you a little longer.” - hints at another source of Ellie’s seemingly wildly irrational and disproportionate reactions when one of her adult sons leaves Southfork or threatens to do so.
 
Last edited:

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
Pointing all of that backstory, you're right. The noteriety of Soap characters such as the Ewings would reach levels of absurdity given all the trials, shootings and remarriage if they didn't let it ebb and flow as the script called for it. How could John Ross show his face at school?
The lines, however, imho seem very later Dallas. They seem to dilute the urgency of the situations.
the blaring headlines in the Dallas Press and special KGIM bulletins whenever something relevant to the plot needs to be reiterated to the audience or revealed to a character are pretty hilarious, though.

“Mr. Cole, who as you all know, is married to former Senator ‘Wild Bill’ Orloff...”

MURDER OR SUICIDE?

RAYMOND "RAY" KREBBS USES TOILET


etc, etc.
 
Last edited:

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
It's a good scene and totally works in context, but it also kind of strikes as me as a "nicer" version of the earlier JR/Ellie confrontation that led to Sue Ellen's first sanatarium visit ("Is there anyone you love?" "I love Sue Ellen" "From the moment you brought that girl into this house you neglected her ..."). It feels less complicated somehow, like all the emotional rough edges have been sanded down.
one of my favorite parts of the scene is that the word Miss Ellie seemed to deliver with the most emotion and vitriol behind it was "discreet". So old-school, and something hinted at from time to time.

There was a line from Ellie to Lucy in an earlier episode about young people seeing through the veneer that older people put up. It's part of why it's a shame Lucy was relegated to 'serial idiot relationship girl' status.
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
It was always a little fuzzy how famous the Ewings were supposed to be. It fluctuated depending on the storyline at the time and for the most part I think that was fine. That said, by the time Mandy comes into the picture, JR and Sue Ellen have already been at the public centre of a paternity suit, a custody fight, a bitter divorce and remarriage, plus she'd been arrested for his shooting (and never proved innocent; rather, charges were dropped due to lack of evidence) and her sister had died in bizarre circumstances while he was present. So within that context, Mandy's line makes sense
----------
But I also recall you expressing problems with Mandy's line, too. At least previously.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
the blaring headlines in the Dallas Press and special KGIM bulletins whenever something relevant to the plot needs to be reiterated to the audience or revealed to a character are pretty hilarious, though.

“Mr. Cole, who as you all know, is married to former Senator ‘Wild Bill’ Orloff...”

MURDER OR SUICIDE?

RAYMOND "RAY" KREBBS USES TOILET


etc, etc.
--------------

Oh. I know. With 8 x 10 glossies on the front page... I kind of hate that, because it screams "cartoon TV show!" and just makes the Ewing family seem all the less "real."
 

James from London

International Treasure
----------
But I also recall you expressing problems with Mandy's line, too. At least previously.
That rings a vague bell. It must have been about fifteen years ago or thereabouts.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
“Mr. Cole, who as you all know, is married to former Senator ‘Wild Bill’ Orloff...”
just looked back at this and realized I unintentionally missed the part about it being Wild BIll's daughter Nancy... I prefer the visual above though! Who knew a couple of conservative Texas politicians in the 70s, no matter how dashing and stylish, could be so progressive??
 
Top 5 JR and Miss Ellie scenes

  1. s1 Ep 28 John Ewing 1 - scene with JR after Bobby carried in a drunk and pregnant Sue Ellen , I gave you up too soon JR
  2. S4 Ep 81 Little boy lost - at SF after getting out of helicopter from San Angela trip and failed attempt to snatch John Ross back
  3. s8 Ep 194 Those Eyes - after finding Sue Ellen in the Psych ward she has a chat with JR at SF
  4. S12 Ep 316 Daddy Dearest - with the letter for JR from sainted Jock after her trip to Pride etc
  5. S5 E[ 129 Things aint going so good again at SF - When she tells JR Youve destroyed her again
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
the blaring headlines in the Dallas Press and special KGIM bulletins whenever something relevant to the plot needs to be reiterated to the audience or revealed to a character are pretty hilarious, though.

“Mr. Cole, who as you all know, is married to former Senator ‘Wild Bill’ Orloff...”

MURDER OR SUICIDE?

RAYMOND "RAY" KREBBS USES TOILET


etc, etc.
joking aside, one of the things that always jumped out at me as not jibing with the real world is that the Ewings and those around them seemed to be at least quasi-celebrities, but very rarely would we get the slightest mention of Bobby's football hero days.

I say it often on here, but an all-SWC quarterback at the University of Texas absolutely would have been "Texas famous", and still well-known to many football fans nationwide at the time the show started.


dig the above, as the jazz cats would say: Bobby would have starred in at least one Cotton Bowl game in the 70-74 time period, depending on which Ewingverse timeline you use.

That game was a BIG DEAL in Texas and likely especially Dallas itself in those days. National TV on New Year’s Day, maybe for the NCAA title, etc etc. Right up there with “Who Shot JR?” in many circles, for an inverse-real-world comparison. Think ‘March Madness’ or a hyper-local Super Bowl these days and you’re kind of in the ballpark.

with apologies to JR and the flaccid saddletramp Steven "Dusty" Farlow, Bobby would have been the Ewing who'd had the famous showdowns at the Cotton Bowl.

(ha, ok, enough!)
 
Last edited:

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
Aside from the ones mentioned above, I really liked this dream season scene - I feel like it's one of the rare times that she promised to support him and actually did.

JR and Miss Ellie seemed closer in the dream season after Bobby's death. Especially in the opening episodes.

I haven't watched season nine in quite a while, time for a rewatch methinks. :)
 

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I loved that episode in the dream season when JR was thinking of leaving Southfork and Ellie clearly did not want that and did what she could do to stop his wanting to leave. It was a rare instance of her caring about JR's feelings.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
I always loved that scene towards the end of the Dream Season when JR sees Miss Ellie misty-eyed and tries to comfort her. She says that everything is changing or something like that, and it´s so true about the show itself at that point! JR should have answered: "As long as you won´t change again, Mama..."

1631568492258.png 1631568639257.png​
 
Top