Which Character On Dallas Was The Most Difficult To Play?

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
As far as the requirements the role demands of the actor, which Dallas character do you think was the most difficult to play?

I think Cliff was probably the most difficult to play. The range of emotions Cliff displayed on a regular basis would already be enough to make the role challenging.

Then on top of that he had to be convincing in scenarios where it just doesn't seem reasonable any man would react the way Cliff did. He could have had a nice life if he'd walked away from the feud with the Ewings. He had a law degree, was reasonably intelligent, and had a good aptitude for politics. He could have moved to Austin or Washington DC and had a successful career in politics. He stayed primarily because he wanted to stay and perpetuate the feud his father had began.

That might seem reasonable for a while, but Cliff got beaten again and again by the Ewings when he went up against then. First he got beaten in politics by the candidate the Ewings were backing in the election. Finally he gets beaten badly enough that he drops out of politics so he can go into the oil business and compete with them directly. He isn't a particularly good oilman and Ewing Oil is the biggest independent oil company in Texas. Cliff gets beaten over and over again. His girlfriend feels bad about that so she sleeps with an oilman so that Cliff will be able to successfully make the deal for the refinery - one that JR desperately wants to buy. Cliff thinks he succeeded in beating JR in making that deal on his own merits and then finds out the truth. On top of that his mother effectively disowns him for embezzling from her company, despite her abandoning him as a child and his forgiving her for it. Cliff then attempts suicide.

He was convincing in all of that and that's only the first 5 seasons. He keeps going after the Ewings far past what any reasonable person would consider and remains convincing throughout all of it - the highs and lows he experiences in his feud with the Ewings, his failed romances and his strained relationship with Pam.

Had Dallas been the type of show that delineates characters as heroes and villains, depending on the necessary adjustments to the script that change would require Cliff might have been placed into the role of a hero for battling the Ewings despite facing overwhelming odds, or he might have been placed in the role of a villain for intentionally causing the Ewing family so much trouble by perpetuating a senseless feud out of jealousy, but that's not the type of show it is. Cliff exists in that grey area between hero and villain, as do all the main characters, and because of that has to be somewhat sympathetic. When his mother disowns him, when he attempts suicide, when his mother dies in a plane crash that she took to try to help him, he can be very sympathetic. But he's also very easy to dislike because of his bitterness, the way he mistreats his girlfriends, and the way he treats Pam. She has a husband she loves, but Cliff unapologetically jeopardizes her marriage by perpetuating a senseless feud against her husband's family. Cliff places Pam right in the middle of the Barnes -Ewing feud, he knows he's doing it, and refuses to stop doing it. It's a uniquely complicated role to play and Ken Kercheval made the most of it.
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
As far as the requirements the role demands of the actor, which Dallas character do you think was the most difficult to play?

I think Cliff was probably the most difficult to play. The range of emotions Cliff displayed on a regular basis would already be enough to make the role challenging.

Then on top of that he had to be convincing in scenarios where it just doesn't seem reasonable any man would react the way Cliff did. He could have had a nice life if he'd walked away from the feud with the Ewings. He had a law degree, was reasonably intelligent, and had a good aptitude for politics. He could have moved to Austin or Washington DC and had a successful career in politics. He stayed primarily because he wanted to stay and perpetuate the feud his father had began.

That might seem reasonable for a while, but Cliff got beaten again and again by the Ewings when he went up against then. First he got beaten in politics by the candidate the Ewings were backing in the election. Finally he gets beaten badly enough that he drops out of politics so he can go into the oil business and compete with them directly. He isn't a particularly good oilman and Ewing Oil is the biggest independent oil company in Texas. Cliff gets beaten over and over again. His girlfriend feels bad about that so she sleeps with an oilman so that Cliff will be able to successfully make the deal for the refinery - one that JR desperately wants to buy. Cliff thinks he succeeded in beating JR in making that deal on his own merits and then finds out the truth. On top of that his mother effectively disowns him for embezzling from her company, despite her abandoning him as a child and his forgiving her for it. Cliff then attempts suicide.

He was convincing in all of that and that's only the first 5 seasons. He keeps going after the Ewings far past what any reasonable person would consider and remains convincing throughout all of it - the highs and lows he experiences in his feud with the Ewings, his failed romances and his strained relationship with Pam.

Had Dallas been the type of show that delineates characters as heroes and villains, depending on the necessary adjustments to the script that change would require Cliff might have been placed into the role of a hero for battling the Ewings despite facing overwhelming odds, or he might have been placed in the role of a villain for intentionally causing the Ewing family so much trouble by perpetuating a senseless feud out of jealousy, but that's not the type of show it is. Cliff exists in that grey area between hero and villain, as do all the main characters, and because of that has to be somewhat sympathetic. When his mother disowns him, when he attempts suicide, when his mother dies in a plane crash that she took to try to help him, he can be very sympathetic. But he's also very easy to dislike because of his bitterness, the way he mistreats his girlfriends, and the way he treats Pam. She has a husband she loves, but Cliff unapologetically jeopardizes her marriage by perpetuating a senseless feud against her husband's family. Cliff places Pam right in the middle of the Barnes -Ewing feud, he knows he's doing it, and refuses to stop doing it. It's a uniquely complicated role to play and Ken Kercheval made the most of it.

Trying to think of another more difficult role but you make some very good points regarding Cliff. When the character had run its course on Dallas they changed him up to bid and the feud was over, at least with everyone but JR. They did a good job by him where the others they seemed to ruin in order to keep from changing. Right to the end (not including TNT’s version) Cliff was Cliff.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Their bartender.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I wonder if the character of Cliff ended up being so wide-ranging partially because Kercheval had the capability as an actor. In the other direction, I think the character of Lucy could have been far more interesting if the powers that be had more confidence in the acting ability of Charlene.
 

Bill Dilks

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I would have to say JR. Sure, Hagman was talented. But, look at the dimension he brought to and instilled in that character...we loved to be angry at the SOB, but were still rooting for him, the pr*ck that he was, and couldn't stop watching him. He played it so tongue-in-cheek, exactly what it took to make the character become a world-wide phenomenon. That to me took something, someone, really really special.

JR.jpg
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
He played it so tongue-in-cheek

By tongue-in-cheek do you mean comedic? Because if you look at the JR in season 3 and got shot which started a phenomenon, JR at that time was one bad MF'er. They changed the character and watered it down in the later years of the show. They changed the whole tone of the show. Dallas did not need to be changed.

If I hadn't chosen the character of Cliff as the most difficult to play, it would have been JR. To do some of the things he did and still be so popular and well liked takes a one of a kind actor. One thing he did which was very important as JR was to have a positive outlook. While other people were miserable, sitting around and complaining, he was enjoying life. He was having a good time. He smiled a lot and Hagman knew it's tough not to like happy people.
 
Last edited:

Victoriafan3

Telly Talk Addict
By Larry’s own words, ‘playing a good character is much harder to play than a bad character’. While I couldn’t imagine anyone else as JR, while he was great at playing JR and made him his own, while I think he loved every minute of it and he had a lot of fun at work and playing him, while he was a huge part of the shows success, I don’t know that it was that ‘hard’ for him to play JR persay?
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
By Larry’s own words, ‘playing a good character is much harder to play than a bad character’. While I couldn’t imagine anyone else as JR, while he was great at playing JR and made him his own, while I think he loved every minute of it and he had a lot of fun at work and playing him, while he was a huge part of the shows success, I don’t know that it was that ‘hard’ for him to play JR persay?

He made it look easy didn't he?
 

Grant Jennings

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Bobby: he's the good-looking favorite son of a Texas billionaire who has been living the life of a playboy while his older brother has been busy growing the family fortune. He stole his ranch foreman's girlfriend and has a short-temper - he's inclined to "punch first, ask questions later". And he's the romantic hero of the series.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Bobby: he's the good-looking favorite son of a Texas billionaire who has been living the life of a playboy while his older brother has been busy growing the family fortune. He stole his ranch foreman's girlfriend and has a short-temper - he's inclined to "punch first, ask questions later". And he's the romantic hero of the series.

It would have been interesting to see at least one season of when Bobby was still living life as a playboy. He was married on the first episode so we only heard about those days.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
It would have been interesting to see at least one season of when Bobby was still living life as a playboy. He was married on the first episode so we only heard about those days.

Kenny Coyote, this is a good point, and it made me think of another character who would be difficult to play.

You should have known your good friend, TheLastKidPicked, would come along and contribute something crazy for your thread.

Are you ready?

I'm doing a rewatch now, and am beginning to think that John Beck did a really good job as Mark Graison.

***ducks as people start throwing things at me***

But if you watch those episodes again, see if you don't notice:

Mark Graison has to make the transition from a care-free playboy to a man who is so in love with Pam that he wouldn't be happy without her. And he has to pursue Pam without appearing to be a stalker.

Also, it would be hard to feel sorry for Mark. He has grown up in a wealthy family and led a life of privilege. But as he opens up to his best friend, we find out the Mark feels his life has been empty up until he met Pam. John Beck sells this well by underacting it. How ironic that Mark feels he can really start living at the same time we, as the audience, find out he is dying.

I don't like the whole storyline any better than the rest of you, but I have to say that in the spirit of Kenny Coyote's thread, Mark Graison would be one of the most difficult characters to play. And John Beck did a nice job.
 
Last edited:

Michelle Stevens

'The Lovely Michelle'
Donna Reed's Miss Ellie merely by the situation she entered the role. Unlike Gary or Jenna Wade who were initially played by different actors, the Barbara Bel Geddes Miss Ellie was the definitive Miss Ellie and Donna Reed had the almost impossible task in living up to the character BBG had played for seven seasons.

After that I would say Cliff Barnes with his complexities.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Donna Reed's Miss Ellie merely by the situation she entered the role. Unlike Gary or Jenna Wade who were initially played by different actors, the Barbara Bel Geddes Miss Ellie was the definitive Miss Ellie and Donna Reed had the almost impossible task in living up to the character BBG had played for seven seasons.

After that I would say Cliff Barnes with his complexities.

That's an interesting thought. That had to be the most difficult situation. There you have a case where no matter how well she or anyone else they could have gotten had played the character, the audience still wouldn't have been satisfied. If they had tried to replace Jock after Jim Davis died they would have also been in a no-win situation. I'm glad they never tried that.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I'm doing a rewatch now, and am beginning to think that John Beck did a really good job as Mark Graison.

***ducks as people start throwing things at me***

But if you watch those episodes again, see if you don't notice:

Mark Graison has to make the transition from a care-free playboy to a man who is so in love with Pam that he wouldn't be happy without her. And he has to pursue Pam without appearing to be a stalker.

Also, it would be hard to feel sorry for Mark. He has grown up in a wealthy family and led a life of privilege. But as he opens up to his best friend, we find out the Mark feels his life has been empty up until he met Pam. John Beck sells this well by underacting it. How ironic that Mark feels he can really start living at the same time we, as the audience, find out he is dying.

I don't like the whole storyline any better than the rest of you, but I have to say that in the spirit of Kenny Coyote's thread, Mark Graison would be one of the most difficult characters to play. And John Beck did a nice job.

That's a very perceptive observation. I hadn't ever thought of it in those terms but you're right. It was a difficult part to play convincingly and I think John Beck did an excellent job.

If I can add anything to what you've already explained very well, it's that John Beck was also in a very difficult situation because by the time he came along in the storyline of the series, the people watching had, for the most part, already decided that they wanted to see Pam and Bobby together no matter what obstacles they may have faced in their marriage.

It's just like any actress playing a role where she would have been Bobby's next girlfriend or wife. I liked Priscilla Presley as Jenna Wade. Sheree J. Wilson did a wonderful job playing April Stevens. I've seen the reactions to both of them and most of the people still didn't seem to think what either did was enough. I don't think there's any actress they could have found to play either of those roles who could have ever done enough to where most of the fans would have been happy.
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
It's just like any actress playing a role where she would have been Bobby's next girlfriend or wife. I liked Priscilla Presley as Jenna Wade. Sheree J. Wilson did a wonderful job playing April Stevens. I've seen the reactions to both of them and most of the people still didn't seem to think what either did was enough. I don't think there's any actress they could have found to play either of those roles who could have ever done enough to where most of the fans would have been happy.

Yes! Because people didn't see Jenna Wade or April Stevens as Bobby's love interest. They saw them as trying to replace Pam.

I think the writers did the best job they could of softening the entrance of Jenna. Many of the characters, including Miss Ellie, Punk Anderson, and Mavis Anderson commented on how Jenna Wade was always Bobby's FIRST love. You could tell that generation was hoping that Bobby and Jenna would be together.

J.R. put an even finer point on it when he told Bobby:

"That Jenna Wade loves you, and so does her little girl. When Jenna jilted you it caused you to make the biggest mistake of your life-- marrying that Barnes woman. Well, now you're free to marry Jenna. At least you should be. Pam is marrying Mark Graison and you are free to marry Jenna."

So if there was ANYBODY the fans would accept for Bobby, it would be Jenna-- his first sweetheart.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I was doing a re-watch of the Clayton and Lady Jessica Montfort episodes and it brought me back here to @Kenny Coyote 's thread.

The character of crazy Lady Montfort should have been the most difficult to play.

But watch Alexis Smith in the role. She was really having fun with it. Almost as if she decided, "I'm going to let loose and play it over-the-top, and we'll see what happens."

We did see what happened. It was a great and fun storyline that had us back to the old days of anxiously waiting for the next episode to see what was going to happen next.

It was a helluva ride!
 

Laurie Marr

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
The emotional volatility and unpredictability of Cliff was something that Kercheval brought to the role. We know that he varied his approach so frequently and spontaneously that he regularly caught out some of his co-actors as he’d often deliver lines in a completely different way than he had at rehearsal. Occasionally Kercheval’s approach could be hammy - but he always brought a frisson of tension to every scene. As he said, it wasn’t easy playing the perennial loser yet he was often brilliant in his depiction of tv’s best known neurotic.
 
Top