Who should they have cast as Jamie?

Presea

Telly Talk Addict
Speaking of Morgan Fairchild. I watched her performance as Jenna Wade last night. Pity she lasted just an episode, Lord she is stunning, and those eyes. Can you imagine Morgan Fairchild and Morgan Brittany playing off against each other as Jenna Wade and Katherine Wentworth.

images


View attachment 1767

Two women hell bent on securing Bobby's services with poor Pam fending them off.
​
It's Morgan vs. Morgan! With Punk (Morgan Woodward) as the referee!
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Personally I believe Jenilee was the issue and I also agree the writing of the character was poor. I thought the idea of adding another Ewing was great. I loved how the Ewing family were suspicious of her ancestry but after this, what? In the episode "Jamie" we are about to bid farewell to one our most beloved characters, Katherine. Then this thing (Jamie) walks onto Southfork. There really wasn't anywhere to take the character except to marry Cliff, which they did. Poor choice for Cliff in my opinion.

In hindsight I wonder if it would have been better to swap the characters sex around and have Jack arrive rather than Jamie. By this stage it was 1984 and the youth movement was beginning to ratchet up. We had the likes of Michael Jackson, Madonna, Prince, Sony Walkman's, Boom Boxes.

I thought the introduction of Peter Richard's was a good one though the choice of Christopher Atkins was poorly executed. I know at the time a lot of fans had issues with the story but once again Dallas proved it was a head of its time. Does the name cougar ring a bell? But, I could see what the writers/producers were attempting. The 80's was my era and by introducing characters that I could identify with was a good one.
 

Richard Channing

Eternal Member
There really wasn't anywhere to take the character except to marry Cliff, which they did. Poor choice for Cliff in my opinion.

Agreed. I did find it funny though when he was trying to get rid of her and told her he couldn't have children, and it just made her love him even more! I think we all wanted to see the back of her by that point.

I thought the introduction of Peter Richard's was a good one though the choice of Christopher Atkins was poorly executed. I know at the time a lot of fans had issues with the story but once again Dallas proved it was a head of its time

I liked the story line too. Someone else would probably have been better for the role, someone not so twinky, but I could live with Atkins.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Will definitely watch the whole thing at some point.
I have the video, but it's become a cult classic and many fans worldwide are still waiting for the DVD release.
Love that her name was 'Tallon'
That was the only Dynasty reference. It was mostly about Dallas and Falcon Crest. Well, and Gregory Harrison of course.
I remember her being a pretty bad actress. Her "Oh James" wasn't very convincing.
"Oh James" is very difficult, everybody knows that. I think "Oh Cliff" would have been easier to tackle.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
Haha, another Charlie's Angel then.

Including the parody role of Sue Ellen in "Fresno"!

How about another Bond girl, like Tanya Roberts?
tanya-roberts.jpg


Or blond
Tanya-Roberts-1.jpeg

Ha poor Tanya! She looks like Mandy Winger´s (slightly younger but sluttier) sister!! Though she and Jenilee have an enemy in common: their plastic surgeon.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
The funny thing is that Jenilee auditioned for the Mandy Trampy part, but ended up being Jamie. I for one didn´t care too much about her and I´d even say that a character like her was necessary at that moment on "Dallas" after Landers and Brittany left. The problem is that they gave more thought to her storylines than to poor Charlene´s, who spent 7 years (+2 more) repeating the same story and lines over and over...I always had the impression that Jenilee sort of "stole" Charlene´s space in the show. Oh and I notice there´s no comment about the "implicit but non-existing lesbian subtext" in the Jamie-Sue Ellen friendship. How very Laura from dear ol´Sue... :danc:
 

Richard Channing

Eternal Member
The funny thing is that Jenilee auditioned for the Mandy Trampy part, but ended up being Jamie.

I didn't know about that. God, she would have been awful as Mandy as well. Can you imagine her as the face of Valentine lingerie?? Dallas was just not the show for Jenilee.
 

Richard Channing

Eternal Member
Just watched this clip on youtube. Sue Ellen's 'surprise' is one of her worst ideas ever, and she's had plenty. Love how JR wipes the smile right of Jamie's face and then annihilates her. :D

 

Richard Channing

Eternal Member
I cringed a little when she said "I'll show you that I'm a Ewing!" Or something like that. Uh-huh. Yeah. Sure. Riiight.

It didn't help that Jenilee is one of those people who can't say 'ing' properly, instead pronouncing it 'een', thus making her a Eween. One of many words ending in 'ing' that she pronounced with an 'een'. Am I the only one who noticed that?
 

Karin

Moderator
Staff Member
The funny thing is that Jenilee auditioned for the Mandy Trampy part, but ended up being Jamie. I for one didn´t care too much about her and I´d even say that a character like her was necessary at that moment on "Dallas" after Landers and Brittany left. The problem is that they gave more thought to her storylines than to poor Charlene´s, who spent 7 years (+2 more) repeating the same story and lines over and over...I always had the impression that Jenilee sort of "stole" Charlene´s space in the show.

Excellent points Toni. I didn't know she had auditioned for Mandy Winger!
And yes Charlene should have been given better plots. The Hot Buscuit plot this season with yet another loser (Eddie) wasn't her finest plot for sure.

Then as for Jamie, I never had a problem with the actress but I found both Jamie and Jack sort of boring characters that didn't really serve much purpose on the show. I think the best thing about Jack was that he introduced April.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Someone else would probably have been better for the role, someone not so twinky, but I could live with Atkins.

Other posters have stated Christopher was hired simply because he was the "It" guy of his time, while others were aghast at his acting - especially when playing angry Peter. I on the other hand didn't mind it as much. I thought Christopher playing a young immature man dealing with his affections for Sue Ellen was spot on.
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
I really liked Jennilee as Jamie. Although I'd rather stick pins in all my major organs than watch her, or anyone, as Mandy Winger.
 

Don Howard

Telly Talk Fan
Y8.jpg

Wouldn't it have been a gasser to have her as Jamie? Coming fresh from Dynasty the previous season, that would have been a grabber. She'd have had to be billed in the opening credits, however.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Don if your implying Pamela Sue Martin as Jamie, I agree. She would have been a great catch for Dallas. I even see her playing Mandy Winger.
 

Don Howard

Telly Talk Fan
Don if your implying Pamela Sue Martin as Jamie, I agree. She would have been a great catch for Dallas. I even see her playing Mandy Winger.

Oooooo. Pamela Sue as Mandy and Deborah Shelton as Jamie. How about those?
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Deborah Shelton as Jamie. How about those?

I won't argue about Deborah Shelton's beauty, that's not in dispute. I just thought her acting wasn't quite up to scratch. But Pamela Sue Martin as Mandy would have been interesting. The above photo illustrates her similarities to the character of Sue Ellen and I think this would have been an interesting idea to cast an actress who had similar looks to Linda. This would explain J.R.'s attractiveness to her.
 
Top