Who Was More Profoundly Damaged - Kristin Or Katherine?

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I think DALLAS got away with it with Katherine. She was fun to watch then and she still is.

She was fun to watch but as @Toni has described, the quality of the character - particularly her lines, became more and more over the top to the point of cartoonish, and frankly, embarrassing. She became sort of a self parody. I don't blame the actress; I blame the writers and the producers for taking the character so far in that direction. I think her last great scene was the one where Bobby had just told Katherine he was going to marry Jenna. Katherine just lost it (but in a good way) and said: "No! You can't! Not that slut with the child from that awful Italian"!

That didn't happen with Kristin. She had some extreme qualities, absolutely, but they still used some measure of restraint to keep her quality level high. They never allowed her to get cartoonish.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
That’s correct. For example, during the tail end of the classic Dallas era, being a villain meant kidnaping someone on their wedding day and dragging her to Europe where you hire a hitman to kill your partner in order to frame the person you kidnapped. In early Dallas being a villain meant throwing someone off a building.

Dallas was always a show about characters with shades of gray - good and bad qualities. Dallas never delineated its characters into heroes and villains and I'm glad they didn't do that because they way they did it worked.

Notice how your example of the characters becoming closer to being delineated into heroes and villain came at the "tail end of the classic Dallas era." Having just regular people with good and bad qualities led to years of remarkable success and the other approach the black and white hero or villain approach coincided with the show's downfall.

Most people can relate to characters who have some good and some bad qualities, with some leaning more towards the good side and others towards the bad side. How many truly "all bad" or "all good" people have you actually met? Besides, if you have a villain, you need a hero or there is no point! A villain exists so that the audience can watch the hero and the villain fight and then ultimately give the audience the satisfaction of seeing the hero vanquish the villain.
 
Last edited:

Laurie Marr

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Interesting how easy we find it to pathologise villainy when the miscreant is a woman......and there was a surfeit of emotionally unstable women on the show who ended up in hospitals, police cells or floating face down in a pool. The others just got regular shots from Dr Danvers.

To even things up just a little: what was the source of JR’s personality disorder/psychological malaise? Kirstin’s assassination attempt looks like high jinx when compared with the long list of JR’s crimes and misdemeanours.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
To even things up just a little: what was the source of JR’s personality disorder/psychological malaise?
This would have been an interesting avenue to explore with JR, right after Bobby's imagined death. Perhaps that's a topic of conversation in another thread.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
This would have been an interesting avenue to explore with JR, right after Bobby's imagined death. Perhaps that's a topic of conversation in another thread.

Back in 1982, when "Dallas" was BIG in Spain, a psychologist tried to explain J.R.´s behavior from his professional POV, and he said that it was probably due to his genitals being too small (sic) and his obsession to compensate for it by flaunting around his hookers and cars. Not my opinion, Sarah... :cool1
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Interesting how easy we find it to pathologise villainy when the miscreant is a woman......and there was a surfeit of emotionally unstable women on the show who ended up in hospitals, police cells or floating face down in a pool. The others just got regular shots from Dr Danvers.

To even things up just a little: what was the source of JR’s personality disorder/psychological malaise? Kirstin’s assassination attempt looks like high jinx when compared with the long list of JR’s crimes and misdemeanours.

How about Bobby's emotional instability? He lost his cool so easily it was unreal. Somehow he never had to pay a price for it. It's almost like TV characters are held to a different standard than real people.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
I for one loved that blank background the writers gave (not) for Krazy Kat. She could have done everything, anything, to anyone out there. Because once she came back to Dallas, all she had in mind was to keep Bobby and Pam apart and waiting for the right time to get revenge on that "nasty little man" called Cliff.

But what did she do before? Things we knew about Katherine in her first episodes:
- She lived in N.Y.
- She wanted to be a journalist (not too much devotion shown about this...)
- She used to dump every guy she dated.
- She seemed to adore her father (Electra complex alert?).
- She loved wearing blue dresses.
- She had vivid memories of his dad´s office at Tool and Die (Electra complex alert 2?)..
- She thought Bobby was an attractive man (she said it to mum and Cliffie).

Things we knew around the time she "died" in Pam´s dream:
- She paid a killer to get rid of Naldo and Jenna.
- She began to wear blonde wigs.
- She got used to tomato juice.
- She kept up a diary where she confessed all her crimes (just like Jessica... I wonder why...)

Everything else in between had to do with her obsession with Bobby. Kristin had less character development (maybe that episode with her old boyfriend?) and we didn´t even know what she thought of wigs, tomato juice or diaries...

:danc::danc::danc::danc::danc::danc::danc::danc::danc::spinning::spinning::spinning:
 
Last edited:
Top