Why Are Nighttime Dramas Overlooked In Ranking The Greatest TV Shows Ever?

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I just randomly viewed three “100 greatest TV shows of all time” list, and Dallas didn’t even make the list on two of them and on The Rolling Stones list, they were 81. Dallas was on for 14 years and over 350 episodes, don’t tell me they’re not one of the top shows ever. But shows with a fraction of episodes with far less cultural impact makes the list?

Why is that?
 

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I wouldn't read too much into that. Such articles are written and TV shows produced for intended target group under the age of ~50. Therefor only handful series from the last century can be found there (Simpsons, Star Trek TNG, X-Files).

Also the term "best series" is subjective. In my opinion Dallas' first 8/9 years are simply the best TV, unrivaled to this day. If you include the next 4 years, the result is certainly different. During the last decades series got fewer seasons/episodes and therefor hardly these drops in quality all major Primetime soaps endured.

It's a matter of taste.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I believe Dallas rates very highly with Time Magazine. It's such a shame the dream season resolution paints Dallas in such a bad light. As @the-lost-son rightly points out...
In my opinion Dallas' first 8/9 years are simply the best TV, unrivaled to this day.
...pity then the last few seasons hoodwinks the judges of these things into believing Dallas was all bad. It wasn't. Dallas changed primetime viewing forever. If it wasn't for Dallas we wouldn't have Knots Landing, Dynasty, Falcon Crest and other primetime smash hits. Dallas paved the way for others to follow and they should all get down on their feet and kiss the legend that is...

download.jpg​
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
It depends on the criteria they use to judge what's great. Popularity and longevity doesn't always equate to greatness. As much as I love Dallas, Knots Landing and Falcon Crest, as a piece of art or ground-breaking television I wouldn't say it was greater than Lost, The Larry Sanders Show or The X-Files.
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
Also the term "best series" is subjective. In my opinion Dallas' first 8/9 years are simply the best TV, unrivaled to this day. If you include the next 4 years, the result is certainly different. During the last decades series got fewer seasons/episodes and therefor hardly these drops in quality all major Primetime soaps endured.
I think this is a huge issue for the soaps - they were on until they were literally run into the ground. If you look at television today there are far more shows that end on their own terms rather than when they stop being profitable. Of course, that's not to say shows still aren't run into the ground (hello The Simpsons!), but it does seem like it lessens especially with serialised television. A show like Succession would probably run for ten+ seasons in the 80s with 22+ episodes per season on broadcast - right now the creator is talking about maybe ending it after season 4, or maybe season 5 (which would be 50 episodes - about two Dallas' seasons worth of episodes).
 

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
. ..pity then the last few seasons hoodwinks the judges of these things into believing Dallas was all bad. It wasn't.
The idea to finish a series on a high note is rather new. Back then ratings were the only indicator for a successful TV show. Today a constant quality is somehow mandatory to promote the series for DVD sales and streaming providers.

I think it was obvious to everyone of Dallas that the quality detoriated. (Hagman: the bloom is off the rose.) To drag things out as long as possible was the way to produce TV back then.

In today's TV landscape Dallas, Dynasty, Falcon Crest and probably Knots Landing would have been canceled at least 2 years earlier.

@tommie : funny I wrote the same in the very minute, just in other words
 
Last edited:

Monzo

Telly Talk Star
I wouldn't take these lists too seriously, because at first editors have to include those shows that were big at the Emmys. If you overlook shows that won 20 Emmys or more in it's run, then your top 100 list can't be right. Then you have to add those shows you might not have much Emmy love, but inspired writers and directors like The Twilight Zone or Twin Peaks. Finally, editors add their personal favorites, those shows that are overlooked everywhere else. In the end when there is room left on your list you check most watched shows and finally Dallas and sometimes Dynasty appear on a top 100.

Dallas was a ratings powerhouse, but not so much at the Emmys unlike ER which was big at both for many years. Still, ER seems to appear on these lists only top 20 or top 30 because it overstayed it's welcome. Dallas also overstayed it's welcome, but should it have been cancelled earlier just to be more popular for some random editors?
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Such articles are written and TV shows produced for intended target group under the age of ~50.
Yes, a few years ago, one publication came out with their list for either greatest cliffhangers or series finales "of all time," and every example was from 2007 or later. And that was several years ago...

I assume it was written by a 14 year old.
 

Monzo

Telly Talk Star
In today's TV landscape Dallas, Dynasty, Falcon Crest and probably Knots Landing would have been canceled at least 2 years earlier.
I think it would be the other way around, just look at Grey's Anatomy or NCIS. 15 years ago when it would have been TV (or VCR/DVR) only both shows would have cancelled after 10+ seasons, because they got too expensive, but nowadays networks try to keep anything on the air that brings demos to TV instead of streaming, because networks still make most money out of advertising and not their own streaming services.

Sadly, I don't know exactly how big primetime soaps were doing at the demos. Dynasty was bigger than Dallas for more than one season, mostly due to the fact that it aired on Wednesdays and not on Fridays when demos were not at home. In today's landscape ABC would have kept Dynasty on air if it's doing good enough in demos for as long as possible, same with CBS and their soaps.
 
Last edited:

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I think it would be the other way around, just look at Grey's Anatomy or NCIS. 15 years ago when it would have been TV (or VCR/DVR) only both shows would have cancelled after 10+ seasons, because they got too expensive, but nowadays networks try to keep anything on the air that brings demos to TV instead of streaming, because networks still make most money out of advertising and not their own streaming services.

Sadly, I don't know exactly how big primetime soaps were doing at the demos. Dynasty was bigger than Dallas for more than one season, mostly due to the fact that it aired on Wednesdays and not on Fridays when demos were not at home. In today's landscape ABC would have kept Dynasty on air if it's doing good enough in demos for as long as possible, same with CBS and their soaps.
That is totally possible. Obviously the whole TV industry became more complicated in regards to finances.
There is an interesting (short) article worth reading on thus subject:
 

Monzo

Telly Talk Star
Some Simpsons episodes almost got under 1 million US viewers same day anymore. I remember like 10 - 15 years ago when Simpsons voice actors wanted more money each season, nowadays live tv viewers never could save The Simpsons.

Would The Blacklist be still on air if there wasn't a great Netflix deal? Netflix can't save a show forever like Good Girls proved this season. It was saved instead of bad tv ratings for three seasons thanks to NBC's Netflix deal, but someday it's enough.

Another factor are studios, I guess. ABC tries to produce all shows on their own. I think that's another reason why Grey's Anatomy still exists. Would Lorimar have survived in times like these?
 

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Some Simpsons episodes almost got under 1 million US viewers same day anymore. I remember like 10 - 15 years ago when Simpsons voice actors wanted more money each season, nowadays live tv viewers never could save The Simpsons.

Would The Blacklist be still on air if there wasn't a great Netflix deal? Netflix can't save a show forever like Good Girls proved this season. It was saved instead of bad tv ratings for three seasons thanks to NBC's Netflix deal, but someday it's enough.

Another factor are studios, I guess. ABC tries to produce all shows on their own. I think that's another reason why Grey's Anatomy still exists. Would Lorimar have survived in times like these?
Matt Groening (the creator of the Simpsons) could tell one or two stories on that subject.

Started in the late eighties zo become an American and consequently world-wide phenomenon for more than 30 years. The quality detoriated in the last 20 years. Although I know the first 8-9 years of the Simpsons by heart (as many people my age) I can't watch any of this "new" episodes.

Nonetheless they are still here and probably will stay much longer.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
At the same time I find it a little suspicious that the classic nightime dramas usually dominate these "charts" here on tellytalk[/tongue in cheek]
Such articles are written and TV shows produced for intended target group under the age of ~50. Therefor only handful series from the last century can be found there
Interestingly, PEYTON PLACE is largely overlooked in our Best Of Lists because (apparently) it's not relevant to the DALLAS and DYNASTY generation.
So...aren't we doing the same thing?
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Interestingly, PEYTON PLACE is largely overlooked in our Best Of Lists because (apparently) it's not relevant to the DALLAS and DYNASTY generation.
So...aren't we doing the same thing?
I have heard of the series but it was before my time and not available for viewing in my area growing up. Because of this I'm unable to pass judgement. Perhaps this is why Dallas fails to register with people today because it's no longer available to view. There was that short lived series TNT Dallas but it failed to find traction with audiences for obvious reasons.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I have heard of the series but it was before my time and not available for viewing in my area growing up. Because of this I'm unable to pass judgement. Perhaps this is why Dallas fails to register with people today because it's no longer available to view. There was that short lived series TNT Dallas but it failed to find traction with audiences for obvious reasons.

That’s a very good point. Maybe it’s because night time serials of the 80’s are pretty much non-existent in syndication.
 
Top