Why It Wouldn't Have Worked If More Of The Ewings Besides JR Were Devious

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I've seen opinions that maybe JR shouldn't have been the only Ewing who was willing to be devious and do things that as a lot of people put it "made you love to hate him."

The Ewings were the central family of Dallas and while the Barnes family was featured a good amount, Cliff was the antagonist who wanted to avenge his drunk of father, Digger Barnes, for not having had his "fair share of Ewing Oil." The Ewings were the family the audience primarily tuned in to watch, and if you're going to tune in to watch the same family every week, that means you like that family. If you don't like them, you don't watch.

The whole show was based around the Ewings fighting off threats to their family whether they came from Cliff, Katherine, or Rebecca of the Barnes/Wenworth family, or it came from Jeremy Wendell or Carter McKay.

The one thing in common these threats all had is they wanted to destroy the Ewings, or at the very least, hurt them badly. In various seasons and episodes, the threats would come from different people, which kept it exciting. The Barnes - Ewing feud was the center of the conflict in the show and Cliff in particular spent an inordinate amount of his life (arguably all of it) on revenge. Nobody likes someone so bitter they'd dedicate their lives to revenge. "Bitter" isn't a quality people look for in people they want to like. Bitterness is probably one of the most unlikable qualities a person can have because not only are they spending their lives with the objective of hurting other people, but they ruin their own chance of happiness in the process. If you're a miserable person and you manage to hurt someone else, you haven't made your life better; you've just made someone else's life worse.

Did you notice how Cliff could never keep a girlfriend? Perhaps Afton said it best when she said to Cliff: "You are the coldest man I've ever met. You make JR Ewing look like a saint." Afton said that after Cliff said it didn't bother him that Bobby got shot and his justification was "He's a Ewing." As she says she's leaving for good, Cliff says "Just when everything was going great"! Afton replies: For whom? For Cliff Barnes, the only person you've ever cared about." Cliff is so oblivious that he really doesn't see that he has been making Afton miserable by treating her terribly. He's so bitter and self-centered that it's almost like he's literally blind.

Bobby was the Ewing who got Cliff out of being accused of murdering Julie Gray. Bobby was the Ewing who tried to find Cliff a job when Cliff was down and out. Bobby was the Ewing who fought for Cliff getting his 50% of the proceeds from Ewing 23. Despite all that, Cliff was so oblivious that he couldn''t tell the difference between Bobby and JR. When the two were in the contest for Ewing Oil, Cliff didn't care which one won because, again he didn't have the discernment to be able to perceive that Bobby treated him far, far better than JR did, and that Bobby actually would have liked to have been friends with Cliff. But Cliff was too blind to see it.

Obviously with awful people like Cliff, murderous types like Katherine and Kristin, extremely cold people like Jeremy Wendell and outright losers like Digger Barnes, the show had to have someone to pull for, and for Dallas fans it was the Ewing family.

It's like in sports where whenever people go to see a team sport, they almost always cheer for the home team and they boo the visiting team. They want the team they know and like to win. For Dallas fans, the Ewing family was the home team. They were the ones the audience always wanted to see prevail, to find happiness and be safe from outsiders who wanted to hurt them.
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Lucy had her devious moments, it has to be said, especially in her ill-though running away from Southfork to meet up with Willie Gust.

But I agree if there had been a broader level of deviousness throughout the entire family, it would probably wouldn't have served the show as well.

Swami
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
The one thing in common these threats all had is they wanted to destroy the Ewings, or at the very least, hurt them badly
But there are so many types of villains. JR was a bully and a schemer eventhough he belonged to the "good camp" i.e. the family that audiences rooted for.
I've seen opinions that maybe JR shouldn't have been the only Ewing who was willing to be devious and do things that as a lot of people put it "made you love to hate him."
But that doesn't mean that all the others had to be super-nice people. Sue Ellen certainly wasn't, and eventhough I can't picture Lucy as a mover & shaker she could have been a troublesome vixen without being an out-and-out villain.

Either way, it certainly worked for Falcon Crest and Dynasty.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
It’s VERY important to have the central family be liked. If everybody was as devious as JR, the show wouldn’t have never worked or at the least, been as popular.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
It’s VERY important to have the central family be liked. If everybody was as devious as JR, the show wouldn’t have never worked or at the least, been as popular.

Yeah, if you don't like the central family, you don't watch the show. I'm not saying that JR was the only one who could ever do something that would make the audience mad at him, but to have had another Ewing doing that many devious, sometimes cruel things, would have made the family as a whole less likable and less sympathetic. Sue Ellen wasn't exactly likable (to me) but at least the audience could feel sympathy for her, having a husband who cheated right from the start of the show, then having that drinking problem too, you felt bad for her. Miss Ellie, Jock, Bobby, Pam, Ray and Lucy were basically nice people - some flaws to make it interesting and believable - but overall a likable family.

The other thing is having another character try to be like JR would diminish the effectiveness of JR's character - they'd be stealing what he's known for, his trademark, and almost certainly doing it less well.

JR was a one of a kind character played by a one of kind actor. He had just the right mix of good and bad and played it in just that certain way that he was likable and also could make the audience mad at him.

If JR had just been a thoroughly bad character like Naldo Marchetta, or Katherine or Andre Schuman, there's no way they could have based so much of the show around him, to where he got more screen time than any other character.
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
but to have had another Ewing doing that many devious, sometimes cruel things, would have made the family as a whole less likable and less sympathetic
Well I think most people would prefer to watch a group of different characters.
just that certain way that he was likable and also could make the audience mad at him.
I root for the villain because if he would always fail then it would undermine the story. But I don't root for him because I think he deserves to win.
and played it in just that certain way that he was likable and also could make the audience mad at him.
I don't find him very likeable but he's very entertaining. That's the difference.
If JR had just been a thoroughly bad character like Naldo Marchetta, or Katherine or Andre Schuman
JR was just as bad but he was another kind of villain with different tactics and priorities.
He also tried to destroy Bobby and Pam's marriage, Katherine's method was just more extreme.
 

James from London

International Treasure
The Ewings were the family the audience primarily tuned in to watch, and if you're going to tune in to watch the same family every week, that means you like that family. If you don't like them, you don't watch.

I enjoyed watching the Ewings without necessarily being on their side. I was moved when Jock and JR died, but thought it was just great when Southfork caught fire and the family lost Ewing Oil. I thought Sue Ellen taking over Valentine Lingerie was cool, but I also loved it whenever she started drinking again. Bobby and Pam splitting up was great, Bobby and Pam getting back together was great. I thought Cliff striking it rich in the Gulf was great, I also thought his suicide attempt was pretty exciting.

Nobody likes someone so bitter they'd dedicate their lives to revenge. "Bitter" isn't a quality people look for in people they want to like. Bitterness is probably one of the most unlikable qualities a person can have because not only are they spending their lives with the objective of hurting other people, but they ruin their own chance of happiness in the process. If you're a miserable person and you manage to hurt someone else, you haven't made your life better; you've just made someone else's life worse.

I loved Cliff's bitterness. Doesn't mean I'd want to share a flat with him.

Did you notice how Cliff could never keep a girlfriend? Perhaps Afton said it best when she said to Cliff: "You are the coldest man I've ever met. You make JR Ewing look like a saint." Afton said that after Cliff said it didn't bother him that Bobby got shot and his justification was "He's a Ewing." As she says she's leaving for good, Cliff says "Just when everything was going great"! Afton replies: For whom? For Cliff Barnes, the only person you've ever cared about." Cliff is so oblivious that he really doesn't see that he has been making Afton miserable by treating her terribly. He's so bitter and self-centered that it's almost like he's literally blind

In that scene, I felt sympathetic towards both Cliff and Afton.

It's like in sports where whenever people go to see a team sport, they almost always cheer for the home team and they boo the visiting team. They want the team they know and like to win. For Dallas fans, the Ewing family was the home team. They were the ones the audience always wanted to see prevail, to find happiness and be safe from outsiders who wanted to hurt them.

I don't think it's as black and white as that. If it was, I don't think I'd find Dallas all that interesting. Hopefully, there's room for a bit more nuance in drama than just picking one side over another.
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Cliff is so oblivious that he really doesn't see that he has been making Afton miserable by treating her terribly
JR, on the other hand, was very aware of the impact he had on his women, and he also couldn't care less. Is it worse when Cliff does it?
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
David Jacobs' original concept of the Ewings was to have them all scoundrels to some degree, and KNOTS continued to describe them as such even though DALLAS didn't (at least, not for long). Most of the Ewings villainy was quickly downgraded to neurotic dysfunction, and actual criminality came from outside the family -- although Jock's past seemed to be pretty shady, even by his own admission.

Could DALLAS have worked if they were all as devious as JR? Maybe, but the show would have had to have been as nuanced as its spin-off, and it largely wasn't.
 

James from London

International Treasure
If JR had just been a thoroughly bad character like Naldo Marchetta, or Katherine or Andre Schuman, there's no way they could have based so much of the show around him, to where he got more screen time than any other character.

Had Naldo or Katherine or Schuman appeared in all 356 episodes, we would have doubtless learned more about what makes them tick, thereby allowing them more opportunity to capture our imaginations. As it was, the show wasn't as interested in exploring them the way it did JR and the rest of the Ewings so we'll never know for sure.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I'd have like to have seen Miss Ellie, maybe after a bump on the head or something, go full-on JR-level devious/evil for 2/3 of a season or so, doing her trademark "gaze worriedly into the middle distance" after seeing trouble befall one of the main characters, then breaking into a darkly mischievous grin as the dramatic strings swell and the Phillip Capice freeze frame appears, revealing it was her dastardly scheme all along
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
JR was just as bad but he was another kind of villain with different tactics and priorities.

You don't see a moral difference between JR and a professional hitman? OK!

I loved Cliff's bitterness.

I find bitterness to be an exceptionally unappealing quality.

I don't think it's as black and white as that. If it was, I don't think I'd find Dallas all that interesting. Hopefully, there's room for a bit more nuance in drama than just picking one side over another.

There's a difference between indecisiveness and nuance. I can know who I like and who I don't like and still see nuance in the story. It makes it so much better when you know who you like, because then it matters a lot more what happens to whom.

JR, on the other hand, was very aware of the impact he had on his women, and he also couldn't care less. Is it worse when Cliff does it?

Oh hell yes, it's worse with Cliff because he's too damn dumb to know when or if he's screwing up a relationship and why. Cliff really didn't understand why Afton was leaving. He even asked her why she'd leave "just when everything was going great." Cliff didn't have a clue.

Someone who is intelligent but ethically flawed is still potentially teachable. There's still some hope for someone like that. There's no cure for stupid.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
As it was, the show wasn't as interested in exploring them the way it did JR
With the character of JR I think there was more to tell. For as long as Dallas has aired there are two characters I believe we still know little about: Jock and JR. Others like Miss Ellie, Bobby, Pam and Sue Ellen had real depth to them. While Jock was gruff in personality JR would often come across as just cold...not evil. JR had two weak spots; Ewing Oil and John Ross. But Ewing Oil was JR's Achilles heel. Despite all his wheeling and dealing JR would inevitably come undone, much like Cliff and his constant vendetta against the Ewing family.

I believe the writers missed a golden opportunity to explore the character of JR after Bobby's death. There are two paths the character could have taken; full on revenge against those responsible for his brothers death or witnessing JR collapse into a foetal position, burned and worn out by his own excessive need to have it all. Hell, I would have thrown everything at JR. Crippled by his own guilt at being partially responsible for Bobby's death I would have taken that smirk off JR's face and have the character tortured by his own greed.
 
Top