Why M. Michaels' "Pam" not working worked.....

TJames03

Banned
......for me.......

Because it showed that the Pam we knew was completely and utterly gone, both physically and psychologically and was never coming back, no matter how much we screamed and moaned about it. VP's was absolutely nothing more than a memory and fans had better accept it.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
For me it felt like just a shard of Pam that was left. I didn't view it that that was it in regards of not seeing Pam again.

It didn't finish Pam's story at all but merely left it up in the air again.

If Victoria had wanted to return I'm sure that the Producers would have welcomed her with open arms. She didn't of course, but I don't think there was any intention of fully recasting the role with Margaret Michaels taking it over permanently. Michaels was just there to give a temporary closure to the character but nothing more. :)
 

Clubsoda

Telly Talk Active Member
I could never accept that scene with Margaret and Ken and would rather it had never happened.

They simply should've linked Pam's disappearance with Katherine that's all that was required. I could only ever have accepted Pam staying away from Bobby and Christopher as being properly dead or against her will not through choice.

I'm not sure how they could've written Pam's outright death into the script in relation to Katherine, maybe another plane crash that killed Pam but not Katherine allowing Morgan to return for yet another stint to be sent to prison and provide the back story?

I despise how it all worked out including in new Dallas. I'll never ever rewatch anything past The Fall of the House of Ewing.
 

ArchieLucasCarringtonEwing1989

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
I'm against recasts in prime time soaps in general, it never works, just look at Dynasty, all four Carrington siblings were recasted and it jarred the series up.

However regarding Margaret Michaels becoming Pam long term I can accept it, she looked like VP, same mannerisms as VP and even the same voice as VP, it was uncanny, plus after implausibly surviving that hellfire of a car crash, she was always going to look different! But the differences between VP and MM are very few and far between.

I would rather have five seasons of Margaret Michaels as Pam than
Ten episodes of Cally, Michelle, April & James.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
I'm against recasts in prime time soaps in general, it never works, just look at Dynasty, all four Carrington siblings were recasted and it jarred the series up.

However regarding Margaret Michaels becoming Pam long term I can accept it, she looked like VP, same mannerisms as VP and even the same voice as VP, it was uncanny, plus after implausibly surviving that hellfire of a car crash, she was always going to look different! But the differences between VP and MM are very few and far between.

I would rather have five seasons of Margaret Michaels as Pam than
Ten episodes of Cally, Michelle, April & James.

I could've accepted Margaret Michaels as a recast Pam if they had chosen to go down that route. It's just a shame they didn't as I always felt that the character of Pam was essential to the succcess of the show. After Victoria left, the show never really recovered from Pam's departure. Perhaps if the role had been recast the long term outcome for the show would've been very different. :)
 

Clubsoda

Telly Talk Active Member
You could re cast though and the chemistry between Duffy and the re cast just wouldn't be there. I personally wasn't feeling his scenes with Michaels as Jeanne O'Brien and never wish to watch these scenes ever again.

So yes Pam was important but chemistry is also important and cannot be easily replaced.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
As the saying goes, hindsight is 20/20. It’s very easy for any us to look back all these years later and say “oh, they should’ve just done this instead of that, and it would it would have worked out much better for the show", but I could see why at the time the producers and writers weren’t sure, and decided to go down the various routes that they did. When you’re talking about major characters, such as Pam, it’s not easy to decide how to proceed when an actor leaves (or dies). And especially when you consider what Dallas had already been through, in regards to some of their characters. Bobby and Miss Ellie were both essential to the original series. They tried recasting one, and that didn’t work, and they wrote one out completely but then had to take an extraordinary method to bring him back. So at this point they were scared to recast Pam, and scared to kill her off on screen.

Now, I agree that the way they handled it was terrible, but I can at least see why they thought it was a good solution. Who could have predicted that VP would end up some big millionaire make-up mogul? She could have easily bombed post-Dallas and returned at some point. Hell, according to her, she’d told the producers months in advance that season 10 would be her last, but no one believed her, they just assumed it was a negotiating tactic. So when they time came, they weren’t ready for it. And yeah the burning did give them some cover if they ever chose to fully recast her.

Personally, I would have just went with the story they ended up doing with Sue Ellen when Linda Gray left. Have Pam and Bobby break up for good, whether Pam remarried someone else, or just decided she’d had enough of the Ewings and wanted to get away from them all, and just have her move away somewhere, while deciding to let Christopher stay at SouthFork (and write him out for a few episodes every season to say he’s visiting her).

Now when they had Margaret Michaels actually play Pam in that one scene, I thought that was fine under the circumstances. It at least gave us the explanation that Pam was dying, and that’s why she wouldn’t return, because having her just stay away after recovering was too out of character. While it still left open the possibility of her returning. Then having her play the other woman who looked like Pam was also an okay story, because we needed to see Bobby finally get over Pam, so he could move on, which was necessary while the show continued (sorry you die-hard Bobby + Pam 4ever fans, but just leaving Bobby as a single man mourning his One True Love for the rest of his life just wouldn’t make sense).


As for Dallas TNT, I think they should have just went with the original plan, as shown in the pilot episode first draft, of establishing that Pam had come back to Dallas and died a few years after the original series ended, so that storyline was settled right from the start and they could just move on. The whole Search For Pam storyline was a waste.


But, again, it’s hindsight. Let’s be honest, no matter what choices they’d made in either of these storylines, it never would have pleased everyone. Some fans would still be complaining. That’s just the nature of the business.
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
she looked like VP
I think the main reason recasts have a bad reputation is that they often don't even try for someone like the original actor. They either treat it like a new character or go for stunt casting. By contrast, the recasting of Becky in Rosanne worked as they were quite similar and I think Margaret Michaels could have been the same
I personally wasn't feeling his scenes with Michaels as Jeanne O'Brien and never wish to watch these scenes ever again.
In fairness, it was a different character. Jeanne (understandably) had no interest in him.
 

Balena

Telly Talk Member
[QUOTE="Jabari Lamar, post: 114119, member: 2208"
Personally, I would have just went with the story they ended up doing with Sue Ellen when Linda Gray left. Have Pam and Bobby break up for good, whether Pam remarried someone else, or just decided she’d had enough of the Ewings and wanted to get away from them all, and just have her move away somewhere, while deciding to let Christopher stay at SouthFork (and write him out for a few episodes every season to say he’s visiting her).
[/QUOTE]

:ig:That would have been the only way for the story to make sense. And it would still have left a door open for Victoria Principal to return.
 

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
You could re cast though and the chemistry between Duffy and the re cast just wouldn't be there.

True, but with good writing they could have explained the change of chemistry as being down to the trauma that Pam has suffered. It would probably have been better for Seasons 12-14 had they gone down this route and kept most of the main characters there, than what they actually did instead. Still, damage had already been done with the botching up of the aftermath of Pam's car being engulfed in flames, which nobody could have survived in reality, along with Pam's absence then meaning that the feuds and relationships so longer joined up properly in Season 11. The actors weren't taking it seriously when Pam was mummified in the hospital, so why would the viewers?

A return of the Pamela Barnes Ewing character in Season 12, even played by Margaret Michaels, might have limited the plummeting descent of Dallas that took place after Michaels' brief appearance as Pam in Season 12 Episode 1, but it would require taking it all seriously and as realistically as possible, which nobody seemed to be doing on Dallas in Seasons 12-14 as it descended into parody. Instead, budget cuts were stepped up, old characters were removed or their appearances scaled back, a load of inferior characters were introduced which nobody believed in, and J.R. and Bobby became terrible shells of their former selves.
 
Top