Kenny Coyote
Telly Talk Star
On surface, it doesn't make any sense that Sue Ellen would have always won full custody of John Ross, doesn't it? Especially in season nine- the dream season - it seems absurd that Sue Ellen would win custody of John Ross.
Why does it seem so absurd that Sue Ellen would not only win custody, but full custody, of John Ross in season nine? Only about six episodes before she won custody of her son, she was in jail, having been found literally drinking on the street of a bad part of town with homeless people! In six episodes she goes from undergoing the DTs, to appearing court and convincing the judge that she was the parent who John Ross would be best off living with!
How does something like that happen? If she'd won partial custody that would be surprising, but it might possibly be understandable. Sue Ellen had gone to rehab for alcoholics after being detoxed in the DT ward of the hospital. Yes, the DT ward. Sue Ellen had become such a terrible alcoholic that she went into the DTs while detoxing from alcohol. That only happens to the most hardcore drinkers and even some them don't get the DTs when they quit drinking. She had gone from the hospital to a rehab clinic for alcoholics and after 4 to 6 weeks, had decided she didn't need to stay any longer. She had a terrible alcoholism problem, she’s got all the money to stay for three months or whatever they offered her, but instead she leaves after only about a month or 6 weeks just to be contrary. As soon as JR said he thought that if the place was helping her, she should stay longer,that of course she wouldn’t stay any longer because she
Let's take look at the other option the judge had, besides giving custody to Sue Ellen. JR was the father and he was a highly capable, productive man with no history of abusing drugs or alcohol. Anyone would have testifies that JR was an excellent father .
If JR had gotten custody of his son, that would mean that John Ross would get to live not only with his father, but the judge would be sending John Ross to live with his grandmother Miss Ellie and Clayton, who was like a grandfather to John Ross! He’d also have his uncle Ray and aunt Donna nearby, and his cousin Lucy was never gone for too long. How is John Ross living just with Sue Ellen preferable in the mind the judge to living with JR and all the rest of the relatives John Ross had at and around Southfork? The ranch was the only home he’d ever know, he loved the horses, and he was already going through such a difficult time with his parents getting a divorce, why make things harder on the kid by also forcing him to move from his home and all his relatives there?
Generally a judge asks that a parent who wants to get custody have at lest one full year of sobriety! Why them did Sue Ellen always win her custody battles against JR? There is just a good reason: It was done to keep the character of Sue Ellen relevant. Sue Ellen would not have been relevant enough to the show if she had lost custody, to warrant continuing to pay her salary. To be relevant she had to either work at Ewing Oil, work against Ewing Oil with Cliff or Wendell, or at least live at Southfork. Since she wasn’t expected to live at Southfork anymore, the only way they could keep her relevant was to give her something JR something he desperately, such as custody of their son.
Again, why make it so unrealistic that Sue Ellen would win overss being in Sue Ellen’s custody also made it a huge threat when she started dating. What if she started seeing Cliff? he could potentially become John Ross’ new stepfather! Can you imagine JR’s reaction to that? Yes, having her receive full custody still made her important to the story and that’s why they wrote the script to that the judge awarded custody to Sue Ellen.
Whenever there is a custody battle or some other form of contest in Dallas, always look for the underdog to win and for the same reason - so the character remains relevant! When JR and Bobby had the big contest for Ewing Oil, all the oilmen thought JR would whip Bobby and I think most of the fans agreed thatJR would likely win the contest. They couldn’t have JR win the contest though, because he didn’t have Boby’s generous nature and wouldn’t have shared the company with Bobby.
Since JR would have run Ewing Oil all by himself, then the character of Bobby doesn’t have much to do in the story anymore. Pam had already abandoned him. She’d taken Christopher with her too! So, Bobby wouldn’t have had a job at Ewing Oil, a wife or a son at home. They needed Bobby to win so that the rivalry between JR and Bobby could continue. That is one of the most important rivalries in the whole show. If JR wins the contest, it would have been very difficult continue that exciting, fun to watch rivalry. Whoever needs to win any type of contest or battle so that their character will still have interesting things to do that relate to the story
Why does it seem so absurd that Sue Ellen would not only win custody, but full custody, of John Ross in season nine? Only about six episodes before she won custody of her son, she was in jail, having been found literally drinking on the street of a bad part of town with homeless people! In six episodes she goes from undergoing the DTs, to appearing court and convincing the judge that she was the parent who John Ross would be best off living with!
How does something like that happen? If she'd won partial custody that would be surprising, but it might possibly be understandable. Sue Ellen had gone to rehab for alcoholics after being detoxed in the DT ward of the hospital. Yes, the DT ward. Sue Ellen had become such a terrible alcoholic that she went into the DTs while detoxing from alcohol. That only happens to the most hardcore drinkers and even some them don't get the DTs when they quit drinking. She had gone from the hospital to a rehab clinic for alcoholics and after 4 to 6 weeks, had decided she didn't need to stay any longer. She had a terrible alcoholism problem, she’s got all the money to stay for three months or whatever they offered her, but instead she leaves after only about a month or 6 weeks just to be contrary. As soon as JR said he thought that if the place was helping her, she should stay longer,that of course she wouldn’t stay any longer because she
Let's take look at the other option the judge had, besides giving custody to Sue Ellen. JR was the father and he was a highly capable, productive man with no history of abusing drugs or alcohol. Anyone would have testifies that JR was an excellent father .
If JR had gotten custody of his son, that would mean that John Ross would get to live not only with his father, but the judge would be sending John Ross to live with his grandmother Miss Ellie and Clayton, who was like a grandfather to John Ross! He’d also have his uncle Ray and aunt Donna nearby, and his cousin Lucy was never gone for too long. How is John Ross living just with Sue Ellen preferable in the mind the judge to living with JR and all the rest of the relatives John Ross had at and around Southfork? The ranch was the only home he’d ever know, he loved the horses, and he was already going through such a difficult time with his parents getting a divorce, why make things harder on the kid by also forcing him to move from his home and all his relatives there?
Generally a judge asks that a parent who wants to get custody have at lest one full year of sobriety! Why them did Sue Ellen always win her custody battles against JR? There is just a good reason: It was done to keep the character of Sue Ellen relevant. Sue Ellen would not have been relevant enough to the show if she had lost custody, to warrant continuing to pay her salary. To be relevant she had to either work at Ewing Oil, work against Ewing Oil with Cliff or Wendell, or at least live at Southfork. Since she wasn’t expected to live at Southfork anymore, the only way they could keep her relevant was to give her something JR something he desperately, such as custody of their son.
Again, why make it so unrealistic that Sue Ellen would win overss being in Sue Ellen’s custody also made it a huge threat when she started dating. What if she started seeing Cliff? he could potentially become John Ross’ new stepfather! Can you imagine JR’s reaction to that? Yes, having her receive full custody still made her important to the story and that’s why they wrote the script to that the judge awarded custody to Sue Ellen.
Whenever there is a custody battle or some other form of contest in Dallas, always look for the underdog to win and for the same reason - so the character remains relevant! When JR and Bobby had the big contest for Ewing Oil, all the oilmen thought JR would whip Bobby and I think most of the fans agreed thatJR would likely win the contest. They couldn’t have JR win the contest though, because he didn’t have Boby’s generous nature and wouldn’t have shared the company with Bobby.
Since JR would have run Ewing Oil all by himself, then the character of Bobby doesn’t have much to do in the story anymore. Pam had already abandoned him. She’d taken Christopher with her too! So, Bobby wouldn’t have had a job at Ewing Oil, a wife or a son at home. They needed Bobby to win so that the rivalry between JR and Bobby could continue. That is one of the most important rivalries in the whole show. If JR wins the contest, it would have been very difficult continue that exciting, fun to watch rivalry. Whoever needs to win any type of contest or battle so that their character will still have interesting things to do that relate to the story