Why The Fans Could And Did Like JR Ewing

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
After Bobby doing all those things to Jock, Jock's ultimate reaction was "He's a hell of a son, a hell of a man"! If I'm JR I'm thinking: "How the hell can I ever compete when in Daddy's eyes, Bob can do no wrong"?

This is a good point, Kenny. It is interesting to go way back to the miniseries to remember that J.R. started out to be a sympathetic character.

Bobby was single then, and was out acting the Playboy, having expensive dinners and generally throwing a lot of money around. The three B's, as Jock would say.

It was left to J.R. to stay around, putting in the long hours at the office, doing the dirty work that nobody else wanted to do. And receiving very little praise or respect for it.

You can jump into the series at any time, and watch J.R. as he manipulates and schemes his way into building Ewing Oil into the largest independent oil company in Texas. But if you watch from the beginning, where J.R. started out as sympathetic character, then you appreciate the Magnificent Bastard all the more.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Don’t forget it was Bobby who kept Ewing Oil afloat when JR gets shot. Don’t forget it was JR who destroyed their relationship with the cartel. Don’t forget it was Bobby and not JR who got Ewing Oil the refinery that Jock always wanted. Imagine that, wet behind the ears Bobby did what the mighty JR couldn’t do. Which prompted JR to say, “I’m going to cut Bobby out even if I have to destroy Ewing Oil to do it.” But he loves his family so much. Lol Don’t forget it was Bobby who ran Ewing Oil AND Southfork when JR and Ray were crying like little kids when their daddy died. Don’t forget to leave out the BD Calhoun storyline where JR lost Ewing Oil and it was Bobby who got the name back.

JR might have been better at blackmailing people to get what he wanted, but was he truly ever respected by the masses? I think Bobby was.
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Don’t forget it was Bobby who kept Ewing Oil afloat when JR gets shot. Don’t forget it was JR who destroyed their relationship with the cartel. Don’t forget it was Bobby and not JR who got Ewing Oil the refinery that Jock always wanted. Imagine that, wet behind the ears Bobby did what the mighty JR couldn’t do. Which prompted JR to say, “I’m going to cut Bobby out even if I have to destroy Ewing Oil to do it.” But he loves his family so much. Lol Don’t forget it was Bobby who ran Ewing Oil AND Southfork when JR and Ray were crying like little kids when their daddy died. Don’t forget to leave out the BD Calhoun storyline where JR lost Ewing Oil and it was Bobby who got the name back.

JR might have been better at blackmailing people to get what he wanted, but was he truly ever respected by the masses? I think Bobby was.

Also Bobby got the company back in with the cartel after JR had dumped the Asian oil leases on them.

Swami
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
This is a good point, Kenny. It is interesting to go way back to the miniseries to remember that J.R. started out to be a sympathetic character.

Bobby was single then, and was out acting the Playboy, having expensive dinners and generally throwing a lot of money around. The three B's, as Jock would say.

It was left to J.R. to stay around, putting in the long hours at the office, doing the dirty work that nobody else wanted to do. And receiving very little praise or respect for it.

They did convey JR's impossible task of pleasing his father early on (David Jacobs spells that out in the first draft on the pilot script - "JR tenses: he can't take reprimands from Jock"), and Jock's favoring of Bobby - "ran into Punk Anderson and some of the old boys and got to telling them what a fine executive you've turned out to be" - but they'd already established JR as a heel just seconds into his first appearance, kind of sleazily fondling his secretary's thigh at work while his wife was at home. Then the last act of the pilot centers on his underhanded scheme to sabotage the marriage of the two characters established in the very first scene as the fan favorites.

WC6J0Xm.png


I would have liked it if they'd kept the character of Jock more like his initial portrayal... they seemed to mix the initial 'hard-ass patriarch' in with 'doddering grandpa who can't even win a game of backgammon' and 'naive man who can't quite figure out what's going on at his own company' almost at random. He and Pam and Lucy lost some of their early edge with the first full season. Instead of Pam and Lucy dealing with issues like age-inappropriate relations and fabricated sexual assault as blackmail, we get bratty Lucy shutting off Pam's boombox as her favorite song starts to play. I don't remember - was the first full season broadcast in an earlier time slot than the miniseries? Right from the opening scene with everyone hanging out around the pool, the tone is far lighter.

ocM0H3q.png
Ve5IMc2.png
WAcHyv0.png

(C - Pam looking quite callipygous here as... wait, wrong thread..)

Sue Ellen is another character who suddenly springs into life as something closer to the character we all know in Barbecue, double-fisting it with the champagne and wine and verbally jousting with JR. The way they were portrayed in Spy In The House (a meekly sincere Sue Ellen trying to seduce a grumpy, disinterested JR - "I don't know what come over me") was pretty far removed from anything we saw later.

batAnB5.png
5i8tHih.png
kL22u6c.png

(I'm not sure we see Sue Ellen show much drunken good humor after this, though - "I was just about to take off my clothes and play Lady Godiva")
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Don’t forget it was Bobby who kept Ewing Oil afloat when JR gets shot. Don’t forget it was JR who destroyed their relationship with the cartel. Don’t forget it was Bobby and not JR who got Ewing Oil the refinery that Jock always wanted. Imagine that, wet behind the ears Bobby did what the mighty JR couldn’t do.

I think the biggest issue is that Bobby knew deep down in his heart that he would be happier running Southfork Ranch than he ever would be running Ewing Oil.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
They did convey JR's impossible task of pleasing his father early on (David Jacobs spells that out in the first draft on the pilot script - "JR tenses: he can't take reprimands from Jock"), and Jock's favoring of Bobby - "ran into Punk Anderson and some of the old boys and got to telling them what a fine executive you've turned out to be" - but they'd already established JR as a heel just seconds into his first appearance, kind of sleazily fondling his secretary's thigh at work while his wife was at home. Then the last act of the pilot centers on his underhanded scheme to sabotage the marriage of the two characters established in the very first scene as the fan favorites.

As you said, they did establish JR as devious in the first episode - after all he did try to break up his brother's marriage. That's awful. There's just no justification for that. JR had help though. Does anyone remember who helped JR try to wreck Bobby and Pamela's brand new marriage?

Ray's helped! That's at last partly because Bobby took Pam away from Ray. Ray brought her to a Southfork dance and of course out of all the women he could have gone after, Bob has to go after his ranch foreman's date. Nice. This really is not the story of a good brother and a bad brother. I know sometimes people just use that expression for simplicity's sake and yes, Bobby is a better man than JR, of course. The thing is, he's not nearly as much better as he thinks he is!

That's what really made Dallas what it was. Just a story of a perfectly noble, saint like brother who finds himself having to compete with a brother who is evil incarnate would be too damn cliched! We've already seen those kinds of stories but this was something new! It was a reasonably good brother who still had some serious flaws and a fairly bad brother who still had some very redeeming qualities. That's so much more interesting; it has so many more possibilities.

I think what @Lastkidpicked was getting at (correct me if I'm wrong), is that they showed reasons why you could feel sympathetic for JR right from the start. He said JR was a "sympathetic character" at the start - not a noble character.

You could understand why JR turned out the way he had. You had reasons to feel bad for him. JR was the only brother who wasn't either Ellie's favorite or Jock's favorite. Favoritism is really a debilitating thing for the child or the children who get left out, for the ones who aren't the favorites. Basically I think Jock and Ellie were good people but were they good at being parents? NO!

While JR spent his life doing whatever Jock asked of him, Bobby was playing football, partying and just being a playboy. Then as soon as Bob settles down, once he's married, all of the sudden Jock gives him the opportunity to work right at the top of Ewing Oil with JR. That makes JR so sympathetic - to see a guy who has earned his way to the top, climbing every rung of the ladder on the way, to have to share his position with his brother who never had the discipline or the desire to put in the requisite work to earn that position.

One brother had to earn that position and the other brother - Jock just handed it to him.

I think Bobby was smart enough to have worked his way to the top but he rarely showed the desire or the discipline for it in the early years. In fact, he liked being the road man for Ewing Oil but Pam talked him into getting into management, into running the company. Bobby would have ended up happier if he'd had the guts to stand up to his wife and say: No, I like my job as road man. Running the company is JR's thing; he's spent his whole life doing whatever Daddy asked him so that he could run the company one day - that's his.

At the end of the story, Bobby sells Ewing Oil because he doesn't want to have anything to do with Ewing Oil. I think that pretty much shows where JR's career priorities were and where Bobby's career priorities were not.

I'm very glad that they did have Bobby let Pam talk him into getting into management though because the rivalry, the competition between the two bothers is one of the things that made Dallas great.

I would have liked it if they'd kept the character of Jock more like his initial portrayal... they seemed to mix the initial 'hard-ass patriarch' in with 'doddering grandpa who can't even win a game of backgammon' and 'naive man who can't quite figure out what's going on at his own company' almost at random. He and Pam and Lucy lost some of their early edge with the first full season. Instead of Pam and Lucy dealing with issues like age-inappropriate relations and fabricated sexual assault as blackmail, we get bratty Lucy shutting off Pam's boombox as her favorite song starts to play. I don't remember - was the first full season broadcast in an earlier time slot than the miniseries? Right from the opening scene with everyone hanging out around the pool, the tone is far lighter.

I agree that they weren't consistent with how they portrayed Jock and Lucy. Pam was pretty consistent. At least until she made the absolutely absurd claim that the contest for Ewing Oil killed her mother. How about pilot error? When two planes collide isn't that generally the culprit? Whatever. It was silly, but again it was one of those things they felt like they just had to do because it would create more drama and I can't really argue. It's pretty damn hard to argue with success.

I can tell you why the characters weren't necessarily portrayed in a consistent way. It's because they had a team of writers. How are a team of writers all going to have the exact same artistic vision, the exact same level of ability to be able to make sure everything stays as consistent as it would if just one man or one woman wrote the whole thing? Great art isn't made by committee. Great TV apparently can be though.


I think the biggest issue is that Bobby knew deep down in his heart that he would be happier running Southfork Ranch than he ever would be running Ewing Oil.

Yes. Bobby was an outdoors type of guy. I think a guy like him likes to have a job with some physicality to it, not just a desk job. He was constantly changing career paths too, he was kind of a dilettante. He was into solar energy for a couple months, then construction, then politics, then he quit that too and meanwhile he was in and out of Ewing Oil and I guess that means he was still looking for something he loved to do. That's very understandable. You only live once, so it's good to do something you love doing. For Bobby I think you nailed that one - he would have been happier running the ranch with Ray than running Ewing Oil with JR.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I think the biggest issue is that Bobby knew deep down in his heart that he would be happier running Southfork Ranch than he ever would be running Ewing Oil.

I agree with that, but circumstances always brought him back to Ewing Oil and they all centered around JR.
 
Top