Lastkidpicked
Telly Talk Dream Maker
@Laurie Marr
I like your profile pic.
I like your profile pic.
After Bobby doing all those things to Jock, Jock's ultimate reaction was "He's a hell of a son, a hell of a man"! If I'm JR I'm thinking: "How the hell can I ever compete when in Daddy's eyes, Bob can do no wrong"?
Don’t forget it was Bobby who kept Ewing Oil afloat when JR gets shot. Don’t forget it was JR who destroyed their relationship with the cartel. Don’t forget it was Bobby and not JR who got Ewing Oil the refinery that Jock always wanted. Imagine that, wet behind the ears Bobby did what the mighty JR couldn’t do. Which prompted JR to say, “I’m going to cut Bobby out even if I have to destroy Ewing Oil to do it.” But he loves his family so much. Lol Don’t forget it was Bobby who ran Ewing Oil AND Southfork when JR and Ray were crying like little kids when their daddy died. Don’t forget to leave out the BD Calhoun storyline where JR lost Ewing Oil and it was Bobby who got the name back.
JR might have been better at blackmailing people to get what he wanted, but was he truly ever respected by the masses? I think Bobby was.
This is a good point, Kenny. It is interesting to go way back to the miniseries to remember that J.R. started out to be a sympathetic character.
Bobby was single then, and was out acting the Playboy, having expensive dinners and generally throwing a lot of money around. The three B's, as Jock would say.
It was left to J.R. to stay around, putting in the long hours at the office, doing the dirty work that nobody else wanted to do. And receiving very little praise or respect for it.
Don’t forget it was Bobby who kept Ewing Oil afloat when JR gets shot. Don’t forget it was JR who destroyed their relationship with the cartel. Don’t forget it was Bobby and not JR who got Ewing Oil the refinery that Jock always wanted. Imagine that, wet behind the ears Bobby did what the mighty JR couldn’t do.
They did convey JR's impossible task of pleasing his father early on (David Jacobs spells that out in the first draft on the pilot script - "JR tenses: he can't take reprimands from Jock"), and Jock's favoring of Bobby - "ran into Punk Anderson and some of the old boys and got to telling them what a fine executive you've turned out to be" - but they'd already established JR as a heel just seconds into his first appearance, kind of sleazily fondling his secretary's thigh at work while his wife was at home. Then the last act of the pilot centers on his underhanded scheme to sabotage the marriage of the two characters established in the very first scene as the fan favorites.
I would have liked it if they'd kept the character of Jock more like his initial portrayal... they seemed to mix the initial 'hard-ass patriarch' in with 'doddering grandpa who can't even win a game of backgammon' and 'naive man who can't quite figure out what's going on at his own company' almost at random. He and Pam and Lucy lost some of their early edge with the first full season. Instead of Pam and Lucy dealing with issues like age-inappropriate relations and fabricated sexual assault as blackmail, we get bratty Lucy shutting off Pam's boombox as her favorite song starts to play. I don't remember - was the first full season broadcast in an earlier time slot than the miniseries? Right from the opening scene with everyone hanging out around the pool, the tone is far lighter.
I think the biggest issue is that Bobby knew deep down in his heart that he would be happier running Southfork Ranch than he ever would be running Ewing Oil.
I think the biggest issue is that Bobby knew deep down in his heart that he would be happier running Southfork Ranch than he ever would be running Ewing Oil.