Why Was JR So Hell Bent On Getting Rid Of Pam?

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
OK, I know, there was the Ewing/Barnes feud. I can understand JR having it in for Digger and Cliff, but what was the reason for the hate for Pam? It didn’t take no time for Miss Ellie and even Jock to accept her at Southfork. Sue Ellen eventually came around and she acted as an older sister to Lucy.

Was JR that insecure that Bobby would have the 1st male heir?
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
OK, I know, there was the Ewing/Barnes feud. I can understand JR having it in for Digger and Cliff, but what was the reason for the hate for Pam? It didn’t take no time for Miss Ellie and even Jock to accept her at Southfork. Sue Ellen eventually came around and she acted as an older sister to Lucy.

Was JR that insecure that Bobby would have the 1st male heir?

I don't know if he ever said exactly why, but one possibility is that he objected to her marrying into his family on general principle, kind of like how Cliff treated Bobby badly even though Bobby was good to him.
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
It’s actually not that complicated, though it is complex.

JR felt that by hating Pam, he was showing a loyalty to Jock, because of what had happened with Digger. He wanted his Daddy's approval which was so lacking no matter what he did. Digger hurt Jock, according to Jock, so JR was determined to hate anything Barnes related, even if it wasn’t logical (as in Digger wasn’t actually Pam’s real father).

When Jock died he couldn’t let it go, and was determined to keep it going, for the loyalty and approval he never got.

:(
 

James from London

International Treasure
Was JR that insecure that Bobby would have the 1st male heir?

Absolutely! What could be more important?

And because she might have been a spy for her brother. And because she was the one who talked Bobby into coming off the road and taking an active interest in Ewing Oil. And because her and Bobby's love for each other exposed the coldness of his own marriage. And because Pam stood up to him, which meant their animosity soon became personal. "But mostly because she's a Barnes," as Sue Ellen once explained to Jamie.
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
I think the J.R./Pam antagonism was baked in the show's premise right from its inception, back when David Jacobs planned to off Bobby and have the two of them duke it out (which ironically happened decades later, until it turned out silly Dallas viewers dreamed it). In the early episodes anyway, Cliff talked about how incredulous he was Pam married a Ewing because both of them had bought Digger's myth about the Ewings as the coldhearted bastards that robbed the Barnes family of their rightful legacy. Couple that with J.R. knowing from Ray about Ray's affair with Pam, and the stigma of white trash that came with gossip, it made for a powerful negative vibe from the beginning. And as @James from London mentioned, she proved to be even more trouble with her influence on Bobby early on, and even later her own brother was the one who cuckolded him and then her mother--whom she found--was able to bankroll Cliff's business ambitions. If anyone in the Barnes family had a spine (and brought the family together like glue) it was Pam , so wouldn't she be J.R.'s most consistent target?
 
Oddly enough I didn't see that in the episodes eventhough it makes perfect sense that he should feel that way.

As early as Digger's Daughter, Jock stressed the spirit of competition there. Stood on the porch, they could hear laughter from Bobby and Pam's bedroom and Jock made some comment that if JR didn't attend to Sue Ellen, his first grandson would be Bobby and Pam's.

There's also a fair bit of needling from Sue Ellen to JR about it in early-ish episodes.

And of course how disturbed he is by Pam's pregnancy in Barbecue. Which led to the (not completely answered) question of whether he pushed Pam from the hayloft.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
And of course how disturbed he is by Pam's pregnancy in Barbecue. Which led to the (not completely answered) question of whether he pushed Pam from the hayloft.

There is no question. I watched that episode about a week ago so it's fresh in my memory. He didn't push her.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Jock stressed the spirit of competition there
Did it matter to him that JR would give him his first grandson?
There's also a fair bit of needling from Sue Ellen to JR
Yes. But I found JR remarkably uncompetitive and indifferent in regard to Pam's pregnancy, maybe there was the shock that Ewing and Barnes blood had mixed.
He had lost interest in Sue Ellen as soon as he had conquered her, but surely it wouldn't have been impossible to conceive a child with her? And then lose interest - that would make more sense.
Especially if he had wanted it so badly (if only to please Jock).
 
Did it matter to him that JR would give him his first grandson?

I'd say it mattered more to him that he had a grandson. It didn't matter which of the two sons gave it to him (though I do think it would have been kind of interesting to see Jock and JR's feelings if Gary had produced a son. Not necessarily instead of Lucy, but before John Ross).


found JR remarkably uncompetitive and indifferent in regard to Pam's pregnancy, maybe there was the shock that Ewing and Barnes blood had mixed.

He seemed quite defeated, I thought. It's one of the few times in the series when he was visibly drunk.


He had lost interest in Sue Ellen as soon as he had conquered her, but surely it wouldn't have been impossible to conceive a child with her? And then lose interest - that would make more sense.

Yes, it would. I've got the impression his immediate loss of interest once married created... difficulties in the bedroom, so it was kind of beyond his control.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
He had lost interest in Sue Ellen as soon as he had conquered her, but surely it wouldn't have been impossible to conceive a child with her? And then lose interest - that would make more sense.
Especially if he had wanted it so badly (if only to please Jock).

They'd also been married for something like seven years already when the series begins, so I don't have any reason to think that having a son before Bobby had a son was in any way a high priority for JR. It kind of seems like it should've been a priority for him, given the other things we know about him, so some people might say it was inconsistent writing to not have had it been more important to JR. I don't have a definite opinion on that. Having a child makes a marriage more permanent because then you'll always be connected to that person, even if you get a divorce. It could be that he felt like having a child with Sue Ellen would make him feel like he'd be chained to Sue Ellen forever. They never went into it, so I can only speculate. That their marriage wasn't good, that they did end up divorcing all indicate it's a possibility that he specifically did not want a child at that time.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Well I think the problem was that Bobby and Pam brought the baby issue back into the picture, so yes that's definitely a reason to dislike her.
Was JR that insecure that Bobby would have the 1st male heir?
But I never got the impression that he wanted to beat Bobby, because he could have done that.
 
In the early days, there's also some weird sexual undercurrent to the dynamic of JR and Pam's relationship, I think. Certainly throughout the mini-series there's some kind of frisson (and at the beginning of Season One there's a less subtle nod to this when he admires her "boo-eys"). It's a while since I've watched, but isn't there a one-to-one between them in an early-ish episode where he says something about her being attractive and she gives him a derisive look up and down and tells him how disgusting she finds him?

If she weren't a Barnes - and his brother's wife - she's exactly the kind of woman he'd enjoy the challenge of pursuing. And yet she's not only off limits, she finds him repellent. Not because he's a Ewing, but because of who he is. He can't charm her and he can't intimidate her. I think he finds that confusing.

Perhaps he envies Bobby for having something he doesn't. Not just Pam herself, but - in those early days - a marriage that's happy and demonstrative.
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
I actually don’t think it’s anything to do with envy. Pam, babies or otherwise.

The stupid immature idiot had a wife who adored him and he was so scared of debasing her that he sought affection elsewhere. Not Sue Ellen’s fault - he later finds out how passionate she is - HIS fault.

I love him but it does crack me up how he manages to wangle pity for things that are his own doing.

Still that is the beauty of his character - he is anything but one dimensional!! :)
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
It's a mutual dislike of the two families exacerbated by the fact that Cliff keeps gunning for JR.

JR felt quite wrongly that if he couldn't hurt Cliff he could at least take it out on Pam.

Pam was sadly caught in the middle of the Barnes Ewing feud, but that was to the benefit of the show as the central premise of Dallas for me wasn't the feud itself but the rivalry & competition between JR & Pam. :)
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I think the bigger question here is why JR had such a hatred for his brothers partners. Think Pam and Valene.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
In the early days, there's also some weird sexual undercurrent to the dynamic of JR and Pam's relationship, I think. Certainly throughout the mini-series there's some kind of frisson (and at the beginning of Season One there's a less subtle nod to this when he admires her "boo-eys"). It's a while since I've watched, but isn't there a one-to-one between them in an early-ish episode where he says something about her being attractive and she gives him a derisive look up and down and tells him how disgusting she finds him?

If she weren't a Barnes - and his brother's wife - she's exactly the kind of woman he'd enjoy the challenge of pursuing. And yet she's not only off limits, she finds him repellent. Not because he's a Ewing, but because of who he is. He can't charm her and he can't intimidate her. I think he finds that confusing.

Perhaps he envies Bobby for having something he doesn't. Not just Pam herself, but - in those early days - a marriage that's happy and demonstrative.

I always found this little scene between J.R. and Pam very revealing and underappreciated. It´s from middle Season 2 (original) and I wish they had kept this dynamics going on. It sort of precedes the infamous slap scene from "Ewing Inferno" with sex insults included. Funny that they are alone in both scenes and are truly fighting each other with their tongues (so to say):

Edit to add the writing credits for both scenes: Katzman wrote "Love and Marriage" (first scene) and Arthur B. Lewis "Ewing Inferno" (second scene). They clearly knew the show´s bible and character motivations!
 
Last edited:
isn't there a one-to-one between them in an early-ish episode where he says something about her being attractive and she gives him a derisive look up and down and tells him how disgusting she finds him?
I always found this little scene between J.R. and Pam very revealing and underappreciated. It´s from middle Season 2

Oh thanks. That's one of the scenes I meant, but I'd have had trouble finding it.


Funny that they are alone in both scenes and are truly fighting each other with their tongues (so to say)

Yes. There's a very distinct energy between the two of them in those one-to-ones. There are parts of themselves aspects of their characters that only seem to emerge when they're alone together. Like they can drop the niceties because there are no-one else's feelings to spare or nobody to reign them back in. It started with the "Miss Barnes" scene in Digger's Daughter where JR gave her a tour of the ranch and tried to buy her off.
 
I always found this little scene between J.R. and Pam very revealing

Looking back at this again, JR's line to Pam: "Anytime you wanna find out it can be easily arranged" is so enjoyably sleazy. And dangerously close to where anyone - his wife, his mother, Pam's husband - could have overheard.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I think the bigger question here is why JR had such a hatred for his brothers partners. Think Pam and Valene.

I was going to bring that up. He even initially tried to break up Ray and Donna. Did he think he was the only one that should have a wife?
 
Top