Why Was JR So Hell Bent On Getting Rid Of Pam?

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Gary didn't know.

Ellie and Jock's motives were a little more selfish: they enjoyed having Lucy around (the Van Wormer book says Ellie, who missed having children round, was "elated" to have Lucy on Southfork, with her viewing Lucy as "the daughter she never had"). They were able to turn a blind eye to the kidnap by justifying it as being in the best interests of the child. Something for which Ellie later made a sincere apology to Valene.

That's pretty much how I pictured it. They said Gary got Valene pregnant when she was 15 years old, so she was at most, 16 years old when Lucy was born. I can picture Jock and Ellie saying how can a 16 year old girl raise our granddaughter? I tend to think that a sixteen year old girl is going to have problems raising a child by herself. She shouldn't have been kept out of the picture though. Ideally they'd have offered to help her raise Lucy and either had Valene move into Southfork, or given her some money so she could have rented a nearby apartment.

Did Gary not know because he and Valene had gotten divorced and he showed no interest in Lucy, or did he not know what was going on with his daughter because he was off an a drinking binge?

I'm not familiar with that book. What's the title of it?
 
She shouldn't have been kept out of the picture though. Ideally they'd have offered to help her raise Lucy and either had Valene move into Southfork, or given her some money so she could have rented a nearby apartment.

I assume Jock and Ellie had no contact and no way of knowing where Val was after she was driven from Southfork. JR would had some idea having kept tabs on her - certainly up to the point he snatched Lucy, and enough to try and prevent Val returning to Dallas.


Did Gary not know because he and Valene had gotten divorced and he showed no interest in Lucy, or did he not know what was going on with his daughter because he was off an a drinking binge?

I don't believe Gary and Val formally divorced.

He left Southfork after a drinking binge to try to get himself together and ended up drifting across the country for the next decade and a half. He'd left Val and Lucy on Southfork, hoping that Ellie would look after them.



I'm not familiar with that book. What's the title of it?

Dallas: The Complete Ewing Family Saga* by Laura Van Wormer

09cb6aaed359b2aa6ed35564c3cf2dec--dallas-tv-saga.jpg


It's basically biographies based on information known at the time of writing (1985). Mostly accurate, but in filling in gaps some facts such as dates of birth differ from what was later said in the series. It was also written before The Early Years and before Jamie showed up so I don't believe there's a mention of Jason Ewing.

It's worth getting for Dallas fans, has some nice images throughout and beautiful matte paintings on the front and back covers. It can probably be picked up on Amazon, eBay or suchlike.

The author also wrote a companion book on Knots Landing which expands Gary and Val's bios.




*To give it its full title:
Dallas: The Complete Ewing Family Saga, Including Southfork Ranch, Ewing Oil, and the Barnes-Ewing Feud - 1860-1985
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
Gary was also in denial and rarely faced reality during those times, and in early Knots Landing. He didn't know and didn't want to know.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
As keen as JR was to keep Gary and Valene in California, they (and Lucy by extension) weren't really threats to him running the business.

Swami

True, but I don't think it was all about the business. JR, for all his bluster and bullying, was wildly insecure at times. Keeping Gary and Val in CA meant he was keeping them away from Southfork and so he wouldn't have to fight them for attention and affection - not only from Jock, but from Miss Ellie too.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Gary was also in denial and rarely faced reality during those times, and in early Knots Landing. He didn't know and didn't want to know.

That's part of why Gary broke Jock's heart. Jock said "It broke my heart when I found out Gary didn't have any guts." Part of having guts is facing reality. It's unlikely someone who lives in a state of denial and refuses to face reality will do things like take responsibility or handle stress effectively.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
That's part of why Gary broke Jock's heart. Jock said "It broke my heart when I found out Gary didn't have any guts." Part of having guts is facing reality. It's unlikely someone who lives in a state of denial and refuses to face reality will do things like take responsibility or handle stress effectively.

Jock is his father and needs to take some responsibility for how he raised his children. When parents make no bones about how they favor one child over another, that's a recipe for disaster.
Jock was very judgmental of other people, yet I can't recall too many times where he looked in the mirror and really faced his own reality. There were times he ran roughshod over innocent people, and chalked it up to being " tough." Did he ever consider it's not "tough" being an unethical bully.
As far as Gary goes, as he aged he did face reality and his alcoholism. It takes a certain kind of guts to do that.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Jock is his father and needs to take some responsibility for how he raised his children. When parents make no bones about how they favor one child over another, that's a recipe for disaster.

Yes, I absolutely agree with that. Jock and Ellie were both guilty of favoritism and that's what led to the type of family we saw every Friday night when we watched Dallas. Jock favored Bobby and neglected Gary. Ellie's favorite was Gary and she favored both Gary and Bobby over JR. She told Jock she wanted him to leave Bobby in control of Ewing Oil, taking JR's job away from him - the job he had worked for all his life. Ellie told Jock she didn't care what that did to Ewing Oil - the company he'd spent his whole life building and that if Bobby moved out she would never forgive Jock. All she cared about was having things the way she wanted them ( her adult sons never moving out of Southfork into homes other own) and didn't care what it took make that happen or how it affected other people.

Jock was very judgmental of other people, yet I can't recall too many times where he looked in the mirror and really faced his own reality. There were times he ran roughshod over innocent people, and chalked it up to being " tough." Did he ever consider it's not "tough" being an unethical bully.

I'd have loved to have seen a series that showed Jock building Ewing Oil so we could've seen how he did it. I think Jock became what he had to be to survive in a business as cutthroat as the oil business. From what little we know about it, from hearing a story here and there, instead of seeing it, I don't know that Jock's ethics were any different from those of his competitors. It seemed like the type of business where if you tried to be ethical all the time and be a nice guy, you'd get put out of business. Jock became very good at first surviving in that environment and then flourishing. When he got out of the business by retiring, it seems to me that he wondered how he could have done some of the things he did and been so callous. He did some good things like making sure Amanda was provided for for the rest of her life, welcoming Ray into the family very generously, and having the attitude of "I'm proud of what Bobby did. He showed people that Ewing Oil stands for something."

As far as Gary goes, as he aged he did face reality and his alcoholism. It takes a certain kind of guts to do that.

Yes, later on Gary did conquer his alcoholism and that's very admirable. I didn't see Knot's Landing, so I only saw what little of Gary they showed in Dallas. If there had not been a Knot's Landing, there would have been more time to go into what Jock as talking about in "Reunion" where he said to Ellie that he wasn't thinking of building walls up between him and Gary; he wanted to tear the walls down. There was a scene where Jock said he wanted to address the problems between Gary and the rest of the family, especially between Gary and himself. Jock was ready to take accountability for where he'd failed Gary and it would have been a fascinating storyline, but instead they went with showing JR setting up Gary with a company wouldn't be able to handle and they never got back to the original idea of Jock attempting to mend the relationship between Gary and him. After Knot's Landing started, Gary never appeared in Dallas for long enough to do a storyline like that.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
For a parent be so heartbroken that a child doesn't conform to their expectations that they are prepared to simply write them off seems at best a little unhealthy.


As a parent I’d have found it heartbreaking to see my son become an alcoholic and a compulsive gambler who couldn’t handle any type of responsibility. Gary got a 15 year old girl pregnant and then became a deadbeat dad, not knowing what was going on with his daughter or helping to raise her in any way. What kind of parent wouldn’t be heartbroken to see their son end up that way? Not that you ever write off a child, but it would still be a heartbreaking situation.

We didn't get to see any of that happen or how Jock and Ellie reacted to it, but I found the episode "Reunion" very positive when Jock decided to have a talk with Gary and the rest of the family and said they should talk about: "Who did what to whom, who needs to be forgiven, who needs to forgive." He was trying his best to mend his relationship with Gary, to "tear down the walls between them." Unfortunately they cut that scene short and never showed the conversation, so we didn't find out "who did what to whom", but it was a very positive step to want to have that talk with Gary and take accountability for wherever he'd failed Gary.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Miss Ellie once said to Jock when talking about Gary.

“You might have loved him, but you didn’t care for him.”

That says a lot.
 
As a parent I’d have found it heartbreaking to see my son become an alcoholic and a compulsive gambler who couldn’t handle any type of responsibility.

And would those outcomes be your son's fault?

Gary's illnesses of alcoholism and gambling weren't the cause of Jock's rejection. If anything, they were a response to it.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
And would those outcomes be your son's fault?

Gary's illnesses of alcoholism and gambling weren't the cause of Jock's rejection. If anything, they were a response to it.

We have no way of knowing the answer to that because we didn't see what took place between them. In these types of situations it's very difficult to blame only one side. Much like when two people decide they don't want to be married to each other anymore, there is almost always some fault on both sides. Here, we have a situation were the other side is two people: Jock and Ellie. They raised him and clearly they made mistakes. Gary has accountability in it too. As children become adults, the problems they carry with them from their childhood then becomes of a matter of: Am I going to do what's necessary to fix my problems, or am I just going to blame my parents for the rest of my life? As Gary got older and he had a daughter whom he didn't even know where she was or how she was doing, he'd become a deadbeat dad. That's hard to defend. Gary did eventually confront his problems, but too late for it to do Lucy any good as she was growing up.
 
Last edited:
Gary did eventually confront his problems, but too late for it to do Lucy any good as she was growing up.

Much like Jock finally "tearing down walls" with his son as he entered his seventies, which you've managed to repeatedly praise without focussing on the fact that it was too late to do Gary any good.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Much like Jock finally "tearing down walls" with his son as he entered his seventies, which you've managed to repeatedly praise without focussing on the fact that it was too late to do Gary any good.

You don't converse; you just raise objections.

I "managed" to talk about that episode because it's the first episode of the series that has Gary in it. How much earlier in the show would you like me to start?

They raised him and clearly they made mistakes. Gary has accountability in it too.

Wow, what an unfair assessment of the situation that was.

Meanwhile, you've "managed" to not assign any of the fault to the parent who was primarily responsible for raising the kids or to Gary for taking no self-accountability for his actions until he was in his thirties.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Making judgemental criticisms of the individual rather than focussing on the logic of their argument is no less objectionable.

Please refrain from doing so in future.

It's only alright if you're the one doing it?

BTW, you thought it was funny before and clicked on "funny" but then undid it, so what changed your mind?
 
Last edited:
Top