Would Dallas be in danger of removal from streaming services?

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
They should just re-cut the entire series to only feature the Best of Holly Harwood and Mandy Winger: True Feminist Heroines. :spinning:
 

Frank Underwood

Telly Talk Champion
You being fat has nothing to do with your race. It has no links to a past of oppression and slavery. You being fat has nothing to do with racial segregation. You being FAT has no relevance in this conversation. Fat people were not ripped from their home lands and kept as stock by white people as slaves you moron!
The truth is I'm not literally offended by those shows. However, there are fat positivity groups out there who have grievances with them. Thus, the relevance is that just about anybody can have a reason to be offended by how they're depicted on television. I've heard The Big Bang Theory and Will and Grace described as black face for nerds and gay people respectively. Although I think that's a tad hyperbolic, I get their point. My point is that I believe individuals need to exercise personal responsibility when it comes to choosing not to watch or listen to something they find offensive. Just because I choose to separate fictional depictions from the treatment of people in the real world doesn't make me a racist. I oppose injustice and inequality of every kind in the real world, but the reality is the world has an ugly side. Censoring works of fiction and deciding what entertainment is and isn't acceptable won't fix that.

You're imaginary hypothetical slights are not the same thing as very real black oppression. You racist idiot.
Real black oppression is the problem, not the work of fiction.

What about the hypothetical of a beloved show like Breaking Bad being pulled because of the negative depiction of minorities as drug dealers? Tell me, oh arbiter of entertainment.

I have a different opinion than you, yet I'm not the one hurling insults. Ironically, you seem to have hate in your heart, and you're seeing racism where there is none.

He trivialised Black Lives Matter and things that are occurring right now, by comparing his offence of jokes about overweight people on sitcoms to the attacking, mocking and racist portrayal of black people in TV and film. They are not the same thing. It appeared he needed that explained to him in the bluntest terms.
I neither trivialized black lives matter, nor the protests for racial justice. You chose to equate my views on fiction with my views on real world racial issues. They are not the same thing!

And your explanation wasn't blunt, it was insulting. There's a difference.
​
 
Last edited:

Frank Underwood

Telly Talk Champion
This is how it works for people who are resistant to accepting equality in diversity. When people challenge them they create a hostile environment to force people away from the discussion or to close it down. That way nothing changes so they win by default.
Except I was insulted and demeaned by someone who I assume supports equality and diversity. Apparently that doesn't apply to opinions with him.

I don't know what your race is but that's not the experience of many black people. When I was at school I was often taunted with racist insults that appeared in films and TV. Whenever Gone With The Wind was on TV I could guarantee that someone would call me a "darkie" the next day.

What about the rights of black people not to have to endure being treated like a piece of dirt.
People who use slurs like that will find any reason to do so. This is like the conservative groups that blame gun violence on video games when some people are just naturally vile.
​


I'm not in favour of fat shaming or mocking people who carry some excess kilograms but it's not really comparable with anti-black racism. Fat people are not twice as likely to be unemployed than other people, fat people aren't more likely to be suspended from school that other students, fat people who are found guilty of crimes are not more likely to get a harsher sentence that other people and fat drivers are not 30% more likely to be pulled over that slimmer ones. Making a joke about a fat person is not the same as perpetuating a white supremacist agenda.
For the record, I wasn't literally offended by those shows, but I know many overweight people are.

Also, I agree with you about the treatment of black people. Anybody who follows my posts on the politics forum knows I strongly support reforming our criminal justice, education, and healthcare system, along with reducing unemployment and increasing wages. That would benefit everybody, including minorities. The distinction I make is between fiction and reality.

People talk about free speech like it doesn't apply to black people. Black people living in a racist society complaining about racists portrayals in entertainment also have a right to say when things should change. TV has a choice: it can continue to perpetuate the systemic racism that has existed in the industry forever or it can change to bring about more racial equality. People need to used their voices to ensure the latter is the choice they make.
Of course black people have just as much right to free speech, and to express their opinion on how they're portrayed on TV. However, not every black person agrees on what's considered a positive portrayal of themself. This includes when a black person is at the helm. For example, Tyler Perry has been accused by some black people of making them look like buffoons.

If a black producer did a show where all white people were stereotyped as a bunch of oppressive, country club attending, racist snobs, I obviously wouldn't find that to be an accurate depiction of every white person. And if they called us honkies and crackers, I wouldn't like that either. However, I still wouldn't demand that it be pulled and treated like it doesn't exist.

If it's pulled because nobody's watching, that's a different story. But a show like the Dukes of Hazzard was pulled because of the confederate flag, and that was not a racially charged show.

Angela Channing said:
I agree with your point about Dallas. I think the only offensive thing I can recall is the term JR used to describe gay men. but I think that was in keeping with his character. However, there should have been someone in that scene to challenge his use of the word so the viewer was clear that it was unacceptable..
That could be considered treating the audience like they're stupid. If you don't already know it's wrong to use a homophobic or racial slur, is a television character going to convince you?

Besides, Bobby technically defended Kit. He told JR that Kit was more of a man than he'd ever be, and Lucy protected his secret. So in the end, they did show the other side.
​
 
Last edited:

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
The truth is I'm not literally offended by those shows. However, there are fat positivity groups out there who have grievances with them. Thus, the relevance is that just about anybody can have a reason to be offended by how they're depicted on television. I've heard The Big Bang Theory and Will and Grace described as black face for nerds and gay people respectively. Although I think that's a tad hyperbolic, I get their point. My point is that I believe individuals need to exercise personal responsibility when it comes to choosing not to watch or listen to something they find offensive. Just because I choose to separate fictional depictions from the treatment of people in the real world doesn't make me a racist. I oppose injustice and inequality of every kind in the real world, but the reality is the world has an ugly side. Censoring works of fiction and deciding what entertainment is and isn't acceptable won't fix that.


Real black oppression is the problem, not the work of fiction.

What about the hypothetical of a beloved show like Breaking Bad being pulled because of the negative depiction of minorities as drug dealers? Tell me, oh arbiter of entertainment.

I have a different opinion than you, yet I'm not the one hurling insults. Ironically, you seem to have hate in your heart, and you're seeing racism where there is none.


I neither trivialized black lives matter, nor the protests for racial justice. You chose to equate my views on fiction with my views on real world racial issues. They are not the same thing!

And your explanation wasn't blunt, it was insulting. There's a difference.
​
God bless America!
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
That could be considered treating the audience like they're stupid. If you don't already know it's wrong to use a homophobic or racial slur, is a television character going to convince you?
I agree. The emotion and implication should come from the story and characters itself, not some footnote comments.
When the tendency to racism or any other kind of hate is already there then a statement in or before the movie isn't going to change their minds (if not the opposite, because hatred is a hunger that will do anything to feed itself).

When a movie like GWTW is obviously romanticizing history then most people would see it as depicted by the cheesy and over-romanticized movie, not the real world.
If they would show fictional Jewish prisoners singing "Hi-Ho!" in a concentration camp then I wouldn't think "Hm, maybe it wasn't so bad after all".
DALLAS didn't romanticize certain ethnics, they completely ignored them, so I assume it was only popular amongst white viewers?
It was fictional and incorrect, but it's a work of fiction that doesn't have to adhere to anything - and whether it's perceived as good or bad concerns the creator, not the viewer.
The creator is the one who has to deal with any (hypothetical) consequences.

We could all have decided to simply not watch Dallas, but we did. And how we loved it. And that's why it feels a bit hypocritical to say that there should have been characters of other ethnics in DALLAS, because no-one had a problem with the all-white cast until these threads popped up.
Especially because we know it can't be changed retroactively. To me, it comes across as fair-weather support.

So, instead of stating the obvious to the audience, maybe we could simply decide that GWTW, regardless of its popularity, is an overrated epic that no longer deserves to be in the Top 10 Best Films Of All Times.
An (unfortunate) decision that would only affect the creators, not the viewers. The viewer doesn't have to take responsibility for its content, they only react to it.
That said, a streaming service has the right to take responsibility for making certain content available or adjust it with a certain subtext - and again, the consequences of those actions will only concern the streaming service itself.

There's a reason why we teach children factual history in school - because we shouldn't forget. We shouldn't forget how the slavery happened and what it meant.
The confederate slavery can't be used as an argument for all eternity. At some point the past becomes the past. It's like saying that we should keep hating the modern Germans for what happened in WWII all those many years ago.
There was still a whiff of anti-Germany back in the 1970s, maybe the 80s too, but that was 50 years ago and afaik it no longer exists.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
That could be considered treating the audience like they're stupid. If you don't already know it's wrong to use a homophobic or racial slur, is a television character going to convince you?

Besides, Bobby technically defended Kit. He told JR that Kit was more of a man than he'd ever be, and Lucy protected his secret. So in the end, they did show the other side.

People who are easily offended might find it offensive that Bobby, while he's presented as being a basically good guy, doesn't hesitate to use violence, or the threat of violence to get his way or to intimidate and he never seems to have to pay a price for it. Of course, punching someone isn't a slur; it's an action. Maybe only words count as "offensive" to the types of people who would get that bothered over a piece of fiction.
 
Last edited:

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
People who are easily offended might find it offensive that Bobby, while he's presented as being a basically good guy, doesn't hesitate to use violence, or the threat of violence to get his way or to intimidate and he never seems to have to pay a price for it. Of course, punching someone isn't a slur; it's an action. Maybe only words count as "offensive" to the types of people who would get that bothered over a piece of fiction.

The thing about the current extreme "cancel culture" and banning everything that bvb could be deemed as offensive is that's is like a snake swallowswa its own tail. Nobody is safe from it because you could probably go back long enough and find a way everyone anything has offended someone. In in the end it will devour us all.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
If they would show fictional Jewish prisoners singing "Hi-Ho!" in a concentration camp then I wouldn't think "Hm, maybe it wasn't so bad after all".
Did you guys ever get HOGAN'S HEROES ??

The thing about the current extreme "cancel culture" and banning everything that bvb could be deemed as offensive is that's is like a snake swallowswa its own tail. Nobody is safe from it because you could probably go back long enough and find a way everyone anything has offended someone. In in the end it will devour us all.

There are those today in the woke culture (and I'm a solid leftist) who want nothing more than to cancel everything retroactively.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
There are those today in the woke culture (and I'm a solid leftist) who want nothing more than to cancel everything retroactively.[/QUOTE]

Interestingly, the "woke" people may consider themselves progressive, but they are now acting like the people who wanted to censor every book under the sun. I would not be surprised if we start seeing book burnings.
 

Justine

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Oh they were there to say Telephono Mrs Ewing or Dinner is served! ;)

I think we have to accept that things happened that were considered OK back in the day, a different time and place/.

Whats not acceptable now, was in 1970/80s etc

Fawlty Towers was the best comedy drama ever for me but there are phrases used that wouldnt be acceptable today, but it shouldnt be banned

JR made derogatory marks about Homosexuals, different time and place

I do think Political Correctness will kill off many things and we have to be so touchy feely, tread on toes, careful not to offend anyone these days

but whats in the past is in the past, cant change it, but can ensure that things change for the better in the future and past mistakes arent made.

I'm 100% with you on this point. I absolutely support the #BlackLivesMatter movement but I think any shows from previous decades that may be deemed offensive in any way should have a disclaimer attached and be available for viewing. TV shows are as much a part of history as anything else.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
I'm 100% with you on this point. I absolutely support the #BlackLivesMatter movement but I think any shows from previous decades that may be deemed offensive in any way should have a disclaimer attached and be available for viewing. TV shows are as much a part of history as anything else.


There was a time before there were 300+ channels when all channels followed a format of 8-9 being geared toward kids, 9-10, late teens/adults and 10-11 the shows that required the most maturity were aired. If All in the Family used the "N" word in an episode that highlighted the evils of racism, the theory is that people up that late would get it, and wouldn't proceed to casually use that word. Grammar schools supposedly wouldn't get the satire. Hence the caveat "For Mature Audiences Only." Of course, I know young kids who are a lot more mature than adults, but that's a different subject.
With cable television and, of course, the internet those guidelines have disappeared. Kids of any age or maturity level can see anything. In fact, my students have told me of things they've seen on the internet that I wouldn't be able to sit through without needing shock treatment.
I don't believe in censorship per se, but there is such a thing as age appropriate viewing and the value of parental control.
 

Justine

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
There was a time before there were 300+ channels when all channels followed a format of 8-9 being geared toward kids, 9-10, late teens/adults and 10-11 the shows that required the most maturity were aired. If All in the Family used the "N" word in an episode that highlighted the evils of racism, the theory is that people up that late would get it, and wouldn't proceed to casually use that word. Grammar schools supposedly wouldn't get the satire. Hence the caveat "For Mature Audiences Only." Of course, I know young kids who are a lot more mature than adults, but that's a different subject.
With cable television and, of course, the internet those guidelines have disappeared. Kids of any age or maturity level can see anything. In fact, my students have told me of things they've seen on the internet that I wouldn't be able to sit through without needing shock treatment.
I don't believe in censorship per se, but there is such a thing as age appropriate viewing and the value of parental control.

Absolutely, it's so much harder to censor TV nowadays. We're fairly used to it but if you stop and think, it's actually insane that kids could watch Dallas (a show that started in the 70s) online today and become fans.

At the end of the day, you will never be able to keep any TV show, comedy sketch etc. hidden because it's racist/homophobic etc. It will always be available out there somewhere. In my mind, it's better that content be available and frowned upon (with a disclaimer) for it's offensive moments.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I actually found the characters of the early BBQ planners Telly and her husband a bit more offensive.
Billy could you elaborate how you found the characters of Telly and her husband offensive? From memory they had their own business and assisted the Ewing family with the annual bar-b-que.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
HOGAN'S HEROES --- a 1960s sitcom, produced by Kristin Shepard's warbling father, about hijinks in Nazi concentration camps where the prisoners of war ran circles around Himmler's wacky officers.

What's not fun about that?
Was/Is still one of my favourite series. I've also heard the Germans love this show.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Billy could you elaborate how you found the characters of Telly and her husband offensive? From memory they had their own business and assisted the Ewing family with the annual bar-b-que.

The way they referred to them as Mr Jock or Mr Bobby. It’s reminiscent of how a house slave may have referred to the slave owner. Bobby even asked Telly to please stop calling him Mr.
 
Top