Would Dallas be in danger of removal from streaming services?

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
Just reading about the removal of Little Britain, Gone with The Wind and hearing apologies from comedians with regards to offensive character portrayal, I'm wondering would Dallas ever be removed from Prime (or any other streaming service)?

I don't think Dallas portrays anyone in a role that could be deemed as offensive, but I do remember an old conversation on here when we discussed Teresa and Raoul and their nationalities within the context of working for a rich, white American family. Perhaps that is offensive to some?

Dora Mae is black but has a good standing position as hostess of the Oil Barons Club. Theo Daltry was high up in the CIA. JR also once referred to Kit Mainwairing in a derogatory homosexual term.

My feeling is no, Dallas was very much of it's time and I'm confident it was accurate in how things were in Texas (maybe in many places it still is common place to have servants of a different ethnicity).

It's just a thought that occurred to me after reading GWTW had been taken off HBO Max.....

What do you think?
 
Last edited:

James from London

International Treasure
Dallas was very much of it's time and was I'm confident accurate in how things were in Texas

I'm not sure DALLAS ever claimed to be an accurate portrayal of how things were in Texas. Certainly, David Jacobs never made any secret of the fact that he'd never even been there when he devised and wrote the mini-series.

Dallas was very much of it's time and was I'm confident accurate in how things were in Texas

Wasn't/isn't there a large Hispanic population in Texas? If so, that certainly wasn't accurately reflected in the original series. Save for a couple of interchangeable servants, Hispanics simply didn't exist on DALLAS.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Just reading about the removal of Little Britain, Gone with The Wind and hearing apologies from comedians with regards to offensive character portrayal, I'm wondering would Dallas ever be removed from Prime (or any other streaming service)?

I don't think Dallas portrays anyone in a role that could be deemed as offensive, but I do remember an old conversation on here when we discussed Teresa and Raoul and their nationalities within the context of working for a rich, white American family. Perhaps that is offensive to some?

Dora Mae is black but has a good standing position as hostess of the Oil Barons Club. Theo Daltry was high up in the CIA. JR also once referred to Kit Mainwairing in a derogatory homosexual term.

My feeling is no, Dallas was very much of it's time and was I'm confident accurate in how things were in Texas (maybe in many places it still is common place to have servants of a different ethnicity).

It's just a thought that occurred to me after reading GWTW had been taken off HBO Max.....

What do you think?

The answer is a resounding NO!!! Now I would say, I don’t believe the characters of Teresa and Raoul would fly in 2020. I actually found the characters of the early BBQ planners Telly and her husband a bit more offensive. But they were only in one episode I believe.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
t's just a thought that occurred to me after reading GWTW had been taken off HBO Max.....

What do you think?

I think they're acting like a bunch of sissies. Gone With The Wind is on of the greatest movies ever made, not just because I say it is, but because of the amount of accolades it got. It's a classic. I've already got in DVD so it doesn't affect me, but I may cancel my HBO subscription just on principle. I rarely watch it anyway, but it comes in handy right now because of the Corona virus.

They could take Dallas off or any series off of Prime. They've already sold seasons of it to customers, so those people will still have it. There's nothing they can do about that; it's a done deal.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
I think they're acting like a bunch of sissies. Gone With The Wind is on of the greatest movies ever made, not just because I say it is, but because of the amount of accolades it got. It's a classic. I've already got in DVD so it doesn't affect me, but I may cancel my HBO subscription just on principle. I rarely watch it anyway, but it comes in handy right now because of the Corona virus.

They could take Dallas off or any series off of Prime. They've already sold seasons of it to customers, so those people will still have it. There's nothing they can do about that; it's a done deal.

Very true, and what of those with DVDs? Will they suddenly demand a mass recall of boxsets?

Where would you draw the line?

Swami
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Depends on where this slippery slope slides. They could certainly argue that JR's "misogyny demeans women, and therefore we have chosen to" blahlahblah.

It could happen.
 
Save for a couple of interchangeable servants, Hispanics simply didn't exist on DALLAS.

Oh they were there to say Telephono Mrs Ewing or Dinner is served! ;)

I think we have to accept that things happened that were considered OK back in the day, a different time and place/.

Whats not acceptable now, was in 1970/80s etc

Fawlty Towers was the best comedy drama ever for me but there are phrases used that wouldnt be acceptable today, but it shouldnt be banned

JR made derogatory marks about Homosexuals, different time and place

I do think Political Correctness will kill off many things and we have to be so touchy feely, tread on toes, careful not to offend anyone these days

but whats in the past is in the past, cant change it, but can ensure that things change for the better in the future and past mistakes arent made.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Oh they were there to say Telephono Mrs Ewing or Dinner is served! ;)

I think we have to accept that things happened that were considered OK back in the day, a different time and place/.

Whats not acceptable now, was in 1970/80s etc

Fawlty Towers was the best comedy drama ever for me but there are phrases used that wouldnt be acceptable today, but it shouldnt be banned

JR made derogatory marks about Homosexuals, different time and place

I do think Political Correctness will kill off many things and we have to be so touchy feely, tread on toes, careful not to offend anyone these days

but whats in the past is in the past, cant change it, but can ensure that things change for the better in the future and past mistakes arent made.

One thing that it is important to point out that television in the 21st century is much much nastier - I think chiefly of reality TV - than 70s/80s/90s.

Nowadays the likes of reality shows go out of their way to simultaneously cause offense and take offense.

So many of the great British sitcoms of the 70s and 80s would never get off the ground today if you were to apply today's standards.

A classic example I can think of is Open All Hours, where Ronnie Barker researched the issue of the stuttering shopkeeper, so that no offense would be caused. As it turned out, one of the first letters he received was from a family, all member who stuttered, to say it was the funniest thing they had ever seen, and nothing at all offended them.

Swami
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Since when is working as a servant no longer acceptable in ou society?
rosario-karen-will-grace.jpg


Nice to know that you're doing a job that's considered so extremely awful it has to be censored. Only people with a wonderful career exist in our Perfect World.
That's just so eighties.
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
Controversial as it sounds - no one, NO ONE!!! Would remove my VHS or DVD collection from me!!!

Nooooooo one!!!! :tv1:
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Shouldn't DYNASTY be banned, considering how Blake treated his homosexual son? Oh, and how about all the movies and tv series that shows characters smoking cigarettes?
It could give the precious kids some bad ideas.

But let's keep the movies and games with extreme violence and rape and shooting sprees - what could possibly go wrong with that.
 

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
Shouldn't DYNASTY be banned, considering how Blake treated his homosexual son? Oh, and how about all the movies and tv series that shows characters smoking cigarettes?
It could give the precious kids some bad ideas.

But let's keep the movies and games with extreme violence and rape and shooting sprees - what could possibly go wrong with that.
You are all jumping the gun here. Dallas has not been banned, nor is it likely to be...
And all of this hyperbole is belittling and trivialising things that are problematic and offensive.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
You are all jumping the gun here. Dallas has not been banned, nor is it likely to be...
And all of this hyperbole is belittling and trivialising things that are problematic and offensive.
I dunno. There's a PC culture out there that just wants the twentieth century to go away.
 

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
I fully understand why Little Britain has been pulled. I get why people are looking at GWTW again. The '80s soaps are not going anywhere and I think that really you all know that.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
If they were going to stop showing anything, why wouldn't they go after shows that have graphic violence and drug use? When it comes down to a show where a character uses a slur or a show where they display graphic violence and drug use, how is it even close?
 

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
If they were going to stop showing anything, why wouldn't they go after shows that have graphic violence and drug use? When it comes down to a show where a character uses a slur or a show where they display graphic violence and drug use, how is it even close?
Because the slur is directed at someone in a derogatory way pertaining to their race or sexual orientation and isn't just a random act of violence or scenes of characters willingly partaking in the use of drugs. If you cant understand that, then I don't know what you could understand.
 
Top