Would Dallas be in danger of removal from streaming services?

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
It means that they aren't in danger of being banned for being offensive.
Oh. Hope you're right and there's no momentum to this.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
Oh they were there to say Telephono Mrs Ewing or Dinner is served! ;)

I think we have to accept that things happened that were considered OK back in the day, a different time and place/.

Whats not acceptable now, was in 1970/80s etc

Fawlty Towers was the best comedy drama ever for me but there are phrases used that wouldnt be acceptable today, but it shouldnt be banned

This reminded me of how the Spanish dubbing of "Fawlty Towers" was changed regarding the waiter. He wasn´t "Manuel" but another name, now Italian!
 

Toni

Maximum Member
Well, if all that happens and the Supersoaps are banned for indecency, this will turn this forum into a clear presentation of immorality and Hell...How fun!!

:danc::danc::danc::danc::danc::ms::ms::ms::ms::ms::spinning::spinning::spinning::spinning::spinning:
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Because the slur is directed at someone in a derogatory way pertaining to their race or sexual orientation and isn't just a random act of violence or scenes of characters willingly partaking in the use of drugs. If you cant understand that, then I don't know what you could understand.

A shooting is directed towards someone in a specific way. Someone wants them dead. Death vs being insulted. I''d rather take the insult than the bullet.
 

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
A shooting is directed towards someone in a specific way. Someone wants them dead. Death vs being insulted. I''d rather take the insult than the bullet.
But that is not the same as insulting someone because they are black, or Asian or gay etc. A bad guy getting blown up in Die Hard which is a fictional action film with a massive body count is not the same as insulting someone on the basis of their race. Are you really serious?
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
But that is not the same as insulting someone because they are black, or Asian or gay etc. A bad guy getting blown up in Die Hard which is a fictional action film with a massive body count is not the same as insulting someone on the basis of their race. Are you really serious?

They're fictional shows so how seriously can anyone take them? They're entertainment. They can't hurt anyone. They're also protected by freedom of speech. We have freedom of speech, in part, so the government can't dictate what kinds of movies and shows we can see and which ones we can't. I don't want anyone, government or not, telling me what I can watch or read. I'm a strong believer in freedom of speech. There is no such thing as a "freedom to not be offended." You can only either have freedom of speech or a freedom to not be offended. You can't have both.
 

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
They're fictional shows so how seriously can anyone take them? They're entertainment. They can't hurt anyone. They're also protected by freedom of speech. We have freedom of speech, in part, so the government can't dictate what kinds of movies and shows we can see and which ones we can't. I don't want anyone, government or not, telling me what I can watch or read. I'm a strong believer in freedom of speech. There is no such thing as a "freedom to not be offended." You can only either have freedom of speech or a freedom to not be offended. You can't have both.
Because they are perpetuating and inciting racism and homophobia and normalising it. Talk about white privilege!

The level of racism and bigotry is disgusting.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
They're fictional shows so how seriously can anyone take them? They're entertainment. They can't hurt anyone. They're also protected by freedom of speech. We have freedom of speech, in part, so the government can't dictate what kinds of movies and shows we can see and which ones we can't. I don't want anyone, government or not, telling me what I can watch or read. I'm a strong believer in freedom of speech. There is no such thing as a "freedom to not be offended." You can only either have freedom of speech or a freedom to not be offended. You can't have both.

You are so full of it. It’s all fun and games until some kid repeats what he sees and hears on TV to one of his classmates. Kind of reminds me of that idiot president talking about “build that wall”. When this was a hot topic, some Caucasian kids went to school and shouted to some Mexican kids “build that wall.” Now Trump’s ignorance and racism has scarred a group of kids for life.

Please spare me the “freedom of speech” nonsense.
 
Last edited:

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
I don't know how things are in Europe, but I see a lot of hypocrisy in the PC crowd here in the United States.
Whenever something too racy or offensive to Christianity, the response is, "If you don't like it, don't watch it" and "freedom of speech!" However, this cancel culture nonsense will attack everything else, no matter how innocuous or realistic a portrayal. You can make a hundred jokes calling all priests pedophiles, but don't you dare even suggest there might be even on Muslim associated with terrorism.
Martina Navratilova is an out lesbian former tennis player. She made a comment on transgender players in sports. She said it has to be looked at on an individual case, but a 6 ft muscular man can't suddenly say, "I identify as female" and play in women's tennis, because he has an unfair advantage. There has to be more to it than just him declaring he's female. She was fired from the station(which may have been the BBC) for which she was a commentator for that remark. That is complete insanity.
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Because they are perpetuating and inciting racism and homophobia and normalising it
Then the famous library scene in Dynasty's season 1 also couldn't/shouldn't have happened. Or the wife rape being accepted by the wife. And so fort and so on.

Be careful what you wish for, that's all I'm saying.
 

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
Then the famous library scene in Dynasty's season 1 also couldn't/shouldn't have happened. Or the wife rape being accepted by the wife. And so fort and so on.

Be careful what you wish for, that's all I'm saying.
But this is really not about that. It's about offensive things like in Little Britain and Bo Selecta, where you had white actors/comedians in blackface mocking black people. Little Britain also had an I'm a lady sketch, which I could see as being offensive. It mocked disability and other things. It's offensive and perpetuates racial discrimination. Personally I don't think any TV show should ever have a white person portray a black person, or an Asian or Indian or any non-white. And it was also about GWTW and it's whitewashed, literally!, imaginary representation of the old south and slavery.

Dynasty and the library scene was showing two sides of a situation. Steven wasn't there as a gay man solely for the viewer to laugh at or be ridiculed for being gay. That is not at all how the scene was written. Steven in fact wasn't a stereotypical representation of a gay man at that time, and the writing showed two sides, and was leaning more on the sympathetic side regarding Steven. Blake calls his son a Fag, indeed, but there is more going on than just that. It's about context.

The other things I have mentioned weren't two sided. They either mocked or disrespected people of colour. Or re-wrote history in order to romanticise the dreadful history of slavery. GWTW has slaves that actually seem to love being a slave. Only a white person, who's no history of such oppression could see nothing wrong with that. Nobody by the way was talking about banning GWTW, just adding a contextual introduction.

Nobody has said anything at all about removing Dallas, or Dynasty, or any soaps from Streaming Services. It wont happen. It's not important.
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
It's about context
In the context of freedom of speech it's difficult to pick and choose and present a strong case simultaneously.
But it's good to know that somebody knows who's going to respond to what,and how.

They did the black make-up face in MAD MEN too, btw. Acceptable - yes/no?
It wont happen
At some point in my life I stopped saying that.
 

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
In the context of freedom of speech it's difficult to pick and choose and present a strong case simultaneously.
But it's good to know that somebody knows who's going to respond to what,and how.
I'm sorry that you don't understand the difference between showing two sides of something and enforcing a biased oppressive discriminatory point of view.
They did the black make-up face in MAD MEN too, btw. Acceptable - yes/no?
I'd say no off the bat, but again, it's about context and I have never watched MAD MEN so don't know at all what those scenes entailed.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
but again, it's about context
Of course it is. But what makes you so sure that *everyone* gets it - while at the same time (apparently) we're not *all* intelligent enough to see when something is an obvious/outdated biased oppressive discriminatory point of view? Or really bad comedy?

As for the "it won't happen", well the thing with GWTW didn't happen last year it happens now. Not that I care what happens to that movie, but the point is that there's always a first time for everything. Like that Christmas song.
 
Last edited:
Top