Would season 8 have been a better dream season?

Pamela_E

Admin Emerita
I have been rewatching Dallas, nice not to have seen it for years and years and to revisit it.

I have just watched End Game, Bobby's shooting and wondered how things would have been if this has been his exit?

We ended with three Bobby cliffhangers in a row....

I thought it would be quite shocking not to have all the sentimental build up with Bobby and Pam, and instead just this sudden murder.

I;m about to embark on season 8 and I'm not overly looking forward to it. Was there really anything that season that was worth keeping and not writing off as a dream?

Donna Reed as Miss Ellie. Yes Pam's dream could have taken a weird turn, dreaming Miss Ellie had a glam new head. Pam wakes up and Miss Ellie is back to normal.

Sure we had Jamie and Jack, but they could have rearrived, or not at all. I did like Mandy, so she could have come into it post dream.

I just don't recall much of this season that left any lasting impact.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
Was there really anything that season that was worth keeping and not writing off as a dream?
I wouldn’t have wanted to lose Bobby and Pam’s reunion, and that’s exactly what happens if he’s murdered in End Game. Granted their reunion didn’t end up lasting long anyway but I’d rather have that than them never getting back together at all.
 

James from London

International Treasure
Was there really anything that season that was worth keeping and not writing off as a dream?
A lot of Season 7, Season 8, the 84/85 season is familiar - another sister-in-law revealed as a shooter, another woman Cliff and JR are both involved with, another cheating man after Lucy's money, another fight for Ewing Oil, another Barnes Ewing feud, another back from the dead plot, another murder trial, another Krebbs martial crisis over Donna's career, another reconciliation/affair/separate bedrooms/falling off the wagon arc for Sue Ellen and JR, all culminating in 'Swan Song' which has always felt like a DALLAS Greatest Hits compilation to me - but that repetitiveness is part of what makes DALLAS DALLAS. These are the roles the characters have been born into, the patterns of behaviour and obsessions they can't break away from. If you could somehow magic the whole year all away just because we've seen most of it all before in some shape or form, I think you'd lose something.

What is different is the way all these familiar storylines rub against each other, especially in the second half of the season. For instance, I really love how JR exploits Pam's search for Mark to keep her away from Bobby after Jenna stands him up at the altar, only for his plan to backfire resulting in Pam joining forces with Cliff and Jamie in their fight for Ewing Oil. Or the way Jenna's murder mystery repeatedly impacts the chances of Bobby and Pam reconciling. Or that late night chat between Sue Ellen and Donna about "the curse of the Ewings" that couldn't really have happened in any other season. And everyone's a lot more glamorous this year, which perhaps shouldn't make a difference but does: they feel rich in a way they haven't before. But perhaps the biggest difference is this is the one year we get to see Pam on her own without a man. As I posted somewhere else recently, this results in her being ballsier than she's ever been before and a bit of a basket case at the same time. If nothing else, that's worth tuning in for (especially during the first third of the season which is a bit shapeless, as first thirds of seasons often are).
 
Last edited:

Pamela_E

Admin Emerita
A lot of Season 7, Season 8, the 84/85 season is familiar - another sister-in-law revealed as a shooter, another woman Cliff and JR are both involved with, another cheating man after Lucy's money, another fight for Ewing Oil, another Barnes Ewing feud, another back from the dead plot, another murder trial, another Krebbs martial crisis over Donna's career, another reconciliation/affair/separate bedrooms/falling off the wagon arc for Sue Ellen and JR, all culminating in 'Swan Song' which has always felt like a DALLAS Greatest Hits compilation to me - but that repetitiveness is part of what makes DALLAS DALLAS. These are the roles the characters have been born into, the patterns of behaviour and obsessions they can't break away from. If you could somehow magic the whole year all away just because we've seen most of it all before in some shape or form, I think you'd lose something.

What is different is the way all these familiar storylines rub against each other, especially in the second half of the season. For instance, I really love how JR exploits Pam's search for Mark to keep her away from Bobby after Jenna stands him up at the altar, only for his plan to backfire resulting in Pam joining forces with Cliff and Jamie in their fight for Ewing Oil. Or the way Jenna's murder mystery repeatedly impacts the chances of Bobby and Pam reconciling. Or that late night chat between Sue Ellen and Donna about "the curse of the Ewings" that couldn't really have happened in any other season. And everyone's a lot more glamorous this year, which perhaps shouldn't make a difference but does: they feel rich in a way they haven't before. But perhaps the biggest difference is this is the one year we get to see Pam on her own without a man. As I posted somewhere else recently, this results in her being ballsier than she's ever been before and a bit of a basket case at the same time. If nothing else, that's worth tuning in for (especially during the first third of the season which is a bit shapeless, as first thirds of seasons often are).

I just finished watching episode Jamie, and I agree there are certain scenes that are brilliant. Yes it does feel like a rehash but not done as well, it has campy daytime soapy tone to it. Like Bobby's blindness. There are points where you almost end up laughing at the dialogue. I don't recall that with JR's shooting.

I love Pam being all ballsy and threatening JR, she done it when Cliff was arrested and I recall she does it again after the search for Mark. But I guess the issue I had was that she never really delivered on it. These early season episodes with Pam promise a great deal but as usual she didn't really deliver. But better than the Pam we had seen for a while.

I also liked Sue Ellen being all spikey towards Pam. It felt like Sue Ellen from those early episodes.

So there are some lovely moments but perhaps i's the pacing and tone that brings it down for me. We may have had stories like a trial in previous seasons, but they were wrapped up pretty quickly.

Also for the first time I was relieved to see the back of Katherine. She was becoming a bad caricature of a female villain. Whereas Kristin had an edge and made sense. Katherine was just a bit telenovela.

I assume the long drawn out plots were devised to keep Bobby and Pam apart until that final season episode.

I have found myself liking Jenna Wade more than I remembered. Despite acting like she is on high a dose of pain killers , I found that she fits in quite nicely.

Early days into this season for me, so I will see where I end up with it
 

James from London

International Treasure
Like Bobby's blindness. There are points where you almost end up laughing at the dialogue. I don't recall that with JR's shooting.
I think Dr Elby hypnotising Sue Ellen so she could recall who shot JR might be one of the first times I found myself laughing at rather than with the show. I still loved it though.
I love Pam being all ballsy and threatening JR, she done it when Cliff was arrested and I recall she does it again after the search for Mark. But I guess the issue I had was that she never really delivered on it. These early season episodes with Pam promise a great deal but as usual she didn't really deliver.
Well, she does deliver insofar as she gives Cliff the money he needs to keep his court case going against JR, and that's enough to drive another wedge between her and Bobby, but no, she doesn't go off on her own all-out vengeance trip against JR. But those showdowns between them are so good that it doesn't really matter.
So there are some lovely moments but perhaps i's the pacing and tone that brings it down for me. We may have had stories like a trial in previous seasons, but they were wrapped up pretty quickly.
Well, it's a loooong season and takes a while to really heat up, but once Naldo forces Jenna into marriage, I think it gets really good. I've never had a problem with the trial itself because of the way it's interwoven with everything else that's going on. And I really like all the minor characters we get to meet along the way: good old Scotty Demarest, the ornery judges who aren't impressed by the Ewings' wealth or Jenna's convoluted back story, the junkie ex-girlfriend, the junkie ex-girlfriend's sister, the art dealer who witnesses the junkie ex-girlfriend's death on the plane, Bobby's cop friend from The Breakfast Club, the detective who'll eventually morph into the doctor who tells Christopher Pam's really dead on New DALLAS, and Naldo's real assassin - he's really cool.
 
Last edited:

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Some very interesting, intriguing thoughts.

I think pretty any season could theoretically turned into a dream season, but I'm not a fan of dream solution and would have preferred any other scenario for two reasons:
1. Storylines get repetitive.
If the dream is over, some storylines just have to be revisited. For example Ray&Donna / Cliff&Jamie working out their differences during the dream. After the wake-up they're not able to work them out, same storyline, different outcome.
Other storylines with the same result - JR leaving Mandy or Wes Parmalee/Ben Stivers staring at pictures in the living room AGAIN.
It's repetitive and boring regardless the outcome.

Same would have been the case e.g. for Jack / Jamie a season before. The excitement is gone because we've met the characters before.

2. A dream needs to have consequences. The worst about the dream was not only for audience's wasted time. It was so bad because nothing mattered - INCLUDING Pam!!!

After the dream she should have been worried about Bobby's or Christopher's or her own safety with Katherine still free. She should look once more for Mark after she dreamt about him so detailed.

Even a dream should have consequences!Dallas was great till then because past actions mattered in the present. It was weird that Pam forgot about her dream after 3 minutes in the season.

For example I would have liked JR dreaming about everybody leaving Southfork, losing EwingOil, maybe John Ross or SueEllen dying.
After the dream he gets new motivation to get it all back - everyone back, Southfork and Ewing Oil run by the family again...
 
Last edited:

Pamela_E

Admin Emerita
I was thinking as I watched this, I don't think I have rewatched this season since it was on UK Gold. So my then and now perceptions are forming rather differently.

So far this season, it does feel like Pamela has taken centre stage. JR appears to have taken a step back from the usual wheeling, dealing and plotting, and instead we have Pam's dramas as the main points. I don't recall Victoria having so many scenes in a season.

Watching them back to back, seeing Donna Reed is rather a jolt but she isn't as bad as I remembered. I don't think the dialogue is any different from what we would have heard from BBG, the delivery is slightly different. BBG's Miss Ellie might say something inappropriate, but her warm fluffy persona hid it, but Donna Reed tells Bobby he still is in love with Pam, has a more critical tone. But still as direct as BBG's version.

But I thought she was great taking down the painting of Jock.

So yes, there is a lot worth keeping this season, although I do struggle with the Jenna/Bobby/Charlie scenes.

I also prefer Mandy with Cliff and Pamela. She seems more ballsy, with JR she seemed far less interesting.

I used to really like Jamie but again have found her rather annoying this season.

I was thinking how Knots Landing managed to integrate new characters into the show later in it's run and make them fan favourites, like Paige and Ann for example. But Dallas doesn't seem to take the same care and attention to casting.
 

Pamela_E

Admin Emerita
Some very interesting, intriguing thoughts.

I think pretty any season could theoretically turned into a dream season, but I'm not a fan of dream solution and would have preferred any other scenario for two reasons:
1. Storylines get repetitive.
If the dream is over, some storylines just have to be revisited. For example Ray&Donna / Cliff&Jamie working out their differences during the dream. After the wake-up they're not able to work them out, same storyline, different outcome.
Other storylines with the same result - JR leaving Mandy or Wes Parmalee/Ben Stivers staring at pictures in the living room AGAIN.
It's repetitive and boring regardless the outcome.

Same would have been the case e.g. for Jack / Jamie a season before. The excitement is gone because we've met the characters before.

2. A dream needs to have consequences. The worst about the dream was not only for audience's wasted time. It was so bad because nothing mattered - INCLUDING Pam!!!

After the dream she should have been worried about Bobby's or Christopher's or her own safety with Katherine still free. She should look once more for Mark after she dreamt about him so detailed.

Even a dream should have consequences!Dallas was great till then because past actions mattered in the present. It was weird that Pam forgot about her dream after 3 minutes in the season.

For example I would have liked JR dreaming about everybody leaving Southfork, losing EwingOil, maybe John Ross or SueEllen dying.
After the dream he gets new motivation to get it all back - everyone back, Southfork and Ewing Oil run by the family again...

The dream slightly shifts Pam in regards to the search for Mark. In the dream she turns out to be right all along, so everyone thinking she had the lost the plot and had become irrational were incorrect. But it turns out she was irrational after all but with JR helping her along.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
But it turns out she was irrational after all but with JR helping her along
Which always made me wonder, who was the Asian gentleman really talking to on the phone when Pam and Sue Ellen are leaving Hong Kong?

In the dream season Mark tells Pam he was there and didn’t want to see her for her own good since he was still very sick. So was Mark on the phone? Or because Pam’s conversations with Mark were part of the dream are we supposed to think Mark was never in Hong Kong at all and it was just another goose chase set up by J.R.?
 

Pamela_E

Admin Emerita
Which always made me wonder, who was the Asian gentleman really talking to on the phone when Pam and Sue Ellen are leaving Hong Kong?

In the dream season Mark tells Pam he was there and didn’t want to see her for her own good since he was still very sick. So was Mark on the phone? Or because Pam’s conversations with Mark were part of the dream are we supposed to think Mark was never in Hong Kong at all and it was just another goose chase set up by J.R.?
What did he say? Was something about everything going exactly to plan? I guess it could have been JR, although he denied it. So maybe Katherine. Or maybe Mark was alive.

Also I did wonder what happened to all of Mark's money etc.

Is Rosa still there now looking after the house as if Mark never left? Is his white car still driving around Dallas?

They should have used it in random scenes when Dallas came back. Just have it drive past in the background. :)
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
What did he say? Was something about everything going exactly to plan?
It was pretty much that. I think he says the plane just took off and everything went exactly as you planned.

I guess it could have been JR, although he denied it
Yes, there is the scene at Pam’s house where he admits to sending her to the Caribbean but says he wasn’t behind Hong Kong. He assures her everything he’s telling her is the truth but let’s face it, it is J.R. talking.

So maybe Katherine
That’s something I’ve never considered but I do find it intriguing. We know Katherine was on the run but that didn’t stop her from pulling strings from behind the scenes framing Jenna. So why not Hong Kong also? This is a very interesting outlook!
 

James from London

International Treasure
In the dream season Mark tells Pam he was there and didn’t want to see her for her own good since he was still very sick. So was Mark on the phone? Or because Pam’s conversations with Mark were part of the dream are we supposed to think Mark was never in Hong Kong at all and it was just another goose chase set up by J.R.?
For me, the most satisfyingly tragic answer is that everything Mark describes in the dream was true ... but then he died before he could make it back to Dallas. So he was in Hong Kong, but pretended he wasn't because he didn't want to get Pam's hopes up in case his treatment didn't work, which it didn't.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
The scene with Mis-Ellie taking down Jock's portrait was well-written, well executed and well-scored. But it reflected everything that was wrong with the recasting.

Bobby almost took it down and they should have let him.

f1c4a717e4a3e9479def0e606029d568--dallas-tv-bobby.jpg
 
Top