1. Four Seasons Of Love
The hits:
Spring Affair; Winter Melody
Recommended album track: Summer Fever
A concept album based around the four seasons. Sometimes the simplest ideas are the best.
Donna and Giorgio pull this one off with great skill with tracks sequenced and flowing into one another so that - as with the seasons they’re about - it’s difficult to pinpoint where one ends and the next begins.
With just five tracks, there’s no room for filler. Each track is different in tone: the chirpy joy of
Spring Affair the sultry heat and soaring highs of
Summer Fever; then there’s
Autumn Changes with the protagonist sensing an ending ahead with a steel band as an almost taunting echo of sunnier days; then it flows into to the beautiful sub mid tempo, Moog-based mellow melancholy of
Winter Melody. And just when all seems lost, there’s a
Spring Reprise. Has the protagonist found a new romance? Has love been rekindled? Or is it simply a memory - another echo of the past? It’s up to the listener to decide.
This is an album I can play over and over again without skipping and as great as each individual track is, the whole album needs to be heard to get the best out of the experience.
2. Love To Love You Baby
The hit:
Love To Love You Baby
Recommended album track:
Pandora’s Box
Like, I suspect, most people, I came to hear the title track in its full glory (at almost seventeen minutes it takes up one entire side of the vinyl). If one listens to nothing else, it’s still worth the entry fee and worthy of a place in anyone’s top five.
The tracks on Side Two are quite different in tone - more representative, perhaps, of the material Donna had been performing before LTLYB took the disco world by storm - but they’re no less brilliant. Each of them takes a different angle on lost love.
After the epic journey of the title track,
Full Of Emptiness feels stripped back and stark. Which makes it more effective. The fadein/fadeout and driving speed of
Need A Man Blues makes it the track that always is and always was. There’s something about it that brings the sleaze of the Seventies to life in the best way.
Whispering Waves is simply one of Donna’s sweetest songs full stop.
Pandora’s Box has a cracking, angry vocal and a hint of country to it. The country sound goes all out with the half instrumental reprise of
Full Of Emptiness, ending the album on something of a downer. The listener is left with one of two choices at the end - sit and let the sadness resonate or flip it over and have another hit of
Love To Love You Baby. Neither is a bad choice.
3. I Remember Yesterday
The hits:
Can’t We Just Sit Down (And Talk It Over); I Feel Love; I Remember Yesterday; Love’s Unkind
Recommended album track:
Black Lady
Another concept album - this one based around sounds of the past, present and future. This one has it all: from the bizarre Roaring Twenties disco mashup that is the title track (it works incredibly well, in case you’re wondering) through the Motown sound of
Back In Love Again to the song that became the sound of the future not only figuratively but literally:
I Feel Love.
Black Lady has a similar story to
Lady Marmalade and features a great Donna power vocal.
Can’t We Just Sit Down (And Talk It Over) slows things down beautifully with a great deal of emotional intelligence.
4. A Love Trilogy
The hits:
Could It Be Magic; Try Me, I Know We Can Make It
Recommended album track:
Wasted
Following on from the phenomenon of the
Love To Love You Baby single, Giorgio and Donna give us a full album of that new sound, with each track uptempo, innovative and way ahead of the curve.
Try Me, I Know We Can Make It - this album’s whole-side epic - outdoes even LTLYB in terms of length. The 18 minute track is a suite of several different sections, each playing with some of the title’s phrasing. It’s a corker of a track which proves that
Love To Love You Baby wasn’t a fluke. In many ways,
Try Me is even slicker, though of course it owes its genes to the previous album.
As if that’s not enough, there’s a 6+ minute, sexed-up dance cover of Barry Manilow’s
Could It Be Magic - complete with coital cries à la
Love To Love You - which by song’s end shows off the powerful full-voice that Donna would become known for. And two new tracks -
Wasted and
Come With Me that put new spins on the Moroder sound.
5. Bad Girls
The hits:
Hot Stuff; Bad Girls; Dim All The Lights; Sunset People; Our Love; Walk Away
Recommended album track:
Journey To The Centre Of Your Heart
Among critics and fans this is consistently the most acclaimed Donna album. And it is truly a hugely impressive achievement on every level. A double album with many of the tracks sequenced. Some huge hits (
Hot Stuff; Bad Girls; Dim All The Lights; Sunset People). Varied sound including a couple of gorgeous ballads. Technically it’s polished without being too shiny. It’s a cohesive double album experience with many tracks sequenced to perfectly complement one another. The rock elements are very welcome. And Donna’s voice never sounded so sexy, powerful and raw.
6. Once Upon A Time
The hits:
I Love You; Fairy Tale High; Once Upon A Time; Rumour Has It
Recommended album track:
Dance Into My Life
Another concept double album with a fairy tale theme. This was the most ambitious project to date when it was recorded and pulls it off beautifully. Naturally, there’s a whole side devoted to the electronic sound pioneered on the previous album’s
I Feel Love.
7. Live And More
The hits:
MacArthur Park; Heaven Knows
Recommended album track:
Last Dance (“Live”);
MacArthur Park Suite (“More”)
Donna in concert at the height of her powers. She belts out her hits at breakneck speed, serenades her daughter with a bedtime song she’d written and covers - among others - Gershwin and Streisand.
The “More” section is a brand new 18 minute studio track - a suite based on Richard Harris’s
MacArthur Park, incorporating new tracks
One Of A Kind and
Heaven Knows, featuring Brooklyn Dreams. An edited version of
MacArthur Park became a huge hit in its own right, with the
Heaven Knows section giving another single.
And it has a fantastic cover!
8. Christmas Spirit
Recommended album tracks:
Christmas Is Here (original);
White Christmas (cover)
Summer does the standards and shows off a gentler side in this gorgeous album recorded with the Nashville Symphony Orchestra. From simple carols to all out gospel and two original songs written by Summer herself. It may not be her most innovative or provocative material, but it’s beautiful and continues to prove she could handle any genre of music.
9. Another Place And Time
The hits:
This Time I Know It’s For Real; I Don’t Wanna Get Hurt; Love’s About To Change My Heart; Breakaway; When Love Takes Over You
Recommended album track:
Whatever Your Heart Desires
Donna inspires greatness in the Hit Factory sound.
This Time I Know It’s For Real is perhaps as mainstream as Donna ever got, while
Love’s About To Change My Heart effortlessly taps into - and pulls off - the ballad intro/power vocal combo of her hits from a decade earlier.
10. Crayons
The hits:
I’m A Fire; Stamp Your Feet; It’s Only Love; Fame (The Game)
Recommended album track:
Sand On My Feet
As it turns out, this was Donna’s final studio album. And she went out on a high, with some catchy dance hits supported by a gorgeous ballad or two.
SPECIAL MENTION:
Thank God It’s Friday
The hits: Last Dance;
Je T’Aime (Moi Non Plus)
Recommended album track:
With Your Love
Not a Donna album, per se, but worth a mention as it’s the one that includes the glorious
Last Dance (twice!); the 16 minute masterpiece that is
Je T’Aime (Moi Non Plus) and the delightfully catchy
With Your Love.
There’s also the Donna-penned
Take It To The Zoo, sung here by Donna’s sisters (with Donna giving backup).
And let’s not forget that Donna starred in the film!