Why Lucy Was The Most Expendable Character Of The Main Cast

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
And it's not as if she was ripping his clothes off, she just wanted to start dating again. And even if she had been ripping his clothes off, so what? Whatever gets you through.

Lucy wasn't the type to just go up to Peter and rip his clothes off next to the Southfork pool - she operated more subtly than many realize...

R6U9su8.png


59428649_2493229594221821_6926886560554175315_n.jpg
 
Last edited:
I rarely find a character with a lack of goals fascinating or even interesting. I certainly don't find a lack of them to make a character more fascinating.

Fair enough. And vive la différence.



I'd agree, but only with the caveat that at some point in the story, they have to begin to set goals, even one goal, and the story has to have a logical progression where we see that character overcome their insecurity and lack of self-esteem.

In long-running drama it's essential that characters change in some way and have a sense of journey, so I fully agree with you that the story has to have a logical progression.



It's the story that decides for the characters what happens to them, not vice versa.

Yes. There's an oddly symbiotic relationship between character and story. The story decides how the characters progress. But the characters must inform their responses within each situation written for them
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
That's not to say characters should necessarily fail at every turn
Happiness is also part of the drama genre, and I think it's normal that the viewer wants to see a likeable character to "achieve" that happiness or growth or success or whatever.
We also want the villains to succeed otherwise all that plotting and blackmailing would be a waste of time.
So I think it's more about the payoff for the time and emotion invested in those characters and storylines.

But when I watch a soap I'm not thinking about where they're going to be in the next season or what they will achieve 5 or 10 years later. Only the current storylines are relevant to me.
I honestly don't know how to perceive "journey" and "progression" in the soap genre because a big twist can turn everything upside down or move a character back to square one.
There are examples of characters with such an organic development that it almost looks planned from the very beginning e.g. Jill Bennett and Chase Gioberti. But these are exceptions, I think?
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
In long-running drama it's essential that characters change in some way and have a sense of journey, so I fully agree with you that the story has to have a logical progression.

Have you ever seen One Tree Hill? Dan Scott may be the best example of character I've seen in a long-running drama (not a soap because OTH has a definitive ending) who has such a well thought out, logical progression to his character. The show made mistakes with some of their other characters, but the Dan Scott character had a very well thought out, meaningful progression.

I don't think that's likely to consistently happen on a soap. I haven't seen any of the shows traditionally called soaps except Dallas, but from what I know of them they don't start out with a particular destination for the story in mind, it's just something that in theory just goes on forever rather than having a clearly defined beginning , middle and an end. The only thing that brings them to an end, as far as I know, is cancellation. They usually have a variety of writers and even a variety of people in charge - the producers or show runners.

I'd think it would be very unlikely that they'd on any consistent basis have a well thought out vision for the story they want to tell and how they want the characters to develop because they do have so many people writing them and running them. In another form of art, like painting, Rembrandt wouldn't have started a painting and then said: "Well, I've gotten this off to a good start, why don't you paint the rest of it"? I look at a Dallas episode from season 3 or 4 and then if I see something from season 11 or 12, that's what it looks like. It's like a painting where one artist was painting it and then at some point they started having other artists come in to "help" and you end up with something that goes in all sorts of directions without a clear vision for what they're trying to accomplish.
 

James from London

International Treasure
I worked with a writer recently who said the best characters are always their own worst enemy. That made sense to me. You see it a lot in Shakespeare's tragedies where the main character has a fatal flaw that ultimately leads to his downfall.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
She did play the bad girl well and I think that should have continued into adulthood. If she had been J.R.'s daughter, it could have swung either way but it definitely would have been interesting to see Lucy team-up with him.

This was mostly my thoughts regarding the character, although I did not think she needed to be J.R.'s daughter. The Uncle/Niece relationship was good enough, and as he was the one who had her taken from Val and brought to Southfork, he should have basically raised her to be his little evil ally, a young Alexis Carrington/Erika Kane-type of femme fatale. Occasionally having her seduce and blackmail enemies, that sort of thing. And I would have had it so that he'd essentially brainwashed her into hating her parents as much as he did. She looks down on her mother for being some White trash nobody, and considers her father some little weakling who doesn't deserve to be a Ewing. And that's why she never joined them on Knots Landing after they reconciled.

And, of course, over the years there could have been stories where she and J.R. turn against each other and maybe she temporarily reconciles with her parents, and such. Even still eventually having her date and marry Mitch, with him becoming a successful doctor in Dallas and moving into Southfork with her, and then having various trials in their marriage, could have worked (his later work on Santa Barbara showed he was good "soap opera actor" in the longterm).

There were plenty of imaginative ways to use the character of Lucy on the show, the writer and producers just didn't have enough imagination. As others have noted before, Dallas was unique among soap operas in that it was primarily based around the male characters, and thus many of their prominent female characters ended being short-changed in various ways.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
This was mostly my thoughts regarding the character, although I did not think she needed to be J.R.'s daughter. The Uncle/Niece relationship was good enough, and as he was the one who had her taken from Val and brought to Southfork, he should have basically raised her to be his little evil ally, a young Alexis Carrington/Erika Kane-type of femme fatale.

I'm glad they didn't try to make Lucy evil. Charlene Tilton was too naturally likable to have been convincing as an evil woman. Besides, Lucy was "Shortcake"! That was my favorite nickname they had for her. How can you have an evil Shortcake? It just doesn't work.
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I didn’t think Charlene was able to pull off the bad-girl version of Lucy. And then when they made her good, they had no idea what to do with her. She just bounced from plot to plot (Kit Mainwaring, Alan Beam, Mitch, Miss Short Dallas, the Hot Biscuit, etc).

I’m rewatching season 4 and I realize that Lucy and Mitch never got back together after their separation at the end of season 3. Instead, Mitch hangs around for most of the season during the longest-ever soap opera separation.

I did like the Hot Biscuit story, but it was kind of unnaturally cut short after production moved back to Hollywood (and they clearly didn’t want to spend the money to re-create the Hot Biscuit on the soundstage).

They should have just let Lucy and Mickey ride off into the sunset together. Lucy by that point had overcome her shallowness and didn’t really care about the materialistic trappings of the rich anymore. That would have been a natural ending point for her character arc.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I didn’t think Charlene was able to pull off the bad-girl version of Lucy. And then when they made her good, they had no idea what to do with her. She just bounced from plot to plot (Kit Mainwaring, Alan Beam, Mitch, Miss Short Dallas, the Hot Biscuit, etc).

I’m rewatching season 4 and I realize that Lucy and Mitch never got back together after their separation at the end of season 3. Instead, Mitch hangs around for most of the season during the longest-ever soap opera separation.

I did like the Hot Biscuit story, but it was kind of unnaturally cut short after production moved back to Hollywood (and they clearly didn’t want to spend the money to re-create the Hot Biscuit on the soundstage).

They should have just let Lucy and Mickey ride off into the sunset together. Lucy by that point had overcome her shallowness and didn’t really care about the materialistic trappings of the rich anymore. That would have been a natural ending point for her character arc.

They should have just let Lucy and Mickey ride off into the sunset together. Lucy by that point had overcome her shallowness and didn’t really care about the materialistic trappings of the rich anymore. That would have been a natural ending point for her character arc.

I just come here to say the exact same thing. I had just watched the episode where they remarried. That should have been the conclusion to the Lucy storyline. Heck, they should have even had kids off camera.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I would have liked to have seen Lucy and Mickey get married. Their lifestyle and their values would've added sharp contrast to the way of life at Southfork. Not that the accident wasn't a great storyline; it was certainly a well told story. But, there would have been a whole lot more longevity to their story - one that would have added a different perspective on life in Dallas, if they'd gone for the slow build instead of the sudden tragic accident. Mickey was a character of such value, who had such a positive effect on Lucy, that I think he could've been added to the main cast very well.

From a strictly business standpoint, it would have helped Dallas bring in more of that young demographic that shows want so badly too - something they tried doing much later with James and Michelle but failed to accomplish.
 
Last edited:

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
In hindsight I think they missed a trick with Lucy, what they should have done at some point was make her an ally of JR and then have a few schemes of her own.

Unfortunately she was the least interesting Ewing (of the main clan) and was only ever used in relationship/love plots but Lucy certainly had the teeth to do more scheming IMO. When the show began she was certainly a devious character who you wouldn't trust and then they went down the poor little rich girl route which ultimately led to a cul de sac (see what I did there!).

So having Lucy as a protege could have been very interesting.
 
Top