stevew
Telly Talk Star
As we were talking about Miss Ellie and JR, I got thinking, what should have Miss Ellie done after Jock died?
I know her life was suddenly a mess and Jock didn’t make things any easier on my opinion, but if she could find the strength...
I would have advised her to sell any shares of Ewing Oil and ask Bobby and JR to move out until the “fight” is over, or skip the fight, making it clear she will not be involved in anyway. I’d then say she should ask Gary to return and offer him the ranch (the business not the land, house or oil). He cared about it while Bobby and JR we caught up in the oil business - at least offer it. I’d then suggest she set up a non-profit to protect the land, lease it to the South Fork Cattle Co (Gary) and do good works for the people of Texas. I’d also talk to her about exploring the best option to drill for oil under her control so it doesn’t happen after she’s gone and use the money for the foundation. She could also use the oil to get the boy’s to agree to split Ewing Oil, “If you do, I’ll give Ewing Oil the oil lease. If you don’t, I’ll lease it to someone else, in order to stay out of the fight.” She should also turn the house over to JR (at least first option) as her oldest son and offer for Bobby to build his own house on the property somewhere. Then she could move into a cottage on the property and decide, free from the fight and doing right by her boys, what to do next with her life.
Just an idea. I don’t think what she did was right. She at least should have made an effort with Gary and make it clear she will not be in the middle of any fight (though I wouldn’t suggest she take anything to court). I also don’t think she should later share SF with Clayton, especially after the big deal she made over Garrisons return and the importance of it staying in the family. Finally, giving it to Bobby was wrong. It cut out two other children and their children (it also ignored the extreme and very real burden of gift taxes).
I know her life was suddenly a mess and Jock didn’t make things any easier on my opinion, but if she could find the strength...
I would have advised her to sell any shares of Ewing Oil and ask Bobby and JR to move out until the “fight” is over, or skip the fight, making it clear she will not be involved in anyway. I’d then say she should ask Gary to return and offer him the ranch (the business not the land, house or oil). He cared about it while Bobby and JR we caught up in the oil business - at least offer it. I’d then suggest she set up a non-profit to protect the land, lease it to the South Fork Cattle Co (Gary) and do good works for the people of Texas. I’d also talk to her about exploring the best option to drill for oil under her control so it doesn’t happen after she’s gone and use the money for the foundation. She could also use the oil to get the boy’s to agree to split Ewing Oil, “If you do, I’ll give Ewing Oil the oil lease. If you don’t, I’ll lease it to someone else, in order to stay out of the fight.” She should also turn the house over to JR (at least first option) as her oldest son and offer for Bobby to build his own house on the property somewhere. Then she could move into a cottage on the property and decide, free from the fight and doing right by her boys, what to do next with her life.
Just an idea. I don’t think what she did was right. She at least should have made an effort with Gary and make it clear she will not be in the middle of any fight (though I wouldn’t suggest she take anything to court). I also don’t think she should later share SF with Clayton, especially after the big deal she made over Garrisons return and the importance of it staying in the family. Finally, giving it to Bobby was wrong. It cut out two other children and their children (it also ignored the extreme and very real burden of gift taxes).