Miss Ellie After Jock

stevew

Telly Talk Star
As we were talking about Miss Ellie and JR, I got thinking, what should have Miss Ellie done after Jock died?

I know her life was suddenly a mess and Jock didn’t make things any easier on my opinion, but if she could find the strength...

I would have advised her to sell any shares of Ewing Oil and ask Bobby and JR to move out until the “fight” is over, or skip the fight, making it clear she will not be involved in anyway. I’d then say she should ask Gary to return and offer him the ranch (the business not the land, house or oil). He cared about it while Bobby and JR we caught up in the oil business - at least offer it. I’d then suggest she set up a non-profit to protect the land, lease it to the South Fork Cattle Co (Gary) and do good works for the people of Texas. I’d also talk to her about exploring the best option to drill for oil under her control so it doesn’t happen after she’s gone and use the money for the foundation. She could also use the oil to get the boy’s to agree to split Ewing Oil, “If you do, I’ll give Ewing Oil the oil lease. If you don’t, I’ll lease it to someone else, in order to stay out of the fight.” She should also turn the house over to JR (at least first option) as her oldest son and offer for Bobby to build his own house on the property somewhere. Then she could move into a cottage on the property and decide, free from the fight and doing right by her boys, what to do next with her life.

Just an idea. I don’t think what she did was right. She at least should have made an effort with Gary and make it clear she will not be in the middle of any fight (though I wouldn’t suggest she take anything to court). I also don’t think she should later share SF with Clayton, especially after the big deal she made over Garrisons return and the importance of it staying in the family. Finally, giving it to Bobby was wrong. It cut out two other children and their children (it also ignored the extreme and very real burden of gift taxes).
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
On what planet would she just give Southfork to JR just to move into a cottage on the same property?

Earth. Many families do something similar. My aunt lived in the “honeymoon” cottage with my uncle (his family farm) and their three small kids until her father-in-law died and then they all moved down the driveway to the main farm house and her mother-in-law moved into the cottage. Later her mother-in-law moved back into the main house to be taken care of. It’s certainly more common than a single grown woman living in a big house with her grown sons and their families. I’m wondering in what world you’re familiar with where that is the norm.
 
Last edited:

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Earth. Many families do something similar. My aunt lived in the “honeymoon” cottage with my uncle (his family farm) and their three small kids until her father-in-law died and then they all moved down the driveway to the main farm house and her mother-in-law moved into the cottage. Later her mother-in-law moved back into the main house to be taken care of. It’s certainly more common than a single grown woman living in a big house with her grown sons and their families. I’m wondering in what world you’re familiar with where that is the norm.

Does that sound like something Miss Ellie would do? You know, the same person that would break down in tears when one of her grown sons threatened to leave.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Does that sound like something Miss Ellie would do? You know, the same person that would break down in tears when one of her grown sons threatened to leave.

Yes it does, because it would be a better set up then what she ended up with. The idea would be to hold her family together, and in terms of Gary bring him home - something she very much wanted. Also the premise is what “should” she have done. Obviously what she did do wasn’t good for her family.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I would have advised her to sell any shares of Ewing Oil and ask Bobby and JR to move out until the “fight” is over, or skip the fight, making it clear she will not be involved in anyway. I’d then say she should ask Gary to return and offer him the ranch (the business not the land, house or oil). He cared about it while Bobby and JR we caught up in the oil business - at least offer it.

I like that idea of Ellie selling her shares of Ewing Oil to whichever son wanted to buy them. If both want to buy, then try to sell an equal amount of shares to each one. It might turn out that Bobby can't afford to buy as many as JR because he hasn't worked as many years as JR, in that case, sell an equal amount to both until Bobby can't afford any more and then sell JR the rest, until she's sold all of hers or until JR can't afford to buy any more. Sell shares to Lucy, Ray, and Gary too if they're interested. Under no circumstances sell to any non-family member, upholding Jock's wish that nobody but a Ewing must ever own any portion of Ewing Oil.

Gary wouldn't have returned because of Knot's Landing and I think she may have said to Gary at some point that she shouldn't ask him to return because she knows he's not happy there. Although I don't remember for sure if she said that, I think she did, and it seems that was probably Gary's sentiment anyway. I think Ellie knew Gary wasn't happy at Southfork, so I wouldn't have her ask him to come back. I'd have her ask him if she could visit him, since that would get her away from the boys for a while.

I’d then suggest she set up a non-profit to protect the land, lease it to the South Fork Cattle Co (Gary) and do good works for the people of Texas. I’d also talk to her about exploring the best option to drill for oil under her control so it doesn’t happen after she’s gone and use the money for the foundation.

I doubt most of the fans knew or cared if a non-profit would protect the land. I'd have her go with the tried and true approach her parents and grandparents had used.

I don't see it as being in Ellie's character to drill on Southfork. That was the reason Jock hadn't drilled on Southfork - it was for Ellie.


She should also turn the house over to JR (at least first option) as her oldest son and offer for Bobby to build his own house on the property somewhere. Then she could move into a cottage on the property and decide, free from the fight and doing right by her boys, what to do next with her life.

Having them all live together is one of the main premises Dallas is based on and I wouldn't change that. The show worked very well that way. "If it ain't broke, don't try to fix it."

I also don’t think she should later share SF with Clayton, especially after the big deal she made over Garrisons return and the importance of it staying in the family. Finally, giving it to Bobby was wrong. It cut out two other children and their children (it also ignored the extreme and very real burden of gift taxes).

I agree she should't share SF with Clayton for the reasons you mentioned. She shouldn't have given it all to Bobby either, as it showed favoritism towards Bobby. She should will it to all her sons equally. Gary could give Lucy his share if he thinks she'd enjoy it more than him and have more use for it.

As for gift-taxes, much like setting up the non-profit, I don't think the majority of the audience was interested in technicalities of the tax laws. I'd keep it simple and again stick with the tried and true method the Southworths had always used in the past to hand down Southfork to the next generation.

The only difference I'd make there is to distribute the land equally to her kids instead of just leaving it to one of them. There is plenty land for each of her sons to own a huge portion of the ranch's land. I'd have her will the house to JR and Bobby equally to continue the tradition of the family living in the same home. If they ever stopped wanting to do that, they could sell the house and split the money between them, although I doubt they'd ever sell it.

The main thing I'd have her do is just not get involved in the contest, since it only caused her stress. I think since it caused her stress and she didn't have a role in the contest anyway, she should just not concern herself with it.

The next part is something she would have her do only if this were a real life situation because it makes sense, but since Dallas is a show designed to entertain people, I wouldn't have her do it, since I think the fights entertained the fans.

In a real world situation: She said she couldn't stand to see the boys fighting. Well, they were in a contest, but as far as the fighting they did, that wasn't necessary for the contest and the were too old be punching each other anyway. I'd have her be strictly enforce a no physical violence in or around the house rule. The first one to throw a punch or otherwise physically attack the other would be out of there! Maybe that would help force Bobby to finally grow up since he always initiated the violence and was too old to be acting that way.
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I like that idea of Ellie selling her shares of Ewing Oil to whichever son wanted to buy them. If both want to buy, then try to sell an equal amount of shares to each one. It might turn out that Bobby can't afford to buy as many as JR because he hasn't worked as many years as JR, in that case, sell an equal amount to both until Bobby can't afford any more and then sell JR the rest, until she's sold all of hers or until JR can't afford to buy any more. Sell shares to Lucy, Ray, and Gary too if they're interested. Under no circumstances sell to any non-family member, upholding Jock's wish that nobody but a Ewing must ever own any portion of Ewing Oil.

Gary wouldn't have returned because of Knot's Landing and I think she may have said to Gary at some point that she shouldn't ask him to return because she knows he's not happy there. Although I don't remember for sure if she said that, I think she did, and it seems that was probably Gary's sentiment anyway. I think Ellie knew Gary wasn't happy at Southfork, so I wouldn't have her ask him to come back. I'd have her ask him if she could visit him, since that would get her away from the boys for a while.



I doubt most of the fans knew or cared if a non-profit would protect the land. I'd have her go with the tried and true approach her parents and grandparents had used.

I don't see it as being in Ellie's character to drill on Southfork. That was the reason Jock hadn't drilled on Southfork - it was for Ellie.




Having them all live together is one of the main premises Dallas is based on and I wouldn't change that. The show worked very well that way. "If it ain't broke, don't try to fix it."



I agree she should't share SF with Clayton for the reasons you mentioned. She shouldn't have given it all to Bobby either, as it showed favoritism towards Bobby. She should will it to all her sons equally. Gary could give Lucy his share if he thinks she'd enjoy it more than him and have more use for it.

As for gift-taxes, much like setting up the non-profit, I don't think the majority of the audience was interested in technicalities of the tax laws. I'd keep it simple and again stick with the tried and true method the Southworths had always used in the past to hand down Southfork to the next generation.

The only difference I'd make there is to distribute the land equally to her kids instead of just leaving it to one of them. There is plenty land for each of her sons to own a huge portion of the ranch's land. I'd have her will the house to JR and Bobby equally to continue the tradition of the family living in the same home. If they ever stopped wanting to do that, they could sell the house and split the money between them, although I doubt they'd ever sell it.

The main thing I'd have her do is just not get involved in the contest, since it only caused her stress. I think since it caused her stress and she didn't have a role in the contest anyway, she should just not concern herself with it.

The next part is something she would have her do only if this were a real life situation because it makes sense, but since Dallas is a show designed to entertain people, I wouldn't have her do it, since I think the fights entertained the fans.

In a real world situation: She said she couldn't stand to see the boys fighting. Well, they were in a contest, but as far as the fighting they did, that wasn't necessary for the contest and the were too old be punching each other anyway. I'd have her be strictly enforce a no physical violence in or around the house rule. The first one to throw a punch or otherwise physically attack the other would be out of there! Maybe that would help force Bobby to finally grow up since he always initiated the violence and was too old to be acting that way.

I’d agree to offer to family first, but I would care about Jock’s wishes as he set up the “fight.” I’d sell to be done with it even if that meant Cliff Barnes. Now of the boys want to not engage in the competition we’d have a different story. But if Jock expected me (assuming I’m Ellie) to respected his wishes he’d need to respect me enough not to put my sons in competition against each other.

I agree Gary wouldn’t return but the offer should be made. The land meant a great deal to him, like the company did to JR and I’d make sure it was his choice not my assumption that was the deciding factor.

I doubt most fans knew any of the business aspects anymore than I would know the medical aspects of Grey’s Anatomy, but a serious drama (which Dallas began as) still tries to live up to reality. So using true methods to protect the land was my point. Also I’m not talking about what was best for the story but what should a real Miss Ellie have done.

I agree it was not in her character to drill on SF but that again wasn’t reality (though it was during the time of the movie Giant, which is where they got the idea). An intelligent adviser, and someone like Clayton certainly would have been could have shown her his to safely get the oil now so that after she was gone someone wouldn’t get at it and destroy the land. A solution could be had and she could use the money up but more and more land in order to protect it, or any other cause she felt was worth while. I think if she looked at this way Miss Ellie would agree. It kills the drama but again I’m not talking about a good story, I’m talking about what she should actually do.

Again, I agree for drama purposes living in the same house worked, but again I’m not talking about drama, I’m talking about a strong and healthy woman making good choices for her family. The fact that she was weak, ignorant, selfish, ill-advised all worked for the drama, and can be realistic. But I’m curious what could she have done otherwise for the good of her family.

I agree with keeping the story simple as you stare and not diving into tax laws, except when ignoring such leads to an unrealistic result like just giving Bobby SF like such is possible. Once the writes do such a thing it is no longer drama but fantasy and the story looses it impact as it had in its first seasons, or it certainly seemed to work out that way.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I’d agree to offer to family first, but I would care about Jock’s wishes as he set up the “fight.” I’d sell to be done with it even if that meant Cliff Barnes. Now of the boys want to not engage in the competition we’d have a different story. But if Jock expected me (assuming I’m Ellie) to respected his wishes he’d need to respect me enough not to put my sons in competition against each other.

From the context I'm guessing you meant you "wouldn't" care abut Jock's wishes as he set up the fight. Those wishes were in a letter included with his will, which is why they were all read at the same time. I don't know how she can not care about Jock's (literal) last request. Wills are created so that people can do with the company they've built or whatever assets they have, whatever they want, as long as it's legal. If Jock had wanted something illegal in his will, Harv would have told him he couldn't do that. I'd like for a character to have asked Miss Ellie: "What would you think about Jock trying to overturn your will and/or ignoring your last wishes if you had died first? Wouldn't you hope that even if he didn't like what you requested, that'd he'd respect it? Why have wills if they're only valid as log as the surviving spouse likes what they say"?

Selling to Cliff Barnes? You think that would have been alright? The show is built on the premise those two families hate each other. Why help the family who hates your family attack your family?

I doubt most fans knew any of the business aspects anymore than I would know the medical aspects of Grey’s Anatomy, but a serious drama (which Dallas began as) still tries to live up to reality. So using true methods to protect the land was my point. Also I’m not talking about what was best for the story but what should a real Miss Ellie have done.

OK, I'm talking abut what's best for the story, except where I specifically said otherwise.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
From the context I'm guessing you meant you "wouldn't" care abut Jock's wishes as he set up the fight. Those wishes were in a letter included with his will, which is why they were all read at the same time. I don't know how she can not care about Jock's (literal) last request. Wills are created so that people can do with the company they've built or whatever assets they have, whatever they want, as long as it's legal. If Jock had wanted something illegal in his will, Harv would have told him he couldn't do that. I'd like for a character to have asked Miss Ellie: "What would you think about Jock trying to overturn your will and/or ignoring your last wishes if you had died first? Wouldn't you hope that even if he didn't like what you requested, that'd he'd respect it? Why have wills if they're only valid as log as the surviving spouse likes what they say"?

Selling to Cliff Barnes? You think that would have been alright? The show is built on the premise those two families hate each other. Why help the family who hates your family attack your family?



OK, I'm talking abut what's best for the story, except where I specifically said otherwise.

Yes sorry, I did mean “wouldn’t.”

And no I would not care about my spouse’s last request if it was a contest between my children. His will showed zero respect for her or his family, so it’s a bit much to ask for respect. I do agree it was legal which is one reason I would not have taken it to court as she did but I don’t believe that I must do what ever any ones says because it’s was their last request, especially if I find it morally offensive.

Another example was her father and not drilling on SF land. It worked in his day but no longer worked by the 1980’s. The land could be drilled with minimal harm and should be before the family drilled in more harmful places, like off shore.

I am bound by the will of God not man. I will do my best to honor my parents and spouse’s wishes but I still must use my judgement. And if Jock wished to prevent her from selling it there were legal means to do so, means he did not choose.

I don’t mean to sell to Cliff Barnes but if he’s the highest bidder I’m going to take what I can get. This of course is based on the willingness of the boys to fight. If they choose not to fight them there’s no issue.

And it’s fine to look at what’s best for the story but that isn’t the idea of this thread: “what should have Miss Ellie done after Jock died?” was the lead question. I take it as long as legal you believe she should honor his last wish. I believe as long as she can accept it she should honor his last wish. But if she cannot, and she obviously couldn’t, she should remove herself from the issue all together. She can only co tell her own behavior and in doing so she should not participate in something she objects to.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Yes sorry, I did mean “wouldn’t.”

And no I would not care about my spouse’s last request if it was a contest between my children. His will showed zero respect for her or his family, so it’s a bit much to ask for respect. I do agree it was legal which is one reason I would not have taken it to court as she did but I don’t believe that I must do what ever any ones says because it’s was their last request, especially if I find it morally offensive.

Another example was her father and not drilling on SF land. It worked in his day but no longer worked by the 1980’s. The land could be drilled with minimal harm and should be before the family drilled in more harmful places, like off shore.

I am bound by the will of God not man. I will do my best to honor my parents and spouse’s wishes but I still must use my judgement. And if Jock wished to prevent her from selling it there were legal means to do so, means he did not choose.

I don’t mean to sell to Cliff Barnes but if he’s the highest bidder I’m going to take what I can get. This of course is based on the willingness of the boys to fight. If they choose not to fight them there’s no issue.

And it’s fine to look at what’s best for the story but that isn’t the idea of this thread: “what should have Miss Ellie done after Jock died?” was the lead question. I take it as long as legal you believe she should honor his last wish. I believe as long as she can accept it she should honor his last wish. But if she cannot, and she obviously couldn’t, she should remove herself from the issue all together. She can only co tell her own behavior and in doing so she should not participate in something she objects to.

The thing about the contest is that while for whatever reason, Ellie didn't like it, she wasn't in the contest so it shouldn't have affected her. The contest primarily affected the two people in it, and they were pleased that Jock had set up the contest. Both JR and Bobby found it to be a reasonable and fair way to determine who should run the company. Considering how seldom JR and Bobby agreed on things, I found that to be a strong endorsement of the amount of respect Jock had shown in his will.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
The thing about the contest is that while for whatever reason, Ellie didn't like it, she wasn't in the contest so it shouldn't have affected her. The contest primarily affected the two people in it, and they were pleased that Jock had set up the contest. Both JR and Bobby found it to be a reasonable and fair way to determine who should run the company. Considering how seldom JR and Bobby agreed on things, I found that to be a strong endorsement of the amount of respect Jock had shown in his will.

You are wrong. The contest was about her children , children which lived in her house. It did have an impact t on her life. I’ll agree it didn’t directly involve her - which is why I said she SHOULD totally distance herself from it.

I seriously doubt JR believed that after all the work he put into the company the contest was anywhere near fair. I wouldn’t consider it fair either and only asking for unethical behavior. Too many factors go into running such a company and turning a profit both in the short term (which was what he set up and made Jock look like an ignorant executive more than a man setting up something to out live himself) and long term. To split it the way that was done was actually unrealistic and would have put the entire business at risk. In fact as an investor I would gladly testify to his mental instability in setting such up.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
You are wrong. The contest was about her children , children which lived in her house. It did have an impact t on her life. I’ll agree it didn’t directly involve her - which is why I said she SHOULD totally distance herself from it.

I seriously doubt JR believed that after all the work he put into the company the contest was anywhere near fair. I wouldn’t consider it fair either and only asking for unethical behavior. Too many factors go into running such a company and turning a profit both in the short term (which was what he set up and made Jock look like an ignorant executive more than a man setting up something to out live himself) and long term. To split it the way that was done was actually unrealistic and would have put the entire business at risk. In fact as an investor I would gladly testify to his mental instability in setting such up.

No, I’m not wrong. I actually understated things by saying the boys thought the contest was reasonable and fair. There is a scene where JR looks at the sealed will, before the contest was announced and right after JR reads it, he looks upwards and says “Thank you Daddy.” Bobby described the will in very positive terms as well, saying how he liked that Jock saw the potential in him that he might have what it took to beat JR in a contest. It was a huge compliment that Jock thought that Bobby would be competitive in business with his much more experienced, knowledgeable brother.

As for Ellie, the contest required her to do absolutely nothing. It was not about her. Describing the contest as primarily affecting JR and Bobby is just telling it like is.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
So are you saying every time JR and Bobby got in each other’s face, sometimes in HER house, it didn’t concern her?

Or when all those oilmen were ready to beat up JR, on HER property, it didn’t concern her?

Or the fact that her two sons are fighting it out in front of all of Dallas over a company her deceased husband left all of them, didn’t concern her?

Plus, she had a huge stake in Ewing Oil.

She had every right to be concerned.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
No, I’m not wrong. I actually understated things by saying the boys thought the contest was reasonable and fair. There is a scene where JR looks at the sealed will, before the contest was announced and right after JR reads it, he looks upwards and says “Thank you Daddy.” Bobby described the will in very positive terms as well, saying how he liked that Jock saw the potential in him that he might have what it took to beat JR in a contest. It was a huge compliment that Jock thought that Bobby would be competitive in business with his much more experienced, knowledgeable brother.

As for Ellie, the contest required her to do absolutely nothing. It was not about her. Describing the contest as primarily affecting JR and Bobby is just telling it like is.

JR thought he could easily take Bobby out not that what he thought his father did was right. Bobby was proud his father thought well enough of him to win even though his brother didn’t. But the fact is for the company it was poor idea focused on short term profits. It’s the behavior of a man Id hire to run the company not a man who intended to pass it on and keep it in the family. It was a seriously flawed business idea that no one would realistically do.

It was her sons fighting and getting dirty to do it do yes it was her concern. Also because as his widow and an heir she had millions tied up in the company so yes she had every right to pullout, pull away from the fight and pull her money out of the way. If you tell me several million dollars of my money is on the line for some reason no serious business investor would consider and it’s none of my business I’d show you how fast I can get my money out.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
JR thought he could easily take Bobby out not that what he thought his father did was right. Bobby was proud his father thought well enough of him to win even though his brother didn’t. But the fact is for the company it was poor idea focused on short term profits. It’s the behavior of a man Id hire to run the company not a man who intended to pass it on and keep it in the family. It was a seriously flawed business idea that no one would realistically do.

It was her sons fighting and getting dirty to do it do yes it was her concern. Also because as his widow and an heir she had millions tied up in the company so yes she had every right to pullout, pull away from the fight and pull her money out of the way. If you tell me several million dollars of my money is on the line for some reason no serious business investor would consider and it’s none of my business I’d show you how fast I can get my money out.

The point is the contest was voluntary and the sons not only accepted, but gladly accepted. The were grateful for the opportunity for the compete to determine who would run Ewing Oil.

The money Ellie had tied up in the company was a non-issue as far as the story they told because she never made it an issue. She never said anything regarding the contest to indicate she was worried about her finances. That Ewing Oil actually went on to get bigger nullifies that idea that the contest would destroy the company because we all saw it didn’t. The company grew!

Ellie didn’t even believe Jock was incompetent but she went to court on those grounds anyway because she was willing to do whatever she could to stop her boys from fighting with each other. You’d have thought she’d never seen them fight before! The distinction between business competition and a fistfight needs to be made, which is why I always specifically refer to the “contest for Ewing Oil.” The contest didn’t necessitate any physical fighting; it was a business competition. Nothing wrong with that. Competition is productive. Business in America is founded on the concept that competition brings out the best result. That's an entirely separate thing from physical assault, which is the result of grown men and women who can’t control themselves.

We all saw Bobby physically fight JR anytime he felt like it from the first episode of the whole series onwards. The idea that Ellie had a nice peaceful family that got along well and only started fighting because of the contest was a fantasy Ellie had that never existed. The boys often fought and Bobby was, as far as I remember, the one who initiated the violence every single time! If she wanted to stop that the only way to do that, aside from Bobby growing up and not punching people whenever he lost his temper, was to have Ellie tell Bobby he had to either show he could learn to control his temper or move out. But then we wouldn’t have had as fun of a show to watch.
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
The point is the contest was voluntary and the sons not only accepted, but gladly accepted. The were grateful for the opportunity for the compete to determine who would run Ewing Oil.

The money Ellie had tied up in the company was a non-issue as far as the story they told because she never made it an issue. She never said anything regarding the contest to indicate she was worried about her finances. That Ewing Oil actually went on to get bigger nullifies that idea that the contest would destroy the company because we all saw it didn’t. The company grew!

Ellie didn’t even believe Jock was incompetent but she went to court on those grounds anyway because she was willing to do whatever she could to stop her boys from fighting with each other. You’d have thought she’d never seen them fight before! The distinction between business competition and a fistfight needs to be made, which is why I always specifically refer to the “contest for Ewing Oil.” The contest didn’t necessitate any physical fighting; it was a business competition. Nothing wrong with that. Competition is productive. Business in America is founded on the concept that competition brings out the best result. That's an entirely separate thing from physical assault, which is the result of grown men and women who can’t control themselves.

We all saw Bobby physically fight JR anytime he felt like it from the first episode of the whole series onwards. The idea that Ellie had a nice peaceful family that got along well and only started fighting because of the contest was a fantasy Ellie had that never existed. The boys often fought and Bobby was, as far as I remember, the one who initiated the violence every single time! If she wanted to stop that the only way to do that, aside from Bobby growing up and not punching people whenever he lost his temper, was to have Ellie tell Bobby he had to either show he could learn to control his temper or move out. But then we wouldn’t have had as fun of a show to watch.

Again my premise is what Ellie SHOULD do.

Ewing oil went on to go out of business eventually but that’s besides the point, as it was fictional. No such business could actually be long term viable based on feuding family members. It was not believable. Yes that was the phone of the story but again I was getting at should.

Competition is good externally but never internally, not long term. American is based on completing with “them” not each other. There are countless examples of such. Locally for me Ford Motor is one such real example which required a family change of procedure to survive and then prosper. The greatest name in oil would totally disagree as well. Rockefeller Sr. worked well with Jr. - like they were one and he even advocated against competition.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Again my premise is what Ellie SHOULD do.

Ewing oil went on to go out of business eventually but that’s besides the point, as it was fictional. No such business could actually be long term viable based on feuding family members. It was not believable. Yes that was the phone of the story but again I was getting at should.

Competition is good externally but never internally, not long term. American is based on completing with “them” not each other. There are countless examples of such. Locally for me Ford Motor is one such real example which required a family change of procedure to survive and then prosper. The greatest name in oil would totally disagree as well. Rockefeller Sr. worked well with Jr. - like they were one and he even advocated against competition.

Are you looking at it from a standpoint of what Ellie should do if she were a real person and were making her decisions based on a set of priorities you either suppose she would have or should have? Either way, that’s something else. I don’t even like to tell people who I know extremely well what they should do in their personal lives. I think “what Ellie SHOULD do” is whatever would make the best show. I learned the difference between show business and real life when I was young. What might make her happy might also make for an extremely dull show.

Their objective was to create excitement and they did a tremendous job of it in season six. Isn’t it funny how despite her best efforts to overturn Jock’s will, she still ended up getting what she wanted? She got her two sons working together, running Ewing Oil. If she’d had any faith in Jock, she wouldn’t have had to get so upset over it, go to court and basically let it eat her up. The purpose of the contest was to get JR and Bobby to respect each other’s abilities and realize they were far better off together than apart. They were too damn stubborn to take Jock's word for it while he was still alive. So, he created a situation in his will where their own actions would give them tangible proof of what he’d been saying to be true. Brilliant.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Are you looking at it from a standpoint of what Ellie should do if she were a real person and were making her decisions based on a set of priorities you either suppose she would have or should have? Either way, that’s something else. I don’t even like to tell people who I know extremely well what they should do in their personal lives. I think “what Ellie SHOULD do” is whatever would make the best show. I learned the difference between show business and real life when I was young. What might make her happy might also make for an extremely dull show.

Their objective was to create excitement and they did a tremendous job of it in season six. Isn’t it funny how despite her best efforts to overturn Jock’s will, she still ended up getting what she wanted? She got her two sons working together, running Ewing Oil. If she’d had any faith in Jock, she wouldn’t have had to get so upset over it, go to court and basically let it eat her up. The purpose of the contest was to get JR and Bobby to respect each other’s abilities and realize they were far better off together than apart. They were too damn stubborn to take Jock's word for it while he was still alive. So, he created a situation in his will where their own actions would give them tangible proof of what he’d been saying to be true. Brilliant.

Again the post was what she should do. If you don’t like to tell what should be done, why would you comment on this post in the first place? And if you know the difference between show business and real life, why would it matter to tell Miss Ellie what she should do, as you realize she’s not real? Why would any intelligent person have had any faith in such a stupid plan even if hiding the intent to get them to work together. Far from brilliant. The biggest man in oil did the exact opposite, he created an unbeatable partnership with his son and grandsons. Hunt’s and Getty’s empires were torn apart as was their families. Real life example in oil prove Jock was greatly mistaken. You’re right the story of Hunt and Getty is more entertaining, but again I’m asking about should not entertainment. Please don’t feel compelled to reply if commenting on should makes you uncomfortable.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Again the post was what she should do.

I replied because what she should do depends. I replied to get a clarification. Is it what she should do to make the story even better? Or is it:

Are you looking at it from a standpoint of what Ellie should do if she were a real person and were making her decisions based on a set of priorities you either suppose she would have or should have? Either way, that’s something else.

BTW, which is it: Priorities you suppose she would have or should have?

Far from brilliant.

How is this not brilliant: The purpose of the contest was to get JR and Bobby to respect each other’s abilities and realize they were far better off together than apart. They were too damn stubborn to take Jock's word for it while he was still alive. So, he created a situation in his will where their own actions would give them tangible proof of what he’d been saying to be true.

It was a storyline that got them an average of over 30 million viewers a week. That’s success! Sure, you’re entitled to your opinion, but it’s damn hard to argue with success.
 
Last edited:
Top