Dallas Season 5 - Their Biggest Missed Opportunity

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
In season 5 there was a pivotal moment in the series that had they taken a different direction with it would have completely changed the future course of the show.

Here's what has happened so far: JR presents Bobby with papers that show Kristen is the mother of Christopher and that Bobby had been scheming to steal JR's son from him. Bobby had altered Christopher's birth certificate and then convinced Sue Ellen to sign a letter saying she approves of Bobby and Pam adopting her sister's child and she has no knowledge of who the father is. JR is now holding a copy of the affidavit and showing it to Bobby. Meanwhile, Sue Ellen has broken off JR's attempts at a reconciliation and has been seeing Cliff. Apparently seriously, since Cliff has bought an engagement ring for Sue Ellen and when he proposes to her she is unsure of what to say and asks for time to think it over.

You know what followed that. Imagine how much it would have impacted the show if in that one scene they'd done this instead. This could have led to the most heated, most emotionally charged Dallas storyline there ever was:

JR says he can't believe Bobby would try to steal JR's son from him, especially after all the times Bobby has acted as if he's morally superior to JR. JR says he's done a lot of things, but nothing on this level, not with family. JR decks Bobby and then Bobby, in self-disgust, doesn't even try to fight back. This follows:

Bobby: I did it for Pam!

JR: So you figured whatever makes Pam happy justifies anything, even stealing your own brother's son?

Bobby: I wasn't thinking; I just reacted to the look on Pam's face and. . .

JR: And what? You've just been lying to her and everyone else about Christopher ever since?

Bobby: What else could I do? Pam needs him!

JR: So that justifies the whole thing? Bobby, why is it that you say the two things you hate above all else are lies and secrecy? Seems to me you've mastered them. I've done some dirty deals in my time, but with family, I play fair. I've never walked around telling people that I hate lies and secrecy like you do, acting so damn sanctimonious and self-righteous, like I'm above it all. I've told some lies but I'm not half the pretender you are. I don't claim to be what I'm not.

Bobby: What are you gonna do?

JR: I'm gonna do what I have to do. Sue Ellen broke off my attempts at a reconciliation. She's even seeing that rodent of a brother-in-law you have. If Sue Ellen can't see the difference between me and him, then she deserves him. They deserve to be married to each other but John Ross sure as hell doesn't deserve them! I may not have been the best husband there ever was, but there isn't a man in Texas who is a better daddy than I am. I'd commit suicide before I'd live in the shame of allowing Cliff Barnes to raise one of my sons. My sons are all I have, I am all they have, and I will not let them down. Either of them. Bobby, we can do this the easy way or we can do this the hard way. You wanna fight me over this, then you had better come at me with both barrels loaded and cocked and ready to fire!
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
Love your passion for thoughtful threads @Kenny Coyote but I couldn't disagree with you more.

The joy of this storyline was the fact that we, the viewers were also convinced that it was J.R's son, so after Bobby has taken Christopher to J.R and been re-railed by Pam it brought a huge amount of angst and jeopardy for all concerned.

The storyline built up from a letter with a photo sent to Bobby and grew and evolved as it twisted around the characters involved.

And then the genius rug pulling move, that even after a blackmail attempt by J.R, Bobby and Pam discover it wasn't his son at all and Bobby punches J.R in the nursery.

For me it had so many great elements that I think it played out perfectly and packed so much emotion and drama into it that I can't imagine changing any aspect of it.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Love your passion for thoughtful threads @Kenny Coyote but I couldn't disagree with you more.

The joy of this storyline was the fact that we, the viewers were also convinced that it was J.R's son, so after Bobby has taken Christopher to J.R and been re-railed by Pam it brought a huge amount of angst and jeopardy for all concerned.

The storyline built up from a letter with a photo sent to Bobby and grew and evolved as it twisted around the characters involved.

And then the genius rug pulling move, that even after a blackmail attempt by J.R, Bobby and Pam discover it wasn't his son at all and Bobby punches J.R in the nursery.

For me it had so many great elements that I think it played out perfectly and packed so much emotion and drama into it that I can't imagine changing any aspect of it.

I like to hear what you and other people think of different ideas, so if you like the way they did it better, I don't mind at all. I enjoyed what they did, but to me, they settled for so much less than what they could have had, it was a shame. We're talking about a man's son, and they have him willing to settle for his brother to vote his way for a few months until the will gets read and the voting shares mean nothing? They settled for that! They had far greater stakes at hand than that.

I'd have liked to have seen them really get into what was going on: A man was trying to steal his brother's son and he never has to own up to it? No consequences? Without consequences where is the drama?

That's too surface-level for my taste. Have Bobby have to face the fact he isn't as righteous as he claims to be, that yes, he was going to try to steal his brother's son. How does it affect Bobby when he genuinely has to own up to that? It should tear him up, he should be so emotionally conflicted because at the same time he wants the best for Pam, and they both have grown to love Christopher.

If JR shows that when it comes to his children, he will do anything and everything for them, then you have JR, Bobby and Pam all fighting for what means the most to them. Think of how it affects Pam when she finds out Christopher is JR's son and JR wants him. How will it affect Bobby and Pam's marriage? JR realizes he has lost his wife and he is determined that he will not also lose his sons. He feels like they're all he has left. The intensity would have been through the roof. The stakes could not be any higher.
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
I do think it would have ended up with Sue Ellen being marginalised, and she needed to be a central character.

Swami
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
JR gets called out on his misdeeds all the time, but Bobby and Pam seem to get away without people calling attention to theirs (Bobby buying Christopher; Bobby hiding Christopher’s parentage; married Pam traipsing off to Europe with the Pornstache). At least JR called Pam out on the latter.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
I do think it would have ended up with Sue Ellen being marginalised, and she needed to be a central character.

Swami

Oh, I don't know. I think it could have set up some GREAT drama for Sue Ellen.

Think about it -

At that point, JR was the one who always hurt HER. But here she has hurt HIM. She lied on the affidavit, allowing Bobby and Pam to adopt Christopher and claiming she had no idea who the father was. By doing that, she is playing an ACTIVE part in keep JR's son away from him.

The thought of JR confronting her, of her being the "guilty" one for a change. It could have opened up SO many dramatic opportunities between the two characters.

Does JR blackmail her back into marriage with the perjury? Would he threaten to use it against her in a renewed custody battle for John Ross? Is she then forced to go back to Southfork and raise JR's bastard son by her sister?

Or

Does JR come to her, heart on his sleeve with his lost little boy act that she always falls for, make Bobby and Pam the bad guys, win her back that way and set up a dramatic and constant battle between the two couples are Southfork?

I don't think it would have marginalized her character so long as they didn't take her out of the situation completely by marrying her off to Cliff.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Perhaps that might have worked if John Ross was Cliff's and JR and Sue Ellen therefore had to raise both childen, each of them guilty of their infidelity.

Swami
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Bobby, we can do this the easy way or we can do this the hard way. You wanna fight me over this, then you had better come at me with both barrels loaded and cocked and ready to fire!

This could have set up the biggest fight this side of the contest for Ewing Oil!
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Oh, I don't know. I think it could have set up some GREAT drama for Sue Ellen.

Think about it -

At that point, JR was the one who always hurt HER. But here she has hurt HIM. She lied on the affidavit, allowing Bobby and Pam to adopt Christopher and claiming she had no idea who the father was. By doing that, she is playing an ACTIVE part in keep JR's son away from him.

The thought of JR confronting her, of her being the "guilty" one for a change. It could have opened up SO many dramatic opportunities between the two characters.

Does JR blackmail her back into marriage with the perjury? Would he threaten to use it against her in a renewed custody battle for John Ross? Is she then forced to go back to Southfork and raise JR's bastard son by her sister?

Or

Does JR come to her, heart on his sleeve with his lost little boy act that she always falls for, make Bobby and Pam the bad guys, win her back that way and set up a dramatic and constant battle between the two couples are Southfork?

I don't think it would have marginalized her character so long as they didn't take her out of the situation completely by marrying her off to Cliff.

Nice ideas regarding Sue Ellen.

Is the idea I presented something you'd have rather seen than what they did?
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
Nice ideas regarding Sue Ellen.

Is the idea I presented something you'd have rather seen than what they did?

Yes. For many reasons.

It would provide an opportunity to explore Bobby, Pam, JR, and Sue Ellen - not to mention Ellie - in ways we never got to see play out in the show.

How far would Bobby actually go? How would Pam hold up emotionally under the stress? Would JR's fight for his sons be more important to him than total control of Ewing Oil? Would Sue Ellen ever deal with her feelings about her sister? Who would Ellie support?

I think it could have been an incredible story if told that way.
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I have no issues how it played out originally, but this is good.... It shows Bobby wasn't always on the high horse and was less honest about his dishonesty than JR.

I like how it basically planted a bomb in the Ewing living room and only the viewers know its there. Would have put up a lot of moral questions? Bobby will do anything for Pam. Pam will do anything to keep the child and JR will do anything, (or will he?) to keep Ewing Oil. I think we know the answer to the last one. Will SE later use that for some leverage? What if Katherine found out and did some quality scheming? So much material from one simple storyline.
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Although the potential of the storyline being great, it would also have slimed Bobby in a not particularly great light, but as long as it was compelling, I think all would appreciate the nuances and turns it took.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Although the potential of the storyline being great, it would also have slimed Bobby in a not particularly great light, but as long as it was compelling, I think all would appreciate the nuances and turns it took.

It doesn't show Bobby in any worse of a light than the storyline they used because either way, he was willing to try to steal what he thought was his brother's baby. This scenario makes him have to genuinely own up to what he tried to do. That makes it more compelling because we see how it affects Bobby to have to live up to what he tried to do. He is forced to confront the reality that he isn't as righteous of a man as he claims to be. How does Bobby handle it when he has to face the fact that he wasn't able to live up to the image he tried to create for himself? As I said, that should tear him up inside.

How does Pam handle finding out Bobby tried to steal his brother's baby? How does Bobby react when Pam asks him: "How could you have let me bond with a baby that you had no good reason to believe we would be legally allowed to keep"! The internal conflict within Bobby as well as the conflict it creates between Bobby and Pam would have been tremendous.

The way they did it, Bobby tried to steal what he believed was his brother's baby and never had to own up to it. That short-changed the audience. We didn't see Bobby have to face any consequences for trying to steal his brother's baby. If there are no consequences no matter what you do, then where's the drama, what does it all mean? What's the point if Bobby can do whatever he wants and never has to pay a price for it?
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
JR gets called out on his misdeeds all the time, but Bobby and Pam seem to get away without people calling attention to theirs (Bobby buying Christopher; Bobby hiding Christopher’s parentage; married Pam traipsing off to Europe with the Pornstache). At least JR called Pam out on the latter.

You're right! So imagine how Bobby would feel when JR says:

Bobby, why is it that you say the two things you hate above all else are lies and secrecy? Seems to me you've mastered them. I've done some dirty deals in my time, but with family, I play fair. I've never walked around telling people that I hate lies and secrecy like you do, acting so damn sanctimonious and self-righteous, like I'm above it all. I've told some lies but I'm not half the pretender you are. I don't claim to be what I'm not.

Then when news of what Bobby did gets around, Bobby has no choice but to own up to what he did. After all that time saying how much he hated lies and secrecy above all else, and now he's one of the biggest offenders! We'd never seen Bobby in that situation before. It would have been new and interesting, because how will it affect Bobby to admit to himself he has failed to live up to the image he created for himself, and failed in a big way!

How will it affect his marriage when Pam asks him: "How could you have allowed me to bond with a child you had no reason to believe we could legally keep"?
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I like how it basically planted a bomb in the Ewing living room and only the viewers know its there. Would have put up a lot of moral questions? Bobby will do anything for Pam. Pam will do anything to keep the child and JR will do anything, (or will he?) to keep Ewing Oil. I think we know the answer to the last one. Will SE later use that for some leverage? What if Katherine found out and did some quality scheming? So much material from one simple storyline.
First if all, the phrase "What if Katherine found out and did some quality scheming?" Is pure gold! The phrase itself has me picturing Katherine in all her underhanded glory!

At first I thought the original storyline was too far fetched, but when you re-watch those episodes, notice how well the writers set it up.

How many of us get trapped in a bad situation, as when Pam said, "Oh, Bobby! You found us a baby!" And you just stammer your way through an answer.

And each time you try to resolve the issue, it's harder because hopes are raised and you don't want to disappoint everyone.
And this is what is going through your mind:

How will it affect his marriage when Pam asks him: "How could you have allowed me to bond with a child you had no reason to believe we could legally keep"?

So it's quickly becoming too late to tell the truth, and it's down into the rabbit hole we go!

Until it gets like it was in our teenage school years, where it's so far out of control that you just give up and hope for the best.

"I can't believe this semester went by and I never studied for that big test. Maybe a Tsunami will just float the school away tonight and everything will be okay."

Amirite, Bobby?
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
First if all, the phrase "What if Katherine found out and did some quality scheming?" Is pure gold! The phrase itself has me picturing Katherine in all her underhanded glory!

At first I thought the original storyline was too far fetched, but when you re-watch those episodes, notice how well the writers set it up.

How many of us get trapped in a bad situation, as when Pam said, "Oh, Bobby! You found us a baby!" And you just stammer your way through an answer.

And each time you try to resolve the issue, it's harder because hopes are raised and you don't want to disappoint everyone.
And this is what is going through your mind:

How will it affect his marriage when Pam asks him: "How could you have allowed me to bond with a child you had no reason to believe we could legally keep"?

So it's quickly becoming too late to tell the truth, and it's down into the rabbit hole we go!

Until it gets like it was in our teenage school years, where it's so far out of control that you just give up and hope for the best.

"I can't believe this semester went by and I never studied for that big test. Maybe a Tsunami will just float the school away tonight and everything will be okay."

Amirite, Bobby?

Bobby had put himself in a predicament that by all indications was gonna come back to bite him in the ass. The longer he waited to tell Pam what he did, the deeper of a hole he dug for himself because Pam was becoming more and more attached to Christopher.

They settled for giving Bobby the easy way out - he finds out the baby wasn't JR's and then somehow, that fact that he had been willing to steal a child he believed belonged to his brother wasn't even brought up again. Bobby got a miracle which prevented him from having to face the hard truth of what he'd done and deprived us from seeing how he'd feel when he had to take responsibility for trying to steal his brother's baby. They gave Bobby the easy way out, preventing him from ever having to take self-accountability for his actions or face the consequences for his actions.

In my story, Bobby doesn't get an easy way out. The baby would have proved to be JR's baby, which would have forced Bobby to take a good, long, hard look in the mirror and take responsibility for what he'd tried to do. How does it affect him and how does it affect his marriage?

Then when Bobby and Pam try find a way to keep Christopher, they're facing overwhelming odds. How are they going to win against the biological father? So they highlight that they are the only parents that Christopher knows and that the baby has bonded with them.

JR responds with: Christopher would have bonded with me too but my brother stole my right to have that opportunity! How can you reward him for breaking the law, and doing something so awful to his own brother?

It certainly would seem JR would have the upper hand in court, and if he does win, what will that do to Pam? Will she end up back in a mental institution? Will she remain reasonably stable mentally, but blame Bobby for letting her bond with Christopher and divorce him because she is just so disillusioned with Bobby and who she though he was?

One last thought: What is more believable to you:

A. Pam leaves Bobby because she says the contest for Ewing Oil killed Rebecca ( a mother she knew for a year and abandoned her when she was an infant) even though the plane crash is something Bobby had no control over

Or

B. Pam leaves Bobby because the Bobby she married would never have sunk to stealing someone's baby - especially his own brother's baby - and then allowing her to bond with the baby, despite Bobby knowing they had no legal right to keep the baby?

I find option B far more convincing.
 
Last edited:

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I'm guessing they didn't go that route in fear of making Bobby look terribly underhanded, yet motivated by noble reasons. I think it would have been great. Bobby was always a revelation when he pulled some of JRs tricks. I loved it when he and Ray did the Driscoll stuff- attempting to blame JR, realizing they were just as guilty. Bobby needed more of that. Come down to reality, off the high horse and do some dirty work. BUT they show needed a good guy and Patrick played him pitch perfect. I'm usually bored by the class tattletale, but Bobby was not dull, equally measured.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I'm guessing they didn't go that route in fear of making Bobby look terribly underhanded, yet motivated by noble reasons. I think it would have been great. Bobby was always a revelation when he pulled some of JRs tricks. I loved it when he and Ray did the Driscoll stuff- attempting to blame JR, realizing they were just as guilty. Bobby needed more of that. Come down to reality, off the high horse and do some dirty work. BUT they show needed a good guy and Patrick played him pitch perfect. I'm usually bored by the class tattletale, but Bobby was not dull, equally measured.

The way they'd gone they'd already shown him alter the birth certificate and ask Sue Ellen to lie, my way only shows him have to pay a price for doing it.

As for Driscoll, Bob's big mistake was bailing him out. Had he not bailed him out, he couldn't have crippled Mickey.
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
One last thought: What is more believable to you:

A. Pam leaves Bobby because she says the contest for Ewing Oil killed Rebecca ( a mother she knew for a year and abandoned her when she was an infant) even though the plane crash is something Bobby had no control over

Or

B. Pam leaves Bobby because the Bobby she married would never have sunk to stealing someone's baby - especially his own brother's baby - and then allowing her to bond with the baby, despite Bobby knowing they had no legal right to keep the baby?

I find option B far more convincing.

I agree that B is far more convincing. And this could have pushed Pam over the edge, which would have been sad but would have showed off the acting skills of Victoria Principal.

I'm guessing they didn't go that route in fear of making Bobby look terribly underhanded, yet motivated by noble reasons. I think it would have been great.

This would have set up some great moral questions. What if Bobby does the wrong thing but for the right reasons? What if Bobby has to be underhanded and manipulating, but doing so for a noble cause? Is that right or wrong? It could have made for a very interesting season.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I agree that B is far more convincing. And this could have pushed Pam over the edge, which would have been sad but would have showed off the acting skills of Victoria Principal.

Or maybe it almost pushes her over the edge, but she doesn't let it because she's already been through that and knows she isn't any good to anyone when she's off somewhere in an institution instead of in court, making her case for why she thinks she and Bob should get Christopher.

This would have set up some great moral questions. What if Bobby does the wrong thing but for the right reasons? What if Bobby has to be underhanded and manipulating, but doing so for a noble cause? Is that right or wrong? It could have made for a very interesting season.

This story does not show Bobby in a worse light than the original because this story begins after he's already bought Christopher, already told Pam he's theirs, already altered the birth certificate and already asked Sue Ellen to lie for him. For him to do all those things and not have to own up to it, not have to pay a price for it, then what's the point? It's facing the consequences of criminal behavior and the change it effects in Bobby to have to own up to it that makes it have true meaning! Where is the meaning in a story where Bobby can do anything he wants and not ever have to pay a price for it?

The original story didn't show Bobby having to pay a price for trying to steal what he thought was JR's baby. Where is the drama in a guy who does that and never has to own up to it?

Of course in this story, so that it means something, Christopher really is JR's baby, so Bobby doesn't get that miracle save that he somehow thinks seems to absolve him of any wrongdoing.

Bob thinks he did it for the right reasons, but the ends never justify the means when the means are evil or illegal. Bobby has to face the fact that he will use lies and secrecy just as much as anyone else, when it's good for him. How will the internal conflict he goes through as a result of that change him? Maybe it spurs him on to actually live up to the image he created for himself, of someone who always does the righteous thing and hates lies and secrecy. Or maybe he tries to change in that way and fails. He comes to the realization that he is a good man but not better than other people, not a man who should walk around judging other people and telling them how to live their lives, or beating them up when they tell a joke he doesn't like or when they don't let him get his way (just as long as they're smaller than him or older than him).
 
Last edited:
Top