Dallas Season 5 - Their Biggest Missed Opportunity

WeldonBallou

Telly Talk Active Member
In season 5 there was a pivotal moment in the series that had they taken a different direction with it would have completely changed the future course of the show.

Here's what has happened so far: JR presents Bobby with papers that show Kristen is the mother of Christopher and that Bobby had been scheming to steal JR's son from him. Bobby had altered Christopher's birth certificate and then convinced Sue Ellen to sign a letter saying she approves of Bobby and Pam adopting her sister's child and she has no knowledge of who the father is. JR is now holding a copy of the affidavit and showing it to Bobby. Meanwhile, Sue Ellen has broken off JR's attempts at a reconciliation and has been seeing Cliff. Apparently seriously, since Cliff has bought an engagement ring for Sue Ellen and when he proposes to her she is unsure of what to say and asks for time to think it over.

You know what followed that. Imagine how much it would have impacted the show if in that one scene they'd done this instead. This could have led to the most heated, most emotionally charged Dallas storyline there ever was:

JR says he can't believe Bobby would try to steal JR's son from him, especially after all the times Bobby has acted as if he's morally superior to JR. JR says he's done a lot of things, but nothing on this level, not with family. JR decks Bobby and then Bobby, in self-disgust, doesn't even try to fight back. This follows:

Bobby: I did it for Pam!

JR: So you figured whatever makes Pam happy justifies anything, even stealing your own brother's son?

Bobby: I wasn't thinking; I just reacted to the look on Pam's face and. . .

JR: And what? You've just been lying to her and everyone else about Christopher ever since?

Bobby: What else could I do? Pam needs him!

JR: So that justifies the whole thing? Bobby, why is it that you say the two things you hate above all else are lies and secrecy? Seems to me you've mastered them. I've done some dirty deals in my time, but with family, I play fair. I've never walked around telling people that I hate lies and secrecy like you do, acting so damn sanctimonious and self-righteous, like I'm above it all. I've told some lies but I'm not half the pretender you are. I don't claim to be what I'm not.

Bobby: What are you gonna do?

JR: I'm gonna do what I have to do. Sue Ellen broke off my attempts at a reconciliation. She's even seeing that rodent of a brother-in-law you have. If Sue Ellen can't see the difference between me and him, then she deserves him. They deserve to be married to each other but John Ross sure as hell doesn't deserve them! I may not have been the best husband there ever was, but there isn't a man in Texas who is a better daddy than I am. I'd commit suicide before I'd live in the shame of allowing Cliff Barnes to raise one of my sons. My sons are all I have, I am all they have, and I will not let them down. Either of them. Bobby, we can do this the easy way or we can do this the hard way. You wanna fight me over this, then you had better come at me with both barrels loaded and cocked and ready to fire!

You hit the nail on the head with dressing down Bobby. His duplicitous nature always irked me and made me find him to be one of the most annoying characters in the show. He needed to be knocked down several pegs with that sanctimonious crap he was pulling whenever he "felt like it". Same as when he tried to pull that on Jock and Jock put him in check.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
You hit the nail on the head with dressing down Bobby. His duplicitous nature always irked me and made me find him to be one of the most annoying characters in the show. He needed to be knocked down several pegs with that sanctimonious crap he was pulling whenever he "felt like it". Same as when he tried to pull that on Jock and Jock put him in check.

It's not done only to make Bobby own up to the fact that he tried to steal his brother's baby, although that it one of the major benefits: Bobby realizes he is not the man he claims to be. That's something he has to confront because while he's been saying the two things in the world he hates most are lies and secrecy, over the last three or four months, he's been the biggest perpetrator! So, how does it affect Bobby when he has to take a good, long look at himself in the mirror and accept that he is not the man that he claims to be - that he is more than willing to use lies and secrecy when it helps him!

There's so much more to the story though- how does this affect Bobby and Pam's marriage when she finds out the depths he was willing to sink to to get what he wanted?

The most emotionally charged, the most heated storyline in Dallas history is brought about when you have JR on one side and Bobby and Pam on the other side, with each side fighting for what means most to them in life! What storyline could them fighting over stakes as valuable as a son!

To make this storyline work, they have to show JR as valuing his sons above all else, that yes, he does have badd qualities, but when it comes to his sons he is willing to do anything to ensure that they get what they need and he genuinely believes that what his sons need is for him to raise them. Whatever shortcomings JR may have, he believes with all his heart that he is as good a father as any man in Texas and he absolutely refuses to let his sons down!

That's the key to this storyline having the power it should and what makes it s compelling - Bobby and Pam believe Christopher needs them more than anything, but JR believes every bit as strongly that as Christopher's real father, he has an obligation to Christopher to ensure that he raises Christopher the best way he knows how. JR believes his sons are all he has left and that he is all his sons have left!
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I do think it would have ended up with Sue Ellen being marginalised, and she needed to be a central character.

Swami

The way I visualize it, that wouldn't happen. Sue Ellen would be seeing Cliff, but isn't entirely happy with him. Cliff would be very happy with her and believes he is on the way to eventually marrying Sue Ellen. They keep dating, but meanwhile, Sue Ellen sees how hard JR is fighting for the right to be able to raise his own son. Sue Ellen sees something in JR that she hasn't seen before - she never realized just how important JR's son from Kristin would be to him. She sees JR fight so hard for his son that she falls in love with JR all over again and comes back to him. They're together again and now Cliff has one more reason to hate JR - JR took Sue Ellen away from him, the woman Cliff had thought he was going to marry!
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
The way I visualize it, that wouldn't happen. Sue Ellen would be seeing Cliff, but isn't entirely happy with him. Cliff would be very happy with her and believes he is on the way to eventually marrying Sue Ellen. They keep dating, but meanwhile, Sue Ellen sees how hard JR is fighting for the right to be able to raise his own son. Sue Ellen sees something in JR that she hasn't seen before - she never realized just how important JR's son from Kristin would be to him. She sees JR fight so hard for his son that she falls in love with JR all over again and comes back to him. They're together again and now Cliff has one more reason to hate JR - JR took Sue Ellen away from him, the woman Cliff had thought he was going to marry!

That would have worked out perfectly.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
That would have worked out perfectly.

Thank you @CeeCee72. Maybe that indicates the first step in a growing process for JR and then instead of turning him into a loser as they chose to, they have the character mature and become a better man. Doing that with JR's character so that his character has an arc to it, his character develops in a positive way. It would be a slow, challenging process but that - personal growth - is something that JR desperately needed to remain an innovative, fresh character.

When we first saw Dallas, we hadn't seen a character like him before and it made compelling TV! After seasons and seasons of doing the same types of things though, that innovative aspect wears thin because it's not new anymore. We've already seen him do the same types of things over and over and get himself in trouble as a result, over and over. If the character doesn't learn from his mistakes and he doesn't gain wisdom with age, he just doesn't stay as interesting as he used to be. As the audience grows the show has to grow with it if it wants to continue to enjoy that #1 or #2 most watched show on TV status.

Sadly, they took the least challenging, least creative route and they changed JR by taking away the exact things about the character that made it such a success! If they'd been purposely trying to hurt the show that's exactly what they would have done - take a character so successful he's become an icon and then take away the things about him that the fans like!
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
@Kenny Coyote , I think they fell into the same trap that many long running shoes fall into. They want to try something new and different and end up destroying the very thing that made the show successful instead.

I also think they misjudged the audience. They thought we all wanted to see JR "get what he had coming to him," but we didn't. We wanted him to grow and change, but not be turned into a weak loser.

They really should have known better.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
@Kenny Coyote , I think they fell into the same trap that many long running shoes fall into. They want to try something new and different and end up destroying the very thing that made the show successful instead.

I also think they misjudged the audience. They thought we all wanted to see JR "get what he had coming to him," but we didn't. We wanted him to grow and change, but not be turned into a weak loser.

They really should have known better.

If they thought the audience was watching to see JR get what he had coming to him, then when he got put in prison would have pulled in a huge audience. People would have been calling their friends on the phone and saying: Ya know that show Dallas you quit watching because the bad guy never got his comeuppance? Well guess what? He's finally getting it - turn on your TV!

That didn't happen. Dallas should have learned from that but didn't.
 
Top