Kenny Coyote
Telly Talk Star
When we saw them weaken the character of JR, we were watching them actually tear apart the foundation upon which they'd built the show. The foundation of the show was that JR was both feared and respected. He could get away with treating people the way he did because he was so good at what he did. Even if you hated JR, you had to acknowledge his competence - that he was on of the best oilmen in Texas. Bobby even said that about JR. Jeremy Wendell said JR was possibly the only man he considered a threat. That's the best compliment anyone could ever get from Wendell.
JR may have lied and used underhanded tricks, but he was an intimidating force and people respected that. The cartel, even after being screwed over by JR ,went on to do more business with him because they knew JR knew how to make them money. In the contest for Ewing Oil, Bobby won, but he was just one day away from losing. Had the contest ended the previous day, JR would have won. Bobby made a gamble that payed off with only hours to spare and Bobby had enjoyed the help of Katherine, Pam, Rebecca, Cliff, the cartel, and still JR almost won!
That was the character JR was when the show was drawing over a 20 Nielsen rating, year after year. As soon as they got into the "let's make JR a loser and have every woman humiliate him and one-up him" the ratings declined in a direct relationship to how much JR was weakened. Nobody wanted to see that JR. He had become an 80s icon because he was the man men wanted to be and women wanted to be with. When the character lost its appeal, the show lost its appeal. If Dallas were a sports team, JR Ewing would have been referred to as their franchise player. As goes the franchise, so goes the team.
I honestly don't know what they were thinking. I can only guess that maybe they thought the fans would have enjoyed it if other, weaker characters who had been mistreated by JR got their revenge. If JR had been a hated character by the audience, that might have worked. Again, JR was a very unique character who could not be treated as if, perhaps he'd been a villain who the fans couldn't wait to see get his comeuppance. The Dallas audience liked JR too much to want to see him get his comeuppance. If they had, they Haleyville storyline where JR got sent to prison would have done tremendous numbers, but it didn't! if they had, Sue Ellen helping ruin JR's attempt to take over Westar over would have gotten great ratings, but it didn't! Dallas was getting its greatest ratings when JR was at the peak of his powers. When he stopped being the guy men wished they could be and women wished they could be with, the people stopped watching. The worse JR was weakened, the worse ratings Dallas got.
JR may have lied and used underhanded tricks, but he was an intimidating force and people respected that. The cartel, even after being screwed over by JR ,went on to do more business with him because they knew JR knew how to make them money. In the contest for Ewing Oil, Bobby won, but he was just one day away from losing. Had the contest ended the previous day, JR would have won. Bobby made a gamble that payed off with only hours to spare and Bobby had enjoyed the help of Katherine, Pam, Rebecca, Cliff, the cartel, and still JR almost won!
That was the character JR was when the show was drawing over a 20 Nielsen rating, year after year. As soon as they got into the "let's make JR a loser and have every woman humiliate him and one-up him" the ratings declined in a direct relationship to how much JR was weakened. Nobody wanted to see that JR. He had become an 80s icon because he was the man men wanted to be and women wanted to be with. When the character lost its appeal, the show lost its appeal. If Dallas were a sports team, JR Ewing would have been referred to as their franchise player. As goes the franchise, so goes the team.
I honestly don't know what they were thinking. I can only guess that maybe they thought the fans would have enjoyed it if other, weaker characters who had been mistreated by JR got their revenge. If JR had been a hated character by the audience, that might have worked. Again, JR was a very unique character who could not be treated as if, perhaps he'd been a villain who the fans couldn't wait to see get his comeuppance. The Dallas audience liked JR too much to want to see him get his comeuppance. If they had, they Haleyville storyline where JR got sent to prison would have done tremendous numbers, but it didn't! if they had, Sue Ellen helping ruin JR's attempt to take over Westar over would have gotten great ratings, but it didn't! Dallas was getting its greatest ratings when JR was at the peak of his powers. When he stopped being the guy men wished they could be and women wished they could be with, the people stopped watching. The worse JR was weakened, the worse ratings Dallas got.