Why Weakening JR Wrecked Dallas

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
When we saw them weaken the character of JR, we were watching them actually tear apart the foundation upon which they'd built the show. The foundation of the show was that JR was both feared and respected. He could get away with treating people the way he did because he was so good at what he did. Even if you hated JR, you had to acknowledge his competence - that he was on of the best oilmen in Texas. Bobby even said that about JR. Jeremy Wendell said JR was possibly the only man he considered a threat. That's the best compliment anyone could ever get from Wendell.

JR may have lied and used underhanded tricks, but he was an intimidating force and people respected that. The cartel, even after being screwed over by JR ,went on to do more business with him because they knew JR knew how to make them money. In the contest for Ewing Oil, Bobby won, but he was just one day away from losing. Had the contest ended the previous day, JR would have won. Bobby made a gamble that payed off with only hours to spare and Bobby had enjoyed the help of Katherine, Pam, Rebecca, Cliff, the cartel, and still JR almost won!

That was the character JR was when the show was drawing over a 20 Nielsen rating, year after year. As soon as they got into the "let's make JR a loser and have every woman humiliate him and one-up him" the ratings declined in a direct relationship to how much JR was weakened. Nobody wanted to see that JR. He had become an 80s icon because he was the man men wanted to be and women wanted to be with. When the character lost its appeal, the show lost its appeal. If Dallas were a sports team, JR Ewing would have been referred to as their franchise player. As goes the franchise, so goes the team.

I honestly don't know what they were thinking. I can only guess that maybe they thought the fans would have enjoyed it if other, weaker characters who had been mistreated by JR got their revenge. If JR had been a hated character by the audience, that might have worked. Again, JR was a very unique character who could not be treated as if, perhaps he'd been a villain who the fans couldn't wait to see get his comeuppance. The Dallas audience liked JR too much to want to see him get his comeuppance. If they had, they Haleyville storyline where JR got sent to prison would have done tremendous numbers, but it didn't! if they had, Sue Ellen helping ruin JR's attempt to take over Westar over would have gotten great ratings, but it didn't! Dallas was getting its greatest ratings when JR was at the peak of his powers. When he stopped being the guy men wished they could be and women wished they could be with, the people stopped watching. The worse JR was weakened, the worse ratings Dallas got.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
If JR had merely mellowed - much like Jock before him - then that wouldn't have been a problem, because presumably he would still get his hands dirty if need be. But turning him into a pushover was daft.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
If JR had merely mellowed - much like Jock before him - then that wouldn't have been a problem, because presumably he would still get his hands dirty if need be. But turning him into a pushover was daft.

Swami

How do you figure Jock mellowed? Granted, the actor was sick in his last episodes, so maybe he didn't appear as physically in top shape, but he still ruled the roost! He didn't exactly appear "mellow" here

 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I honestly don't know what they were thinking. I can only guess that maybe they thought the fans would have enjoyed it if other, weaker characters who had been mistreated by JR got their revenge.

I suppose I understand the writers wanting to go in a different direction than having J.R. come out on top all the time. Their solution was to weaken the character.

Could they have done something different?

Yes! They could have kept J.R. the Magnificent Bastard that he was, but put him against impossible odds.

To put a finer point on it-- Don't weaken J.R., but instead increase the challenges so he has to rise to the occasion.

Remember the contest for Ewing Oil? J.R. and Sue Ellen are having dinner at the Cattleman's Club when they run into some adversaries. J.R. tells Sue Ellen, "I can beat Bobby with one hand tied behind my back. But it appears a lot of people are conspiring to band together against me."

Sue Ellen notices that J.R. is advisably worried.

Is that a weakened J.R? No, it is the same J.R. against greater odds.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I suppose I understand the writers wanting to go in a different direction than having J.R. come out on top all the time. Their solution was to weaken the character.

Could they have done something different?

Yes! They could have kept J.R. the Magnificent Bastard that he was, but put him against impossible odds.

To put a finer point on it-- Don't weaken J.R., but instead increase the challenges so he has to rise to the occasion.

Remember the contest for Ewing Oil? J.R. and Sue Ellen are having dinner at the Cattleman's Club when they run into some adversaries. J.R. tells Sue Ellen, "I can beat Bobby with one hand tied behind my back. But it appears a lot of people are conspiring to band together against me."

Sue Ellen notices that J.R. is advisably worried.

Is that a weakened J.R? No, it is the same J.R. against greater odds.

That's a good idea @Lastkidpicked!

There's a third possibility - the one I like best. JR becomes intent on bettering himself. He's older and wiser now and is ashamed at some of the things he used to do. It wouldn't be an overnight quick fix. It would be incredibly difficult to change habits that are ingrained in him. He is pushed to his limits to try to break these patterns of behavior and become a good husband and overall a better man. The conflict here is internal conflict - the conflict within JR and Larry Hagman and the ability to make this work!

Then you might say, won't it be dull if everyone at Southfork gets along and is happy? No, it won't be dull, because then instead of so much of the conflict being within the family (which had already been done to death), we get a new dynamic where the Ewings are facing an aggressive takeover attempt or attempt to run them out of business by Westar! Promote William Smithers up to the main cast and now you have an enemy for the Ewings who isn't the goofy, almost likable Cliff Barnes who never had the expertise or the emotional stability to be an awesome opponent for the Ewings. Cliff had the desire to break the Ewings but not the wherewithal to accomplish it. Jeremy Wendell comes across as a cold, calculating bad MF'er who not only wants to break the Ewings, but convinces you that he is the man who not only wants to, but also has the ability to do it! William Smithers had the ability to convince you that he was "that guy. "
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
How do you figure Jock mellowed? Granted, the actor was sick in his last episodes, so maybe he didn't appear as physically in top shape, but he still ruled the roost! He didn't exactly appear "mellow" here


Fair enough but that was at a time when he was keen to get a bit more involved in business again, and resented the fact that Bobby suggested he consult him before he withdrew the money.

Swami
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Jeremy Wendell comes across as a cold, calculating bad MF'er who not only wants to break the Ewings, but convinces you that he is the man who not only wants to, but also has the ability to do it! William Smithers had the ability to convince you that he was "that guy. "
The reason Jeremy Wendell is such a good adversary is that he doesn't have the usual "soft targets".

Try to bribe him? He already has plenty of money.

Set him up with a hooker, then threaten to tell his wife? He's not married so nobody would care.

Blackmail him? He seems to be very smart about keeping things secret.

I love that to Jeremy, J.R. is nothing but a nuisance. Listen to how he says it when J.R. walks in the room. It's almost as if Jeremy is talking to a piece of gum he found on his shoe:

"Oh, hello J.R."

BHWHAHAHAHA! Don't ever change, Jeremy.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
The reason Jeremy Wendell is such a good adversary is that he doesn't have the usual "soft targets".

Try to bribe him? He already has plenty of money.

Set him up with a hooker, then threaten to tell his wife? He's not married so nobody would care.

Blackmail him? He seems to be very smart about keeping things secret.

I love that to Jeremy, J.R. is nothing but a nuisance. Listen to how he says it when J.R. walks in the room. It's almost as if Jeremy is talking to a piece of gum he found on his shoe:

"Oh, hello J.R."

BHWHAHAHAHA! Don't ever change, Jeremy.

I think the way Wendell talks, the way he delivers his lines is what makes him such a unique character. Like JR he doesn't lose his composure under stress, but he has a completely different personality and speaking style than JR has. There really is no other character on Dallas who is so cavalier about the way he threatens people; he doesn't let anyone shake him. That and his choice of words, saying things like telling April when she offers him "Cliff'a head on a plater" Jeremy first replies "What would I want with him? but then goes on to say "On the other hand, your attitude isn't entirely out of line."

Do you remember the time Cliff "intruded" on Jeremy's lunch and after Cliff left, Jeremy was so flustered he couldn't remember which fork was the salad fork or which hand to hold it in? He was just completely exasperated at Cliff having the gall to interrupt his lunch, it was great!
 
Last edited:

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
The weakening of JR destroyed the show.

He was always so fun to watch - never knowing what he was going to do and to whom and how. There was never any doubt that he would always figure a way to come out on top.

The JR of later seasons became a clown, an empty shell of what he once was. He was bested by the weakest of opponents...Michelle, James, Cally... It was ridiculous. Even Dusty and Cliff got in shots. John Ross traipsed off to England and JR just accepted it when he said he was staying. That's not JR.

Also, I always felt that the removal of Ellie, John Ross, and Sue Ellen from his life made him seem less human. The thing about JR that always appealed to me the most was that as mean, nasty, and underhanded as he was, there were always people in his life that he cared for. It made it easier for me to care about him.

Honestly, I grew to hate him so much, by the time the final episode rolled around, I actually hoped he had shot himself and put himself out of his misery.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
The weakening of JR destroyed the show.

He was always so fun to watch - never knowing what he was going to do and to whom and how. There was never any doubt that he would always figure a way to come out on top.

The JR of later seasons became a clown, an empty shell of what he once was. He was bested by the weakest of opponents...Michelle, James, Cally... It was ridiculous. Even Dusty and Cliff got in shots. John Ross traipsed off to England and JR just accepted it when he said he was staying. That's not JR.

Also, I always felt that the removal of Ellie, John Ross, and Sue Ellen from his life made him seem less human. The thing about JR that always appealed to me the most was that as mean, nasty, and underhanded as he was, there were always people in his life that he cared for. It made it easier for me to care about him.

Honestly, I grew to hate him so much, by the time the final episode rolled around, I actually hoped he had shot himself and put himself out of his misery.

When Dallas was successful, the JR they presented was a serious, intimidating man who coud do what he said he could do and nobobdy doubted his ability to get things done! Even of you didn't like other thing about him, you could admire his expertise, his sense of mastery over the oil business and admire how incredibly capable he was in getting what he wanted!

Who wouldn't love the ability to be assured that you could have anything you wanted as long as you seriously went after it? No wonder JR Ewing became a pop culture icon! People admired the money, the notoriety, the persuasive ability he had to get people to see things his way - in one word, what people admired and even envied about JR was his overall competency!

The key element of the character of JR is he is extremely competent! Strip the competency from the character, and you no longer have JR Ewing because competency was a defining characteristic of who JR was! Portray JR as not being able to get anything he goes after, and he's not the same guy anymore!
 
Last edited:

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I am in agreement, they did destroy JR's character starting with that ridiculous Hayleyville storyline and the sheriff coming to his office. JR accepting James when he was suspecious of Jamie was especially bad and ruining JR and John Ross' relationship.

We loved JR always winning and being on top if he had to lose, it should have been with people who were his equals.
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
I remember seeing a feature (possibly on one of the DVDs???) where the producers said they decided that season 11 (DVD) had featured too much business and that season 12 (DVD) would move more outdoors - hence the Hayleyville trip.

This just shows how much out of touch they were with the viewers, the odd trip outside Dallas fine, but we tuned in to watch the wheeling and dealing in Dallas, J.R's schemes and how they affected everyone. Season 12 (DVD) not only weakened the character of J.R but that of the other Ewings - it was a knock on effect that had characters reacting completely irrationally to what they would have done normally.

It was also the start of the J.R/Bobby show, that would take the last 3 seasons to it's bitter end.

I have no idea who came up with the idea of Conundrum, but they obviously thought that the viewers would swallow anything, and that kind of contempt is what ruined the show and the character of J.R.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I remember seeing a feature (possibly on one of the DVDs???) where the producers said they decided that season 11 (DVD) had featured too much business and that season 12 (DVD) would move more outdoors - hence the Hayleyville trip.

This just shows how much out of touch they were with the viewers, the odd trip outside Dallas fine, but we tuned in to watch the wheeling and dealing in Dallas, J.R's schemes and how they affected everyone. Season 12 (DVD) not only weakened the character of J.R but that of the other Ewings - it was a knock on effect that had characters reacting completely irrationally to what they would have done normally.

It was also the start of the J.R/Bobby show, that would take the last 3 seasons to it's bitter end.

I have no idea who came up with the idea of Conundrum, but they obviously thought that the viewers would swallow anything, and that kind of contempt is what ruined the show and the character of J.R.

Nice post @pete lashmar! When did moving more outdoors ever spike their ratings? That isn't what the show was built on. The business, the wheeling and dealing was one of the primary foundations upon which Dallas was built along with the family interactions and romances.

The biggest ratings they ever got were spurred by JR's wheeling and dealing which led to a scenario where many of JR's business associates were possible suspects in his shooting. If JR had been an ineffectual businessman who couldn't get anything done, he wouldn't have been perceived as a threat, and there wouldn't have been all those businessmen who were thinking of killing him because of how he'd screwed them in that Asian deal.

It's because JR was so good at wheeling and dealing that he was perceived as a threat. Take a away his competence, his skill, his ability and where is the threat? Without the threat, where is the drama?

Notice how much of the time even when JR isn't in a scene, how much the other characters talk about JR. He is the single most talked about character on the show. The reason they talked about him so much is because he was such a capable, formidable adversary to anyone who tried to compete with him. Many characters, at various times, talked about "how are we going to stop JR"?

If the fans had been watching for years and years to finally see him get his comeuppance, then seeing him get put in prison would have done extraordinary ratings but it didn't because most people didn't want to see that! The audience had fun seeing JR winning. They liked that. JR at the peak of his powers was a ratings grabbing monster! There wasn't any other TV character as talked about among the general populace as JR Ewing when he was at the peak of his powers. As JR's powers diminished, so did the size of their audience. Their audience dwindled year after year as they stripped the character of his competence, yet nobody in charge woke up and said: This isn't working! We're losing viewers"!
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
I agree @Kenny Coyote, and by taking characters away that fed on J.R, it weakened him ever further. Without Miss Ellie at Southfork he was weakened, without Sue Ellen he was even weaker. The show had really lost it's way, to the point where BBG was only offered 3 or 4 episodes for the final series, which she refused (quite rightly). Linda Gray could probably have been lured back, but they didn't want to spend money - so for the final series we got J.R, Bobby and a hoard of characters no one was interested in - most of whom were up against J.R and brought him down.

The writers had completely lost the ability to write for the character and for some strange reason Larry thought it was a good idea to make J.R lose time after time after time. Normally J.R would be deadly when beaten in anything, he would wreak revenge on anyone that crossed him, but there wasn't that pay off anymore - there wasn't even a twist.

I think it's also true that Bobby became a love sick puppy for the final season - but his demise started in season 11 (DVD) when he just accepted Pam's departure and divorce without any kind of fight. The writers were not doing justice to the characters - Clayton got the same treatment with the Laurel story.

With writers losing their spit, the characters lost their grit and what was a giant in TV became a whimpering, sentimental oozing snore fest.

Alas even the TV movies that followed had no bite either because, once again they centered everything around an already floored J.R and flooded them again with characters that no one knew or cared for - even thought it was wonderful to have Linda back.
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Although to be fair JR Returns was much more like the old Dallas, it had more of the key ingredients in place.

JR Returns can be fun to watch if you are just wanting to have some fun without thinking too hard. A fun little jaunt down memory lane.

I do like the payoff when J.R. gets the better of Carter McKay. Early on, Carter turns down J.R.'s offer to buy back Ewing Oil by saying, "No way, J.R.-- Ewing Oil is part of a long range plan I promised the board."

At the end, when J.R. gets the upper hand he says:

"Don't kid yourself, Mac. Your long range plan just fell on it's ass."

BHAHAHAHA! That magnificent bastard!

I try to use that line whenever I can.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
JR Returns can be fun to watch if you are just wanting to have some fun without thinking too hard. A fun little jaunt down memory lane.

I do like the payoff when J.R. gets the better of Carter McKay. Early on, Carter turns down J.R.'s offer to buy back Ewing Oil by saying, "No way, J.R.-- Ewing Oil is part of a long range plan I promised the board."

At the end, when J.R. gets the upper hand he says:

"Don't kid yourself, Mac. Your long range plan just fell on it's ass."

BHAHAHAHA! That magnificent bastard!

I try to use that line whenever I can.

Even Cliff was much more like himself in it, rather than the devil-like figure that TNT made him.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Even Cliff was much more like himself in it, rather than the devil-like figure that TNT made him.

Swami

I was also surprised when I first watched it, but that's one of the few things about TNT Dallas that made sense. Cliff had allowed bitterness, jealousy and revenge to consume him and it took its toll! It would have had to. Nobody can allow all those negative emotions to fill their mind and not have it eat them up from the inside.

Cliff could have had a good life as a capable lawyer, but he threw his career away going after an unbeatable opponent that crushed his political career when he kept attacking them and they had to - it was self-defense. Cliff could have done anything in law that didn't involve the Ewings but he wouldn't.

We saw how it had already affected him. When we first saw Cliff, he seemed to be a relatively normal, bright guy with a promising future. Then he started ruining his life by allowing all those negative thoughts to fill his mind. He couldn't keep a woman because he was so inconsiderate to them. He probably even talked to them about JR when they were in bed! He could not have a conversation without saying "JR" because Cliff was absolutely obsessed.

He started acting goofy (which he had not done before) and we saw him him adopting weird awkward physical mannerisms. He was mentally crumbling.

Now imagine the progression of that from the end of the original show to the start of TNT Dallas. All that negativity had absolutely eaten him up from the inside; it had consumed his soul. He had become exactly what you would expect a man would become of he allowed his mind to filled with bitterness, jealousy and vengeance. It had consumed anything good that had once been within him and what was left of the man was what you saw in TNT Dallas.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
They turned JR into a buffoon who always lost!

You do not do that with the key character in a well established hit series!

Especially if that key character is the main break out character people tune in to see what dastardly schemes he's up to. :(
 
Top