Dallas Character What's the best scene with JR and Miss Ellie?

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
What do you think is the best scene with these two characters, one that reveals the layers of their relationship?
All the scenes I can recall really don't seem to delve too deeply into the complicated emotions they must have. Miss Ellie either seems oblivious to JR's true nature or just not to actually like him.
 

James from London

International Treasure
The first one that springs to mind is at the end of Season 1 when Bobby carries a drunken Sue Ellen into the house in front of the family, and Miss Ellie asks to speak to JR alone. She admits to standing by and letting Jock raise him, asks if there's anyone really he loves, and tells him he's treated Sue Ellen like dirt since they first got married. He seems unrepentant, but this seems to be one of the contributing factors in him having Sue Ellen sectioned.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
There’s a few. When A drunken Sue Ellen storms out after a fight with JR and Miss Ellie confronts JR with “We’ll, you’ve destroy her again, WILL YOU EVER LEARN!?!?”

The scene when JR was down and Miss Ellie comes to JR’s office and gives him a letter from Jock.

Miss Ellie bailing JR out vs Cliff and the Cartel where she chastised them for taking advantage of JR. Had to be kind of embarrassing to JR. Lol

As for Miss Ellie being oblivious to JR true nature, she knew exactly what JR was all about but chose to ignore it. It was Jock’s job to keep him in line.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
The first 2 that come to mind are:
  • The scene when Ellie refuses to go along with JR plan to kidnap John Ross from the Southern Cross
  • The scene when Ellie takes down Jock's portrait at Southfork
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
There’s a few. When A drunken Sue Ellen storms out after a fight with JR and Miss Ellie confronts JR with “We’ll, you’ve destroy her again, WILL YOU EVER LEARN!?!?”

The scene when JR was down and Miss Ellie comes to JR’s office and gives him a letter from Jock.

Miss Ellie bailing JR out vs Cliff and the Cartel where she chastised them for taking advantage of JR. Had to be kind of embarrassing to JR. Lol

As for Miss Ellie being oblivious to JR true nature, she knew exactly what JR was all about but chose to ignore it. It was Jock’s job to keep him in line.

The scene with Miss Ellie giving JR the letter from Jock is a good example.
Miss Ellie being in denial about JR is a great character point. In so many ways she is strong and noble, with the exception of this area. It shows a well-written(and acted), multi layered character.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
The first one that springs to mind is at the end of Season 1 when Bobby carries a drunken Sue Ellen into the house in front of the family, and Miss Ellie asks to speak to JR alone. She admits to standing by and letting Jock raise him, asks if there's anyone really he loves, and tells him he's treated Sue Ellen like dirt since they first got married. He seems unrepentant, but this seems to be one of the contributing factors in him having Sue Ellen sectioned.
Is that the scene in which she says," I should have held on to you a little longer"?
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Aside from the ones mentioned above, I really liked this dream season scene - I feel like it's one of the rare times that she promised to support him and actually did.

--------------

One small quibble I have with this scene is Ellie's comment that Sue Ellen is "a woman we have loved and who has loved us...." Maybe you had to be around back then, but it feels very '80s in a DYNASTY sort of way.
 

Justine

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
--------------

One small quibble I have with this scene is Ellie's comment that Sue Ellen is "a woman we have loved and who has loved us...." Maybe you had to be around back then, but it feels very '80s in a DYNASTY sort of way.

Interesting observation - I'm not completely sure on what you mean as I haven't watched Dynasty but I quite liked the line (and the whole sentiment) that Sue Ellen was a Ewing and would be regardless of whether she and J.R. were married.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Interesting observation - I'm not completely sure on what you mean as I haven't watched Dynasty but I quite liked the line (and the whole sentiment) that Sue Ellen was a Ewing and would be regardless of whether she and J.R. were married.
Yeah, it's not the sentiment I have an issue with. Like I said, it's an era specific thing, like DYNASTY's constant reiterating the relationship identities between the characters a la "I'm your father"/"You're my daughter"/"I'm your son"/"You're my mother"/"He's my gardener"/"She's my furrier", etc...

I always winced when DALLAS did it, and it seemed to during Peter Dunne's dream season... I mean, I winced when DYNASTY did it, too, but that was a hopeless situation.
 

James from London

International Treasure
One small quibble I have with this scene is Ellie's comment that Sue Ellen is "a woman we have loved and who has loved us...." Maybe you had to be around back then, but it feels very '80s in a DYNASTY sort of way.
It's a good scene and totally works in context, but it also kind of strikes as me as a "nicer" version of the earlier JR/Ellie confrontation that led to Sue Ellen's first sanatarium visit ("Is there anyone you love?" "I love Sue Ellen" "From the moment you brought that girl into this house you neglected her ..."). It feels less complicated somehow, like all the emotional rough edges have been sanded down.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
The scene works, but the line puts me in mind of Mandy telling JR that he and Sue Ellen "are an institution" the previous season. It's a subtle thing, I guess, but all they had to do was say "from what I hear, you and Sue Ellen...... " to make it not sound as if Mandy watches DALLAS every week.

It's mid-'80s self-consciousness.
 

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
For me it’s the scene that opens the dream season when he’s sitting in the living room very dejected after Bobby’s death and she tells him that she needs him to be strong.
That's my favorite scene of the two as well.

My 2nd choice would be their breakfast scene. JR asking Miss Ellie if she was willing to go ahead with breaking Jock's will. After her confirmation he says:
"Then you leave me no choice. I'll fight you every step of the way. "
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
The scene works, but the line puts me in mind of Mandy telling JR that he and Sue Ellen "are an institution" the previous season. It's a subtle thing, I guess, but all they had to do was say "from what I hear, you and Sue Ellen...... " to make it not sound as if Mandy watches DALLAS every week.

It's mid-'80s self-consciousness.
That "institution" line sticks out like a thumb sore from triteness. It's similar, imho, to the line he gives SE at the Oil Barron's Ball when she confronts him about telling Cally she was a drunk who cheated on him and neglected her child, "Well it's true. Ask anybody here." Maybe ALL the characters are stuck in a Wandavision type universe and watch "Dallas" every week. It puts me in mind of an episode of "Green Acres" in which there's a scene with a pig watching "Green Acres."
 

James from London

International Treasure
It was always a little fuzzy how famous the Ewings were supposed to be. It fluctuated depending on the storyline at the time and for the most part I think that was fine. That said, by the time Mandy comes into the picture, JR and Sue Ellen have already been at the public centre of a paternity suit, a custody fight, a bitter divorce and remarriage, plus she'd been arrested for his shooting (and never proved innocent; rather, charges were dropped due to lack of evidence) and her sister had died in bizarre circumstances while he was present. So within that context, Mandy's line makes sense. But I'm so glad the Ewings weren't regarded as wacky celebs the way the Carringtons are in New DYNASTY, for instance.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
That's the one, yes.
absolutely agree. It was that and Jock’s dressing down of JR, “from now on I’m going to see to it that you stay on the right side of having fun.” or something like that - same episode, I believe, the first part of the two-part finale of the first full season.

The next morning, JR smashed all the bottles Sue Ellen had stashed in the bedroom and told he she was going to ‘dry out’ one way or another.
 
Top