Was Dallas Always a Soap and IF NOT, when did it become one?

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I did not feel Dallas began as a soap opera but a serious family drama about a wealthy family and their businesses. A recent post about Katherine got me thinking it became more of a soap once the Barnes's suddenly became wealthy. I'm not sure the definition but to me a soap has always meant the story is less real world and more over the top - General Hospital and the Ice Princess kind of thing. I'm wondering what others think or if there's more an official definition.
 

Franko

Telly Talk Member
Nah, if anything, Dallas was chili.

No, but seriously, you have to consider that serialized (soap) storytelling was pretty much non-existent for American primetime TV in 1978. The notable exception was miniseries, which Dallas started as. Dallas began its series run with standalone plot, but overall arc, episodes (which I guess qualifies as "non-soap" storytelling), but by 1980 or so, the writing was on the wall.

Personally, I also loathe that the Ice Princess storyline is used to define soap operas. GH used it (Edited to add: the world-freezing angle, specifically) out of desperation during a writers strike and for 40 years now, the genre's either copied it or tried to live it down. (No offense.)
 
Last edited:

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
Nah, if anything, Dallas was chili.

No, but seriously, you have to consider that serialized (soap) storytelling was pretty much non-existent for American primetime TV in 1978. The notable exception was miniseries, which Dallas started as. Dallas began its series run with standalone plot, but overall arc, episodes (which I guess qualifies as "non-soap" storytelling), but by 1980 or so, the writing was on the wall.

Personally, I also loathe that the Ice Princess storyline is used to define soap operas. GH used it out of desperation during a writers strike and for 40 years now, the genre's either copied it or tried to live it down. (No offense.)
there are tons of serial dramas that aren’t considered soap operas these days, though, like all the ‘peak tv’ ones - Sopranos, Breaking Bad, Mad Men (although that was a bit closer, maybe).

I think early serial Dallas started a bit more in that vein and became progressively more soapy over time, with the introduction of Rebecca and Katherine being landmarks in that journey.

(Theresa’s tortilla soup was without peer, I’be been told.. but that was by a clearly-biased Raoul!)
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Oops not sure how to fix that typo. Lol. Soap.

It just seems to me the point is being over the top and leaving behind reality. So the Ice Princess thing is something I heard about and is clearly over the top. I hear about something with Alien Abduction with Dynasty too. So yes the fact that from the start Dynasty was not even a serial made it less soap like, but still the stories seemed more serious, more real, like a Sopranos. I didn’t watch Dynasty in its first run other than in pieces with my grandmother with over the top weddings and choking on the balcony. But when I did later, season 1 seemed less over the top, if you ignore the museum like house. It seemed more realistic to me. Then Alexis and then suddenly Alexis was rich too. It’s this level of credibility which seems to define the genre.

For me with Dallas it seemed when suddenly the Barnes got rich. I don’t think it was the fact they were rich but the suddenness, like winning the lottery. Certainly by the time Bobby returns from the dead, they’re full on soap opera. I’m wondering, did anyone feel this happen earlier in the series? Or maybe it was always a soap by it’s very nature.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Let's see....early Dallas

vixen - check
hunk - check
bribery and blackmail - check
illness- check
big confession - check
recast - check
bitch-slap - check
office showdown - check
hostage scene - check
the shooting - check
stunt casting - check
skeleton in the closet - check
the letter - check
the rivalry - check
singing performance - check
insults - check
hospital scene - check
the affair - check
miscarriage - check
paternity issue - check
the kidnapping - check
the staircase moment - check
 

Crimson

Telly Talk Star
By definition, a soap opera is a melodrama with serialized storylines. Technically, DALLAS became a soap once it abandoned standalone episodes. But, by the literal definition, anything from THE SOPRANOS to GAME OF THRONES kind of fits the bill. When people think about soaps, it's less about the format or even plotlines than about the tone: kind of sordid and outlandish, bumping against implausible. DALLAS started out fairly grounded and became soapier as the years went by.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
Katherine was "soapier" than Kristin, imho, because she was a tad more layered as a character. The viewer got to see a bit more motivation regarding her actions.
Katherine's clothes got "soapier" as her tenure on the series progressed. At first she dressed normally, but then the hats and turbans came along as she became less of a character and more of a "femme fatale."
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
But, by the literal definition, anything from THE SOPRANOS
But I think stories like THE SOPRANOS and MAD MEN are less manipulative, less convenient and less self-explanatory.
Early Dallas, Dynasty and Knots Landing had those moments of cinematic drama too but there were also cheesy soap staples like trying to break up a couple by means of very obvious and villainous plotting.

Even if DALLAS wasn't a traditional soap opera from the very beginning, it started out like all the other exploitative potboiler mini-series from that era.
1621865584934.png
Capricorn Crude, indeed.

The UK was producing this kind of adult drama too, but the tone was more sober and literary. Ironically, this only seemed to highlight the soapier aspects.
Then there's the Australian soaps with their own unique vibe, and the fact that in many European countries "soap opera" wasn't even a word at the time the Big Soaps aired.
Technically speaking, in Holland and Belgium, DALLAS has never been a soap opera. But I don't think that adds anything to the discussion.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
Let's see....early Dallas

vixen - check
hunk - check
bribery and blackmail - check
illness- check
big confession - check
recast - check
bitch-slap - check
office showdown - check
hostage scene - check
the shooting - check
stunt casting - check
skeleton in the closet - check
the letter - check
the rivalry - check
singing performance - check
insults - check
hospital scene - check
the affair - check
miscarriage - check
paternity issue - check
the kidnapping - check
the staircase moment - check
but.. but... ..ah man, that's kind of convincing... ..but the tone wasn't as soapy, at least in the Jock years. Maybe have a rebuttal when I get some time :)
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
By definition, a soap opera is a melodrama with serialized storylines. Technically, DALLAS became a soap once it abandoned standalone episodes. But, by the literal definition, anything from THE SOPRANOS to GAME OF THRONES kind of fits the bill. When people think about soaps, it's less about the format or even plotlines than about the tone: kind of sordid and outlandish, bumping against implausible. DALLAS started out fairly grounded and became soapier as the years went by.
excellent description - so nice and succinct!
 

Crimson

Telly Talk Star
but the tone wasn't as soapy, at least in the Jock years.

I get the gist of the thread, and it's something I've tried to work out in my head through the years. DALLAS did change in its mid-years; it became, well, more DYNASTY-esque. I get the temptation of equating that with being more soapy -- which, obviously, I just did -- but Willie makes a compelling counter-argument. That implies that DYNASTY was a 'true' soap but, by extension, would imply that KNOTTS LANDING -- even more grounded than early DALLAS -- would never have been a soap.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
but the tone wasn't as soapy, at least in the Jock years
1621873757483.png
They're saying we was credible drama, Ellie.
- Give me their names, Jock. I'll shoot 'em in the face!

1621873845910.png
Get the hell out of my soap opera! You're not even stunt casting.

1621874021548.png
I've HAD it with this soap ranch, my mama had promised me a critically acclaimed drama!

1621874175221.png
Hold me, Pam! They're going to erase our early years soap history, like your future dream.

1621874294225.png
But what about meeeeeee!
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
View attachment 27413
They're saying we was credible drama, Ellie.
- Give me their names, Jock. I'll shoot 'em in the face!

View attachment 27414
Get the hell out of my soap opera! You're not even stunt casting.

View attachment 27415
I've HAD it with this soap ranch, my mama had promised me a critically acclaimed drama!

View attachment 27416
Hold me, Pam! They're going to erase our early years soap history, like your future dream.

View attachment 27417
But what about meeeeeee!
don't make me bust out the (rather authentic sometimes) ranching scenes!
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
That implies that DYNASTY was a 'true' soap but, by extension, would imply that KNOTTS LANDING -- even more grounded than early DALLAS -- would never have been a soap.
I guess it's all about the stigma of the soap opera genre, probably derived from the daytime soaps that had been on the air for decades.
For whatever reason we associate True Soap with the high-octane and very plot-driven stories of the later years, but then PEYTON PLACE wouldn't even qualify as a soap opera.
I agree with a part of that stigma, that it's not possible to sell an ongoing story that uses specific tools and plot devices as a "credible and critically acclaimed drama".
It's never going to be a Meryl Streep or Jeremy Irons show.

But that weakness is also the strength of the genre, because it is possible to incorporate Meryl Streep moments, even in the most plot-driven era of the show.
And it's this very clash, the inherently low-quality aspect of ongoing (melo)drama combined with the challenge to make it look great, sophisticated and whatnot, that creates such a wonderful and unique energy.
I think KNOTS and PEYTON PLACE were the most persistent in that regard,

DYNASTY is the most tragic example. It had the strongest start of all the soaps and after that it kinda succumbed to its own success.
FALCON CREST excelled in distinctive atmosphere, once they got rid of that....
 

Crimson

Telly Talk Star
And it's this very clash, the inherently low-quality aspect of ongoing (melo)drama combined with the challenge to make it look great, sophisticated and whatnot, that creates such a wonderful and unique energy.

"There is a very short distance between high art and trash, and trash that contains the element of craziness is by this very quality nearer to art.” -- Douglas Sirk


I guess it's all about the stigma of the soap opera genre

I suspect so. Prior to this discussion, I would have made the point that early- DALLAS was melodrama, while mid- to late- DALLAS was a soap (even while acknowledging the distinction between them probably existed no where except in my own head). I think this might just be tap-dancing around a more obvious point about quality. DALLAS was a great soap that eventually became a good soap, then a mediocre soap, then, finally, a crummy soap.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I feel like a key component of a “soap” is that it doesn’t even try to make its audience suspend disbelief... probably not part of the standard definition, though..
 
Top