Was Dallas Always a Soap and IF NOT, when did it become one?

A few definitions 0f soap opera and Dallas ticks the box ;)

Soap opera, broadcast dramatic serial program, so called in the United States because most of its major sponsors for many years were manufacturers of soap and detergents.

a serial drama performed originally on a daytime radio or television program and chiefly characterized by tangled interpersonal situations and melodramatic or sentimental treatment.

Plots and storylines​

The main characteristics that define soap operas are "an emphasis on family life, personal relationships, sexual dramas, emotional and moral conflicts; some coverage of topical issues; set in familiar domestic interiors with only occasional excursions into new locations".[14] Fitting in with these characteristics, most soap operas follow the lives of a group of characters who live or work in a particular place, or focus on a large extended family. The storylines follow the day-to-day activities and personal relationships of these characters. "Soap narratives, like those of film melodramas, are marked by what Steve Neale has described as 'chance happenings, coincidences, missed meetings, sudden conversions, last-minute rescues and revelations, deus ex machina endings.'" These elements may be found across the gamut of soap operas, from EastEnders to Dallas.[15]

In many soap operas, in particular daytime serials in the US, the characters are frequently attractive, seductive, glamorous and wealthy. Soap operas from the United Kingdom and Australia tend to focus on more everyday characters and situations, and are frequently set in working-class environments.[16] Many of the soaps produced in those two countries explore social realist storylines such as family discord, marriage breakdown or financial problems.

Both UK and Australian soap operas feature comedic elements, often affectionate comic stereotypes such as the gossip or the grumpy old man, presented as a comic foil to the emotional turmoil that surrounds them. This diverges from US soap operas where such comedy is rare.[5] UK soap operas frequently make a claim to presenting "reality" or purport to have a "realistic" style.[17] UK soap operas also frequently foreground their geographic location as a key defining feature of the show while depicting and capitalising on the exotic appeal of the stereotypes connected to the location. As examples, EastEnders focuses on the tough and grim life in the East End of London; Coronation Street and its characters exhibit the stereotypical characteristic of "northern straight talking".[18]

Romance, secret relationships, extramarital affairs, and genuine hate have been the basis for many soap opera storylines. In US daytime serials, the most popular soap opera characters, and the most popular storylines, often involved a romance of the sort presented in paperback romance novels. Soap opera storylines weave intricate, convoluted and sometimes confusing tales of characters who have affairs, meet mysterious strangers and fall in love, and who commit adultery, all of which keeps audiences hooked on the unfolding story. Crimes such as kidnapping, rape, and even murder may go unpunished if the perpetrator is to be retained in the ongoing story.

The successful prime time serials of the 1980s included Dallas, its spin-off Knots Landing, Dynasty, and Falcon Crest. These shows frequently dealt with wealthy families, and their personal and big-business travails. Common characteristics were sumptuous sets and costumes, complex storylines examining business schemes and intrigue, and spectacular disaster cliffhanger situations. Each of these series featured a wealthy, domineering, promiscuous, and passionate antagonist as a key character in the storyline – respectively, J.R. Ewing (Larry Hagman), Abby Cunningham (Donna Mills), Alexis Colby (Joan Collins), and Angela Channing (Jane Wyman). These villainous schemers became immensely popular figures that audiences "loved to hate".

Unlike daytime serials, which are shot on video in a studio using the multi-camera setup, these evening series were shot on film using a single camera setup, and featured substantial location-shot footage, often in picturesque locales. Dallas, its spin-off Knots Landing, and Falcon Crest all initially featured episodes with self-contained stories and specific guest stars who appeared in just that episode. Each story was completely resolved by the end of the episode, and there were no end-of-episode cliffhangers. After the first couple of seasons, all three shows changed their story format to that of a pure soap opera, with interwoven ongoing narratives that ran over several episodes. Dynasty featured this format throughout its run.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
By definition, a soap opera is a melodrama with serialized storylines. Technically, DALLAS became a soap once it abandoned standalone episodes. But, by the literal definition, anything from THE SOPRANOS to GAME OF THRONES kind of fits the bill. When people think about soaps, it's less about the format or even plotlines than about the tone: kind of sordid and outlandish, bumping against implausible. DALLAS started out fairly grounded and became soapier as the years went by.
Well said. Thank you. That is exactly what I was thinking.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
possibly in a clairvoyant effort to provide context for this very discussion, the late Andy Kaufman weighs in on some aspects of Soap


(actually not all that unrelated, as pro wrestling is often called “soap opera for men”. Here, Andy is playing a JR-like villain, riling up the fans so they can enjoy seeing him get pummeled in the ring by the local hero. It’s a cartoonish storyline done with a wink and a nod, like a daytime soap.

For a more JR-like character that people “love to hate”, see the Nature Boy Ric Flair, still popular today after decades in the business.)
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
but.. but... ..ah man, that's kind of convincing... ..but the tone wasn't as soapy, at least in the Jock years. Maybe have a rebuttal when I get some time :)
I agree with you. In fact the list isn’t necessarily proof that it’s unrealistic as all those things can really happen and be portrayed in a realistic way. To me it’s the realism that is the divide not specific events or plots or even characters.
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I guess it's all about the stigma of the soap opera genre, probably derived from the daytime soaps that had been on the air for decades.
For whatever reason we associate True Soap with the high-octane and very plot-driven stories of the later years, but then PEYTON PLACE wouldn't even qualify as a soap opera.
I agree with a part of that stigma, that it's not possible to sell an ongoing story that uses specific tools and plot devices as a "credible and critically acclaimed drama".
It's never going to be a Meryl Streep or Jeremy Irons show.

But that weakness is also the strength of the genre, because it is possible to incorporate Meryl Streep moments, even in the most plot-driven era of the show.
And it's this very clash, the inherently low-quality aspect of ongoing (melo)drama combined with the challenge to make it look great, sophisticated and whatnot, that creates such a wonderful and unique energy.
I think KNOTS and PEYTON PLACE were the most persistent in that regard,

DYNASTY is the most tragic example. It had the strongest start of all the soaps and after that it kinda succumbed to its own success.
FALCON CREST excelled in distinctive atmosphere, once they got rid of that....
Got rid of what regarding Falcon Crest?
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
May I add to this excellent discussion by observing the show's timeline against the timeline of Hollywood thinking?

1979: The Rural Purge is complete. Shows set in the South are out, Westerns are out. Family dramas are in.
Notice that in the Dallas Miniseries, the show was presented squarely as a family drama. The city of Dallas wasn't portrayed as a Southern City, it was portrayed as any other metropolis.

Early 1980s: Viewers are once again drawn to the American Western.

The Man From Snowy River,

1621966184901.png


Kenny Rogers the Gambler

1621966156742.png

Dallas evolved into an American Western set in modern times:

1621966297563.png

1621966391243.png

Notice this is when the ranching side of Southfork was displayed most prominently. Dallas the city was shown to be not just ANY city, but a city squarely in the Texas culture. Episodes were filmed on location at the stock yards.

1621967290059.png


Early 1980's:
Inflation, high gas prices, high restaurant prices. People beginning to stay home. And shows like Saturday Night Live and Dallas made it cool to stay home on weekend nights.
Notice this is the height of the "Who Shot J.R." phenomenon and the Dallas parties on Friday nights.

Mid 1980's:
The economy is getting better and people are going out. Out shopping, Out eating, Out driving. Just OUT.
Television executives had a problem on their hands. Some of the highest rated TV shows were aimed at people staying in. Dukes of Hazzard, The A-Team, and Knight Rider.
What's wrong with that?
The problem is that the audience was made up of teenaged boys, who did not yet have their own disposable income. Not good if you are trying to sell advertising for your show.

Who is suddenly the target market for television? The two income family. Modern appliances allow a homemaker to take a part time job while still maintaining the home. And when they are maintaining that home, they often have a soap opera on the television for a bit of distraction.

Notice that this is where (in some people's opinions) Dallas began more soap-like storylines. Going after that demographic.

Late 1980's: Television viewers are looking for the lighter fare. Top rated shows include America's Funniest Home Videos, Unsolved Mysteries, and Matlock.
Notice this is when J.R. went from the man we love to hate, to a "kinder and gentler J.R. Ewing". (His exact quote).

The Barnes/Ewing feud was watered down to an almost friendly rivalry between J.R. and Cliff. Remember the comical, "You and I are partners!?" scene?

1621967980980.png

To put a finer point on it:
You can almost know what was going on in the outside world just by observing the "stages of life" that Dallas went through over the years.
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Great analysis, @Lastkidpicked!
I wonder how the rise in popularity of country and western music(Mickey Gilley, Kenny Rogers, Dolly Parton) and the success of the movie Urban Cowboy was mixed up in Dallas huge success.

Thank you, @Jimmy Todd .

Our resident musician, @Taylor Bennett Jr. might drop in and answer that question.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
I kind of always saw it as a soap myself, right from the start, but just getting more and more soapier as time went by. But I can see why people would think it was more drama than soap in the beginning.
 
Top