An Alternate Idea For The Jenna/Naldo/Bobby Storyline

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I was thinking about something they could've done in season 8 instead of having Jenna being charged with the murder of Naldo Marchetta. I never found it convincing that Jenna would be charged with murder, because considering the circumstances, even if she had shot him it should have been self-defense. Naldo had abducted Charlie and used that to extort Jenna to marry him! How is doing what's necessary to free herself from that situation not self-defense?

There's a scene between Bobby and Naldo where Naldo tells Bobby he wants his family to spend some time with Charlotte. He says he loves his daughter very much. Bobby asks Naldo how much money will it take for Naldo to overcome his newfound love for Charlie. Bobby says "Just name a figure."

Naldo replies: "No, there is no figure. I have no need for your money. I want back the family that is rightfully mine."

Bobby says: "You gave up the right to that family a long time ago."

Naldo: I am here to reclaim it.

Bobby: Jenna and I are gonna be married and I want you out of Dallas

Naldo: I will not leave without my daughter and you cannot stop me!

Bobby: You just try me, Naldo.

Naldo: You would have to kill me to stop me. Are you really ready to do that?

Bobby: Whatever. You just remember what I said.

(Bobby walks away)

I think there may have been a more interesting possibility there. Realistically, when Jenna didn't show up for the wedding and didn't even tell Bobby about what was going on, and just left a note saying "There is someone I love even more and I am doing what I must" Bobby could have realized that Naldo had done something, especially in light of the conversation I transcribed.

Then Bobby gets a call that he should meet them at a certain address, which turned out to be the home of the justice of the peace who had just married them. Charlie wasn't even there! Doesn't it seem suspicious that she just married Naldo that suddenly, and Charlie wasn't there?

What if they'd had Bobby decide right then that Naldo was forcing Jenna to do this (she hardly looked like a happy bride) and he decided to "take Naldo apart." He's going to beat the truth out of Naldo to force him to explain what was going on, and hits Naldo hard enough to knock him down. Bobby starts punching Naldo in the face and yelling: "Tell the truth! What have you done? Where is Charlie" but Naldo won't talk. Finally Bobby's temper just snaps and he slams Naldo's head into the pavement, killing him.

Then the court case would be about whether Bobby's justified in what'd done. He could say Naldo had threatened to take Charlie back to Italy, that there was nothing that could stop him and Bobby knew full well that Jenna didn't love or even like Naldo. He was trying to protect Jenna and Charlie from whatever Naldo was forcing them to do and his lawyer pleads self-defense since Bobby was acting to protect Jenna and Charlie from Naldo.

Instead of Jenna fearing going to prison it would be Bobby, and there would be more reason to think that Bobby might have gone too far, that he might well have been guilty of using excessive force to protect Jenna, or whatever the legal term would be.

They could have had that quick, violent scene, where Bobby once again loses his temper and assaults someone, but now he might actually have to pay a price for not being able to control his temper. That the way he's acted all his life, using physical violence or the threat of it to make people do what wants had finally come around to bite him in the ass.

He took things too far. He could have just held Naldo there while Jenna went back to the house of the justice of the peace and had him call 911. He could have but he lost control of his temper and for the first time it could have serious consequences for him.

He's got to look back at how he's always relied on being able to control people, how Bobby has continually relied on using that threat of violence to make JR and other people afraid enough of him enough that they would do what he wanted. It always worked for him before, but this time it has turned out badly for him.

Bobby has never had to pay a price for continually relying on using that physical bluff that he always pulls when he wants to get his way, or even actually assaulting people when he feels like they deserve it. Now he wonders if he all those years he acted like that sanctimonious type of man, who judges people every time they don't meet his standards of morality, maybe he was never in a position to judge anybody - that everybody's got their flaws and they're all just doing the best they can with what they've got.
 
Last edited:

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Nah, they needed Bobby around to keep JR in line to a certain degree. Lol

Dallas would have been better off without Jenna. Probably my least favorite character in the series. To this day, I have no idea why Charlie’s father was such a big mystery.
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I think there may have been a more interesting possibility there. Realistically, when Jenna didn't show up for the wedding and didn't even tell Bobby about what was going on, and just left a note saying "There is someone I love even more and I am doing what I must" Bobby could have realized that Naldo had done something, especially in light of the conversation I transcribed.

You might be onto something, Kenny. I'm not sure where they were headed with the whole Jenna storyline and I think they should have done something like you suggest.

There is evidence that they had bigger plans for the Jenna character. They spent time building up her backstory, and even had several characters start building up her arrival by making comments such as "Jenna Wade was Bobby's first love." and "Lucas Wade had a ranch about three miles from Southfork. Jenna and Bobby were together all the time and we figured they would get married."
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
You might be onto something, Kenny. I'm not sure where they were headed with the whole Jenna storyline and I think they should have done something like you suggest.

There is evidence that they had bigger plans for the Jenna character. They spent time building up her backstory, and even had several characters start building up her arrival by making comments such as "Jenna Wade was Bobby's first love." and "Lucas Wade had a ranch about three miles from Southfork. Jenna and Bobby were together all the time and we figured they would get married."

I think it was very out of character for Bobby to be told by Naldo to meet him that exact location "but don't bring anyone" and Bobby just goes along with it, doesn't bring anyone, takes them at their word that they got married while Jenna looks miserable and Charlie isn't there, and Bobby just accepts it and lets them go. If everything is on the up and up, why did he have to come there alone? He didn't find that suspicious?

I think it would've been far more believable for Bobby to have done something to Naldo, demanded some real answers as to what was going on. Anyone could see Jenna was thrilled about marrying Bobby and then all of the sudden, she marries the man she thought so lowly of that she refused to put his name on Charlie's birth certificate? She put Bobby's name on Charlie's birth certificate because she was afraid Naldo might try to take her away from Jenna, and then Bobby believes Jenna willingly married that man again? It's just not believable.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I think it would've been far more believable for Bobby to have done something to Naldo, demanded some real answers as to what was going on. Anyone could see Jenna was thrilled about marrying Bobby and then all of the sudden, she marries the man she thought so lowly of that she refused to put his name on Charlie's birth certificate?

You hit the nail on the head when you said it was out of character for Bobby. I think you have summed up the whole problem with the Jenna Storyline. It was out of character for Bobby, after all these years of trying, to finally father a child. And then try to pretend that everything is normal.

And let's not forget, Bobby just quietly watches as Ray and Jenna take their (and Bobby's) baby off to Europe to live.

Out of character. You said that just right.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
You hit the nail on the head when you said it was out of character for Bobby. I think you have summed up the whole problem with the Jenna Storyline. It was out of character for Bobby, after all these years of trying, to finally father a child. And then try to pretend that everything is normal.

And let's not forget, Bobby just quietly watches as Ray and Jenna take their (and Bobby's) baby off to Europe to live.

Out of character. You said that just right.

Thank you Lastkid. Bobby is the last man who it would make a big difference to whether a child he had been like a father to was his biological child. Christopher was adopted! With Charlie, he hadn't raised her from when she was a baby, but he was like a father to her, certainly the closest thing to a real father Charlie had ever had. Bobby loved Charlie. There is no way he'd think something wasn't very wrong when supposedly Jenna decided to marry a man other than Bobby, that particular man, at a moment's notice, and not even have Charlie with her.

That's why I referenced this:

Naldo: I will not leave without my daughter and you cannot stop me!

Bobby: You just try me, Naldo.

Naldo: You would have to kill me to stop me. Are you really ready to do that?

Bobby: Whatever. You just remember what I said.

Naldo had all but stated he would kidnap Charlie. Now, Charlie is nowhere in sight and Jenna has just married Naldo! I just don't see Bobby not being able to put those things together. The way I see it, there's no way that Bobby just stands there in front of Naldo, hears that extremely suspicious sounding story that Jenna suddenly decided to marry Naldo, and Bobby just lets Naldo drive off with Jenna.

The sad thing for the audience is: Bobby said "You just try me, Naldo." So Naldo does "try" Bobby and Bobby does nothing to Naldo!
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Naldo: I will not leave without my daughter and you cannot stop me!

Bobby: You just try me, Naldo.

Naldo: You would have to kill me to stop me. Are you really ready to do that?

Bobby: Whatever. You just remember what I said.

Naldo had all but stated he would kidnap Charlie. Now, Charlie is nowhere in sight and Jenna has just married Naldo! I just don't see Bobby not being able to put those things together. The way I see it, there's no way that Bobby just stands there in front of Naldo, hears that extremely suspicious sounding story that Jenna suddenly decided to marry Naldo, and Bobby just lets Naldo drive off with Jenna.

The sad thing for the audience is: Bobby said "You just try me, Naldo." So Naldo does "try" Bobby and Bobby does nothing to Naldo!

Your post brings one thing to light very clearly. When people do a re-watch of that story line, there is one thing missing:

There is no sense of urgency.

@James from London points this out in other story lines and it applies here as well. There is no sense of urgency.

Your idea helps give the plot a reason to keep moving forward.
 

James from London

International Treasure
I have to say I always liked this storyline. It got off to a tedious start with Naldo reappearing in Dallas, but once he kidnapped Jenna it got really good. It had a darkly mysterious, slow burn vibe to it that worked well in conjunction with what else was going on at the same time - the fight for Ewing Oil, Pam looking for Mark. I especially liked the way the outlandishness of the plot and Jenna's soapy history was perceived so dispassionately by the legal system: first, the Laredo judge who is so unimpressed by the Ewing name that he sets bail at a million dollars, and then the trial judge who witheringly describes Jenna's backstory as "quite a tangled web you have woven for yourself, Mrs Marchetta." And, of course, Scotty Demarest is always excellent value. The scene early on where he interrogates Jenna in jail is just great and unusually gritty for Dallas: Priscilla Presley acts her little heart out.

Also, the hitman who killed Naldo - Andre Schuman. So chilling!
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Your post brings one thing to light very clearly. When people do a re-watch of that story line, there is one thing missing:

There is no sense of urgency.

@James from London points this out in other story lines and it applies here as well. There is no sense of urgency.

Your idea helps give the plot a reason to keep moving forward.

Thanks @Lastkidpicked. I like the idea of Bobby, who has a real problem with losing his temper so easily, and who has become accustomed to live his life by using the threat of physical violence, that physical bluff he uses so often to intimidate someone into doing things his way, finally having to pay price for thinking he could just keep doing that and ignoring the fact he had a bad problem with his temper. It would make the audience feel real sympathy for him too because this time he'd get in a fight in a situation where he was saving Jenna and Charlie from having been adducted by Naldo and from whatever he was going to do with them.

I think the audience would feel Bobby was very justified in pushing Naldo and using physical force to get him to explain what was going on. Clearly Jenna was too afraid to say anything. Picture this: Bobby starts a fight with Naldo with the intention of forcing him to tell Bobby what he was doing. Jenna gets scared and runs right back to the home of the justice of the peace to call 911 - afraid Bobby and Naldo will kill each other.

Bobby is punching Naldo and demanding he tell him what is really going on because he trusts Jenna and believes there is no way Jenna would voluntarily marry Naldo, breaking her engagement to Bobby with no explanation.

Naldo refuses to say anything helpful and Bobby's temper snaps. He punches Naldo repeatedly, trying to force the truth out of him, and he apparently knocks Naldo unconscious. He keeps punching Naldo in a blind rage, yelling "Wake up you sonofabitch"! Jenna comes back and says "Bobby stop! The police are on there way"! She starts telling Bobby what Naldo did.

The police get there and they examine Naldo. A cop checks Naldo's pulse and says "He's dead."

The cops see Bobby's bloody knuckles and tell him: "We're going to to have to place you under arrest for murder." Jenns starts screaming "He was saving me! Naldo was..."

Bobby cuts her off and says: "Jenna, don't say a thing until Scotty Demarest gets here."

It sets the scenario for a court case where Bobby seems be in real trouble - he went too far. His temper snapped, and he's facing the very real possibility of having to pay a price for it this time.

All our consequences have actions, but in Dallas, it seems like since Bobby never has to answer for his flaws, even serious ones. Now that temper of his, that lack of self-control that he never bothered to do anything about, has finally had a serious negative consequence for him.

This direction of taking the story in makes Bobby serious re-evaluate the way he's been living his life, always throwing punches at the first provocation and asking questions later. Having a temper that snaps when he doesn't get his way. Remember how Pam ran to Cliff's apartment as soon as she found out Bobby suspected Cliff of kidnapping John Ross? She's going there because she thinks Cliff is in danger, to save him from her own husband! Why wouldn't she side with her own husband? Isn't that pretty unusual? Well, she would side with her husband, except she knows how little self-control Bobby has and is afraid Bobby will beat Cliff to a pulp. That's the reputation Bobby's temper has even with his own wife! She doesn't want Cliff hospitalized or Bobby going to jail.

Bobby feels like he can get away with anything because he has such an inflated opinion of himself he thinks anything he does is justified. Maybe that's because he sees himself as "the good brother." Life isn't that simplistic.

Yes, Bobby is on average a better man than JR but it doesn't mean he's without faults or that anything he does is justified because he sees himself as so entirely virtuous. Here's a guy who was prepared to steal his own brother's son! He thought it was justified because it made Pam happy. If something is good for Bobby or Pam, he sees it as justified. There's never even a time when we see Bobby feeling some serious guilt over never telling JR that he has every reason to believe Christopher is JR's son. His plan is to make sure JR never finds out, because that it makes Pam happy to have a baby, any baby, that somehow trumps all other ethical or legal concerns.

Yes, Bobby is basically a good guy but he's not as good as he hinks he is and he's certainly not so good that he's above the law!

When a storyline forces a character to re-evaluate the way they've been living, it creates an impetus for character development, for that character to grow as a person. That's vital to keeping the characters relevant and continually interesting to the audience. That's one thing the people running Dallas and writing it, didn't seem to understand. They seem to operate under the idea: "The audience likes the characters just the way they are, so don't have any significant character development."

For Bobby, that change must literally be forced. He's always seen himself as always on the right side of everything, so he has always felt justified, no matter what. Now he realizes he's still accountable for his own actions, for letting that temper of his go unchecked and for so often using violence as his first response to stress. He's not a kid anymore. He has never developed the self control he should have at his age.

Bobby is going to have to re-evaluate the way he lives his life. I find that so much more intriguing than just having it where "Bobby is the good brother so he never as to pay a price for constantly using that physical bluff he uses to get his way, for punching people whenever he wants and always getting away with it, and for above all else, never taking responsibility for the fact that he has a serious problem controlling his temper."

If characters never have to take self-accountability for their flaws, then it decreases the level of drama because you know that whatever they do, they always get away with it. When you allow that, you kill the incentive for any growth to take place in your characters. Why should they change their ways if they never have consequences, if they never have to pay a price for acting in unacceptable ways?
 
Last edited:

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Your post brings one thing to light very clearly. When people do a re-watch of that story line, there is one thing missing:

There is no sense of urgency.

Especially when it comes to Charlie. I’m actually re-watching this storyline right now and when Jenna’s lawyer comes to see her, she ask about Charlie and his response, “I’m not here to talk about Charlie.”

During that whole storyline Bobby and the lawyer really put finding Charlie on the back burner.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
The problem is not the storyline: it was ambitious and lasted one whole season, in the style of the best Katzman-Paulsen storylines. The problem is that only a good actress could have made all that believable. Not a wooden celebrity sponging her late ex-husband´s last name (probably thinking she´d top the cast in the opening because before "Bel Geddes" came..."Beaulieu").

Not in a million years somebody could believe that a hunk like Bobby might be interested in someone so flat, uninteresting and boring like Prissy P. And that he would be glued to her for two long years...How many times before that the writers and the cast made believable lame plots and twists? A few...but the actors used all their craft and professionality into doing their jobs well.

Prissy P. collected her checks and had yearly holidays in Dallas hanging from the Bobster´s arm in front of a camera...I would have killed to do that, if I had been an actor (I´m not).
 
Last edited:

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
To this day, I have no idea why Charlie’s father was such a big mystery.
Especially since it had already been solved way back in season 2.
 
Top