Kenny Coyote
Telly Talk Star
I was thinking about something they could've done in season 8 instead of having Jenna being charged with the murder of Naldo Marchetta. I never found it convincing that Jenna would be charged with murder, because considering the circumstances, even if she had shot him it should have been self-defense. Naldo had abducted Charlie and used that to extort Jenna to marry him! How is doing what's necessary to free herself from that situation not self-defense?
There's a scene between Bobby and Naldo where Naldo tells Bobby he wants his family to spend some time with Charlotte. He says he loves his daughter very much. Bobby asks Naldo how much money will it take for Naldo to overcome his newfound love for Charlie. Bobby says "Just name a figure."
Naldo replies: "No, there is no figure. I have no need for your money. I want back the family that is rightfully mine."
Bobby says: "You gave up the right to that family a long time ago."
Naldo: I am here to reclaim it.
Bobby: Jenna and I are gonna be married and I want you out of Dallas
Naldo: I will not leave without my daughter and you cannot stop me!
Bobby: You just try me, Naldo.
Naldo: You would have to kill me to stop me. Are you really ready to do that?
Bobby: Whatever. You just remember what I said.
(Bobby walks away)
I think there may have been a more interesting possibility there. Realistically, when Jenna didn't show up for the wedding and didn't even tell Bobby about what was going on, and just left a note saying "There is someone I love even more and I am doing what I must" Bobby could have realized that Naldo had done something, especially in light of the conversation I transcribed.
Then Bobby gets a call that he should meet them at a certain address, which turned out to be the home of the justice of the peace who had just married them. Charlie wasn't even there! Doesn't it seem suspicious that she just married Naldo that suddenly, and Charlie wasn't there?
What if they'd had Bobby decide right then that Naldo was forcing Jenna to do this (she hardly looked like a happy bride) and he decided to "take Naldo apart." He's going to beat the truth out of Naldo to force him to explain what was going on, and hits Naldo hard enough to knock him down. Bobby starts punching Naldo in the face and yelling: "Tell the truth! What have you done? Where is Charlie" but Naldo won't talk. Finally Bobby's temper just snaps and he slams Naldo's head into the pavement, killing him.
Then the court case would be about whether Bobby's justified in what'd done. He could say Naldo had threatened to take Charlie back to Italy, that there was nothing that could stop him and Bobby knew full well that Jenna didn't love or even like Naldo. He was trying to protect Jenna and Charlie from whatever Naldo was forcing them to do and his lawyer pleads self-defense since Bobby was acting to protect Jenna and Charlie from Naldo.
Instead of Jenna fearing going to prison it would be Bobby, and there would be more reason to think that Bobby might have gone too far, that he might well have been guilty of using excessive force to protect Jenna, or whatever the legal term would be.
They could have had that quick, violent scene, where Bobby once again loses his temper and assaults someone, but now he might actually have to pay a price for not being able to control his temper. That the way he's acted all his life, using physical violence or the threat of it to make people do what wants had finally come around to bite him in the ass.
He took things too far. He could have just held Naldo there while Jenna went back to the house of the justice of the peace and had him call 911. He could have but he lost control of his temper and for the first time it could have serious consequences for him.
He's got to look back at how he's always relied on being able to control people, how Bobby has continually relied on using that threat of violence to make JR and other people afraid enough of him enough that they would do what he wanted. It always worked for him before, but this time it has turned out badly for him.
Bobby has never had to pay a price for continually relying on using that physical bluff that he always pulls when he wants to get his way, or even actually assaulting people when he feels like they deserve it. Now he wonders if he all those years he acted like that sanctimonious type of man, who judges people every time they don't meet his standards of morality, maybe he was never in a position to judge anybody - that everybody's got their flaws and they're all just doing the best they can with what they've got.
There's a scene between Bobby and Naldo where Naldo tells Bobby he wants his family to spend some time with Charlotte. He says he loves his daughter very much. Bobby asks Naldo how much money will it take for Naldo to overcome his newfound love for Charlie. Bobby says "Just name a figure."
Naldo replies: "No, there is no figure. I have no need for your money. I want back the family that is rightfully mine."
Bobby says: "You gave up the right to that family a long time ago."
Naldo: I am here to reclaim it.
Bobby: Jenna and I are gonna be married and I want you out of Dallas
Naldo: I will not leave without my daughter and you cannot stop me!
Bobby: You just try me, Naldo.
Naldo: You would have to kill me to stop me. Are you really ready to do that?
Bobby: Whatever. You just remember what I said.
(Bobby walks away)
I think there may have been a more interesting possibility there. Realistically, when Jenna didn't show up for the wedding and didn't even tell Bobby about what was going on, and just left a note saying "There is someone I love even more and I am doing what I must" Bobby could have realized that Naldo had done something, especially in light of the conversation I transcribed.
Then Bobby gets a call that he should meet them at a certain address, which turned out to be the home of the justice of the peace who had just married them. Charlie wasn't even there! Doesn't it seem suspicious that she just married Naldo that suddenly, and Charlie wasn't there?
What if they'd had Bobby decide right then that Naldo was forcing Jenna to do this (she hardly looked like a happy bride) and he decided to "take Naldo apart." He's going to beat the truth out of Naldo to force him to explain what was going on, and hits Naldo hard enough to knock him down. Bobby starts punching Naldo in the face and yelling: "Tell the truth! What have you done? Where is Charlie" but Naldo won't talk. Finally Bobby's temper just snaps and he slams Naldo's head into the pavement, killing him.
Then the court case would be about whether Bobby's justified in what'd done. He could say Naldo had threatened to take Charlie back to Italy, that there was nothing that could stop him and Bobby knew full well that Jenna didn't love or even like Naldo. He was trying to protect Jenna and Charlie from whatever Naldo was forcing them to do and his lawyer pleads self-defense since Bobby was acting to protect Jenna and Charlie from Naldo.
Instead of Jenna fearing going to prison it would be Bobby, and there would be more reason to think that Bobby might have gone too far, that he might well have been guilty of using excessive force to protect Jenna, or whatever the legal term would be.
They could have had that quick, violent scene, where Bobby once again loses his temper and assaults someone, but now he might actually have to pay a price for not being able to control his temper. That the way he's acted all his life, using physical violence or the threat of it to make people do what wants had finally come around to bite him in the ass.
He took things too far. He could have just held Naldo there while Jenna went back to the house of the justice of the peace and had him call 911. He could have but he lost control of his temper and for the first time it could have serious consequences for him.
He's got to look back at how he's always relied on being able to control people, how Bobby has continually relied on using that threat of violence to make JR and other people afraid enough of him enough that they would do what he wanted. It always worked for him before, but this time it has turned out badly for him.
Bobby has never had to pay a price for continually relying on using that physical bluff that he always pulls when he wants to get his way, or even actually assaulting people when he feels like they deserve it. Now he wonders if he all those years he acted like that sanctimonious type of man, who judges people every time they don't meet his standards of morality, maybe he was never in a position to judge anybody - that everybody's got their flaws and they're all just doing the best they can with what they've got.
Last edited: