Clayton - Too Bland To Fit Into Dallas

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I liked Clayton, but I think the character was kind of bland for a show like Dallas. He lacked something. For one, he was pushover. He let Miss Ellie dictate all the terms of their marriage to him and any man who would allow that is going to be a bland character. I think he should have said something like "we've got to meet each other half-way" and not allowed himself to practically become the next Mr. Ewing. He even moved in with his wife's grown children into a house Jock built. Clayton didn't stand up for himself enough or seem to stand for anything in particular except acquiescing to Ellie's wishes.

The part of the story where Bobby, Ray and JR ask him if he's willing to help them and Clayton says he doesn't feel right about it is another example of the character being too bland for Dallas. He got along very well with Bobby and was good friends with Ray. I think it would have been very reasonable for him to have helped them and allowed Clayton to become a little more interesting. But Clayton was frightened that it wasn't "the right thing to do." Clayton was even against the idea of them bringing armed guards onto Southfork when they were being attacked in the range war. He had no solution to the problem though. He wasn't bad guy, but as a character he was kind of empty of anything that might potentially create some entertainment value. Clayton needed some serious moxie!
 
Last edited:

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
I've always felt that Clayton was a critical character in the show.

When you have a show full of characters who are fighting you absolutely need a voice of reason - someone who you know has no hidden agenda.

Of course he strayed from the path a couple of times, but he was there to reassure Sue Ellen, Miss Ellie, Donna & Ray when they needed help and guidance and I thought Howard Keel was a perfect fit for the show.

From his early beginnings as a simply written character as Dusty's father, he had instant screen presence and he grew into someone many of the shows' other characters looked up to.

Like many characters though, the writers kind of gave up giving him anything to really get his acting chops around and in the last years of Dallas his role was hugely reduced - but Clayton was always a support character, he was never really given a big story...and when he did it involved some of the worst acting and plot the show had ever seen - yes Laurel I'm looking at you.

I loved Clayton, he wasn't vital to the show but he was a huge part of it for me.
 
Last edited:

thomaswak

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I liked Clayton. I just had hard time believing he could fall in love with Miss Elie after his "love" for Sue Ellen. Nothing wrong with Mis Elie, or BBG, but to put it in context, I was like 10 or 12 yo when I watched it the first time, so maybe I couldn't get everything.

Clayton was not a vital character imo, but his character worked and didn't feel "out of place" which was really important (and that's why he stayed so long : watchers liked him I guess)
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I've always felt that Clayton was a critical character in the show.

When you have a show full of characters who are fighting you absolutely need a voice of reason - someone who you know has no hidden agenda.

Of course he strayed from the path a couple of times, but he was there to reassure Sue Ellen, Miss Ellie, Donna & Ray when they needed help and guidance and I thought Howard Keel was a perfect fit for the show.

From his early beginnings as a simply written character as Dusty's father, he had instant screen presence and he grew into someone many of the shows' other characters looked up to.

Like many characters though, the writers kind of gave up giving him anything to really get his acting chops around and in the last years of Dallas his role was hugely reduced - but Clayton was always a support character, he was never really given a big story...and when he did it involved some of the worst acting and plot the show had ever seen - yes Laurel I'm looking at you.

I loved Clayton, he wasn't vital to the show but he was a huge part of it for me.

I liked Clayton too and I think Howard Keel was as good a choice as they could have made as long as Miss Ellie was going to get married again. I think he could have been a more vital part of the show if they hadn't tried to play it so safe in the way they wrote the character. Here's an example what I'm trying to describe:

When Clayton wanted to talk about where to live, Ellie acted surprised as if: You're suggesting we should do anything other than have you sell you ranch, leave your business, your town with your friends, so you can move into my ranch, into the house my ex-husband built, to live with adult children?

Yeah, why would that be unreasonable? Ellie makes no sacrifices and Clayton makes all the sacrifices, which apparently to her is reasonable. She's just so out of it! She's oblivious to anything that doesn't involve her desires, while never trying to see anything from Clayton's perspective. I lost some respect for Clayton when he caved in to all her demands.

It's hard for a character to be exciting when he's so agreeable.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
If Wes Parmalee had've been revealed properly as Jock & stayed on, I think the character of Clayton would've been phased out eventually.

The writers would've paired Steve Forrest's Jock back with Miss Ellie which would've made the character of Clayton a bit redundant.

Unless of course they were planning for Clayton to rekindle feelings for Sue Ellen, that would've been interesting. :)
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
He was an excellent addition to the show, but I always preferred Jock.

Swami

Yeah Howard Keel was a great actor, certainly one of the best casting decisions Barbara Miller & Irene Mariano ever did on the show.

I loved the character. Sadly it was because of Jim Davis's death which gave Lorimar the opportunity to keep the character on the show, eventually pairing him off with the Ewing matriarch Miss Ellie. :)
 

Ukdallasfan

Telly Talk Fan
Jock was a stronger character for sure. However, in his early days, Clayton was no push over. Like, when JR asked Miss Ellie to put John Ross in the helicopter. One sentence from Clayton- let the court decide- was all it took to put her straight. The other great scene was the one where JR had bought up all the crude to blackmail Clayton to throw Sue Ellen off the Southern Cross. Clayton was super cool there and put JR down big style. It’s a shame that the character was watered down over time and that the best use wasn’t made of him. The Laurel storyline was, well, just ugh and beneath Howard Keel as an actor :)
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Jock was a stronger character for sure. However, in his early days, Clayton was no push over. Like, when JR asked Miss Ellie to put John Ross in the helicopter. One sentence from Clayton- let the court decide- was all it took to put her straight. The other great scene was the one where JR had bought up all the crude to blackmail Clayton to throw Sue Ellen off the Southern Cross. Clayton was super cool there and put JR down big style.

You have a point, when the character was first introduced he was no pushover. Somehow I don't see that guy you just described as being alright with being told by Miss Ellie that, if he wanted to marry her, it had to be strictly on her terms: Clayton sells his ranch, leaves his town and his friends, moves into Southfork, into the home Jock built and lives with JR and Bobby. I picture him saying something like: I'm supposed to be the only one to make sacrifices? I'm willing to compromise and give up some things to get married, but Ellie, you have got to meet me half way.

I think the producer of the show did that to preserve the dynamic of having everyone lie at Southfork, but it weakened Clayton's character. Clayton, as we originally knew him, would have been far more likely to have said that he was willing to sell his ranch, move to Dallas, and then he and mIss Ellie would both decide on a new house that would be their own house. To expect him to move onto her ranch,, into the house Jock built, and live with her adult children just not reasonable.

I'm not suggesting he become a bad guy; I liked that he was good, but Clayton could still have, for example, helped Ray and Bobby when they asked for his help during the time when Cliff and Jamie were trying to take 2/3 of Ewing Oil away from them. To paraphrase JR, he said something like: You have one chance to help our family and you won't do it. I wonder if Mama realizes what a weak man you are.

Clayton said he "didn't think it was right." Well would it be right if Cliff and Jamie who never lifted a finger to make Ewing Oil what it had become, should profit off all the work the Ewings had done to build Ewing Oil from a medium sized company into an empire? There was no clear right and wrong there but Clayton just didn't want to get involved; he didn't want to take any risk to help the family. If a character isn't willing to take any risks, there is no way that character can be exciting.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Jock was a stronger character for sure. However, in his early days, Clayton was no push over. Like, when JR asked Miss Ellie to put John Ross in the helicopter. One sentence from Clayton- let the court decide- was all it took to put her straight. The other great scene was the one where JR had bought up all the crude to blackmail Clayton to throw Sue Ellen off the Southern Cross. Clayton was super cool there and put JR down big style. It’s a shame that the character was watered down over time and that the best use wasn’t made of him. The Laurel storyline was, well, just ugh and beneath Howard Keel as an actor :)

Good post. I’ll also like to add, just because a man has morals doesn’t make him weak. It took strength to stand up to JR, Bobby and Ray and Clayton was absolutely right and he was right when he told them “you better start doing your homework or there won’t be a Ewing Oil.”

Also, I wouldn’t call anybody weak who threatened to kill someone in front of all of Dallas at the Oil Barons Ball. Heck, even JR seemed proud of Clayton. Lol
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I liked Howard Keel, but Clayton represented a missed opportunity. He should have been positioned a bit more as a business rival to the Ewings. Or maybe someone who ran a competing business but someone who sometimes cooperated, like the cartel. Think about how exciting the family dinners would have been if that were the case. Ellie would have had a tough timing enforcing the “no business talk at dinner” rule.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
Clayton had to be a good character and I don't agree that good is equivalent to bland because he was far from being bland.

The reason why I think he had to be good was to counter the scheming and wickedness of JR, especially after Bobby left and when Ellie became a less significant character due to the producers (wrongly) losing confidence in Donna Reed and Barbara having health problems.
 

Laurie Marr

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I demur from the view that he wasn’t ‘strong.’ If you measure strength only in terms of how imposing someone is, then he certainly was unlike Jock. However, Clayton was highly articulate about feelings, was often wise and discerning in his assessment of people and exercised often extraordinary self discipline in not socking it to those screwed up Ewings more than he did. He was flawed too and was able to acknowledge that when he behaved badly - yet he never came across as self righteous in the way that was often the case with Donna and Bobby.

All of these qualities I regard as indicative of strength.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I’ll also like to add, just because a man has morals doesn’t make him weak. It took strength to stand up to JR, Bobby and Ray and Clayton was absolutely right and he was right when he told them “you better start doing your homework or there won’t be a Ewing Oil.”

I don't think anybody here has called Clayton "weak"; I believe the word was "bland." In that particular situation, there was no clear right and wrong thing to do, but there were two choices:

One would take some effort and some risk - to stand with Ray and Bobby and JR against Cliff and Jamie,

Or

He could sit on the sidelines and offer no help, while still criticizing them for how they were doing a job he himself wasn't even willing to do.

Clayton chose the second one.

To be exciting, a character has got to be willing to take some risk, to do more than sit on the sidelines and observe, and to be willing to stand up for himself and say: You're asking me to make all the sacrifices while you make none. I'll make compromises but you have got to at least be willing to meet me half way.

The scene at the OilBaron's Ball was far from bland; it was exciting, but geez, the occasions when Clayton showed that type of spirit grew to be few and far between!

The reason why I think he had to be good was to counter the scheming and wickedness of JR

If he was there to counter JR's schemes when he married Ellie and moved into Southfork, do you remember any of JR's schemes that he put an end to? There may have been some, but right now, I don't recall any.

I like that he was good, but he was so hesitant to take action that involved any risk. In the range war he was even against hiring armed men to protect Southfork, while offering no alternate solution.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
I don't think Clayton was bland but I will agree that his character did get diluted down over the series run. If that dilution down made the character bland then we can blame the writers for that. :(
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
Surely among the many risks (asking Sue Ellen to marry him, protecting her from JR at Southern Cross, standing up to Parmalee, taking Dusty on as his son), the biggest ever risk Clayton took, was marrying into a family where he knew he wasn’t exactly welcome, and stepping into the shoes of a hugely revered father figure?
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I liked Howard Keel, but Clayton represented a missed opportunity.
You are exactly right!

Howard Keel is a great actor and the writers just didn't know what to do with him. Remember that my favorite characters are the older guys, so I have an idea for a fun storyline:

J.R. and Bobby are on the verge of losing Ewing Oil. The power of Weststar and Jeremy Wendell are bearing down on them. They are becoming desperate.

Clayton senses the urgency and comes to J.R. and Bobby. (Imagine this in Clayton's deep baritone voice) "I love your mother, and I am part of your family now, like it or not. And while I don't relish the idea, I can help you in this fight". Bobby eagerly accepts his offer, while J.R. very reluctantly accepts and we all know he will hire his usual spies to keep an eye on Clayton.

images


The fight is on! The Ewings and Clayton vs. one of the largest oil companies on the planet. And what a fight it is. Clayton has to bring Punk Anderson and his buddies out of retirement to help.
morgan-woodward-dallas.jpg


Things aren't going their way, and Clayton, Punk, and their buddies approach J.R. and Bobby. "Boys, this is the fight of your lives. And we have been through this where you have not. You've never known what it was like to get in a pickup truck, drive to a tool and die company, and ask them to sell you a million dollars worth of equipment on credit. And knowing that if you can't convince them, then your company is bankrupt. We've had to do that before."

Punk takes another drink.

"You've never had to drive to a refinery and ask them to advance you ten million dollars cash against future deliveries of your crude. And doing this with the knowledge that if you can't pull this off, then you cannot make payroll this week. We have been in that position before."

Clayton steps in. "Boys, we are going back to our roots. Punk and I are going to get in Ray's dusty pickup truck and we are going to meet people face to face. We are going to re-negotiate every contract. We are going to ask for advances of cash. We are going to convince billion dollar companies to drop Weststar and do business with us. We are going to do this the old fashioned way, like we did years ago."

Then we get treated to scenes of Clayton and Punk, meeting in dark saloons and dimly lit diners. They are meeting with crews working for Weststar Oil and convincing them to quit a good, strong job and come to Ewing Oil on nothing more than a promise and a handshake from Clayton Farlow and Punk Anderson.

It's a helluva ride!

We see a group of young and tough roughnecks in a bar, who in no way want to jump ship from a sure thing to throw in with a near-bankrupt Ewing Oil. They almost look like they are spoiling for a fight. Then Punk says, "Tommy? I guess you go by Tom now, but aren't you Tommy?"

The roughneck looks surprised. "Yes!"

"Tommy, your dad ever mention Marvin Anderson? Punk Anderson?"

"Mention him? He made my dad a millionaire. Dad talked about Punk Anderson all the time! Hell, there are pictures of him holding me when I was a baby."

Punk just smiles.

"Wait a minute... Punk Anderson had black hair and mutton chop sideburns."

Punk smiles wider. "I was younger then."

This big, tough roughneck breaks into a grin. "Boys! Come and meet my Uncle Marvin. Anything he says, you can believe. I'm throwing in with him right now, and if you're smart you will, too!"

"Sure surprised me to see you in here, Uncle Marvin!"

Punk smiles again, "It will be a helluva ride, boy! And you can call me Punk."
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
You are exactly right!

Howard Keel is a great actor and the writers just didn't know what to do with him. Remember that my favorite characters are the older guys, so I have an idea for a fun storyline:

J.R. and Bobby are on the verge of losing Ewing Oil. The power of Weststar and Jeremy Wendell are bearing down on them. They are becoming desperate.

Clayton senses the urgency and comes to J.R. and Bobby. (Imagine this in Clayton's deep baritone voice) "I love your mother, and I am part of your family now, like it or not. And while I don't relish the idea, I can help you in this fight". Bobby eagerly accepts his offer, while J.R. very reluctantly accepts and we all know he will hire his usual spies to keep an eye on Clayton.

The fight is on! The Ewings and Clayton vs. one of the largest oil companies on the planet. And what a fight it is. Clayton has to bring Punk Anderson and his buddies out of retirement to help.
morgan-woodward-dallas.jpg


Things aren't going their way, and Clayton, Punk, and their buddies approach J.R. and Bobby. "Boys, this is the fight of your lives. And we have been through this where you have not. You've never known what it was like to get in a pickup truck, drive to a tool and die company, and ask them to sell you a million dollars worth of equipment on credit. And knowing that if you can't convince them, then your company is bankrupt. We've had to do that before."

Punk takes another drink.

"You've never had to drive to a refinery and ask them to advance you ten million dollars cash against future deliveries of your crude. And doing this with the knowledge that if you can't pull this off, then you cannot make payroll this week. We have been in that position before."

Clayton steps in. "Boys, we are going back to our roots. Punk and I are going to get in Ray's dusty pickup truck and we are going to meet people face to face. We are going to re-negotiate every contract. We are going to ask for advances of cash. We are going to convince billion dollar companies to drop Weststar and do business with us. We are going to do this the old fashioned way, like we did years ago."

Then we get treated to scenes of Clayton and Punk, meeting in dark saloons and dimly lit diners. They are meeting with crews working for Weststar Oil and convincing them to quit a good, strong job and come to Ewing Oil on nothing more than a promise and a handshake from Clayton Farlow and Punk Anderson.

It's a helluva ride!

We see a group of young and tough roughnecks in a bar, who in no way want to jump ship from a sure thing to throw in with a near-bankrupt Ewing Oil. They almost look like they are spoiling for a fight. Then Punk says, "Tommy? I guess you go by Tom now, but aren't you Tommy?"

The roughneck looks surprised. "Yes!"

"Tommy, your dad ever mention Marvin Anderson? Punk Anderson?"

"Mention him? He made my dad a millionaire. Dad talked about Punk Anderson all the time! Hell, there are pictures of him holding me when I was a baby."

Punk just smiles.

"Wait a minute... Punk Anderson had black hair and mutton chop sideburns."

Punk smiles wider. "I was younger then."

This big, tough roughneck breaks into a grin. "Boys! Come and meet my Uncle Marvin. Anything he says, you can believe. I'm throwing in with him right now, and if you're smart you will, too!"

"Sure surprised me to see you in here, Uncle Marvin!"

Punk smiles again, "It will be a helluva ride, boy! And you can call me Punk."

*Standing Ovation from The Coyote"

Brilliant. That writing, the development of ideas, the risk involved, getting back the grit, getting back to what I like to call the mud, the blood and the beer is exactly what Dallas needed. It's so much better than what we got in the second half of the series.

For people wondering about why I think Clayton was bland (except in very occasional scenes), look at the difference in how Clayton is utilized here. Making Miss Ellie happy is not the only thing he has going on in his life; he has something he's doing besides that for himself:

Clayton is in this to help the family but for more than just that. He's in it for goal achievement. Clayton is engaging in this work for the satisfaction to be gained from taking on a challenge and succeeding. He's an exciting character because he aspires to achieving goals: Taking on an endeavor of that magnitude and cooperating successfully with Punk and the rest of them, enjoying the process, and because of it he derives the type of self-esteem, the sense of efficacy, the sense of mastery that can only be derived from achieving goals.
 
Last edited:

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
If he was there to counter JR's schemes when he married Ellie and moved into Southfork, do you remember any of JR's schemes that he put an end to? There may have been some, but right now, I don't recall any.
That wasn't exactly the point I was making. His purpose wasn't to scupper JR's deals or even to be an obstacle to him but to provide more balance to the series. The series always had light and shade rather than just be scene after scene of scheming. It was by having good characters to provide contrast that made the wicked ones appear more nasty.
 
Last edited:
Top