"Dallas" Politically Incorrect?

What Do You Think Would Ultimately Happen As A Result Of Dallas Debuting Now And Angering PC Groups


  • Total voters
    6
  • Poll closed .

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
Incidentally season ten of Dallas is the last great season of the show which featured the original cast before the rot set in. By that I mean the departures of both Susan Howard as Donna & more importantly Victoria Principal as Pam Ewing. :(

Pam Ewing2.jpg
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
She said that because she didn't have the education,the knowledge or the experience in running a big business to make an accurate analysis of the situation.
I think she said it because she saw business as only caring about profits and not about anyone they hurt in the process. She seemed to have made a pretty good analysis of how business in general, and Ewing Oil in particular, often worked.

Many companies aim to make maximum profits in as short a period of time and do not do adequate contingency planning for lean times. If Scotfield had received a sufficient redundancy package there wouldn't have been a problem. However, when Ewing Oil made the decision to "close down people's jobs and people's lives without so much as a beg your pardon", I can understand her anger.
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I saw someone say on TV the other day asserting that complaints about "identity politics" were unfair because "identity politics is just about civil rights".

But then, she was a bitch.

Likewise, when Obama recently warned the political left about forming a "circular firing squad" in its political correctness, the left proved him right immediately in the way that they insisted that it wasn't true... And I'm a leftist. (There's also a battle between leftists in America about overly-corporate fat cat liberals and progressive liberals more interested in genuinely fixing the system so it's more responsive to the population at large -- which is valid, if those latterday progressive leftists weren't so obnoxious in other ways).

We all know political correctness is not just a concern about people's rights and fairness. That's why "PC" is a pejorative term and should be. There is indeed fascism on both sides.

DALLAS? It was always a bit hard to tell when the show was reflecting sexism and when it was expressing it. But while I always felt Sue Ellen's early problems were just an expression of who she was as a character, I also felt the squelching of Pam (for a while) and Miss Ellie was indeed chauvinism on the part of the show itself -- Katzman just wasn't too interested in them because they were women. And that could be frustrating, even then, to this male viewer.

Larry Hagman says that after the first 1996 TV movie did so well, that CBS was hot to get DALLAS back onto the air as a series, but that it fell apart because the feministic mindset of the executives at that time wanted JR's wings clipped, not excepting the argument that JR's misogyny was just part of the character. But then, that's Larry's story, so who knows how accurate it was.

If DALLAS were on today, the show would be female-centric, probably produced by women. Not that that's necessarily a bad thing. But not necessarily good either. Would it be an all-trans series? Then they really could call it PHALLUS, only with the "PH" exed out, making it "ALLUS."

alice_tv_show.jpg


One could argue that DALLAS is critiquing the behaviour it depicts, at least some of the time.
Yes, and that makes the series a little confusing -- and perhaps more interesting. On one hand they'd have a scene in which they'd describe Texas as the last bastion of male chauvinism, and then shove Pam and Ellie into a barn for long periods of time.

I've often wondered why in the mini-series all the help at Southfork were African American, and it was established that they had worked there for many years, yet at the beginning of season 1 they were gone and the staff were Hispanic instead. Was this a sign of changing times?
I dunno. The black folks at the first Barbecue ran a business, but weren't the house staff.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
.
As a Texan, I want to thank Kenny Coyote for starting this thread, and also thank everyone who has posted here.

One could argue that DALLAS is critiquing the behaviour it depicts, at least some of the time.

Leave it to James from London to bring up a very good point. In fact, Nicolae Ceausescu allowed Dallas to be shown in Romania because he believed that people would watch the greed and corruption of J.R. and say, "We certainly don't want THAT over here!"

But it backfired! People instead realized, "Wait a minute? You mean a lowly ranch hand can drive a brand new pickup and eat steak every night? We DO want that over here!"

And as a person living it. . . Yes, a ranch hand in Texas can drive a brand new pickup (mine is lifted because, well, Texas). And can eat steak every night because there is always someplace in town with a $ 9.99 special going on.
Dallas wasn't politically incorrect. It was sexist. Let's call a spade a spade. Granted, sexism was accepted more in the US at the time, but it was already changing in parts of the US. But it made sense that Dallas, Texas, would be behind the curve.
You are right about this, Michael Torrance. But there is one thing that will make you feel better:

I remember during the original run, where Sly became J.R.'s secretary. She showed that a strong woman could be successful on her own, using her brains and not her body or her connections. And I remember at the time many secretaries around the world pointed to Sly and said, "This is what a strong woman can do." And she was a very positive role model.



One thing with Dallas that always gets my attention is that women still kinda have their traditional place in society, especially in the earlier seasons.
And this is EXACTLY what we needed at the time. Think of it like this:

It's the 1970's in America. Men who had steady jobs with guaranteed retirement were being laid off for the first time in memory. Women who planned to stay home, raise the kids, and manage the household were suddenly forced from these roles and driven to join the workforce. Parents no longer could plan on their kids having it better than they did.

It was an uncertain time to say the least.

And along comes Dallas, which shows Jock as the strong patriarch of the family, with Miss Ellie as the homemaker right by his side. And Jock and Miss Ellie's kids did respect them and hope to honor them by doing even better in life than Jock and Miss Ellie did.

So while many of the Dallas storylines would be out of place today, and while looking at it from 2019 they were certainly not politically correct, the characters and the events were certainly a product of their time.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
We all know political correctness is not just a concern about people's rights and fairness. That's why "PC" is a pejorative term and should be.

Yes! Well said. The best description of political correctness I've heard is this: "Political correctness is the denial of reality." Obviously that wasn't referring to the anti-racist or anti-homophobic aspects of political correctness.

saw someone say on TV the other day asserting that complaints about "identity politics" were unfair because "identity politics is just about civil rights".

This is the first time I've ever come across the term "identity politics." Would you mind explaining what it is?

Larry Hagman says that after the first 1996 TV movie did so well, that CBS was hot to get DALLAS back onto the air as a series, but that it fell apart because the feministic mindset of the executives at that time wanted JR's wings clipped, not excepting the argument that JR's misogyny was just part of the character.

I hadn't heard that story before, because it's a perfect addition to this thread because that is EXACTLY the type of reaction by PC organizations and PC activists that I was envisioning as I created this thread.

I see some changes in society, especially political correctness , as having a pendulum type motion. Our society goes from one extreme side to the other extreme side, just a a pendulum moves, and right now the pendulum has swung to the PC extreme. Whenever the pendulum swings to far in one direction, we hope that at some point common sense will enter the equation and and things will settle on or near a reasonable middle ground instead of settling at one extreme or the other.

When executives can't effectively differentiate between fiction and reality, it's scary. How can they fail to realize that for the purposes of making a good drama, you need conflict? JR is a fictional character so what purpose does "clipping his wings " serve other than to make him dull and ruin the series? When you're creating a fictional character from a prime time soap opera, you want to make him controversial. You want that character to receive a strong emotional reaction from the audience. If you love the character, great. If you hate the character that's fine too. It's when people stop talking about the central character in your show, when they lose that emotional investment in the character they used to either hate or love, that's bad. I've seen numerous stars in the entertainment business say words to the effect of: Loe me, hate, me, but just TALK ABOUT ME"!
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Even the term, and concept of, political correctness has become politically incorrect ---- mostly to the viciously politically correct (or the hellishly passive-aggressive).

Fascism exists on both sides of the political fence. Both. And neither want to hear that.

You'll never see me sucked into conservatism because I'm all too aware of the scam at the center of it. That said, the conservatives are the one who are saying the right things in terms of where feminism is today, whether it's for the right reasons or not --- that always makes me a bit queasy to concede, but a stopped clock is right twice per day.

Anyway, series TV today is produced with a polish unseen in previous eras. But there's always some agenda that supercedes story, sometimes quite cleverly. Yes, there were political agenda evident in series TV decades before, but it didn't feel the same way somehow.

The abuse of women by men still exists in society
Women kill their offspring at a much higher rate than men, even when the fathers are in the household. Is that the fault of the Patriarchy turning women against each other and their children, as some insist?
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I dunno, it's not like Tony Soprano and his buddies, or Don Draper and his colleagues, were politically-correct types. Mafia figures in the early 2000s were largely chauvinistic and racist and homophobic by modern standards, as were most oilmen in the late 70s/early 80s and ad execs in the 50s-60s. I don't see why they wouldn't try to portray the characters accurately today if they made the show as a period piece. Maybe network TV would have more PC influence than cable or streaming, though.
 

James from London

International Treasure
I'm not really sure about 'political correctness' -- it feels like such a nebulous, subjective term -- but the article seems to be asking a similar question to the thread: can you still 'get away with' now what you could then.
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I'm not really sure about 'political correctness' -- it feels like such a nebulous, subjective term -- but the article seems to be asking a similar question to the thread: can you still 'get away' with now what you could then.
It just feels like the extremism is going in both directions, one a reflection of the other.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
the article seems to be asking a similar question to the thread: can you still 'get away with' now what you could then.

I haven't looked at what you linked although I'm familiar with Ellis - he wrote "Less Than Zero" which was turned into a movie of he same name.

The main reason I started the thread is I thought it would be interesting to find out if people thought how Dallas would be received by the extremist groups who have appointed themselves the arbiters of what types of entertainment we should be allowed to enjoy and which ones we shouldn't be allowed to enjoy. I think Dallas, with it's non-PC content would get some of these groups riled up and they'd probably be going crazy on social media trying to bring down the show all of us here grew to know and love. It might be pretty entertaining in itself seeing people who are so oversensitive that they'd actually consider protesting Dallas a good use of their time.

I understand Dallas isn't everybody's cup of whiskey, but how delusional do you have to be to not realize that whatever these characters do during an episode on Dallas, it's no consequence to anybody because they're not real people. It's fiction! They might complain abutting impact on society yo which I might ask them: How many people do you suppose joined the mafia after watching The Sopranos just because it was their favorite show and as a result they wanted to be just like Tony Soprano?

As for the advertisers, sure, they're concerned if some groups say they're going to boycott their products, but they'd have to weigh that against the tremendous amount of people they're able to reach when they advertise on a show as successful as Dallas. Besides, how do grown men and women have time to hold rallies, go on marches, and do whatever it is they do because they're oversensitive and lack the common sense to change the channel if they don't like what they're seeing.

I have to say I find the whole thing both funny and sad at that same time. How does anybody get so delusional that they decide they're the arbiter of what is moral and of what is appropriate entertainment for other grown men and women to partake in?
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I want to touch base on what was talked about briefly. In the mini-series Dallas, they had the black servants. That had to had raised a few eyebrows even in 1978. From the way they referred to the Ewings calling them “Mr Jock, Mr JR, Mr Bobby.” Reminiscent of what a house slave would call their slave owner. And even the original Southfork looked very much like a plantation house. I do wonder if that had anything to do with them choosing another Southfork. I didn’t think of it as a kid, but as an adult, that early Ewing BBQ looked as if it was straight out of the 1800’s.

Someone brought up that they soon changed the help to Latinos. Being in Texas, it does make more sense. None of that would fly today.
 

James from London

International Treasure
In the mini-series Dallas, they had the black servants. That had to had raised a few eyebrows even in 1978. From the way they referred to the Ewings calling them “Mr Jock, Mr JR, Mr Bobby.” Reminiscent of what a house slave would call their slave owner. And even the original Southfork looked very much like a plantation house. I do wonder if that had anything to do with them choosing another Southfork. I didn’t think of it as a kid, but as an adult, that early Ewing BBQ looked as if it was straight out of the 1800’s.

They weren't servants. They were self-employed caterers. Bobby asks Tilly to "drop the mister." Tilly replies that if she drops the mister, she'll have to charge twenty per cent less. So she doesn't use the term out of subservience, but as a business move that exploits pre-existing notions of subservience. That first barbecue was the one time "below stairs" staff at Southfork were shown to have independent personalities and their own points of view (at least on Old DALLAS).
 
Last edited:

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I want to touch base on what was talked about briefly. In the mini-series Dallas, they had the black servants. That had to had raised a few eyebrows even in 1978. From the way they referred to the Ewings calling them “Mr Jock, Mr JR, Mr Bobby.” Reminiscent of what a house slave would call their slave owner. And even the original Southfork looked very much like a plantation house. I do wonder if that had anything to do with them choosing another Southfork. I didn’t think of it as a kid, but as an adult, that early Ewing BBQ looked as if it was straight out of the 1800’s.

Someone brought up that they soon changed the help to Latinos. Being in Texas, it does make more sense. None of that would fly today.
that did seem like something straight out of Gone With the Wind, and was jarring when I first saw the episode 25 years after it first ran.

At least Sam and Tilly seemed like they were running a catering business (although I guess it’s possible they weren’t the owners) and Bobby was clearly uncomfortable with the “Mister” business.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
From the way they referred to the Ewings calling them “Mr Jock, Mr JR, Mr Bobby.” Reminiscent of what a house slave would call their slave owner.

Reminiscent? Geez, and I thought I was old! :)

Someone brought up that they soon changed the help to Latinos. Being in Texas, it does make more sense. None of that would fly today.

It wouldn't? Every maid we've ever employed has been Hispanic. Nothing against hiring Caucasian or black maids but for whatever reason, it's become a predominantly Hispanic business. Every couple we're friends with who have maids have Hispanic maids. It has nothing to do with Texas either because we live in Maryland. For whatever reason, maids are almost exclusively Hispanic these days. Don't tell them it doesn't fly today. It's how they make their living and they're paid well. A maid in my part of the country can earn $200 a day. That's $50,000 a year. What's wrong with earning 50 grand a year when you're a high school dropout who barely even speaks English?

The Hispanic population of The USA is growing much faster than the black population. That may have something to do with it. Because of that fast growth, they will be, or maybe already are, a larger percentage of our country's population than blacks. We also have to remember that while they're both minorities, for the most part, English is the native language of the overwhelming majority of blacks who are American citizens. That doesn't hold true necessarily with Hispanics. Most of the maids we've hired or that our friends have hired speak English poorly. They're first generation immigrants. In many cases they have very little high school education and come from extremely poor countries. To them, what we pay them to clean is big money. What they get paid for a morning's work is very likely more money than they'd earn in a week in the country they're from. So don't tell them the job doesn't fly because they're very grateful to have it.

The lady we have now is a young woman who told us she sends some of the money she makes back home to help support her parents. Family is a very strong aspect of Latino culture- much stronger and more tightly knit than in the majority of white, American families. Americans in general could learn something from Latino culture about the importance of staying closely in touch with our relatives and ensuring that we visit our family members as often as we reasonably can.

By the same token, almost every single time I see an elderly person accompanied by their personal nurse, the nurse is a black woman. I don't know why there isn't more of a variety of ethnic groups of women being personal nurses for elderly people in wheelchairs but that's just the way it is. At least here in the D.C. area it is. Does that hold true for where you live too? Do you also see elderly people in wheelchairs with black nurses?
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Bobby was clearly uncomfortable with the “Mister” business.

I don't know why he would be. It's basic manners. It shows respect. What was the fist name of Dr Danvers, the doctor who made house calls when one of the Ewings wasn't feeling good? I'm not sure we eve heard his first name and they said Doctor too. They didn't just say "Hey Danvers, My son is sick" did they? Who would do that? That's just rude.

For those that have bosses, are you in a first name basis with them or do you say Mr., Ms, Sir, or Ma'am?

There's a very interesting line in "No Country For Old Men" in a part of the movie where a sheriff is wondering why our society is crumbling, why we're having all these mass shootings and such. The sheriff says "I think things started going downhill when you stopped hearing "Sir" or "Ma'am."
 
Last edited:

Miss Texas 1967

Telly Talk Addict
I'm nowhere near as analytical as everyone else in this thread, but to offer a general opinion it's sort of difficult to judge older media on modern standards. I think the answer to the question of if the exact same show would cause controversy today is yes if it was set in 2019 but maybe less so if it retained it's original time setting. People would be more vocal about the attitudes and actions of the characters both ways because some of the stuff that happens would just never fly in polite company in modern society, but if it's a historical piece (like Mad Men) then I think they'd be less likely to get angry about it being 2019 and certain things still being portrayed as normal.

Take the pilot for example, JR's first scene opens with his hand on Julie's thigh, now we know JR and Julie had a thing but that's very much a behaviour rooted in it's time and place. Or Jock telling Bobby and Pam that Ewing women don't work, that's his character and it fits the time and place context but you'd have a harder time passing the same scene in 2019 without more push back from the characters I think (though here Pam did push back and Bobby kind of just let her do what she wanted even if he didn't completely agree with it). Another example would be Lucy's multiple engagements right out of high school, I don't think you'd have nearly as many shows with a casual character plot like that now.

Most of those are more about women's roles rather than anything else, my point is mostly just that society is different now than it was then and they'd have thought you extreme bringing 2019 standards down on them then and so to do the same now isn't an equal fight. Changes happen, some things aren't acceptable anymore and they shouldn't be but it hasn't always been that way.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I'm nowhere near as analytical as everyone else in this thread

I don't know about that, I think you did an excellent analysis of the hypothetical situation this thread is based upon. Your comparison of it to Mad Men made a lot of sense since that's the closest thing we've had on TV to what this would be. Instead of the advertising business in the 60s, it's the Texas oil business of the late 70s and 80s. I only saw a few episodes of Mad men, but enough to see that there was a markedly different social style back then with things like drinking and smoking in the office, and openly hitting on the female secretaries...........and that's only what comes to mind from someone who saw very little of it. I have the whole first season on DVD so maybe I should give it another chance.

That Mad Men was as successful and as well accepted as it was is probably the best indicator of how Dallas with its late 70s and 80s attitudes would be accepted by a modern day audience. people are bright enough to realize that people are products of their time. You can't expect someone who grew up and lived their life in a bygone era to fit in with the standards of present day society.

I think that in general, people look like they were having a better time in the Mad Men era or in the Dallas era than they are now. To me, the way people lived then was much more natural and todays society is in some ways very artificial in how restrictive and uptight it is. It seems tome that society progressed steadily though the 1960s, to the 70s, the 80s, and 90s and in each decade, things that people would have found shocking or offensive before were now accepted. case in point: In the 1950s Elvis Presley was controversial because when he went on the Ed Sullivan show and sang a song, the way he moved his hips was considered to be very sexually suggestive and inappropriate. In the 1960s, that controversy was probably already considered laughable So he moved his hips a certain way when he performed - so what?

In each decade, the standards for what was considered normal and acceptable were more open minded. More different ways of expression were allowed. In the 80s Madonna did things as part of her concerts that would have horrified people of the 50s or 60s. But it was OK in the 80s. It's in the nature of things for us to progress! Yet now, we're more uptight and restrictive than we've been in so long that it seems like a return to a 1950s mentality. It goes against the natural order of things and I just don't get it. I really don't.
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
JR's first scene opens with his hand on Julie's thigh, now we know JR and Julie had a thing but that's very much a behaviour rooted in it's time and place. Or Jock telling Bobby and Pam that Ewing women don't work, that's his character and it fits the time and place context but you'd have a harder time passing the same scene in 2019 without more push back from the characters
I think that's the real issue here. People have no problem watching characters behaving inappropriately, it's how the other characters react to it, they are the ones who send the message.
And since that old-fashioned chauvinism/sexism/racism was a way of living, rather than actions that would serve a plotline (freedom of art) it would be considered unrealistic in our modern times.
I'm not sure if they would organize a protest march in order to get the show banned, but it's possible that the audience itself is having none of it.
 
Top