Yes, of course. Something being hugely commercially successful doesn't necessarily mean it's "good" either. I've seen plenty of blockbuster movies and hit TV shows that I thought sucked.
To me it all depends on the person and what their judgements are like. I watch plenty of TV and film reviews on YouTube, made by various John and Jane Doe's from across the world. Not to mention people I know and who's opinions I trust. Someone being "skilled media" person, whatever that actually means, doesn't necessarily mean I'll agree with their judgment. I like horror movies, so I'd rather take the advice of someone running a horror movie channel on YouTube, because at least I know their taste will be similar to mine. A friend on Facebook got me to start watching a show called You're The Worst, which he recommended to me because he saw me post about It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia and told me it had a similar sense of humor. I initially ignored Empire, because I thought it was just going to be another "hood" show, even though it initially got a bunch of good reviews, but then my brother, the one who got me into Dallas when we were kids, told me he loved it. Based on that, I started watching it. Some fancy reviewer for the New York Times isn't going to sway me just because he or she has a BA in Film Studies.
I tend to agree with the John and Jane Does more often. Plus, specifically talking about award shows like Emmys and Oscars, there's often tons of behind the scenes politics involved in who get nominated and who wins.