"Dallas was Succession before Succession"

Emelee

Telly Talk Warrior
Again, I'm a fellow fan of SUCCESSION, but I just have to disagree on principle with the general idea that "winning big awards = excellent quality". Nah, not necessarily. I mean, obviously "quality" is a subjective term, but winning a bunch of awards just means award show voters and producers like it. Plenty of failed shows over the years have won Emmys.

But also, viewers' likes are subjective. I'd rather hear what skilled media folks thinks of the quality than John & Jane Doe from Arkansas. I tend to agree with the skilled media folks to a large extent. Award winning books, series, films & plays tend to be really good.
 

James from London

International Treasure
Hmm, I think I agree with this ...

I just have to disagree on principle with the general idea that "winning big awards = excellent quality". Nah, not necessarily.

... but I also kind of agree with this:

I'd rather hear what skilled media folks thinks of the quality than John & Jane Doe from Arkansas

Anyway, this is from another Guardian article, about "the arts and pop culture that sum up the Trump era":

An all-powerful, narcissistic father who thinks little of lying and will stop at nothing to get what he wants. A daughter who is next in line for the top job at his multinational corporation and her goofy husband who has been given more responsibility than he can handle. His two sons who compete for his affection but can’t manage a competent act between them. No, I’m not talking about the Trump family, I’m talking about the Roys, the central clan on Succession.

The show, created by British writer Jesse Armstrong, is largely thought to be modelled on the Murdochs but this could really be any rich and powerful family. During the Trump era, many people have realised how insidious money and privilege is to American life, how you can get away with anything if you’re rich, how corrupt systems perpetuate themselves and care about little else.

Yes, Succession could be about the Trumps. But more importantly, it is about what makes the Trumps. Shockingly, the craven manipulation of the Roys is often played for laughs. When talking about an administration that is as corrupt as this one, or a family as awful as the Roys, you can’t make it through without a little comedy.


 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Nobody does. If it was that easy to figure out exactly why certain shows click with an audience then TV and movie studioes would have nothing but hits. But they try it all the time, one show because a breakout, and then there's a bunch of copycats by other networks trying to cash in, and most of them bomb.

Well said.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
But also, viewers' likes are subjective.

Yes, of course. Something being hugely commercially successful doesn't necessarily mean it's "good" either. I've seen plenty of blockbuster movies and hit TV shows that I thought sucked.

I'd rather hear what skilled media folks thinks of the quality than John & Jane Doe from Arkansas.

To me it all depends on the person and what their judgements are like. I watch plenty of TV and film reviews on YouTube, made by various John and Jane Doe's from across the world. Not to mention people I know and who's opinions I trust. Someone being "skilled media" person, whatever that actually means, doesn't necessarily mean I'll agree with their judgment. I like horror movies, so I'd rather take the advice of someone running a horror movie channel on YouTube, because at least I know their taste will be similar to mine. A friend on Facebook got me to start watching a show called You're The Worst, which he recommended to me because he saw me post about It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia and told me it had a similar sense of humor. I initially ignored Empire, because I thought it was just going to be another "hood" show, even though it initially got a bunch of good reviews, but then my brother, the one who got me into Dallas when we were kids, told me he loved it. Based on that, I started watching it. Some fancy reviewer for the New York Times isn't going to sway me just because he or she has a BA in Film Studies.

I tend to agree with the skilled media folks to a large extent. Award winning books, series, films & plays tend to be really good.

I tend to agree with the John and Jane Does more often. Plus, specifically talking about award shows like Emmys and Oscars, there's often tons of behind the scenes politics involved in who get nominated and who wins.
 

Emelee

Telly Talk Warrior
Yes, of course. Something being hugely commercially successful doesn't necessarily mean it's "good" either. I've seen plenty of blockbuster movies and hit TV shows that I thought sucked.



To me it all depends on the person and what their judgements are like. I watch plenty of TV and film reviews on YouTube, made by various John and Jane Doe's from across the world. Not to mention people I know and who's opinions I trust. Someone being "skilled media" person, whatever that actually means, doesn't necessarily mean I'll agree with their judgment. I like horror movies, so I'd rather take the advice of someone running a horror movie channel on YouTube, because at least I know their taste will be similar to mine. A friend on Facebook got me to start watching a show called You're The Worst, which he recommended to me because he saw me post about It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia and told me it had a similar sense of humor. I initially ignored Empire, because I thought it was just going to be another "hood" show, even though it initially got a bunch of good reviews, but then my brother, the one who got me into Dallas when we were kids, told me he loved it. Based on that, I started watching it. Some fancy reviewer for the New York Times isn't going to sway me just because he or she has a BA in Film Studies.



I tend to agree with the John and Jane Does more often. Plus, specifically talking about award shows like Emmys and Oscars, there's often tons of behind the scenes politics involved in who get nominated and who wins.

I prefer the reviews by those who work professionally with reviews. They can easier express themselves with correct terms and see if things follow a logical order, have a point or underlying symbolism etc etc. I especially like the reviews by those who have an education in literature criticism, film analysis or anything similar to that.

Maybe it's because I'm a teacher and I often see pupils' novel & film analyses which only scratches the surface?
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
I prefer the reviews by those who work professionally with reviews. They can easier express themselves with correct terms and see if things follow a logical order, have a point or underlying symbolism etc etc. I especially like the reviews by those who have an education in literature criticism, film analysis or anything similar to that.

See, I'm just looking to hear what's good or not, not deep analysis. Like, I don't expect most professional film critics to like any of the Fast and Furious films, they're not high cinema and don't pretend to be. If you're watching them and picking out plot holes or bad scene transitions or whatever, you're not the audience for that film anyway. I want to hear from someone who, like me, likes those types of films and can tell me if the newest one lives up to the hype.

Maybe it's because I'm a teacher and I often see pupils' novel & film analyses which only scratches the surface?

I guess in this analogy I'm one of those students. And I'd rather talk to my fellow students about the shows and films they like, because they're more likely to have similar tastes to mine than the teacher is.
 
Top