Didn’t Patrick owe it to the fans to insist on no dream

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
I dont get why they didn't tie in Bobby's return with Anjelica Nero?

It could've been plausible that Nero and her cronies had held Bobby captive for that entire year. His flatlining in the hospital could've been explained away as being faked.

Angelica Nero was so ott that this angle could've worked. It would've probably still turned viewers away due to its unrealistic tone but anything would've been better than the dream explanation.

Her involvement was bad enough, don't make it even worse!

Swami
 
'Swan Song' isn't the work of people who don't care, who have no integrity, who've given up. It's the work of people who are doing their best to turn the situation they've been presented with - Duffy's departure - into 65 minutes of brilliant telly. They couldn't have predicted what would happen next.

Agreed, Bobby's death gave some of Dallas's most powerful moments. Patrick's decision to leave - which at the time was understood by everyone to be forever - presented an opportunity to reward the viewer with complete closure to a character's journey. It would be a shame to think producers of a TV series would balk at telling such a story on the slim chance the actor doesn't really mean it when they say they want to leave.

Don Murray made a similar request for his character when he wanted to leave Knots Landing. He, like Duffy, apparently later regretted leaving the series but thankfully sanity - and integrity - prevailed. That didn't stop us getting Cathy and Kate*, but even those are examples of how to do it without completely insulting the audience.



* Oh - I've just realised they have the same name.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
Her involvement was bad enough, don't make it even worse!

Swami

I always thought having some sort of medical miracle involving Dr. Jerry and Grayson research would have been interesting. Think of all the Pam/Mark/Bobby drama. And we could have kept Jerry around as a romantic threat to JR to keep him on his toes.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
All the chat about Patrick reappearing as a twin brother for instance, how could that plausible? Sure Miss Ellie would have known if there had been any more baby Ewings.

Plus dreams happened all the time in Shakespeare's work, so all told it was the least worst option to get Patrick back.

Swami
 

Grangehill1

Telly Talk Fan
I find it incredibly unfair to say they didn’t care about the audience. I’ve met both actors on several occasions and both care a lot about their fans.

There was much more to it than just Patrick not carving out a movie career. Larry wanted him back as did the fans. Ratings suffered without Bobby.

Far far more ludricrous plots exist in Soapland - The Colbys flying spacecraft is probably one of if not the worst.

It was a production decision and although Larry has clout, it was a decision made with other executives.

There are parts of the outcome of the dream that I don’t like and would change but honestly I don’t see half the fuss about it. Especially since we got to keep Bobby.

They DID care about the fans. They did NOT care about the audience. There’s a big difference. The fans carried on watching. The audience declined year after year.

Fans wanted him back? Really? The character was dead and the immediate aftermath was brilliantly done. I remember people missing him but not wanting him to come back because that would just be plain stupid wouldn’t it?...

And re the Colbys. Actually yes it was done better and when Fallon crosses over into Dynasty they tried to at least make some sort of reference with her strange behaviour
 

Grangehill1

Telly Talk Fan
I don't think that's the actor's responsibility. Their job is to deliver the script they're presented with that day as believably as possible. They don't necessarily have the same overarching perspective as fans do.



That's one interpretation. Another is that he was invited back and he said OK. We don't know the exact order of events after that. Say he signs his contract before they tell him it's all a dream - what's he meant to do? Refuse to turn up for work until they change the story? He's gonna put himself in breach of contract for that? Most likely he trusted Katzman - the man who'd turned Dallas into an unprecedented phenomenon in the first place - to do his job.



Hmm, I just don't buy that.



That's a big if. Did he insist or was it a request - a request that made logical sense? After all, if they all really believed he was going for good then killing him off was surely the best creative decision at the time.



I didn't like that storyline and by the end of the season, I'd come to kind of hate Donna, who I'd always really liked before.



I was really pleased.



I much preferred that storyline. It felt very poignant and true to those characters.



All true, and as a result she was kind of boring.



I disagree. 'Swan Song' isn't the work of people who don't care, who have no integrity, who've given up. It's the work of people who are doing their best to turn the situation they've been presented with - Duffy's departure - into 65 minutes of brilliant telly. They couldn't have predicted what would happen next.

Patrick DID have a say in his character. He wanted Bobby back tougher and stronger with more interesting storylines. He also wanted the character killed in the first place so to set those wheels in motion and then want to come whether invited or not, he came back with a healthy payrise as well.
To be built up as the saviour of the show because it struggled hugely without him. That’s what creates the ego.

Larry wanted him back.

So that’s what I mean when they didn’t care about the audience. They just wanted to be back together having a laugh and getting well paid. The female roles were all reduced and never recovered but they were having a laugh and that’s the only thing that mattered
 

James from London

International Treasure
Patrick DID have a say in his character. He wanted Bobby back tougher and stronger with more interesting storylines. He also wanted the character killed in the first place so to set those wheels in motion and then want to come whether invited or not, he came back with a healthy payrise as well.
To be built up as the saviour of the show because it struggled hugely without him. That’s what creates the ego.

Larry wanted him back.

So that’s what I mean when they didn’t care about the audience. They just wanted to be back together having a laugh and getting well paid. The female roles were all reduced and never recovered but they were having a laugh and that’s the only thing that mattered

Well, you're a lot more certain than me! I don't feel as though I know all the facts, just a quote here and a quote there, which I don't feel tell the whole nuanced story. I don't know any of the men involved or enough about the ins and outs of contracts or the way American television functioned in the '80s to draw any firm conclusions, but I suspect the truth is more complicated and more mundane than we know. It usually is.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Patrick has said publicly that he had a say in how Bobby was revived, but it's hard to believe he really did, especially if he'd wanted it done differently than how Katzman wanted it done.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
They DID care about the fans. They did NOT care about the audience. There’s a big difference. The fans carried on watching. The audience declined year after year.

Patrick DID have a say in his character. He wanted Bobby back tougher and stronger with more interesting storylines.

According to the interview he did with Ultimate Dallas, Patrick did not want Bobby back tougher and stronger and wasn't even consulted about it. It was Katzman's idea to do that with Bobby.

Of course they care about the audience because the bigger the audience the more money they make. When the audience goes away, the show gets cancelled and the high paying job goes away.

Here's the part of the interview relevant to those ideas:


UD - Bobby was far more macho post dream.

Patrick - Yep, that's what happened and became a Leonard Katzman decision. It wasn't ever discussed with me. It was never part of any arrangement for me coming back. Leonard is extenuating those parts of the character it was very nice for me. I don't know if I enjoyed the second part of Dallas more than the first, but it was different, so it was refreshing.

(later in the interview)

UD - It was that season. The season you returned.

Patrick - Yes, it was just the way things worked out. The Bobby character ascended a bit. Its show business, a lot of that is not decided on personal whim but what those people in charge decide will add another year longevity, another ratings point. If it hadn't worked in year nine I would have been back to wimpy Bobby. They call it show business for a reason, ultimately its the business.
 

James from London

International Treasure
Patrick Duffy said:
Its show business, a lot of that is not decided on personal whim but what those people in charge decide will add another year longevity, another ratings point. If it hadn't worked in year nine I would have been back to wimpy Bobby. They call it show business for a reason, ultimately its the business.

This rings true to me. I've said this before, but we have no idea what part the network played in the decision-making process on Dallas, only that they were involved. (David Jacobs has said that because Knots wasn't as big as Dallas, it flew under the radar and the network left it pretty much alone, unlike its sister show.)

The idea that Hagman, Duffy and Katzman were allowed to just have fun and do whatever they felt like on a huge money-making show like Dallas - forgive me, but I think that's a little naive. (And I also find it hard to believe that all of Hagman, Duffy and Katzman's creative integrity just suddenly evaporated, that they suddenly decided that they no longer cared about the programme they were making.)
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
(And I also find it hard to believe that all of Hagman, Duffy and Katzman's creative integrity just suddenly evaporated, that they just suddenly decided that they no longer cared about the programme they were making.)

Are there people who think they stopped Hagman and and Duffy and Katzman stopped caring? I hadn't read that or don't remember it. Hagman and Duffy weren't in the creative department - they were talent. They kept trying as far as I could see but you can't make chicken salad out of chicken s**t.

The scripts in the last few years sucked. That's on the writers and Katzman. I think Katzman was creatively burned out. Try to do everything yourself and eventually it happens. It was better when he and Capice worked together.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
Are there people who think they stopped Hagman and and Duffy and Katzman stopped caring? I hadn't read that or don't remember it. Hagman and Duffy weren't in the creative department - they were talent. They kept trying as far as I could see but you can't make chicken salad out of chicken s**t.

The scripts in the last few years sucked. That's on the writers and Katzman. I think Katzman was creatively burned out. Try to do everything yourself and eventually it happens. It was better when he and Capice worked together.
:gp::bravo1:
 

Gold Canyon 340

Telly Talk Member
How else were they going to bring him back? Bringing him back as another character, in my view, would have been far less plausible.

Swami
I have always said they should have brought him back as a ghost.... could have been interesting.... the movie Ghost with Patrick Swayze and Demi Moore was a HUGE hit just a few years later.... Bobby and Pam could have had some intense scenes at the pottery wheel.
 

southfork88

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
I would say ... a ghost who interacts with all the characters, but who is actually Bobby's soul in coma. Then he wakes up among the Amish, gets cloned and travels through time using Jock's portrait as a portal.

Does this remind you anything?
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
I have always said they should have brought him back as a ghost.... could have been interesting.... the movie Ghost with Patrick Swayze and Demi Moore was a HUGE hit just a few years later.... Bobby and Pam could have had some intense scenes at the pottery wheel.

Now that is getting far-fetched, that makes the dream look almost unremarkable.

Swami
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
Where do you draw the line? Was the dream really that bad compared to the Colbys and Fallon being abducted by aliens?

Swami

Oh interesting, I've read about that silliness on here, but never actually saw it and forgot which show it happened on. I just threw that out there to be silly, but I might have been more in the ballpark than intended!
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Season 3 of Falcon Crest?

So they really did that? I was just writing about that yesterday! If you're running a show and you try to justify a storyline you allowed because another show did something worse, where are your standards? What a defeatist attitude, to think: "Well, at least we're not as bad as them."
 
Top