the-lost-son
Telly Talk Well-Known Member
During some of our latest threads about Dallas and the oil industry
or the importance of the Ewing B-B-Qs in the oil business
I realized that all my complete knowledge or imagination of the oil industry is based on a TV show of the 80s - Dallas. Obviously many aspects of the business need to be simplified in TV to address a substantial audience, but as we are lucky enough to have a expert members like „lastkidpicked“ working in the oil industry, other members living in Texas or members with expert knowledge in this forum, I‘d be more than happy to see if some aspects of the oil industry presented in Dallas are close to reality or complete fiction. So please add any questions - I‘m sure we‘ll get our answers.
So here are my 6 burning questions - fact or fake?
1. the cartell
Any Bradley, Jordan Lee and Marilee Stonehurst formed “the cartell“ in Dallas for over a decade. According to Wikipedia: „A cartel is a group of independent market participants who collude with each other in order to improve their profits and dominate the market.“ And „Today, price fixing by private entities is illegal under the antitrust laws of more than 140 countries.“ (including the US). As price-rigging is illegal, is a Cartell like in Dallas realistic? Its members never acted single-handedly if you remember Marilee keeping her involvement with Cliff secret from the other Cartell members.
2. oil field auctions
Edgar Randolph was appointed by the government to sell oil fields by auction. JR blackmailed Edgar for the bids given at the auction by his competitors. In a city full of oil men, wouldn‘t it be easier for possible biders to talk with each other (e.g. at a B-B-Q) and see if a mutual agreement can be arranged in order to keep the price down and divide the fields among themeselves? Classic market/price-rigging.
I consider it naive to hold the auction in Dallas where everybody knows everyone. Do/did auctions like these happen like that?
3. off-shore drilling / gold canyon 340
In the same storyline it was repeated multiple times per episode how unbelievable expensive offshore drilling was. Obviously this emphasized the danger Cliff was putting himself into. I imagine it must be more expansive than drilling on soil, but the expression I got was that off-shore drilling is exceptionally more expensive. Is it really that risky/expensive compared to classic oil drilling?
4. OPEC
In Dallas season 9 (DVD10) JR made some harsh remarks about the OPEC, meeting with an army general and colluding with B.D. Calhoun who blew up some oil fields (somewhere I forgot). As far as I know the US are the world‘s biggest producer of oil and also its biggest consumer. They don‘t export much oil because it‘s needed in their own country. Therefore (?) the US are (and never have been) a member of the OPEC. Ewing Oil realistically never exported any oil and the US probably protected its own industry by regulating (customs) Arabian oil. So did/does the worldwide oil price really affect the American oil industry?
5. oil refinery
Refineries always played a big role in the series. Bobby bought a refinery for Ewing Oil, making Jock proud. I got the impression only refined oil can be sold to customers. So shouldn‘t an oil company always run a refinery as well to be independent? Is/was it that special for a company like Ewing Oil to own a refinery? It seems like this should be standard.
6. fun question - striking oil
In Dallas TNT during the pilot episode, JohnRoss and Elena strike oil.
(0:44). I‘ve seen something similiar like that in very old movies. People are drilling for oil and of course they strike oil, huge fountain, everyone dancing and celebrating under the gentle rainfall of oil. In former times when people had to drill by hand or very primitive tools to find oil under these strenuous circumstances must have been pure joy. But with modern equipment and all the geological reports available, I guess these kind of joy seems exaggerated.
Sorry for the long post.
Thanks in advance for any reply.
Biggest independent oil company of Texas
JR often quotes his Daddy‘s dreams that Ewing Oil one day should become the bigges „independent„ oil company in Texas. I never thought about it - but I don‘t get the term „independent“. Why not just the biggest oil company in Texas? Is it a reference to the „seven sisters“ in the American oil...
tellytalk.net
Ewing B-B-Qs realistic?
My favorite Ewing B-B-Q is in season 6 (WB7). Sue Ellen&Peter, Clayton engaged to Miss Ellie (just loved it when JR and Bobby looked at each other). It was marvelous to watch JR inviting the Barnes clan (Pam, Mark, Afton, Cliff) to Southfork. I wonder is it realistic to invite (apparently)...
tellytalk.net
So here are my 6 burning questions - fact or fake?
1. the cartell
Any Bradley, Jordan Lee and Marilee Stonehurst formed “the cartell“ in Dallas for over a decade. According to Wikipedia: „A cartel is a group of independent market participants who collude with each other in order to improve their profits and dominate the market.“ And „Today, price fixing by private entities is illegal under the antitrust laws of more than 140 countries.“ (including the US). As price-rigging is illegal, is a Cartell like in Dallas realistic? Its members never acted single-handedly if you remember Marilee keeping her involvement with Cliff secret from the other Cartell members.
2. oil field auctions
Edgar Randolph was appointed by the government to sell oil fields by auction. JR blackmailed Edgar for the bids given at the auction by his competitors. In a city full of oil men, wouldn‘t it be easier for possible biders to talk with each other (e.g. at a B-B-Q) and see if a mutual agreement can be arranged in order to keep the price down and divide the fields among themeselves? Classic market/price-rigging.
I consider it naive to hold the auction in Dallas where everybody knows everyone. Do/did auctions like these happen like that?
3. off-shore drilling / gold canyon 340
In the same storyline it was repeated multiple times per episode how unbelievable expensive offshore drilling was. Obviously this emphasized the danger Cliff was putting himself into. I imagine it must be more expansive than drilling on soil, but the expression I got was that off-shore drilling is exceptionally more expensive. Is it really that risky/expensive compared to classic oil drilling?
4. OPEC
In Dallas season 9 (DVD10) JR made some harsh remarks about the OPEC, meeting with an army general and colluding with B.D. Calhoun who blew up some oil fields (somewhere I forgot). As far as I know the US are the world‘s biggest producer of oil and also its biggest consumer. They don‘t export much oil because it‘s needed in their own country. Therefore (?) the US are (and never have been) a member of the OPEC. Ewing Oil realistically never exported any oil and the US probably protected its own industry by regulating (customs) Arabian oil. So did/does the worldwide oil price really affect the American oil industry?
5. oil refinery
Refineries always played a big role in the series. Bobby bought a refinery for Ewing Oil, making Jock proud. I got the impression only refined oil can be sold to customers. So shouldn‘t an oil company always run a refinery as well to be independent? Is/was it that special for a company like Ewing Oil to own a refinery? It seems like this should be standard.
6. fun question - striking oil
In Dallas TNT during the pilot episode, JohnRoss and Elena strike oil.
Sorry for the long post.
Thanks in advance for any reply.
Last edited:





