Fact check - the oil industry of Dallas

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
During some of our latest threads about Dallas and the oil industry
or the importance of the Ewing B-B-Qs in the oil business
I realized that all my complete knowledge or imagination of the oil industry is based on a TV show of the 80s - Dallas. Obviously many aspects of the business need to be simplified in TV to address a substantial audience, but as we are lucky enough to have a expert members like „lastkidpicked“ working in the oil industry, other members living in Texas or members with expert knowledge in this forum, I‘d be more than happy to see if some aspects of the oil industry presented in Dallas are close to reality or complete fiction. So please add any questions - I‘m sure we‘ll get our answers.

So here are my 6 burning questions - fact or fake?
1. the cartell
Any Bradley, Jordan Lee and Marilee Stonehurst formed “the cartell“ in Dallas for over a decade. According to Wikipedia: „A cartel is a group of independent market participants who collude with each other in order to improve their profits and dominate the market.“ And „Today, price fixing by private entities is illegal under the antitrust laws of more than 140 countries.“ (including the US). As price-rigging is illegal, is a Cartell like in Dallas realistic? Its members never acted single-handedly if you remember Marilee keeping her involvement with Cliff secret from the other Cartell members.

2. oil field auctions
Edgar Randolph was appointed by the government to sell oil fields by auction. JR blackmailed Edgar for the bids given at the auction by his competitors. In a city full of oil men, wouldn‘t it be easier for possible biders to talk with each other (e.g. at a B-B-Q) and see if a mutual agreement can be arranged in order to keep the price down and divide the fields among themeselves? Classic market/price-rigging.
I consider it naive to hold the auction in Dallas where everybody knows everyone. Do/did auctions like these happen like that?

3. off-shore drilling / gold canyon 340
In the same storyline it was repeated multiple times per episode how unbelievable expensive offshore drilling was. Obviously this emphasized the danger Cliff was putting himself into. I imagine it must be more expansive than drilling on soil, but the expression I got was that off-shore drilling is exceptionally more expensive. Is it really that risky/expensive compared to classic oil drilling?

4. OPEC
In Dallas season 9 (DVD10) JR made some harsh remarks about the OPEC, meeting with an army general and colluding with B.D. Calhoun who blew up some oil fields (somewhere I forgot). As far as I know the US are the world‘s biggest producer of oil and also its biggest consumer. They don‘t export much oil because it‘s needed in their own country. Therefore (?) the US are (and never have been) a member of the OPEC. Ewing Oil realistically never exported any oil and the US probably protected its own industry by regulating (customs) Arabian oil. So did/does the worldwide oil price really affect the American oil industry?

5. oil refinery
Refineries always played a big role in the series. Bobby bought a refinery for Ewing Oil, making Jock proud. I got the impression only refined oil can be sold to customers. So shouldn‘t an oil company always run a refinery as well to be independent? Is/was it that special for a company like Ewing Oil to own a refinery? It seems like this should be standard.

6. fun question - striking oil
In Dallas TNT during the pilot episode, JohnRoss and Elena strike oil.
(0:44). I‘ve seen something similiar like that in very old movies. People are drilling for oil and of course they strike oil, huge fountain, everyone dancing and celebrating under the gentle rainfall of oil. In former times when people had to drill by hand or very primitive tools to find oil under these strenuous circumstances must have been pure joy. But with modern equipment and all the geological reports available, I guess these kind of joy seems exaggerated.

Sorry for the long post.
Thanks in advance for any reply.
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I'm looking forward to this thread!
We are lucky enough to have a expert members like "Lastkidpicked“ working in the oil industry, other members living in Texas or members with expert knowledge in this forum,
I'm no expert, just a guy working in the oil business and have enough curiosity that I'm always learning new things.
Going to 99 cent Margarita night after work and I'll log in from there. It will be fun to read what others have said and add to it where I can.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
1. the cartell
Andy Bradley, Jordan Lee and Marilee Stonehurst formed “the cartell“ in Dallas for over a decade. According to Wikipedia: „A cartel is a group of independent market participants who collude with each other in order to improve their profits and dominate the market.“ And „Today, price fixing by private entities is illegal under the antitrust laws of more than 140 countries.“ (including the US). As price-rigging is illegal, is a Cartell like in Dallas realistic? Its members never acted single-handedly if you remember Marilee keeping her involvement with Cliff secret from the other Cartell members.
I can tell you there are still cartels here in Texas, but it is much looser than you might think. Here's an example of what I see every day:

@Billy Wall , @Taylor Bennett Jr. , and @DallasFanForever each own companies that specialize in oil field valving and flow control. We all see each other at safety meetings and other events. Even though we are competition for each other, we work together quite often. Much like the cartel in Dallas.
While I think the word "collude" might be a bit harsh, let's call it a "Gentleman's Agreement" that we abide by. For example, Westar Oil (I can't use any real names here) asks @Billy Wall for a bid to run a smart pig through the line at WS4. They also ask me for a bid for the same thing. They love playing us against each other to drive the price down.

I know that Billy will charge about $ 10/foot and adjust accordingly by the job. So I won't go running in there at $6/foot. Doing so would only bleed me dry while also leaving Billy out in the cold. So we don't try to drive up the price, but as a "cartel" we also don't cut each other's throats.

After a while the Seven Sisters (Supermajors) understand that we are all about the same price, so they make their decision based on who performs the best and who can get to it first.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
2. oil field auctions
Edgar Randolph was appointed by the government to sell oil fields by auction. JR blackmailed Edgar for the bids given at the auction by his competitors. In a city full of oil men, wouldn‘t it be easier for possible biders to talk with each other (e.g. at a B-B-Q) and see if a mutual agreement can be arranged in order to keep the price down and divide the fields among themeselves? Classic market/price-rigging.
I consider it naive to hold the auction in Dallas where everybody knows everyone. Do/did auctions like these happen like that?

An auction is the most pure form of capitalism that you will ever see. It is supply and demand pure and simple.
There's no price rigging that I have ever seen, because there are just too many of us bidding. We can barely agree on where to go to lunch, let alone try and rig an auction!
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
It’s funny, I was typing to give my opinion of how I perceived the “cartel” to work on Dallas, and why I didn’t think it fit the type of operation that’s now banned by law as described on Wiki, and before I could finish, @Lastkidpicked posted his comment basically confirming what I was thinking. It was never presented as any type of illegal price-fixing type of thing, it was just simply a matter of, on some deals none of us are big enough individually to compete with the majors like Westar and the Seven Sisters, so we'll partner up to share the expenses and the profits.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
3. off-shore drilling / gold canyon 340
In the same storyline it was repeated multiple times per episode how unbelievable expensive offshore drilling was. Obviously this emphasized the danger Cliff was putting himself into. I imagine it must be more expensive than drilling on soil, but the expression I got was that off-shore drilling is exceptionally more expensive. Is it really that risky/expensive compared to classic oil drilling?

Higher risk-- higher reward.
Why?
Because if you are on shore, there may be multiple rigs from different producers surrounding you.

Imagine a big cup of soda with multiple straws and different people with each straw.

Off shore, you have that whole oil play to yourself. . .

If you hit!

Want my opinion?

Don't invest in offshore drilling. Instead, take that money to Vegas. The odds are better. Bet it all on black.

If you win, you double your money.

If you lose, you get a free buffet dinner.

Still less risky than off shore drilling.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
It’s funny, I was typing to give my opinion of how I perceived the “cartel” to work on Dallas, and why I didn’t think it fit the type of operation that’s now banned by law as described on Wiki, and before I could finish, @Lastkidpicked posted his comment basically confirming what I was thinking. It was never presented as any type of illegal price-fixing type of thing, it was just simply a matter of, on some deals none of us are big enough individually to compete with the majors like Westar and the Seven Sisters, so we'll partner up to share the expenses and the profits.

Jabari, you stated it much better than I did.
Thank you.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
I wonder about #6 too. Yeah, it's a traditional oil-well scene that looks good on screen, going back to the days of James Dean in Giant and other films of the era. Back in the wildcatting days of Jack and Digger where they were literally just drilling wherever Digger thought he "smelled" oil actually striking it would be a huge celebration. But nowadays when they can detect oil and know in advance that it's there, nobody's shocked when it comes pumping out, are they?* Instead of dancing around and shouting I'd imagine they'd be shutting it off as quickly as possible as not to waste any of that oil.

*And as we later saw in the pilot they were drilling on Southfork where they did indeed know there was tons of oil. So, again, not a surprise.
 

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
About the oil refinery, I always thought it was kind of odd that wet behind the ears Bobby could broker a deal to get a refinery, but Jock nor JR couldn’t.
The writers were heavy handed in that. Its like on Dynasty when we were suppose to buy Alexis as a business mogul overnight, we were suppose to buy Bobby being a wiz at business over Jock and JR. Yes the thing with the oil refinery was silly that Bobby was able to do what Jock and JR couldn't.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
I don't know, I was fine with that move. I didn't take it to imply Bobby was specifically a wiz, I would think that sometimes major deals happen thanks in large part to being the right place and right time. Whatever it was the prevented Jock or J.R. from being able to close a deal on a refinery wasn't in the way when Bobby happened to be in charge, and he was able to make it happen.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
The storyline about Bobby being able to buy a refinery when Jock and J.R. couldn't is more realistic than you might think.
It starts out when Bobby re-opens Ewing 23. His field man asks who is going to refine the oil. The only refinery with extra capacity is Mainwaring and "No way will they do business with Ewing Oil. Old man Mainwaring doesn't think much of J.R."

That gave us our first clue.

Bobby did buy Jim Redfield's refinery. It is very possible that Jim Redfield would not want to do business with J.R. for fear of getting scammed. But he might be willing to make a deal with Bobby.

To put a finer point on it-- Jock or J.R. had the resources to buy a refinery, but Bobby was the only one a refinery owner would trust enough to even take an initial meeting.



4. OPEC
In Dallas season 9 (DVD10) JR made some harsh remarks about the OPEC, meeting with an army general and colluding with B.D. Calhoun who blew up some oil fields (somewhere I forgot). As far as I know the US are the world‘s biggest producer of oil and also its biggest consumer. They don‘t export much oil because it‘s needed in their own country. Therefore (?) the US are (and never have been) a member of the OPEC. Ewing Oil realistically never exported any oil and the US probably protected its own industry by regulating (customs) Arabian oil. So did/does the worldwide oil price really affect the American oil industry?

Oh, @the-lost-son I'm very jealous of you right now. Jealous that you didn't experience the pain of the OPEC embargo.

It's the 1970's and gas is cheaper than water. Here's what a Lincoln looked like before we downsized it to Jock's car:
1619211972763.png

It had the "drive the living room" feel!

The seven sisters bought almost all of their oil from the Oil Producing Countries in the Middle East. The seven sisters DID collude to keep prices down.
Then the Oil Producing Countries decided to ban together and try to beat the Seven Sisters.

Impossible?

Not impossible. They really pulled it off. They formed OPEC and decided to shut down oil production. And I mean shut it down entirely.

Imagine this: You need your car to get to work each day (America was even more spread out then, and mass transit wasn't an option. You either drove to work or you were out of a job).

Then, over night, OPEC shuts off the tap. Now gas doubles overnight, but that's only if you can find it!
1619236340792.png
It shut down our entire economy.
It was a domino effect. People couldn't get to work, get to school, or get to the store. We realized that without oil to refine into gasoline, we were back in the dark ages.

The one good thing-- if you had oil you were fabulously wealthy. And Jock Ewing had plenty of oil. So Dallas was born!
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
6. fun question - striking oil
In Dallas TNT during the pilot episode, JohnRoss and Elena strike oil.
(0:44). I‘ve seen something similiar like that in very old movies. People are drilling for oil and of course they strike oil, huge fountain, everyone dancing and celebrating under the gentle rainfall of oil. In former times when people had to drill by hand or very primitive tools to find oil under these strenuous circumstances must have been pure joy. But with modern equipment and all the geological reports available, I guess these kind of joy seems exaggerated.

Back in Jock and Digger' day, this is exactly what would happen. The oil formation would be trapped underground and under pressure. When you hit the formation, the oil would flow up the hole you are drilling and in some cases, would even blow out the derrick.

1619453413628.png

I hate to pour cold water on that cool video of John Ross striking oil, because it makes for great entertainment. But that's not how we do it anymore. We have two things that keep a gusher from happening.

We use drilling mud, which is very heavy. Think about the heavy clay you used when in art class. That is similar to our drilling mud. It fills in around the drill and fills in behind it so the oil can't flow out the top.

There is a second safety used, and that is where I come in. We use blowout preventers that look like this:
1619455814556.png

I service these and sometimes even deliver them. If you are in Texas and see a trailer parked at the local diner welding shop, look at the door of the truck. If its white with blue lettering then it might be me. If there is a Dr. Pepper on the dash, then it is definitely me.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
An auction is the most pure form of capitalism that you will ever see. It is supply and demand pure and simple.
There's no price rigging that I have ever seen, because there are just too many of us bidding. We can barely agree on where to go to lunch, let alone try and rig an auction!
While I don't know the particulars of an oil lease auction, it is way to simple to say there is no price fixing in auctions. A local example I know of is Al Taubman, the real estate developer, "In the early 2000s, an investigation into alleged price-fixing between Sotheby's (owned by Taubman) and rival auction house Christie's led to a confession by Sotheby's CEO Diana Brooks of an elaborate price fixing scheme with her counterpart at Christie's, Christopher Davidge.[8] In a plea bargain arrangement, prosecutors offered to keep her out of prison if she agreed to implicate Taubman. She did, and thereafter Taubman was convicted in a jury trial of price fixing.[14][15][16] He was fined $7.5 million (USD) and imprisoned for ten months in 2002 for antitrust violations.[17][18][19] Taubman was released in 2003,[20] and continued to insist on his innocence.[19]"

All of this criminal stuff is like speeding. It's illegal but nothing happens to most of us. The amazing thing is Taubman (a billionaire) actually did time for this scandal. It doesn't mean that if he had never been caught that he wasn't breaking the law. And law is up for interpretation, so under one prosecutor he might turn a blind eye, under another, he's trying to convince a jury and while one jury might find you innocent, another might sentence you to life. Right and wrong is anything but black and white and the art of war is all about deception.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
The writers were heavy handed in that. Its like on Dynasty when we were suppose to buy Alexis as a business mogul overnight, we were suppose to buy Bobby being a wiz at business over Jock and JR. Yes the thing with the oil refinery was silly that Bobby was able to do what Jock and JR couldn't.
But I can almost buy it. These deals are about relationships and we had the idea that Bobby spent years on the road building relationships. Jock and JR had a particular reputation that probably made it difficult to do business with many people. It's not just knowledge, you can buy that (most famously Henry Ford II and the Wiz Kids), and it's not about money, Jock had that, it also requires networking and the fine line between collusion and friendly deals. I could see Bobby from day one on the job be accepted among the community in a way that JR and Jock would have been kept at arms length.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
The storyline about Bobby being able to buy a refinery when Jock and J.R. couldn't is more realistic than you might think.
It starts out when Bobby re-opens Ewing 23. His field man asks who is going to refine the oil. The only refinery with extra capacity is Mainwaring and "No way will they do business with Ewing Oil. Old man Mainwaring doesn't think much of J.R."

That gave us our first clue.

Bobby did buy Jim Redfield's refinery. It is very possible that Jim Redfield would not want to do business with J.R. for fear of getting scammed. But he might be willing to make a deal with Bobby.

To put a finer point on it-- Jock or J.R. had the resources to buy a refinery, but Bobby was the only one a refinery owner would trust enough to even take an initial meeting.





Oh, @the-lost-son I'm very jealous of you right now. Jealous that you didn't experience the pain of the OPEC embargo.

It's the 1970's and gas is cheaper than water. Here's what a Lincoln looked like before we downsized it to Jock's car:
View attachment 26569

It had the "drive the living room" feel!

The seven sisters bought almost all of their oil from the Oil Producing Countries in the Middle East. The seven sisters DID collude to keep prices down.
Then the Oil Producing Countries decided to ban together and try to beat the Seven Sisters.

Impossible?

Not impossible. They really pulled it off. They formed OPEC and decided to shut down oil production. And I mean shut it down entirely.

Imagine this: You need your car to get to work each day (America was even more spread out then, and mass transit wasn't an option. You either drove to work or you were out of a job).

Then, over night, OPEC shuts off the tap. Now gas doubles overnight, but that's only if you can find it!
View attachment 26575
It shut down our entire economy.
It was a domino effect. People couldn't get to work, get to school, or get to the store. We realized that without oil to refine into gasoline, we were back in the dark ages.

The one good thing-- if you had oil you were fabulously wealthy. And Jock Ewing had plenty of oil. So Dallas was born!
The one thing I'd add, much of the seven sisters came from the ultimate in monopoly, Standard Oil. J. D. Rockefeller had a refinery monopoly that dominated the U. S. even after it was "broken up." If you're Jock trying to sell oil and your only got one buyer, well I guess you take what he gives you. Rockefeller later applied the same to steel, controlling the main ingredient, iron ore, and ventured in giant banks Chase and his brother with Citibank. Took years to detangle that web.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
@stevew ,
Thank you very much for your insightful posts. I learned a lot reading what you had to say.
Very much appreciated. I'm not an expert in the oil industry or law, but I know my local (Detroit) history and we've got some interesting business examples. And I know enough about investing to have some fun with these stories.

Oh and I agree, an auction is as pure as you get to capitalism and free markets, it is (suppose to be) all supply and demand.
 
Last edited:

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
But I can almost buy it. These deals are about relationships and we had the idea that Bobby spent years on the road building relationships. Jock and JR had a particular reputation that probably made it difficult to do business with many people. It's not just knowledge, you can buy that (most famously Henry Ford II and the Wiz Kids), and it's not about money, Jock had that, it also requires networking and the fine line between collusion and friendly deals. I could see Bobby from day one on the job be accepted among the community in a way that JR and Jock would have been kept at arms length.
Right, Bobby was "the company pimp" for several years, on the road spreadin' "broads, booze, and booty" to Ewing Oil's customers and partners. So in that scenario it makes sense that he would have built up a lot of personal goodwill in the industry that would payoff for him when he was finally in charge.

That's also how Bobby ended up winning the contest for control of Ewing Oil after Jock's death. We saw that end that in terms of just regular deals, J.R. clearly earned more profit than Bobby, which indeed shows that he's technically the superior business. But Bobby got lucky with that one major deal which came through for him at the last minute, and that deal was brought to him specifically because the person in charge didn't want to do business with J.R. So yeah that shows how in business, and really life in general, sometimes a good personal reputation can go a long way.
 
Top