stevew
Telly Talk Star
I'm not speaking just for myself; I'm basing it on my observations of what people said about the show. Who else besides you is saying six wasn't good?
We don't have to guess because we saw the reading of Rebecca's will. Clearly, Herbert willed all of his company to Rebecca. He could have willed some of it to Katherine but chose not to. There is nothing that indicates he left Katherine a trust Rebecca ignored. That's sheer speculation on your part.
That people didn't see Katherine as sympathetic isn't my opinion; it's my observation of what other people say about her. She tried to seduce her own sister's husband. She wrote a fake letter to help split up Pam and Bobby. Those aren't things that endear her to people.
Think about what you're saying about your idea making Katherine more sympathetic. Pam and Cliff end up growing up deprived of a mother, but as some consolation Rebecca at least left them what she did in her will. Then Katherine tries to take away the money Rebecca gave to Pam and Cliff and you think the fans would be cheering for Katherine? Really?
I am not saying season 6 was bad, I’m saying over all the quality got worse over time as the writer’s strayed from reality. The fact that the show got worse seems, especially following season 9, to be a common thread and also was reflective in the loss of ratings, the highest ratings being needed to maintain such an expensive show. I’m also not saying where I’d put the reveal of another version of Herbert’s will, but I would do such before I let Katherine go and certainly before I turned JR in to a loser.
Again nothing says Herbert did not, unless you’re stating that Rebecca’s character was so stellar that such manipulation of her husband’s estate was out of character. Everything we state which we do not know is speculation - even your assumption that Rebecca’s will proves Herbert did not intend for his estate to pass on in its entirety to his only child.
I’m not saying Katherine was overall a sympathetic character. I don’t think the show was known for its sympathies characters as JR was the man people loved to hate. That’s not the point. The point was to keep the story tied closer to reality and in return far more entertaining long run. The idea isn’t to make Katherine suddenly sympathetic but all the characters more complicated. Pam wouldn’t just be poor Pam but also someone trying to take what doesn’t belong to her, and of course without her mother’s husband’s money living wouldn’t be so easy for her. She can double down on her blaming of Bobby for her mother’s death and become more and more allied with Cliff and his anti Ewing cause. Katherine can get more involved in the running of these businesses, including a share of BarnesWentworth - characters develop and become more interesting instead of running on a course toward unrealistic - like where Pamela is eventually capable of taking on JR. instead of watching antagonists like Katherine and Wendell fade away they could have used them more, much more.