I don’t see how Bobby in any way was responsible for Rebecca’s death

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I'm not speaking just for myself; I'm basing it on my observations of what people said about the show. Who else besides you is saying six wasn't good?



We don't have to guess because we saw the reading of Rebecca's will. Clearly, Herbert willed all of his company to Rebecca. He could have willed some of it to Katherine but chose not to. There is nothing that indicates he left Katherine a trust Rebecca ignored. That's sheer speculation on your part.



That people didn't see Katherine as sympathetic isn't my opinion; it's my observation of what other people say about her. She tried to seduce her own sister's husband. She wrote a fake letter to help split up Pam and Bobby. Those aren't things that endear her to people.

Think about what you're saying about your idea making Katherine more sympathetic. Pam and Cliff end up growing up deprived of a mother, but as some consolation Rebecca at least left them what she did in her will. Then Katherine tries to take away the money Rebecca gave to Pam and Cliff and you think the fans would be cheering for Katherine? Really?

I am not saying season 6 was bad, I’m saying over all the quality got worse over time as the writer’s strayed from reality. The fact that the show got worse seems, especially following season 9, to be a common thread and also was reflective in the loss of ratings, the highest ratings being needed to maintain such an expensive show. I’m also not saying where I’d put the reveal of another version of Herbert’s will, but I would do such before I let Katherine go and certainly before I turned JR in to a loser.

Again nothing says Herbert did not, unless you’re stating that Rebecca’s character was so stellar that such manipulation of her husband’s estate was out of character. Everything we state which we do not know is speculation - even your assumption that Rebecca’s will proves Herbert did not intend for his estate to pass on in its entirety to his only child.

I’m not saying Katherine was overall a sympathetic character. I don’t think the show was known for its sympathies characters as JR was the man people loved to hate. That’s not the point. The point was to keep the story tied closer to reality and in return far more entertaining long run. The idea isn’t to make Katherine suddenly sympathetic but all the characters more complicated. Pam wouldn’t just be poor Pam but also someone trying to take what doesn’t belong to her, and of course without her mother’s husband’s money living wouldn’t be so easy for her. She can double down on her blaming of Bobby for her mother’s death and become more and more allied with Cliff and his anti Ewing cause. Katherine can get more involved in the running of these businesses, including a share of BarnesWentworth - characters develop and become more interesting instead of running on a course toward unrealistic - like where Pamela is eventually capable of taking on JR. instead of watching antagonists like Katherine and Wendell fade away they could have used them more, much more.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I am not saying season 6 was bad, I’m saying over all the quality got worse over time as the writer’s strayed from reality. The fact that the show got worse seems, especially following season 9, to be a common thread and also was reflective in the loss of ratings, the highest ratings being needed to maintain such an expensive show. I’m also not saying where I’d put the reveal of another version of Herbert’s will, but I would do such before I let Katherine go and certainly before I turned JR in to a loser.

Again nothing says Herbert did not, unless you’re stating that Rebecca’s character was so stellar that such manipulation of her husband’s estate was out of character. Everything we state which we do not know is speculation - even your assumption that Rebecca’s will proves Herbert did not intend for his estate to pass on in its entirety to his only child.

I’m not saying Katherine was overall a sympathetic character. I don’t think the show was known for its sympathies characters as JR was the man people loved to hate. That’s not the point. The point was to keep the story tied closer to reality and in return far more entertaining long run. The idea isn’t to make Katherine suddenly sympathetic but all the characters more complicated. Pam wouldn’t just be poor Pam but also someone trying to take what doesn’t belong to her, and of course without her mother’s husband’s money living wouldn’t be so easy for her. She can double down on her blaming of Bobby for her mother’s death and become more and more allied with Cliff and his anti Ewing cause. Katherine can get more involved in the running of these businesses, including a share of BarnesWentworth - characters develop and become more interesting instead of running on a course toward unrealistic - like where Pamela is eventually capable of taking on JR. instead of watching antagonists like Katherine and Wendell fade away they could have used them more, much more.

I agree with a lot of what you wrote there. The only thing I want to clarify is I didn't intend to imply that Herbert didn't want his estate to ever be passed down to Katherine, just that he could have willed all of it or part of it directly to her to ensure she received it and he chose not to.

As you've stated, Herbert created the money. Rebecca was his secretary whom he married. If he doesn't will some of his assets directly to Katherine, then that creates at least two problems. One is that if he intends for her to enjoy having that wealth, Katherine may have to wait a very long time to begin enjoying it because Rebecca might have lived to be a hundred. The other thing is that as a secretary who married the man who built the company, there's always the chance that Rebecca could have made some bad business deals and ended up with little or nothing to leave Katherine.

It seems to me where we disagree is more related to some of the details than the big picture. A few things like the idea that Pam with her high school diploma and her very average intellect would ever turn out to be capable of taking on JR or anyone else at that level of the business world isn't something I agree with, and to me it wouldn't be believable. I'm not nearly as big of a proponent of realism as you are, but I do think believability is crucial.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Rebecca deserved to die.

Bobby should have told Pam: "It's karma. You don't abandon your children, leave them with an alcoholic, and let them believe you're dead so they won't ask you for any financial support. You don't hide from your children or look your daughter in the eye and tell her you're not her mother. That's bad karma. No wonder her plane crashed."
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
There is a scene in season 7 (DVD) when Katherine visits Pam at "her" house. I sat there wondering....that's YOUR mum's house, it's huge and worth millions, why have you just let your sister, who is worth a fortune in her own right, move in and own it?

Katherine fought for Bobby but never for herself!
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I agree with a lot of what you wrote there. The only thing I want to clarify is I didn't intend to imply that Herbert didn't want his estate to ever be passed down to Katherine, just that he could have willed all of it or part of it directly to her to ensure she received it and he chose not to.

As you've stated, Herbert created the money. Rebecca was his secretary whom he married. If he doesn't will some of his assets directly to Katherine, then that creates at least two problems. One is that if he intends for her to enjoy having that wealth, Katherine may have to wait a very long time to begin enjoying it because Rebecca might have lived to be a hundred. The other thing is that as a secretary who married the man who built the company, there's always the chance that Rebecca could have made some bad business deals and ended up with little or nothing to leave Katherine.

It seems to me where we disagree is more related to some of the details than the big picture. A few things like the idea that Pam with her high school diploma and her very average intellect would ever turn out to be capable of taking on JR or anyone else at that level of the business world isn't something I agree with, and to me it wouldn't be believable. I'm not nearly as big of a proponent of realism as you are, but I do think believability is crucial.

You assume he choose not to. No one saw his estate papers. There is no way to say for certain what you want to say for certain. Now if Katherine were JR, I’d agree. There’s no way I could believe that anyone, even his momma, could get away with such. But with who Rebecca was and who Katherine was it is entirely plausible.

And to anyone with more than a high school diploma and average intellect, it isn’t believable that Herbert and Rebbeca’s estate couldn’t successfully be fought over by Katherine - and that was the point, that it could have proven to be an interesting story. One that could have financially destroyed Pam and Cliff - resetting their roles as they started out. It could have created a bigger role for Katherine, who I always enjoyed watching. It had all sorts of potential, added to the fact that Pam was already blaming the Ewing’s for her mother’s death. And while they already had a fight over a will, this fight was more believable. Kicks fight, while entertaining, wasn’t very believable. I’m not even sure how you’d split such a company in half and how it would run during the year long battle. I’d have believed it more if he gave them a dollar amount to profit off of and had Punk run the company for a year. Other than Dallas, I e never seen such a thing. But I’ve seen fighting over estates multiple times.
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
Sadly I don't think the producers saw Katherine as anything other than a plot point between Bobby and Pam. She was never explored as a character and was written as an out and out villain.

The more I think about it, the more I'd have loved that court battle over the will - J.R pulling strings behind the scenes and as @stevew suggested, seeing Pam and Cliff going under due to the court costs would have really added something. Pam became far too wealthy in her own right and therefore became untouchable. I think in the end she was worth more than the Ewings.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
You assume he choose not to. No one saw his estate papers. There is no way to say for certain what you want to say for certain.

The lawyer saw the papers. We heard him read them. What more were you hoping for? There are no real life estate papers to see; it's not a documentary. That's the story they gave us. The writers of the story purposely chose to not include any element of the story that would have shown the lawyer as likely to have been paid off, that the will had been altered, etc.

You could choose to not go along with the story and say that Bobby probably cheated on Pam often but they just didn't show it. OK, you could, but what would the point be? In fiction, you either go accept the premise of the story they're telling or you quit reading or watching. I guess someone could say they reject the premise of the story but they're going to continue following it anyway, but how much fun would that be?

There's a distinct difference between realism and believability. Jock's will and the contest it created may not have been realistic, but they did in a way that made it believable. They had a top level lawyer who approved it, the accountants made sure the split was equal, Punk Anderson, an oilman with experience was administrating the contest, and that makes it believable. Why? In their world, in the environment that the writers of the story created, the people who were experts in their field reviewed it, accepted the whole concept of the contest and went about dividing it so that by their criteria - pumping capacity - each brother got an equal share of the company to run for that year. Well, they're among the best of the best in their field so they ought to know, right? You're free to either accept or reject the premise of a work of fiction. If you decide that Harv Smithfield and all the rest of these people,including Jock himself were buffoons who had no idea what they were doing because that contest could never work, why would you watch?
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
The lawyer saw the papers. We heard him read them. What more were you hoping for? There are no real life estate papers to see; it's not a documentary. That's the story they gave us. The writers of the story purposely chose to not include any element of the story that would have shown the lawyer as likely to have been paid off, that the will had been altered, etc.

You could choose to not go along with the story and say that Bobby probably cheated on Pam often but they just didn't show it. OK, you could, but what would the point be? In fiction, you either go accept the premise of the story they're telling or you quit reading or watching. I guess someone could say they reject the premise of the story but they're going to continue following it anyway, but how much fun would that be?

There's a distinct difference between realism and believability. Jock's will and the contest it created may not have been realistic, but they did in a way that made it believable. They had a top level lawyer who approved it, the accountants made sure the split was equal, Punk Anderson, an oilman with experience was administrating the contest, and that makes it believable. Why? In their world, in the environment that the writers of the story created, the people who were experts in their field reviewed it, accepted the whole concept of the contest and went about dividing it so that by their criteria - pumping capacity - each brother got an equal share of the company to run for that year. Well, they're among the best of the best in their field so they ought to know, right? You're free to either accept or reject the premise of a work of fiction. If you decide that Harv Smithfield and all the rest of these people,including Jock himself were buffoons who had no idea what they were doing because that contest could never work, why would you watch?

Now you’re getting ridiculous, arguing just to argue. First it would be out of character for Bobby to cheat as you mention. Sure it could be done, we got a Dream season. Anything can be done. Is it more likely Rebecca did something with Herbert estate which wasn’t allowed? Could Rebecca’s lawyers, which you mention, be entirely different lawyers? As you mention it’s fiction. I’m only agreeing with a post that fighting over the Wentworth estate was feasible and believable and in my opinion it would have been entertaining, certainly a good use of the character Katherine Wentworth.

The writers could have consulted top lawyers, they choose not to regarding Jock’s will. I don’t have to find every aspect of a story acceptable to enjoy the story. The fight for Ewing oil was pretty good. But if they’d consulted real top lawyers and had a tighter control on reality, I think it could have been better. I also do t have to think Smithfield or Jock we’re great at what they did to enjoy the show. I thought Cliff was an idiot, if at least became such, and I still enjoyed the show. You’re free to idolize Jock all you want. But I don’t idolize any man, let alone a fictional one - it was a loosely feasible idea but a stupid idea of how to leave your estate if you expect your business to outlast you, that’s just a fact.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Sadly I don't think the producers saw Katherine as anything other than a plot point between Bobby and Pam. She was never explored as a character and was written as an out and out villain.

The more I think about it, the more I'd have loved that court battle over the will - J.R pulling strings behind the scenes and as @stevew suggested, seeing Pam and Cliff going under due to the court costs would have really added something. Pam became far too wealthy in her own right and therefore became untouchable. I think in the end she was worth more than the Ewings.

I agree, like with Wendell, they had something but just let it fade away. The best bad guys, imo, don’t fade away, they go out with thunderous applause (see The Quick and the Dead). They could have gone that way with either of them, but they didn’t.

Thank you and I agree. They changed the Barnes part of the story too much, imo, from their original position in the cast.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I’m only agreeing with a post that fighting over the Wentworth estate was feasible and believable and in my opinion it would have been entertaining, certainly a good use of the character Katherine Wentworth.

I agreed they could have done that too, but I don't think there was anything wrong with the way they handled it. Had they gone with the idea of Katherine contesting the will, I disagree with the idea that Dallas fans would have been hoping Katherine would win. It could have been a fun storyline, but it would have made Katherine more hated, not better liked or sympathized with. I'm referring to ideas such as:

Pathetic was taking a share of man’s money from your sister, whether she complained or not.

You might not feel bad for her, and that’s fine, but more than likely precedent would have been on her side, so a great deal of American society would have been on her side regarding the estates of Katherine and Rebecca.

Pam and Cliff had been deprived of growing up with a mother. Do you really expect that people would think, good, take away the money from the ones who had grown up thinking their mother was dead, have them be deprived of a mother and their inheritance too? Pam was one of the best liked characters on the show. Katherine tried to ruin her marriage. How is Katherine going to start garnering sympathy from the audience when she also decides she's not satisfied with inheriting half a billion dollars and tries to take away from Pam and Cliff the one good thing their mother did for them?

I also do t have to think Smithfield or Jock we’re great at what they did to enjoy the show. I thought Cliff was an idiot, if at least became such, and I still enjoyed the show. You’re free to idolize Jock all you want. But I don’t idolize any man, let alone a fictional one - it was a loosely feasible idea but a stupid idea of how to leave your estate if you expect your business to outlast you, that’s just a fact.

Idolize? Sure, I think Jock was a great character but how does that somehow equate to idolatry? That's not realistic or believable. I'd find it hard to justify spending the time to watch hundreds of episodes of a show that doesn't have any great characters, wouldn't you?
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I agreed they could have done that too, but I don't think there was anything wrong with the way they handled it. Had they gone with the idea of Katherine contesting the will, I disagree with the idea that Dallas fans would have been hoping Katherine would win. It could have been a fun storyline, but it would have made Katherine more hated, not better liked or sympathized with. I'm referring to ideas such as:





Pam and Cliff had been deprived of growing up with a mother. Do you really expect that people would think, good, take away the money from the ones who had grown up thinking their mother was dead, have them be deprived of a mother and their inheritance too? Pam was one of the best liked characters on the show. Katherine tried to ruin her marriage. How is Katherine going to start garnering sympathy from the audience when she also decides she's not satisfied with inheriting half a billion dollars and tries to take away from Pam and Cliff the one good thing their mother did for them?



Idolize? Sure, I think Jock was a great character but how does that somehow equate to idolatry? That's not realistic or believable. I'd find it hard to justify spending the time to watch hundreds of episodes of a show that doesn't have any great characters, wouldn't you?

No I’m sure most fans would not have liked her more, but that’s not the point. The comment was my opinion of such a situation. Frankly, I wasn’t a big fan of Pam’s for many reasons, including the original reason for this thread. But in my opinion it was pathetic of Pam to live off the money her sister’s late father.

The idea was not to get people to like Katherine. She was a villain - one that could have been better used in my opinion.

I’m not one to cry for the poor underdog and justify what they do because they grew up without mommy and say it’s ok you take from people because you had it bad. I realize must would - part of why people watched the story was to see the Barnes come out on top of the big bad Ewing’s, a RobinHood sort of thing. But I don’t take what doesn’t belong to me no matter what someone says, if I didn’t earn it or my parents didn’t earn it (or inherit it themselves), I don’t take it (that doesn’t mean Rebecca didn’t have anything and couldn’t have given something to her other children, she was married to Herbert for years, but not 2/3’s). Our laws and traditions are pretty clear on how these things go and you can justify all you want (you probably we’re in support of Anna Nicole Smith as well), and the audience can root for Pam as well, but I don’t see it that way and have no doubt in a realistic sense, neither would a court. As for entertainment, I think it would have helped put the Barnes back to being the underdogs and been a great way to move forward instead of the silly stuff which followed.
 

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
That would have been a great storyline actually @Kenny Coyote - Katherine fighting the will - especially knowing what Cliff is like with money and power - and where would Pam have fitted in, what would she have done...? But too repetitive after Jock's will.

Yes I would have preferred that Katherine had challenged her mother's will in court as well. That would have been a better story than her bedding JR and chasing after Bobby.
 
Top