I love this post and completely agree.
I've never thought recasting Miss Ellie with Donna Reed was a mistake, in fact, I think it was more of a mistake to switch back to Barbara because it reduced the credibility of the show and gave the impression of desperation.
If anything, re-casting the part of Miss Ellie with Donna Reed was the act of desperation. Bringing the rightful Miss Ellie back to Southfork was simply correcting a mistake.
The way they went about it was awful, of course, but few people bought into Reed's portrayal of Miss Ellie. Her version was far too different from the character as established by BBG.
Unfortunately, the series was basically a series of mistakes from that point on. From the glitz of the dream season, to the dream resolution itself, to the mishandling of Pam's exit, to the campy tone of the final three seasons, the producers seemed hell bent on destroying the show from within. And those series of mistakes began with the hiring of Donna Reed.
On a side note, Reed was part of a season that was rather uneventful overall. However, I always thought it was a shame that she was the one who took down Jock's portrait. That scene would have been much more poignant had it been BBG since she had actually worked with Jim Davis. Having Reed in the role during a pivotal moment such as that caused the scene to fall flat. The same can be said for her lackluster sobbing "no, no Bobby" during Bobby's "death bed" scene.