JR and Miss Ellie

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I think you forgot Donna’s book and the things she exposed that Jock did, which most certainly were the tip of the iceberg. That doesn’t take away from his accomplishments but JR wasn’t alone in being a “bad” guy to accomplish his goals. In fact it was Jock who taught JR to do what ever he “had” to do. You might be comfortable with justifying wrongs because it was the environment of big oil at the time, like done with all sorts of businesses all across time, like with slavery for instance. But not everyone is. In my opinion what is wrong now was wrong then and I expect to be held to that standard by those who follow me. Morality doesn’t change based on time as far as I’m concerned. And I’m not sure I care about the respect of those of the oil industry which included people like H.L. Hunt (real life). The very cartel it self, designed to set prices, was immoral and anti-capitalistic in its nature, not to mention illegal. So yes I find him to be a “bad” guy, and in fact most if not all to be very heavy shades of gray in morality. The point was most seem to view them as such, the two bad guys. I could be wrong. I suppose you could do a poll to see the consensus within this community.

I also believe that these shades of gray are more realistic. Even my own parents were shades of gray and I loved and admired them dearly. And I’m certain my own actions will be judge the same. I don’t pretend otherwise. What I would admire about Jock is that he didn’t strike me as the type of many who would pretend otherwise. He left delusions to people like Digger.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I think you forgot Donna’s book and the things she exposed that Jock did, which most certainly were the tip of the iceberg. That doesn’t take away from his accomplishments but JR wasn’t alone in being a “bad” guy to accomplish his goals. In fact it was Jock who taught JR to do what ever he “had” to do. You might be comfortable with justifying wrongs because it was the environment of big oil at the time

You mean the book where she said when Sam Culver had his cousin committed, Jock was his business partner at the time? I remember that. Sam's part was far worse; he's the one who wrongfully committed the guy and Sam was considered to be practically a hero in Texas. The good Jock did far outweighed the bad. Of course I'm alright with Jock adapting to survive in his particular environment because survival demands it. I see it like being in a shark tank; if you're not the biggest, baddest great white, you're gonna end up being someone else's lunch. It had nothing to do with the time; that goes for any highly competitive, cutthroat industry. If you want to survive, you adapt your environment.

In my opinion what is wrong now was wrong then and I expect to be held to that standard by those who follow me. Morality doesn’t change based on time as far as I’m concerned.

That's your opinion and that's fine, but anyone can have an opinion. Opinion is the lowest form of human knowledge; there's no ifs ands or buts about it. Anyone can form an opinion with little or no actual information and then can go around and spout it off as if it's a real fact, when it's nothing more than theory, conjecture and assumption.
 
Last edited:

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
I think you forgot Donna’s book and the things she exposed that Jock did, which most certainly were the tip of the iceberg. That doesn’t take away from his accomplishments but JR wasn’t alone in being a “bad” guy to accomplish his goals. In fact it was Jock who taught JR to do what ever he “had” to do. You might be comfortable with justifying wrongs because it was the environment of big oil at the time, like done with all sorts of businesses all across time, like with slavery for instance. But not everyone is. In my opinion what is wrong now was wrong then and I expect to be held to that standard by those who follow me. Morality doesn’t change based on time as far as I’m concerned. And I’m not sure I care about the respect of those of the oil industry which included people like H.L. Hunt (real life). The very cartel it self, designed to set prices, was immoral and anti-capitalistic in its nature, not to mention illegal. So yes I find him to be a “bad” guy, and in fact most if not all to be very heavy shades of gray in morality. The point was most seem to view them as such, the two bad guys. I could be wrong. I suppose you could do a poll to see the consensus within this community.

I had totally forgotten about that! You're right though, very shady. Excellent point. I still feel like he had his own idea of what honor meant though, and he lived up to that and expected others around him to do the same.
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
You mean the book where she said when Sam Culver had his cousin committed, Jock was his business partner at the time? I remember that. Sam's part was far worse; he's the one who wrongfully committed the guy and Sam was considered to be practically a hero in Texas. The good Jock did far outweighed the bad. Of course I'm alright with Jock adapting to survive in his particular environment because survival demands it. I see it like being in a shark tank; if you're not the biggest, baddest great white, you're gonna end up being someone else's lunch. It had nothing to do with the time; that goes for any highly competitive, cutthroat industry. If you want to survive, you adapt your environment.



That's your opinion and that's fine, but anyone can have an opinion. Opinion is the lowest form of human knowledge; there's no ifs ands or buts about it. Anyone can form an opinion with little or no actual information and then can go around and spout it off as if it's a real fact, when it's nothing more than theory, conjecture and assumption.

You sure are full of yourself as well as full of justifications and excuses for others, even the behaviors of fictional characters. Most of what you state are opinions, you just don’t label them as such, “a view or judgment formed about something, not necessarily based on fact or knowledge.” We are a long ways from having all the facts about Jock Ewing to form anything but an opinion on him.

But for my statement maybe a better word would have been my belief. “Morality doesn’t change based on time as far as I’m concerned” is my belief, and is based on my Christian up brining. You apparently do not believe the same, but there is no way to state which is right or wrong as a definitive answer though you certainly seem to want such.

But what Jock did was NOT survival in any sense of the word. In a shark tank the shark will eat you, you will die, that’s survival. Jock lived well beyond survival, well beyond the fear of death. What Sam did as being worse is just your attempt to grade on a curve, all a degree of immorality, and then add an excuse because Jock was poor at one point he could do what ever to, in your opinion, “survive.” Yet by that point in his life Jock was long past life and death as a reason why he did what he did. He was looking to prosper even if it violated another’s rights to life and liberty.

You also seem to take my statement as a judgement on his behavior. It’s an assessment of the character from what I know of him, the limited amount we are capable of knowing about a fictional character. I don’t condemn him or any of the characters. I certainly don’t pretend to know what is in their hearts. But I certainly am not going to hero worship a man who participated in Sam Culver’s schemes, who raised JR and Bobby to do what ever it took to win, who pitted brother against brother and then used the excuse to teach them to work together. Not to mention a man who worked with a group of business rivals to impede competition to set higher prices in direct violation of the principals of American free markets and as you state earned their respect. And he has people like you believing his ends justified his means, another way of saying his good outweighed his bad. I could maybe buy the argument if we were talking about more than enriching himself and his family.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
You sure are full of yourself

I'm not sure why you would say that or what possible value you hoped it would add to the thread. I didn't bash you.

We are a long ways from having all the facts about Jock Ewing to form anything but an opinion on him.

We never will have the facts. That show ended in 1991.

But what Jock did was NOT survival in any sense of the word. In a shark tank the shark will eat you, you will die, that’s survival.

The shark tank is an analogy. Not surviving in Jock's situation would be his business being put out of business by competitors if he had not been willing to play by the rules his competitors used. Then his business wouldn't be around anymore. if a shark eats another shark, that other shark isn't around anymore. I didn't think it would be hard to understand the analogy.

You also seem to take my statement as a judgement on his behavior. It’s an assessment of the character from what I know of him, the limited amount we are capable of knowing about a fictional character.

Character influences behavior; they're connected.

Most of what you state are opinions, you just don’t label them as such, “a view or judgment formed about something, not necessarily based on fact or knowledge.”

Yes, we all state our opinions in Dallas. When you stated your opinion on morality, I replied with the statement I did about opinion to make the point that we aren't going to agree on morality because as you said, that's your opinion on it. Morality is not a fixed thing; it varies from person to person. My morality is not the same as your morality, which is not the same as someone else's morality, etc.

Another reason we won't agree is because it appears to me your criteria so far has been to only name examples of things Jock did that you consider bad - therefore you judge him to be bad. I've seen others in this thread use that approach as well, to only name bad things Dallas characters did and then judge them to be bad.

That's very different from how I make the distinction between good and bad. As human beings, we're all very fallible. We've all done bad things. Knowing that, when asked to judge someone as good or bad, I take the good he did and weigh it against the bad. Others have already brought up the bad things Jock did so they were already here in the thread. I saw no need to repeat them. I brought up things about him that had not already been brought up in this thread.

I consider the good Jock did to far outweigh the bad. It's my opinion that the good he did so far outweighs the bad that he was not just good, but a great man. Ray Krebbs said Jock was the best man he ever knew. I think Ray was a good man too. I think Punk Anderson was a good man and Jock was his best friend. The reputation you have among the people who know you best says a lot about you and in Jock's case, the people who knew him best loved him. That's another highly positive thing in his favor.

I never saw Jock as being viewed as "One of the two bad guys" JR yes, I see that people see him as more bad than good and that's my opinion of him as well-- he had some redeeming qualities, but overall the bad outweighs the good.

Dallas was a collection of characters who all had some virtues and some flaws, with some being much closer to the positive end of the spectrum and some being much closer to the negative end. I like the way they did it, rather than having a story of "good guys vs bad guys."

Incidentally, we did have a poll of "Which Dallas Character Did You Find Most Likable" and 16 people voted. Pam won with 5 votes, Jock was the second most likable character with 4 votes, and Miss Ellie came in third with 3 votes. JR received no votes.

http://www.soapchat.net/threads/which-dallas-character-did-you-find-most-likable.8194/
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I'm not sure why you would say that or what possible value you hoped it would add to the thread. I didn't bash you.



We never will have the facts. That show ended in 1991.



The shark tank is an analogy. Not surviving in Jock's situation would be his business being put out of business by competitors if he had not been willing to play by the rules his competitors used. Then his business wouldn't be around anymore. if a shark eats another shark, that other shark isn't around anymore. I didn't think it would be hard to understand the analogy.



Character influences behavior; they're connected.



Yes, we all state our opinions in Dallas. When you stated your opinion on morality, I replied with the statement I did about opinion to make the point that we aren't going to agree on morality because as you said, that's your opinion on it. Morality is not a fixed thing; it varies from person to person. My morality is not the same as your morality, which is not the same as someone else's morality, etc.

Another reason we won't agree is because it appears to me your criteria so far has been to only name examples of things Jock did that you consider bad - therefore you judge him to be bad. I've seen others in this thread use that approach as well, to only name bad things Dallas characters did and then judge them to be bad.

That's very different from how I make the distinction between good and bad. As human beings, we're all very fallible. We've all done bad things. Knowing that, when asked to judge someone as good or bad, I take the good he did and weigh it against the bad. Others have already brought up the bad things Jock did so they were already here in the thread. I saw no need to repeat them. I brought up things about him that had not already been brought up in this thread.

I consider the good Jock did to far outweigh the bad. It's my opinion that the good he did so far outweighs the bad that he was not just good, but a great man. Ray Krebbs said Jock was the best man he ever knew. I think Ray was a good man too. I think Punk Anderson was a good man and Jock was his best friend. The reputation you have among the people who know you best says a lot about you and in Jock's case, the people who knew him best loved him. That's another highly positive thing in his favor.

I never saw Jock as being viewed as "One of the two bad guys" JR yes, I see that people see him as more bad than good and that's my opinion of him as well-- he had some redeeming qualities, but overall the bad outweighs the good.

Dallas was a collection of characters who all had some virtues and some flaws, with some being much closer to the positive end of the spectrum and some being much closer to the negative end. I like the way they did it, rather than having a story of "good guys vs bad guys."

Incidentally, we did have a poll of "Which Dallas Character Did You Find Most Likable" and 16 people voted. Pam won with 5 votes, Jock was the second most likable character with 4 votes, and Miss Ellie came in third with 3 votes. JR received no votes.

http://www.soapchat.net/threads/which-dallas-character-did-you-find-most-likable.8194/

I found your declaration “Opinion is the lowest form of human knowledge” to be a “bash.” You might have just been quoting someone else but you did not state such. Opinions can certainly be just feelings and gut reactions (as your statement seems to be aimed at) but they can also be based on evidence in a subjective case (like pointing out the good and the bad of a character). You seem to have a need to rank things, like stating something is “lowest“ when such is just subjective and being the one to do the subjective ranking gives me the impression you’re “full of yourself.”

It wasn’t hard to understand the analogy and I didn’t think it was hard to understand the word survival. Not having a business isn’t an issue of survival, though many use such a word. A business is a want not a need. A business is not a living being. Shady business dealings, no matter what’s going on around you doesn’t make me see a person as a good guy. As I’ve said over and over it’s all shades of grade. But I’m not going to see Jock as a good guy because he did what he had to do to get or keep what he wanted, regardless of Ray or Punks statements.

I in fact did NOT judge Jock to be bad. I clearly stated that Jock and JR are viewed as bad, which you you seem to confirm, but they were not only ones - that ALL the characters, even Miss Ellie (the point of the post) had “bad“ tendencies even if the majority don’t label them as such. Again the characters were shades of gray, a complexity I appreciate in the story telling. Thus means that yes Jock and even JR we’re also complex enough to be both good and bad.

It seems as if we agree on this shades of grade but in your post you don’t make mention of characteristics and behaviors you go on to weigh weigh such and justify the “bad” as survival. The sum of a man, to understand him and appreciate who he was isn’t to take a total account as if adding up numbers, it’s to recall the good and bad just as they are. I’m sure from what I recall of Jock he would be the first man to say to St. Peter, maybe the only character on Dallas to say, “I don’t need anyone to wash over or justify what I did. I own it all, the good and the bad. One doesn’t take away from the other. It’s all me” - that is the point I’m getting at.

Regarding Miss Ellie, not only is she not seen in the same harsh light, I did not get the impression she would take ownership of the bad. I get the impression she’d say “but” a lot when ask to account for the bad. But in the case of both I don’t know what was in their hearts, not even in JR’s heart so I don’t judge any of them as good or bad, just a lot of shades of gray and I don’t feel the need to weigh or rank them (except for the occasional poll for the fun of it, and I do believe I ranked Jock as my most likable).

Sometimes in a post it is difficult to be clear and sometimes statements can come off with an unintended tone. I do appreciate the challenges you make to my thinking. These challenges help me to better understand myself as a person and for that I thank you very much.
 
Saint Jock of Dallas ;)

Veg0Jk5.jpg
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I found your declaration “Opinion is the lowest form of human knowledge” to be a “bash.” You might have just been quoting someone else but you did not state such. Opinions can certainly be just feelings and gut reactions (as your statement seems to be aimed at) but they can also be based on evidence in a subjective case (like pointing out the good and the bad of a character). You seem to have a need to rank things, like stating something is “lowest“ when such is just subjective and being the one to do the subjective ranking gives me the impression you’re “full of yourself.”

It wasn’t hard to understand the analogy and I didn’t think it was hard to understand the word survival. Not having a business isn’t an issue of survival, though many use such a word. A business is a want not a need. A business is not a living being. Shady business dealings, no matter what’s going on around you doesn’t make me see a person as a good guy. As I’ve said over and over it’s all shades of grade. But I’m not going to see Jock as a good guy because he did what he had to do to get or keep what he wanted, regardless of Ray or Punks statements.

I in fact did NOT judge Jock to be bad. I clearly stated that Jock and JR are viewed as bad, which you you seem to confirm, but they were not only ones - that ALL the characters, even Miss Ellie (the point of the post) had “bad“ tendencies even if the majority don’t label them as such. Again the characters were shades of gray, a complexity I appreciate in the story telling. Thus means that yes Jock and even JR we’re also complex enough to be both good and bad.

It seems as if we agree on this shades of grade but in your post you don’t make mention of characteristics and behaviors you go on to weigh weigh such and justify the “bad” as survival. The sum of a man, to understand him and appreciate who he was isn’t to take a total account as if adding up numbers, it’s to recall the good and bad just as they are. I’m sure from what I recall of Jock he would be the first man to say to St. Peter, maybe the only character on Dallas to say, “I don’t need anyone to wash over or justify what I did. I own it all, the good and the bad. One doesn’t take away from the other. It’s all me” - that is the point I’m getting at.

Regarding Miss Ellie, not only is she not seen in the same harsh light, I did not get the impression she would take ownership of the bad. I get the impression she’d say “but” a lot when ask to account for the bad. But in the case of both I don’t know what was in their hearts, not even in JR’s heart so I don’t judge any of them as good or bad, just a lot of shades of gray and I don’t feel the need to weigh or rank them (except for the occasional poll for the fun of it, and I do believe I ranked Jock as my most likable).

Sometimes in a post it is difficult to be clear and sometimes statements can come off with an unintended tone. I do appreciate the challenges you make to my thinking. These challenges help me to better understand myself as a person and for that I thank you very much.

That's a very nice post @stevew. Re-reading my post, in the part about morality where I wrote "Opinion is the lowest form of human knowledge...it's nothing more than theory, conjecture and assumption" I didn't make it as clear as I should have that that was directed at my opinions every bit as much as yours, with the point being "I can't prove my way of looking at it is the best way any more than you can prove your way is the best way and because of that we aren't going to agree on Jock's morality." That was my fault for not making that clear.

I'm fairly sure we agree on the most essential tenets of morality - don't kill, don't rape, don't steal, respect your parents, don't covet thy neighbor's wife, etc. I know I wouldn't be comfortable doing some of the things Jock did, and I wouldn't want to be in that business where it looks to me that it was what was required to even stay in business. It makes a fun TV show to watch though.

We didn't see a whole lot of Jock's business dealings because he's handing it over to his sons by the time the show begins. I choose to go by what I actually saw of the man than what others said about him, because then it's not someone else's interpretation, which may be heavily biased or even flat-out wrong. Without trying to write a book about it, my primary impression of Jock as businessman was that of a man who wanted to be ethical, sometimes fell short of what he would have made him feel good about himself, but usually acted in a way where the rest of the oil community seemed to have a deep amount of respect for him and would trust him enough that they'd say things like "his handshake was better than a contract."

On the "A business is a want not a need" statement, I think I see your side of it. I look at it from a standpoint of: It takes money to live. If he got put out of business, how does he provide for his family? I have heard that according to the Bible, if a man can't provide for his family, he's worse than an infidel. Maybe you could tell me what your understanding is as to whether that's accurate. I think Jock probably did the least amount of unethical things in business that he had to do and still stay in business while competing with competitors who were as unethical as Jeremy Wendell. I don't know how you stay in business with competitors like Wendell without becoming very hard and aggressive. I never saw Jock screw someone over for the enjoyment of it.

In keeping with how I look at things, it seems to me the good outweighs the bad he did as a businessman. I find it impressive that he was successful in such a competitive industry. As a result of his success he provided an essential product and created a livelihood for many, many employees. I consider hard work and productivity in anyone to be virtues. I don't know where you stand on that. I'd be interested to know.

I don't want to be repetitive, so I'll just briefly say I consider these very positive things: A successful marriage of over 40 years, sons who loved him, and friends who liked him - especially Punk Anderson. The way he treated his wife, maybe best exemplified in the "Mastectomy" episodes show a love and a deep concern with her feelings. I remember Bobby and JR saying something about how he was going to the hospital so much to be with her that he wasn't getting any sleep, to the point they were concerned about his health.

I've always been critical of favoritism as parents, which both Jock and Ellie were guilty of doing. Jock said in "Barbecue" that he spoiled Bobby rotten and "he turned out to be the best of the lot." I'm very against that way of treating one's children. You've seen where I've explained why I think Jock did what he did in business - he was adapting to his environment. I don't see any justification for the favoritism he showed with his children. Allowing Bobby to essentially steal the job JR had earned by working for Jock while Bobby was playing football and being a playboy as something else that I can't justify. Jock certainly did some bad things. I don't know anyone who hasn't. As human beings we're all very fallible. Only God isn't fallible.

I like the part in your post regarding telling St. Peter that he'd own up to the good and the bad. I picture him saying that too. I think your assessment of Miss Ellie was also very good and I also her picture saying what you wrote. I generally liked Ellie, but in season four I found her almost insufferable with her "Keep Bobby from leaving no matter what it takes...or I'll never forgive you." I won't try to list the reasons that was bad. There were other seasons when she seemed so much better than that, I wonder if it's the result of having different writers with different artistic visions for the characters.

There does seem to be a conception in the part of a lot of viewers that Ellie and Bobby were so good that they were virtually incapable of doing wrong. Based on how the show presented other characters' reactions to them, I can see where that idea comes from. I think the show wants us to consider them both as extremely good, virtually flawless characters with almost unlimited virtues. However, based on what I see them do, I see evidence that indicates something quite different about both.

I'd be interested in knowing: Because Bobby acts so self-righteous, is it actually more aggravating to you when he dos something bad? Using JR's time in recovery from his gunshot wounds as an opportunity to take his job from him comes to mind. There's demanding from Jock full control of Ewing Oil in writing (which says "your word isn't good enough for me") and then threatening to move to California if Jock said no. Bobby knew how that would affect Ellie, that she'd blame Jock for it, and used that as leverage. I call it emotional extortion. It's basically: "Give me what I want or I'll make Mama never forgive you." It's exactly because Bobby acted to self-righteous that makes it all the more aggravating when he does it, in my experience watching the show.

Thank you for the nice compliment at the end of your post. it's not often that I find someone who can give me a debate of this kind of substance and I genuinely appreciate it for the same reasons - it makes me take a look at my own thinking.
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
That's a very nice post @stevew. Re-reading my post, in the part about morality where I wrote "Opinion is the lowest form of human knowledge...it's nothing more than theory, conjecture and assumption" I didn't make it as clear as I should have that that was directed at my opinions every bit as much as yours, with the point being "I can't prove my way of looking at it is the best way any more than you can prove your way is the best way and because of that we aren't going to agree on Jock's morality." That was my fault for not making that clear.

I'm fairly sure we agree on the most essential tenets of morality - don't kill, don't rape, don't steal, respect your parents, don't covet thy neighbor's wife, etc. I know I wouldn't be comfortable doing some of the things Jock did, and I wouldn't want to be in that business where it looks to me that it was what was required to even stay in business. It makes a fun TV show to watch though.

We didn't see a whole lot of Jock's business dealings because he's handing it over to his sons by the time the show begins. I choose to go by what I actually saw of the man than what others said about him, because then it's not someone else's interpretation, which may be heavily biased or even flat-out wrong. Without trying to write a book about it, my primary impression of Jock as businessman was that of a man who wanted to be ethical, sometimes fell short of what he would have made him feel good about himself, but usually acted in a way where the rest of the oil community seemed to have a deep amount of respect for him and would trust him enough that they'd say things like "his handshake was better than a contract."

On the "A business is a want not a need" statement, I think I see your side of it. I look at it from a standpoint of: It takes money to live. If he got put out of business, how does he provide for his family? I have heard that according to the Bible, if a man can't provide for his family, he's worse than an infidel. Maybe you could tell me what your understanding is as to whether that's accurate. I think Jock probably did the least amount of unethical things in business that he had to do and still stay in business while competing with competitors who were as unethical as Jeremy Wendell. I don't know how you stay in business with competitors like Wendell without becoming very hard and aggressive. I never saw Jock screw someone over for the enjoyment of it.

In keeping with how I look at things, it seems to me the good outweighs the bad he did as a businessman. I find it impressive that he was successful in such a competitive industry. As a result of his success he provided an essential product and created a livelihood for many, many employees. I consider hard work and productivity in anyone to be virtues. I don't know where you stand on that. I'd be interested to know.

I don't want to be repetitive, so I'll just briefly say I consider these very positive things: A successful marriage of over 40 years, sons who loved him, and friends who liked him - especially Punk Anderson. The way he treated his wife, maybe best exemplified in the "Mastectomy" episodes show a love and a deep concern with her feelings. I remember Bobby and JR saying something about how he was going to the hospital so much to be with her that he wasn't getting any sleep, to the point they were concerned about his health.

I've always been critical of favoritism as parents, which both Jock and Ellie were guilty of doing. Jock said in "Barbecue" that he spoiled Bobby rotten and "he turned out to be the best of the lot." I'm very against that way of treating one's children. You've seen where I've explained why I think Jock did what he did in business - he was adapting to his environment. I don't see any justification for the favoritism he showed with his children. Allowing Bobby to essentially steal the job JR had earned by working for Jock while Bobby was playing football and being a playboy as something else that I can't justify. Jock certainly did some bad things. I don't know anyone who hasn't. As human beings we're all very fallible. Only God isn't fallible.

I like the part in your post regarding telling St. Peter that he'd own up to the good and the bad. I picture him saying that too. I think your assessment of Miss Ellie was also very good and I also her picture saying what you wrote. I generally liked Ellie, but in season four I found her almost insufferable with her "Keep Bobby from leaving no matter what it takes...or I'll never forgive you." I won't try to list the reasons that was bad. There were other seasons when she seemed so much better than that, I wonder if it's the result of having different writers with different artistic visions for the characters.

There does seem to be a conception in the part of a lot of viewers that Ellie and Bobby were so good that they were virtually incapable of doing wrong. Based on how the show presented other characters' reactions to them, I can see where that idea comes from. I think the show wants us to consider them both as extremely good, virtually flawless characters with almost unlimited virtues. However, based on what I see them do, I see evidence that indicates something quite different about both.

I'd be interested in knowing: Because Bobby acts so self-righteous, is it actually more aggravating to you when he dos something bad? Using JR's time in recovery from his gunshot wounds as an opportunity to take his job from him comes to mind. There's demanding from Jock full control of Ewing Oil in writing (which says "your word isn't good enough for me") and then threatening to move to California if Jock said no. Bobby knew how that would affect Ellie, that she'd blame Jock for it, and used that as leverage. I call it emotional extortion. It's basically: "Give me what I want or I'll make Mama never forgive you." It's exactly because Bobby acted to self-righteous that makes it all the more aggravating when he does it, in my experience watching the show.

Thank you for the nice compliment at the end of your post. it's not often that I find someone who can give me a debate of this kind of substance and I genuinely appreciate it for the same reasons - it makes me take a look at my own thinking.

Well put. I will say this, what bothers me most about the show is the self righteousness of those who do bad and those who justify that behavior. Own it or change it my dad use to say. If you can’t own your behavior than change it. If Bobby had to own the truth you just said, which in part I think the character did at times, he wouldn’t have wanted to live with that behavior.
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
Regarding Miss Ellie, not only is she not seen in the same harsh light, I did not get the impression she would take ownership of the bad. I get the impression she’d say “but” a lot when ask to account for the bad.

This is what I feel about Miss Ellie too - as an example in the case of Val/Lucy I feel like she probably told JR to "get her back"; when JR and his henchmen returned with only baby Lucy she really didn't question where Val was or what he did. If anything she's very much of a "don't ask, don't tell" sort of school. As long as she didn't know exactly how things went down, then it wasn't her responsibility. I really wish that she and Val actually had a proper confrontation about that as it would've been good television.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
This is what I feel about Miss Ellie too - as an example in the case of Val/Lucy I feel like she probably told JR to "get her back"; when JR and his henchmen returned with only baby Lucy she really didn't question where Val was or what he did. If anything she's very much of a "don't ask, don't tell" sort of school. As long as she didn't know exactly how things went down, then it wasn't her responsibility. I really wish that she and Val actually had a proper confrontation about that as it would've been good television.

I get that same sense about Miss Ellie. JR would not have gone after Valine and baby Lucy if he didn’t have Jock and Miss Ellie’s blessing.

As for a scene between Val and Miss Ellie talking about that incident? It probably goes some like this:

Val crying: “Why did you allow JR to take the one thing I had in the world?”

Miss Ellie: “I should have put a stop to it. I’m sorry. Please accept my apology.”

Val reluctantly “Oh Miss Ellie, I accept.”
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
I get that same sense about Miss Ellie. JR would not have gone after Valine and baby Lucy if he didn’t have Jock and Miss Ellie’s blessing.

As for a scene between Val and Miss Ellie talking about that incident? It probably goes some like this:

Val crying: “Why did you allow JR to take the one thing I had in the world?”

Miss Ellie: “I should have put a stop to it. I’m sorry. Please accept my apology.”

Val reluctantly “Oh Miss Ellie, I accept.”

Sadly, that is probably how it would play out but I would've personally wanted a proper blow out. The Thrillin' Jill Killer would've certainly had every reason to be properly angry with Miss Ellie and I'm sure that Bel Geddes would've sold the shit out of that meaty material that would've followed.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
That's a very nice post @stevew. Re-reading my post, in the part about morality where I wrote "Opinion is the lowest form of human knowledge...it's nothing more than theory, conjecture and assumption" I didn't make it as clear as I should have that that was directed at my opinions every bit as much as yours, with the point being "I can't prove my way of looking at it is the best way any more than you can prove your way is the best way and because of that we aren't going to agree on Jock's morality." That was my fault for not making that clear.

I'm fairly sure we agree on the most essential tenets of morality - don't kill, don't rape, don't steal, respect your parents, don't covet thy neighbor's wife, etc. I know I wouldn't be comfortable doing some of the things Jock did, and I wouldn't want to be in that business where it looks to me that it was what was required to even stay in business. It makes a fun TV show to watch though.

We didn't see a whole lot of Jock's business dealings because he's handing it over to his sons by the time the show begins. I choose to go by what I actually saw of the man than what others said about him, because then it's not someone else's interpretation, which may be heavily biased or even flat-out wrong. Without trying to write a book about it, my primary impression of Jock as businessman was that of a man who wanted to be ethical, sometimes fell short of what he would have made him feel good about himself, but usually acted in a way where the rest of the oil community seemed to have a deep amount of respect for him and would trust him enough that they'd say things like "his handshake was better than a contract."

On the "A business is a want not a need" statement, I think I see your side of it. I look at it from a standpoint of: It takes money to live. If he got put out of business, how does he provide for his family? I have heard that according to the Bible, if a man can't provide for his family, he's worse than an infidel. Maybe you could tell me what your understanding is as to whether that's accurate. I think Jock probably did the least amount of unethical things in business that he had to do and still stay in business while competing with competitors who were as unethical as Jeremy Wendell. I don't know how you stay in business with competitors like Wendell without becoming very hard and aggressive. I never saw Jock screw someone over for the enjoyment of it.

In keeping with how I look at things, it seems to me the good outweighs the bad he did as a businessman. I find it impressive that he was successful in such a competitive industry. As a result of his success he provided an essential product and created a livelihood for many, many employees. I consider hard work and productivity in anyone to be virtues. I don't know where you stand on that. I'd be interested to know.

I don't want to be repetitive, so I'll just briefly say I consider these very positive things: A successful marriage of over 40 years, sons who loved him, and friends who liked him - especially Punk Anderson. The way he treated his wife, maybe best exemplified in the "Mastectomy" episodes show a love and a deep concern with her feelings. I remember Bobby and JR saying something about how he was going to the hospital so much to be with her that he wasn't getting any sleep, to the point they were concerned about his health.

I've always been critical of favoritism as parents, which both Jock and Ellie were guilty of doing. Jock said in "Barbecue" that he spoiled Bobby rotten and "he turned out to be the best of the lot." I'm very against that way of treating one's children. You've seen where I've explained why I think Jock did what he did in business - he was adapting to his environment. I don't see any justification for the favoritism he showed with his children. Allowing Bobby to essentially steal the job JR had earned by working for Jock while Bobby was playing football and being a playboy as something else that I can't justify. Jock certainly did some bad things. I don't know anyone who hasn't. As human beings we're all very fallible. Only God isn't fallible.

I like the part in your post regarding telling St. Peter that he'd own up to the good and the bad. I picture him saying that too. I think your assessment of Miss Ellie was also very good and I also her picture saying what you wrote. I generally liked Ellie, but in season four I found her almost insufferable with her "Keep Bobby from leaving no matter what it takes...or I'll never forgive you." I won't try to list the reasons that was bad. There were other seasons when she seemed so much better than that, I wonder if it's the result of having different writers with different artistic visions for the characters.

There does seem to be a conception in the part of a lot of viewers that Ellie and Bobby were so good that they were virtually incapable of doing wrong. Based on how the show presented other characters' reactions to them, I can see where that idea comes from. I think the show wants us to consider them both as extremely good, virtually flawless characters with almost unlimited virtues. However, based on what I see them do, I see evidence that indicates something quite different about both.

I'd be interested in knowing: Because Bobby acts so self-righteous, is it actually more aggravating to you when he dos something bad? Using JR's time in recovery from his gunshot wounds as an opportunity to take his job from him comes to mind. There's demanding from Jock full control of Ewing Oil in writing (which says "your word isn't good enough for me") and then threatening to move to California if Jock said no. Bobby knew how that would affect Ellie, that she'd blame Jock for it, and used that as leverage. I call it emotional extortion. It's basically: "Give me what I want or I'll make Mama never forgive you." It's exactly because Bobby acted to self-righteous that makes it all the more aggravating when he does it, in my experience watching the show.

Thank you for the nice compliment at the end of your post. it's not often that I find someone who can give me a debate of this kind of substance and I genuinely appreciate it for the same reasons - it makes me take a look at my own thinking.

Well put. I will say this, what bothers me most about the show is the self righteousness of those who do bad and those who justify that behavior. Own it or change it my dad use to say. If you can’t own your behavior than change it. If Bobby had to own the truth you just said, which in part I think the character did at times, he wouldn’t have wanted to live with that behavior.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
Sadly, that is probably how it would play out but I would've personally wanted a proper blow out. The Thrillin' Jill Killer would've certainly had every reason to be properly angry with Miss Ellie and I'm sure that Bel Geddes would've sold the shit out of that meaty material that would've followed.

Good point, Tommie. I always wanted someone, Valene or Pam, to shout at Miss Ellie, "You raised him!!! He's a reflection of you!!!!"
They might apologize later, but at leasr let someone throw that in her face, fair or not.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
One thing that I have been thinking about...

After Bobby was shot, JR has a conversation with John Ross out by the pool where he explains why it would be bad to take advantage of Bobby's injury to get control of Ewing Oil. It's funny to hear JR say that. Bobby certainly had no problem taking advantage of JR being laid up after Kristen shot him.

All of these characters are big ol' shades of gray.
 
Last edited:

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
One thing that I have been thinking about...

After Bobby was shot, JR has a conversation with John Ross out by the pool where he explains why it would be bad to take advantage of Bobby's injury to get control of Ewing Oil. It's funny to hear JR say that she. Bobby certainly had no problem taking advantage of JR being laid up after Kristen shot him.

All of these characters are big ol' shades of gray.

Bobby and Pam was well on their way to California when JR got shot. Bobby does the family a big favor by taking over in JR’s absence. I would hardly call that taking advantage of JR being shot.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
Yes,
Bobby and Pam was well on their way to California when JR got shot. Bobby does the family a big favor by taking over in JR’s absence. I would hardly call that taking advantage of JR being shot.

And insisting he stay on control after JR recovers using the threat of leaving Southfork to get his way?
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Just when things on the Jock argument started to simmer down, here comes your buddy, The Last Kid Picked to bring in another angle.

Notice from my avatar that I am a Jock fan.

HOWEVER,

If you do a rewatch then you will notice during the miniseries, here is how it was set up:

Bobby: He is the playboy who just got married. The problem is that he married the Ewing's mortal enemy-- a BARNES(!) woman.

Jock: The iron fisted patriarch who ruthlessly built an empire and will do anything to hold on to that empire.

J.R.: The son who is bitter because while Bobby is out partying and entertaining clients and politicians, it is J.R. who has to do the dirty work of keeping Ewing Oil on top.

To drive this point home, there is a scene where you can hear either J.R. or Jock talking into a dictaphone asking the secretaries to find any employees who are approaching retirement age so they can fire them before they are eligible for their pensions.

That seems pretty harsh, but if the miniseries were to stand alone, then it was a fast way for the audience to understand the characters.

And if the Miniseries were to stand alone, that would have been fine. But to expand the miniseries into a long running prime time show, they had to broaden out the characters a bit.

Jock became more of a father and husband. We learn more about his past and he becomes more three dimensional.

Bobby finds out that life at Ewing Oil is not all celebrations and cashing big checks.

J.R.-- Well, Larry Hagman took J.R. from a sympathetic character to the Magnificent Bastard we all love to hate!

So while they did evolve Jock's character as the seasons went on, they started out making Jock a ruthless man who J.R. could never please.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Just when things on the Jock argument started to simmer down, here comes your buddy, The Last Kid Picked to bring in another angle.

Notice from my avatar that I am a Jock fan.

HOWEVER,

If you do a rewatch then you will notice during the miniseries, here is how it was set up:

Bobby: He is the playboy who just got married. The problem is that he married the Ewing's mortal enemy-- a BARNES(!) woman.

Jock: The iron fisted patriarch who ruthlessly built an empire and will do anything to hold on to that empire.

J.R.: The son who is bitter because while Bobby is out partying and entertaining clients and politicians, it is J.R. who has to do the dirty work of keeping Ewing Oil on top.

To drive this point home, there is a scene where you can hear either J.R. or Jock talking into a dictaphone asking the secretaries to find any employees who are approaching retirement age so they can fire them before they are eligible for their pensions.

That seems pretty harsh, but if the miniseries were to stand alone, then it was a fast way for the audience to understand the characters.

And if the Miniseries were to stand alone, that would have been fine. But to expand the miniseries into a long running prime time show, they had to broaden out the characters a bit.

Jock became more of a father and husband. We learn more about his past and he becomes more three dimensional.

Bobby finds out that life at Ewing Oil is not all celebrations and cashing big checks.

J.R.-- Well, Larry Hagman took J.R. from a sympathetic character to the Magnificent Bastard we all love to hate!

So while they did evolve Jock's character as the seasons went on, they started out making Jock a ruthless man who J.R. could never please.

Good post @Lastkidpicked. It's been a while since I've seen the miniseries. My impression was not that JR was bitter about having to run Ewing Oil, while Bobby was out partying and entertaining clients, but that he was bitter about how when Bobby suddenly asked to run Ewing Oil, Jock immediately gave him a job right the top where only JR was above him, and JR was supposed to share everything with Bobby and teach Bobby. At some point in Dallas we find out that JR has done whatever Jock asked of him so that he could one day run the company. Bobby did little that but still gets to run the company. I got the feeling that JR's thought about it was more or less this: "I had to earn my position at the top but Daddy just gifted Bobby with a position at the top."

Another interesting thing is that it wasn't even Bobby's idea to want to run the company. Bobby allowed Pam to tell him his job as the road man for Ewing Oil, which he enjoyed, just wasn't good enough for him and that he should run the company. Of course, that completely goes against everything Pam said when she left Bobby during the contest, saying that it wasn't important whether or not Bobby ran the company and she wanted a "nice, ordinary life." I found Bobby to allow himself to be easily manipulated by his wife, though he wasn't easily manipulated by others. Normally, Bobby would stand his ground on things that were important to him, but with Pam, Bobby could be drug one way or the other. This was just the first example of that.

How about when Pam said she needed to leave Southfork and Bobby said that was a big request, but OK, the two of them would leave and get their own place. Pam told Bobby he didn't understand; she wanted to leave alone. He said: You want leave alone,without mea and Christopher? Pam replied she planned to leave with Christopher but without Bobby. He just agreed! You'd think that Pam wanting to take his son away from him would be something that would at least merit a conversation! I can't imagine allowing a woman who had just been in hospitalized for mental illness a year ago, who'd attempted suicide, to take my son away from me. Not a chance.

As for Jock ruthlessly building an empire, it's hard to say how ruthless he was, since we didn't see him build it, and he was retiring around the time the series began. JR said things about Jock being able to "play hardball", and that one guy in Dove Hunt, Tom Owens, accused Jock of a lot of things, but Jock said he didn't remember doing it and he didn't remember Tom Owens. It was ambiguous. What did we know about Tom Owens to establish his level of credibility? We'd never seen him before and never saw him since.

I believe Jock probably used some very aggressive tactics in business. From what I saw of his competitors, that is the standard for the oil business. I didn't see any of his competitors being ethical and running their businesses like nice guys who always played by the rules. Bobby explained to James: "There are no rules in our business; we have to make our own rules."

From what we saw portrayed of the oil business, if Jock had tried to build and run Ewing Oil by always acting like a nice guy and always being completely ethical, it would have been like bringing a knife to a gunfight.
 
Last edited:
Top