That's a very nice post
@stevew. Re-reading my post, in the part about morality where I wrote "Opinion is the lowest form of human knowledge...it's nothing more than theory, conjecture and assumption" I didn't make it as clear as I should have that that was directed at my opinions every bit as much as yours, with the point being "I can't prove my way of looking at it is the best way any more than you can prove your way is the best way and because of that we aren't going to agree on Jock's morality." That was my fault for not making that clear.
I'm fairly sure we agree on the most essential tenets of morality - don't kill, don't rape, don't steal, respect your parents, don't covet thy neighbor's wife, etc. I know I wouldn't be comfortable doing some of the things Jock did, and I wouldn't want to be in that business where it looks to me that it was what was required to even stay in business. It makes a fun TV show to watch though.
We didn't see a whole lot of Jock's business dealings because he's handing it over to his sons by the time the show begins. I choose to go by what I actually saw of the man than what others said about him, because then it's not someone else's interpretation, which may be heavily biased or even flat-out wrong. Without trying to write a book about it, my primary impression of Jock as businessman was that of a man who wanted to be ethical, sometimes fell short of what he would have made him feel good about himself, but usually acted in a way where the rest of the oil community seemed to have a deep amount of respect for him and would trust him enough that they'd say things like "his handshake was better than a contract."
On the "A business is a want not a need" statement, I think I see your side of it. I look at it from a standpoint of: It takes money to live. If he got put out of business, how does he provide for his family? I have heard that according to the Bible, if a man can't provide for his family, he's worse than an infidel. Maybe you could tell me what your understanding is as to whether that's accurate. I think Jock probably did the least amount of unethical things in business that he had to do and still stay in business while competing with competitors who were as unethical as Jeremy Wendell. I don't know how you stay in business with competitors like Wendell without becoming very hard and aggressive. I never saw Jock screw someone over for the enjoyment of it.
In keeping with how I look at things, it seems to me the good outweighs the bad he did as a businessman. I find it impressive that he was successful in such a competitive industry. As a result of his success he provided an essential product and created a livelihood for many, many employees. I consider hard work and productivity in anyone to be virtues. I don't know where you stand on that. I'd be interested to know.
I don't want to be repetitive, so I'll just briefly say I consider these very positive things: A successful marriage of over 40 years, sons who loved him, and friends who liked him - especially Punk Anderson. The way he treated his wife, maybe best exemplified in the "Mastectomy" episodes show a love and a deep concern with her feelings. I remember Bobby and JR saying something about how he was going to the hospital so much to be with her that he wasn't getting any sleep, to the point they were concerned about his health.
I've always been critical of favoritism as parents, which both Jock and Ellie were guilty of doing. Jock said in "Barbecue" that he spoiled Bobby rotten and "he turned out to be the best of the lot." I'm very against that way of treating one's children. You've seen where I've explained why I think Jock did what he did in business - he was adapting to his environment. I don't see any justification for the favoritism he showed with his children. Allowing Bobby to essentially steal the job JR had earned by working for Jock while Bobby was playing football and being a playboy as something else that I can't justify. Jock certainly did some bad things. I don't know anyone who hasn't. As human beings we're all very fallible. Only God isn't fallible.
I like the part in your post regarding telling St. Peter that he'd own up to the good and the bad. I picture him saying that too. I think your assessment of Miss Ellie was also very good and I also her picture saying what you wrote. I generally liked Ellie, but in season four I found her almost insufferable with her "Keep Bobby from leaving no matter what it takes...or I'll never forgive you." I won't try to list the reasons that was bad. There were other seasons when she seemed so much better than that, I wonder if it's the result of having different writers with different artistic visions for the characters.
There does seem to be a conception in the part of a lot of viewers that Ellie and Bobby were so good that they were virtually incapable of doing wrong. Based on how the show presented other characters' reactions to them, I can see where that idea comes from. I think the show wants us to consider them both as extremely good, virtually flawless characters with almost unlimited virtues. However, based on what I see them do, I see evidence that indicates something quite different about both.
I'd be interested in knowing: Because Bobby acts so self-righteous, is it actually more aggravating to you when he dos something bad? Using JR's time in recovery from his gunshot wounds as an opportunity to take his job from him comes to mind. There's demanding from Jock full control of Ewing Oil in writing (which says "your word isn't good enough for me") and then threatening to move to California if Jock said no. Bobby knew how that would affect Ellie, that she'd blame Jock for it, and used that as leverage. I call it emotional extortion. It's basically: "Give me what I want or I'll make Mama never forgive you." It's exactly because Bobby acted to self-righteous that makes it all the more aggravating when he does it, in my experience watching the show.
Thank you for the nice compliment at the end of your post. it's not often that I find someone who can give me a debate of this kind of substance and I genuinely appreciate it for the same reasons - it makes me take a look at my own thinking.